We used Felico's Catering for my sons Communion Party. My family raved about the food. The Apricot Chicken was delicious, sausage and peppers, penne ala vodka were some of the options. They were very professional and the food was amazing. read more

Felico's catered my daughter's wedding at the Bate's house in September. Not only was the food wonderful, the owner and staff were the best. We had a lot of confusion, and the owner was so patient and made everything work out right. The staff was exceptional, polite and professional. Thank you Felico's for making this a special event. read more

We have ordered from Felico's a number of times, and each occasion results in more and more compliments on their food. I have learned to order more than needed as most of our guests go back for seconds, and even thirds. The food is delicious, with subtle seasonings (meaning nothing overpowering). We even debate on which trays to order each time as everyone has their favorite one. Staff is professional, very friendly and will help with logistics on orders and people. Try them once and you'll get what I'm saying. read more

We attended the Great Jackolatern Sail at Belmont State Park and this place was our Go To for dinner. Their truck was dishing out hot heroes, meatballs and catered cuisine. I decided on the sausage and peppers hero and was not disappointed. Even my 8 year old loved it ! She ate all of hers. Such a shock ! The sweet sausage with the peppers was so good. The soft Italian bread is what made everything even more delicious ! I would love to have them cater some food for my future wedding. So delicious !!!!!!! Staff was super friendly handling all the business that came in today. Keep it up guys ! read more

Felico's Catering - The best - Barbeque Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

I would have never expected to give five stars to a caterer for a school function but holy crap, this place changed my mind. The food is fabulous. The pastas all had great flavor, nothing was overcooked and even the non-traditional items, like the seaweed-filled chicken stood out. The services were really nice and the food was hot as well; incredibly well done all around. Highly recommended for catered functions. read more

Felicos staff was a pleasure to work with. They were efficient and never said "no" to any request -- even if it was to provide space on the buffet for a roasted pig prepared from another vendor. Nancy was particularly helpful and all staff had a smile on their face the entire party. We had sausage and peppers, steak, pasta (thought it would have less sauce and more vegs), delicious ribs, corn on the cob, cole slaw, bbq chicken (a bit dry), and more. They bring good quality plates and their own tins with covers. By the time dessert came out, they had all of the leftover food in covered tins ready to go into the refrig. I would love to use them again. Such a pleasure!! Thanks! read more

I catered my 40 person party with Felico's of Farmingdale. From the first phone call with Eha to the last dish put away, it was a wonderful experience. The 2 women, Eva and Ledy, who brought the food, set up, served, and cleaned up couldn't have been sweeter and more helpful. Because of them, I was able to relax and enjoy my guests. Also, the food was delicious!! read more

Stopped-in for a quick slice while in the neighborhood. Felico's reminded me of the days of grabbing a hot slice after work before my commute home. Great quality of the food and friendliness of the staff. This is what a New York slice is supposed to taste like. read more

Felico's Catering - Felico's - Barbeque Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

In a word, WONDERFUL. This past weekend we celebrated my 50th birthday in our backyard. The Felico's team came to set up 90 minutes early. They were professional, respectful, and could not be nicer. We had an hour of passed hors d'ovres and then a more formal sitdown dinner that lasted ~3 hours. The food was delcious and the service was top notch. The team truly fired on all cylinders and were attentive to the guests' needs wihout being overbearing: a perfect balance. We could not say enough great things about the overall experience and would recommend Felico's to anyone thinking about have a private catered affair. Absolutely fantastic. read more

The BEST SALAD. Every Wednesday ( i wish it was everyday) they have the chicken Milanese which is out of this world. The best chicken cutlet topped with lettuce , red onion, fresh mozzarella and tomatoes paired with this delicious balsamic dressing and a side of bread to sop it all up. Almost every Wednesday I order it. I came here to sit and eat it's a cute place with seating in the back and they change their menu every day but the food is out of this world. read more

Felico's Catering - Barbeque Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

