HIGHLYYYYYY recommend Teddy's! Not only was the food incredible, but the staff was so kind and their waitresses were phenomenal. I cannot rave enough about Teddy's. Everyone needs to use them for catering. read more

There food is amazing Food was excellent. I don't go anywhere else. My quest keeped saying the food was awesome. read more

We hired Teddy's to do my birthday party at our Clubhouse 2 weeks ago, and I cannot rave enough about Teddy's Kitchen Catering. From the start, working with Debbie was amazing, she knew exactly what and how much food to order, and even when I did not feel like it was enough food, she promised me our guests would not go hungry! From the second the staff arrived, they went right to work setting everything up, and really quickly and efficiently. When our guests arrived, the staff, Kristine and Stacy, were all amazing, making sure that I was taken care of, and my 91 year mom, and even my friends with certain food allergies! The food was OUT OF THIS WORLD, and the passed around hors d'oeuvres were huge and did not stop coming around. Then, we had the buffet of food, which was amazing as well, as were the cookies and fruit for dessert! The staff cleaned up amazingly well, and then, we took the leftovers home, and all I can say is that we will be eating them for a long time coming (we froze alot and gave my mom some as well)! Thanks to all the folks at Teddy's Kitchen Catering, I can't wait for our next event! Lisa read more

A+ service! Staff was responsive and organized. Food is always fresh and flavorful. Delivery is reasonable and timely. Highly reccommend.

HIGHLY recommend Teddy's Catering for your future events! We were recommended to Teddy's by Kristen who has used Teddy's for every family event. We were hosting an engagement party in our backyard and loved the many options of catering provided by Teddy's. It was so easy to inquire and book over the phone with Teddy's and we stayed in constant contact with Debbie who was so kind and easy to work with. She was easy to communicate with leading up to the event and event gave suggestions when we wanted to add appetizers. Teddy's dropped off their supplies two days before the event and the staff were timely and professional. Everyone LOVED the food and are excited to book with Teddy's in the future. The cook and the staff were great and went above and beyond for our event. We are thankful Teddy's was a part of our day and cannot wait to recommend Teddy's to all our friends. read more

Friendly staff, very professional parking is a little weird it's not really a gorgeous storefront but extensive catering menu if you're having an event read more

We just had a bbq party on Saturday catered by Teddy's; their food was Amazing! Had read about skirt steak and it is a must to include in your package! Lots of happy guests and my friend already booked her graduation party with them. Peter the chef did an excellent job and Carolyn was very helpful. Book your parties with them. Thanks Debbie for all! Vanessa read more

Can't say enough good things about this place. debbie worked with me till the last minute to finalize the menu and helped me with every single detail. We got lasagna, penne alla vodka, chicken marsala, beef n broccoli and everything was delicious. Beef n broccoli stole the show. They will be my goto company for all catering needs. read more

Teddy, Debbie, and team catered our wedding at George Weir Barn and if I could give them ten stars, I would. They were ABSOLUTELY AMAZING. Completely exceeded my expectations and give you a great price for everything that you get. No matter what you need, they can make it happen. From linens to set-up and tear down to beverage service to incredible food, there is nothing this team cannot do. Our entire wedding at George Weir Barn was catered by Kitchen Catering and there is no one I would ever recommend based on our experience. They put together a full service cocktail hour with passed and stationary appetizers, ran all bartender and beverage service, set up our tables for a champagne toast, hosted a huge buffet dinner with carving board, provided all of the wait staff, served and decorated our wedding cake, and stayed late to do the tear down of all the tables, chairs, etc. that was leftover from our DIY barn wedding so that myself and my new husband wouldn't have to. Their prices are the absolute best you'll ever find, especially since the quality, portion, and delicious food you will get is top tier. Every single dish was delicious - Debbie even made plates for me and the groom so we actually got a chance to eat at our wedding! The entire wait staff, every single person who worked, were so nice and friendly and courteous to each and every single guest and they worked relentlessly for a full near ten hour day for our wedding's start to finish. Anything we needed, they brought - even last minute items we found out we needed the day before and it was never a problem. The entire team was always ready and happy to help. I am BLOWN AWAY by the service, quality, and overall experience we had and would recommend them to anyone for any occasion over any other company. read more