We catered our second small gathering in August 2024 using Felico's and once again they did not disappoint! When I called to plan the menu, Bernadette was able to pull up my last order from 2 years ago and helped me build a new menu. While making the menu, I had a question regarding the beef selections and before I knew it, Frank, the owner, took the call over not only to answer my question but to make recommendations based on the type of guests we were hosting, mostly women. Together we came up with the perfect menu. Furthermore, he gave me his mobile number in case I had any other questions after we hung up. ALL of he food was delicious! We ordered a few appetizers (skewered for easy handling) and the Party Package #3 for 25 people. Our guests ate well and there was so much food leftover that some guests took food home with them. The next day we gave our neighbors some too and we had a freezer full with more food for future meals. But what made this day even better than the last gathering was, Jessie! This time, we decided to hire a waitress from Felico's ($150) to allow me to spend time with guests rather than setting up and cleaning up during the party ourselves. From beginning to the very end, Jessie set up the chafer's, heated the food, walked the hors d'oeuvres, removed plates, napkins, drinks etc. from tables and put them in the trash, managed the buffet, consolidated the rest of the leftovers and stored them in trays and containers and placed them in my refrigerator so not to have the food spoil from sitting out all night. She also set up the dessert table that guests brought with them. She was everywhere all the time but never in the way! Jessie cleaned everything up outside (this was an outside event) and inside. My kitchen looked as if it did before the day began. Jessie did all of this and more, with a smile on her face and kind words spoken to everyone from the moment she stepped foot on our property. She was worth every penny! Throughout the night, my husband and I had side conversations about how to tip Jessie for all of her efforts...we increased it three separate times! Thank you Felico's for your top notch food and service! read more

Felico's catered my twin daughters baptism this weekend, and let me tell you, the FOOD WAS AWESOME!! My guests were blown away, as was my husband and I. We decided to go out on a limb and try Felico's based on their yelp reviews, and let me tell you - they certainly not only lived up to the reviews, but I'd say even surpassed them. Gabby and Yvette were our servers- they were sweet, accommodating, and made everything run smoothly from beginning to end. I truly felt like a guest at my party. They were organized, prompt, and left everything spotless. The food was beyond what I expected. We had a buffet style service for 60 people that included: Penne vodka Rotelli pasta with spinach and sausage Pepper steak Sicilian chicken - my favorite * Eggplant rollatini Garden salad The meat was TENDER .. the Sicilian chicken and pepper steak were melt in your mouth .. everything was perfectly seasoned and packed with flavor. Terry from the office was so sweet and easy to talk to. She made everything easy to plan and she was so easy to contact. I cannot say enough great things. So many of my guests took cards home. I will 100% be using Felico's for ALL of my future parties. Thank you Felico's! read more

For my milestone birthday celebration @ Charlotte's in Farmingdale, Felico's catered a party for me! Terry guided me to the popular and delicious appetizers , crowd-pleasing entrees & all the sides to please pescatarian, vegetarian & gluten-intolerant palettes! Felico's did NOT disappoint!!! oH EM GEE!!!everything was delicious AND not a calorie to be found!!. I have had Felico's before but this party "took the cake"!!! read more

I can't say enough how pleased I am with Felico's! I recently threw a 60th birthday party for my parents at the VFW Hall in Albertson. I worked closely with Frank, the owner of Felico's, to book the hall. He was extremely kind and always willing to help answer any questions I had during the planning process. This was the ideal venue for my parent's party and was spacious, newly renovated, and nicely decorated. In addition to the hall rental, they offered very generous and affordable catering packages including an open bar, appetizers, several main courses, and dessert, all catered by Felico's. I also communicated with Joann, who was very sweet and helpful while making arrangements for the hall and food. We received several compliments from party guests on how delicious the food was. I was very happy with the quality and wide selection they offered! We also had two guests who had dairy allergies which they kindly accommodated with individual dishes. The staff who assisted during the party were also extremely professional and always willing to help with whatever we needed. Frank also helped suggest a DJ for us as well! As a first time party planner, it was such a pleasure to work with Frank, Joann, and the Felico's staff to make the planning for my parent's 60th birthday party as seamless as possible. We received several compliments on the hall, food, and entertainment, and I credit it all to the help Felico's staff. I highly recommend them for any party you're looking to host - thank you Felico's! read more

This review is for catering only. Used for family/friends function. -lasagna -creamed spinach -salad All good! The biggest thing on catering is both on time prompt delivery service and quality - Felico's hit it home on both. They stood out on the day - another vendor was also used for another dish (which admittedly doesn't do as much catering/delivery) and they were delayed. I also had to do a tweak on the order in quantity and what I was ordering- they communicated and responded promptly on notice and adjusted accordingly. read more

Felico's is the real deal. My husband and I had the absolute BEST backyard wedding and we couldn't have done it without the team at Felico's. Not only was the food incredible (and trust me...we had a lot of tough critics) everything was taken care of. The ambience was truly amazing because we had an unbelievable team backing us up. Jenn is simply the best. I can't say it enough. Within a week I felt like I knew her forever and had no doubt we were in safe hands. She was the leader we needed and the one the whole staff responded to and respected leading up to the event and day of. She delivered on every promise she made and more. Frank is fantastic! He made sure everything was perfect and went out of his way to show up every time we needed him. He was very willing to work with us every step of the way to make sure that he could deliver us a truly amazing experience that fit within our budget. He was a true hands-on owner. I can't recommend this business enough. The food, the ambience, the love! read more

We used Felico's for the first time at my annual July 4th Party. I was a little nervous at first, but Joanne and Jen in Catering made me feel comfortable and confident that the food and service would be Exceptional. EVERYTHING was AMAZINGLY INCREDIBLE and my guests could not stop complimenting the food, and the waitress service. In addition to our hot catering order, we ordered a 6 foot hero that was Outstanding! Going forward, this is the Caterer of our choice! Thank You Felico's, you were a Huge part of our Successful party! read more

See all

Wow! I can't say enough about Felico's. I just had a surprise birthday party for my dad at my home. We worked with Janet planning the party and she was so helpful every step of the way. The food was absolutely delicious and appetizers and desserts were presented beautifully. The wait staff was led by Bernadette and they were amazing. I will definitely be using Felico's for any future party. Highly highly recommend! read more

Excellent. Sausage peppers and onions sandwich hit the spot. Penne Vodka was fantastic too. Great little italian deli. 100% would come back. read more

This review is only based on one food item, but mostly customer service. My family and I were at an event in Belmont Lake State park recently, where Felico's had a food truck and tent. The people working served with a smile all day! In the tent were hot dogs, fries etc. In the truck was sausage and peppers, meatballs etc. I wanted to try the chicken meatballs in vodka sauce. I asked the woman if she would put it on the hero bread for me and she accommodated. She also went out of her way to ask someone in the tent for a to go container, who stopped what he was doing to get one. All still smiling with a line for both spots... I walked my food to a bench by the lake where my picky eater child was waiting. She was hesitant to try something new, but did! We were both playfully fighting over each bite! So. Delicious! I went back toward the end of the event to get more to bring home but not suprisingly, there were none left. I cannot wait to get to know this business better. Customer service goes a long way and smiling is contagious! Add good food and you get 5 stars! read more

I can not thank Felico's enough!!!! They catered my wedding on 10/9 and literally could not have been better! Frank and Jen went above and beyond for me and it meant so much to have them part of my special day! They truly felt like family!!! Oh and on top of the excellent service the food was amazing!!!! So many of our guests complimented read more

I can't believe people willingly pay for this garbage! Actually I'm insulting garbage by saying that. Disgusting food makes you sick! I didn't want to give that 2 star but I had to! read more

We used Felico's to cater a graduation party last night and the food was outstanding. Joanne - who helped us when we went in to place our initial order (she even sent us home with to-go bags that day for dinner!!)- ended up being our server for the day and she was out of this world! So helpful and attentive! People were raving about the food! We're even receiving phone calls the next day about how amazing everything was. We can't thank you enough! read more

They catered my daughters graduation party on June 4. The service was impeccable and the food was absolutely delicious. They followed up on everything. Even called after to see how everything was. (Sorry I have not returned call ). I highly recommend them for your next party. Can't say one bad thing. Great job!!!! read more

Had the pleasure of working with Felico's again this weekend. As always , their staff and food was fantastic. They are simply the best !

Best sausage and peppers sandwich you can get. They have the ultimate setup. A flat top dedicated to the sausages, peppers and onions. When you order they cut the sausage in half and grill it before they construct the sandwich. The large is huge so I usually get the small unless I want to save it for later. I get mine with melted mozzarella and hot sauce. They have hot and sweet sausage available. Consistently awesome. read more

Felico's Catering - Sausage and peppers with melted mozzarella and hot sauce. - Barbeque Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

This is for all pharma sales reps...do it. Worth it! They give you great value for the money you have to spend!!! I actually use them For many family functions because the food is just that good! read more

Felico's Catering - Barbeque Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Felico's is definitely my favorite lunch spot. I usually just go with my usual, greek salad with grilled chicken, because it's absolutely delicious. But they also offer a daily menu that changes weekly so you always have plenty of options without getting bored of the same old food. I definitely recommend trying this place because i know you will love it!! read more