Was excited to use Teddys. Was told items would be dropped off 1-2 days prior to my party including the bar and grill. Nothing was. On the day of my event they arrived and due to extensive set up, food service time was an hour after I had requested it. In addition the food took so long to come out, and most was not BBQ but rather prepared/cooked before and warmed in my oven. I was very disappointed. read more

Used them for my backyard engagement party. Above and beyond! It was the hottest day of the year and no breeze but they had amazing service. I've also never received so many compliments on the food. My guests loved it. Make sure to get the marinated skirt steak in your bbq package - biggest hit! read more

Teddy's Kitchen Catering - Party & Event Planning Near Me - Bethpage, New York

See all

We had an amazing experience with Teddy's for our daughter's birthday party. First off, Debbie is a dream to talk to - warm, friendly, helpful, professional, I could go on and on. She made booking and planning the menu for our party extremely easy and enjoyable. On the day of the event, the staff arrived on time and made the entire event run smoothly. Jenna, our server, was tremendously helpful serving our crowd of 50, packing up food, helping set up dessert and cleaning. And most importantly, the food was absolutely delicious! We got so many compliments from our guests and many requests for their number and info. Overall, a fantastic experience. They will be our go-to for all future events. read more

I had my wedding on the 13th of November and the catering was (for me at least) the most stressful part of the wedding planning. My wife and I spent many hours planning everything but when it came to the catering we were a little stressed when it came to finding the right company for the right price with the right quality. Enter Teddy, Howard and Debby. Three amazing people with wonderful personalities and a fabulous eye for great food and great service! Debby coordinated almost everything with Teddy and on the day of, they not only came early to set up, but Howard ensured that everything ran well and kept me and my wife informed of everything that was going on. I cannot tell you how much I appreciate your service and attention to detail. Service was excellent (everyone at my wedding complimented me on the courteousness of the staff and their professionalism). They worked long and hard from setup to cleanup. My wife and I had a wonderful wedding, and I wish there was more we could do than just give this place a 5 star rating. Please - if you're in the Bethpage area, and you are looking for great food at a competitive price with wonderful staff, look no further. Thank you all! -Mr. and Mrs. Thompson read more

Used Teddy's for the first time today for a catered business lunch. Delivery was on time. Everything was plated beautifully. Everything tasted delicious. Teddy's worked with us to create a salad combination we wanted that wasn't on the menu. No problem. Reasonably priced. We are new to the area and have found our go to for business lunches. Highly recommend! read more

It doesn't get any better than teddy's! For all our corporate functions - they are just amazing. From staff breakfasts with omelette station to our annual signature cocktail event - the chefs and servers do an incredible job. read more

Absolutely fantastic experience working with the Kitchen Catering Corp. We had a BBQ for my parents 30th anniversary (on the hottest day of the year of course) and the Kitchen Catering staff made the party a breeze. I didn't have to worry about a thing, the food was AMAZING and the staff went above and beyond, even cutting the cake for us. My family and friends are all asking about the catering and I will absolutely be using them again! read more

Teddy's Kitchen Catering - Cookies, watermelon and cupcakes provided by Kitchen Catering. So good! - Party & Event Planning Near Me - Bethpage, New York

Communion weekend.......... Teddy's does it all. Tents/waitress/fully catered. The ratings only go to 5, but I give him a 10+. Food was outstanding, Tent setup/take down great. One stop shopping here. You won't be disappointed. Next event we will definitely be back!! thanks again for a great weekend. read more

Used Teddy's Kitchen Caterers for a Superbowl Party I had this year, and I have to say. We were seriously Satisfied. Not only were they easy to work with in ordering , the delivery was on time and the Food was EXCELLENT. They were having a special which included a 6' hero, 50 Chicken Fingers & 50 wings, to which I added another 50 wings, and to my amazement they got back in touch with me to let me know that I was due an additional 25 wings, as a Bonus!! " How often does that happen???" My guests loved the chicken fingers and the Lemon Pepper style wings were a crowd favorite, and the Hero gave everyone somehing to enjoy later in the game. I can't say a bad thing about the entire exprience, Quality & Quantity and easy to work with.... TOUCHDOWN! read more