UPDATE: Jennifer was very nice in calling me back. Their customer service turned out to be great so far and they were very sorry we had a rough start. As of right now I am looking forward to working with Felico's. Sometimes things happen and I am okay with this. I am glad this company appreciates their previous and future customers!!!! Previous review below. ************************************ So apparently the wedding coordinator for this awesome catering company (that was referred by a friend) to use for our wedding can't find the time to call me back after I have been trying to reach them since August. @felicoscatering .... Bad form Felico's....bad form. #felicoscatering #poorservice read more

Very professional. Great food! I had my son's first birthday catered. Hanger steak was amazing. I would easily refer them to everyone. read more

See all

From start to finish our graduation party that was catered from Felico's was absolutely amazing!! Frank (owner) made two visits to my home to plan the layout for the bbq. Eha in the office was easily accessible and made the menu planning simple. The staff arrived on time and was professional, friendly and organized. Joanne led the team and kept the party flowing nicely. The two chefs grilled to perfection a variety of meats as well as prepared pizzas for the crowd. The appetizers, bbq selections and salads were all delicious and fresh. This was not our first event with Felico's and it will certainly not be the last!! read more

See all

First a saw 3 cockroaches in the bathroom....the furniture is so outdated is was dirty ...I spent a ton of money for family only to be served on paper plates. NEVER will I got back there again read more

I am an elite yelper for the last two years and this will be the best review I will ever write. Felicos was the best company I have ever dealt with and their product is unlike anything I have ever seen. The care and the passion they put into their service is just absolutely astonishing. Bernadette was the absolute best. And her crew for the day I forget their names also phenomenal. The food absolutely to die for. Everything arrived on time, perfect, and they really made our party an absolute success. The food is so good I ate the leftovers for breakfast this morning I kid you not I couldn't wait to eat it again. If you are thinking of booking felicos for your party DO IT!!! They will be the only catering company I will ever use form here and out. Thank you Felicos for your amazing service for our party yesterday. read more

Felicos deserves more than 5 stars!!! From start to finish they were absolutely amazing! Janet, the catering manager we were dealing with was quick to respond to any requests and changes we wanted to make. She was polite and professional, a real delight :) The delivery team/ servers arrived 15 minutes ahead of their slotted delivery time to begin setting up the food. The staff was courteous and professional. They did an amazing job setting up and cleaning up. Our guests were raving about the food. People were going back for seconds! Their eggplant rollatini was to die for, as was the tortellini with mushrooms. We also had a chicken, and steak dish and penne vodka and all were so delicious. I would absolutely use them again if I needed a catering company for another event. Awesome job felicos!!! read more

Joana and Georganna were FABULOUS! Their food is superb. We had Italian food afficiandos at our party and they loved the food!! Pasta, eggplant, chicken and steak all fantastic. But the best part was how helpful Jo and George were. They helped with ever aspect of the party - going above and beyond. We couldn't be more pleased. read more

Felico's catered our cocktail reception at Charlotte's Speakeasy. Not only was the food absolutely amazing, but they went above and beyond by helping to coordinate the day for us. I didn't hire a wedding planner and they made sure the ceremony had structure and all of my decor was placed how I wanted. My husband and I were so well cared for, having plates of food set aside for us and never having to visit the bar. Our guests raved about the food and we couldn't be happier. read more

Hired them to cater off-site an afternoon BBQ. Food and service were superb. The office staff and field team were very friendly. At our home, staff went out of their way to clean up and pack all of the extra food in our fridge. Best of all the food was delicious. No one expects chicken cordon bleu at a BBQ to be so juicy and flavorful, but it was. I would use them again without hesitation. read more

I can't say enough good things about these guys. I have been using Felico's for years. I use them for personal parties as well as catering for my business events and client gifts. I've gotten to know Frank personally over he years and he's a man who represents the quality of his business. Most recently they catered a bbq we had for 80ppl the day after my wedding. The food was amazing, the staff was even better, and Frank helped design the party layout for us. A+++++. I'm a Felico's guy all the way. read more

My family and I ordered two dinner platters and a grandma pizza. The food was absolutely wonderful and the portions were very generous! Each dish was definitely made with extra care and attention! The employees, especially Nicole and the chef, were so kind and accommodating! They treated us as though we were regular customers. My family and I are so happy we found this special place. We can't wait to visit again! What a delightful and scrumptious treat for my family! Thank you Felico's for making our night so special! read more

Wow the sausage and peppers. Its not usually my favorite , but this place makes it special. Like the food truck or carnival style but even better somehow. read more