Had a gift card for this place and wanted to use it so my wife and I placed an order for a half tray of penne ala vodka. We called later in the day and were able to pick it up only an hour or so later. The guy who packaged it up for us was super nice. He gave us a deal and was very pleasant. The food was great. It wasn't penne, it was actually like rigatoni pasta but pasta is pasta to me...sauce was good thanks very much! We will be back for future catering needs! read more

Just catered the Hawaiian BBQ menu. It was absolutely delicious. Loved everything and so did all my guests. Teddy's never disappoints. Thank you Debbie. Can't wait to cater our next party! read more

The food was a HUGE hit. The "grill guy", Mike was a very nice guy and worked the bbq like a boss. Tamara was our server and she was very polite and hard working. They were a great team. We got the Top Chef package and I had soooo many compliments on the food. They not only cleaned up but put away all of our left overs. I would highly recommend them to anyone! They did not disappoint. read more

We were very happy with our Super Bowl package. This caterer is nearby to our home and we will definitely be using them again. There was a TON of food for the price we paid, and their extended menu is very impressive. We picked up the food from right inside the kitchen and the place is clean and neat, the workers are nice and the food is definitely homemade. I recommend them if you are looking for homestyle cooking that isn't your typical deli or overpriced catering company. read more

I hired Teddy & Debbie to cater my brunch on April 15th and the entire experience was delightful. The only 2 things that I knew I wanted for sure was a waffle station and an omelette station. They created a sample brunch menu and sent it to me to confirm. It consisted of penne a la vodka, chicken francese with asparagus and roasted peppers, southern fried chicken, French toast, bacon, sausage and more. My guests and I loved the food. The omelette and waffle stations were a big hit. As was the penne a la vodka and tuna pinwheel sandwiches. I was not there when they arrived but I was told how sweet and professional they were. The price was more than reasonable for the 55 guests that the food was prepared for. They even wrapped up some left over food for us to take home after the party was over. I would gladly do business with them again. read more

Teddy's Kitchen Catering - Omelette station - Party & Event Planning Near Me - Bethpage, New York

I recently used Teddy's Kitchen Catering for my husband's surprise birthday party held in our backyard. I chose the bar-b-cue option. I ordered in person and then later added 3 dishes by phone with the same person who took my order. She also recommended I hire a server along with the grill person so I could "enjoy my party and leave the work up to her staff". I agreed. The day of the party, two men arrived dressed sloppily as if they had stepped off a fishing boat. They were not in any sort of uniform that would signal they worked for Teddy's. The server turned out to be an assistant to the grill chef only. He did not serve my appetizers, clear dirty dishes and glasses, and never stepped foot in my kitchen except to borrow additional tongs, zip-loc bags, etc. The three additional dishes I added to my order with Teddy's catering manager were never included!!! While I was not charged for them, I also used my own food (cheeses, crackers, grapes, crudite, hummus, spinach dip) to substitute for what was not brought. In addition, items I was told were standard, such as a platter of tomatoes and onions were not brought. The watermelon was never cut for serving until I asked for it. When I called the catering manager a few days later to voice my complaints, she asked that I give her a day or two to "do some research". I waited one week and she never called. I called again and she did not even apologize for her error of never adding my additional dishes to the invoice which is what the kitchen works from when prepping the order. She did not own her error and called it a miscommunication! She did acknowledge that the physical appearance of her staff who serve and how they dress is an ongoing problem. We had a discussion as to the role of the server and that I was kept in my kitchen doing what the server should have done. She finally offered to offset my cost for the server by refunding $100. I thanked her for the gesture. The very next day, she called back and said the owner refused to give me the refund. When I protested, she hung up on me. I felt disrespected, lied to and treated in a totally unprofessional manner. The only positive comment I can make is that the food was good...ribs were excellent! I even told the manager I would not hesitate to use them again, but would be very watchful of the mistakes made this time. I would be sure to confirm the whole order the day before the event and would hire my own server. I would also insist the staff be dressed appropriately. Their appearance was an embarrassment. If I owned Teddy's I would want the employees representing my business to do so in a professional manner. Once I was hung up on, good ribs or not, I would never hire them again. read more

Wonderful caterer to do business. Had them cater my BBQ yesterday. Pete, the grilled was awesome, and a great cook. Kept all my guests (60 people)!!well fed and satisfied. The hot Food was delicious. They bring everything, set up and clean up. I will be using them for all My future parties.m Thank you Teddy and Debbie for all your help read more

Hired Teddy's for my wife's 40th birthday party and so glad I did. Great food, and plenty of it. Everyone at the party was satisfied and commenting on how good everything was. Our grill guy, Pete, was on time, very professional, and grilled the food to perfection. Great experience dealing with Debbie leading up to the party. I will definitely use them again and highly recommend them. read more

I needed to send food for a condolence and of course I looked to Yelp. Another winner! The staff at kitchen catering was professional and informed. They made suggestions on what to send, delivered on time and my relatives were delighted with the tasty trays of pasta, eggplant and chicken. Thank you Kitchen Catering Corp , you made my gift easy and pleasurable to send. Thank you Yelp for helping me make great choices! read more

Ordered from them for the Super Bowl off of a Groupon. They were a pleasure to work with and my guests seemed to love the food. I also loved the amount of food I received for the price, but I'm not sure about their regular pricing. I did find the place a tad hard to find. It's across the street from the shopping center when you round the corner to Hicksville Rd. It's NOT in the shopping center. I would definitely recommend them. read more

We just had a office Super Bowl party. The food and service was amazing. We had chicken wings, chili, mac & cheese and tater tots. There was nothing left. We will surely use this place again! read more

I stumbled upon The Kitchen Catering Corp. Online and I am so glad I did. I ordered from Teddy and Debbie a bunch of trays for my office holiday luncheon. The best beef kabobs I ever had. The beef was so tender and moist. The pasta dishes were wonderful. I never saw my employees ever have 3rd and 4th helpings. Thank you so much and i look forward to my next party. read more

I tried them because I had attended two parties they catered in the past and thought the food and staff were both great. There had been a small issue with the second party, but I was impressed with the way they handled it, so I went ahead and used them for my son's Eagle Scout Court of Honor. We ordered a combination of cold food (heroes and salads) and hot food (two trays). Pros: Debbie was great to work with. We went over the menu and I told her what we wanted. She didn't try to upsell me, and she was very accommodating. The heroes were excellent, and so was the Chicken Francese. We received several compliments on the food. Cons: The salads and baked ziti were just okay. The food was supposed to be delivered before the ceremony started, but the driver got lost. If it hadn't been for my friend who volunteered to help me with the night, I would have missed half of my son's ceremony and delayed the rest of it. It took several phone calls to straighten everything out. This probably wouldn't have been as big of an issue if it was just a casual party at my home, but it was the reception immediately following a ceremony. There was no flexibility in terms of timing, and I was not in a position to take multiple phone calls from the driver to give him directions. The take-away: They were very apologetic when my girlfriend called them to complain the next day. They said they would make sure to take extra care the next time we ordered. That was nice of them, but I won't use them again. read more

We used this company for our Thanksgiving Day Dinner and found it through an email notification from Crossroads Restaurant which closed saying that they did catering. Since we loved the food @ Crossroads and the food served at different events they sponsored I called to have our dinner catered by them. When I called I found out that this was not 'Crossroads" but that the Chef (and owner) was also an owner of Crossroads so I placed the order anyway. THE DINNER WAS DELICIOUS! As close to "home made" as you could get! When ordering I must say that Debbie was an "excellent" customer service person - patient & answered all questions I had and made "adaptations" to some of the items offered with wonderful replacement ideas. My family & I were so impressed with the dinner, I made a point to call the next day to speak to Debbie and got the owner/chef instead and thank him for the wonderful dinner we had, the great job Debbie did and would HIGHLY RECOMMEND their service to all. Thanks again and continued success! read more