Rude and nasty is the only way I can describe our experience at this musty and depressing little room. First we called for a reservation. I was told by an unfriendly man's voice that there was no current availability. I asked if there might be availability later. He rudely snapped, "You have to be here to eat here." Seeing the high Yelp rating, we dismissed his disrespectful attitude, and still stopped by to see if we could be seated for dinner. Upon arrival we were ignored, as was a line of people waiting to eat. There was a boring guitarist playing for a group of neglected-looking senior citizens in this dark and dingy space. After 5 minutes of waiting to be acknowledged by a nonexistent hostess, we left. It's clear that the owners and staff of this establishment have no respect for their patrons. They have more than ample supply of tourists who are willing to subject themselves to such treatment, so do yourself a favor and avoid this awful place. read more

Place sucks- Greg. My buddies and I were paddling up the dumb dumb creek all day and stopped in, could barely grab a beer

Great food!! Had the turkey melt and it was delicious! There was apple butter on the Irish soda bread, along with turkey, melted cheese, and apple slices. Lots of great flavors. Cozy atmosphere and quick service. read more

McGrath's Irish Pub - Cozy atmosphere - Irish Pub Near Me - Killington, Vermont

I went in before I played golf and the recommendation was the Irish Rubin versus the shepherds pie which ended up being lighter and perfect and a great recommendation!!! overall hands-down 100% the best I've ever had and I'm from New York. Then I happened to go back two days later and I tried the shepherds pie I was not disappointed it was amazing!! read more

After a good powder day nothing better than a good pint if Guinness some killer French onion soup and some really good soda bread, top shelf! Bartender is hardcore skier, and Guinness artist extraordinaire . They have live bands at about 7:30 Come back in the summer and climb deer leap after a Reuben! read more

How I have never checked in here before is a wonder. I have been eating and drinking here every year for almost 10 years on a yearly MTB trip. What is there really to write when the review is 5 stars. Night 1 get the stew! Night 2 get the Shepherds Pie with a side of stew or a side of stew gravy or the stew again. Sometimes life is tough. You better like traditional Irish music. Anyplace this good and this charming is going to get crowded. Small, cozy, simple and great. read more

McGrath's Irish Pub - Irish Pub Near Me - Killington, Vermont

Great bar built right into the mountain. Rocks to sit on in the bar area and tables made of local wood. Stew was delicious. Wine leaves a bit to be desired. The kids play room is 80s theme=nothing digital! Sitting by the fireplace with good friends and a nice drink while I write this. Looking forward to my next visit already. read more

McGrath's Irish Pub - Irish Pub Near Me - Killington, Vermont

Great pub in the middle of Killington. We ordered a Ruben & a Shepard's Pie. We can't decide which we like better! Amazing Irish band playing jigs & we couldn't be enjoying it any more! read more

McGrath's Irish Pub - Great Irish pub in Killington! - Irish Pub Near Me - Killington, Vermont

It was a dark and stormy night...a couple of my companions and I were stranded in the middle of a horrific snow storm. We were unable to make it to our chalet and after being verbally accosted by a man, we were beginning to lose faith in humanity. A few members of our party were feeling a bit peckish so, after buying a box of pasta at a gas station, we found the nearest establishment that would take us in. McGrath's Irish Pub welcomed us with open arms. They had a lovely band playing traditional Irish music, and with the snow falling outside, it was truly a surreal experience. The Food was also to die for. Each member of my party got multiple orders of the hummus, we simply could not stop eating it! In total we consumed almost 3 gallons of the chickpea-based dish. In fact, they told us they had never before seen someone consume that quantity of hummus before (I later went on to share this feat to my LinkedIn). After dinner we struggled to secure an Uber to our residence, but Mr. McGrath in his never-ending kindness called us a van to whisk us away. He even let us store our automobile in their parking lot under the condition that we did not block his wife's car. After some deliberation, we happily obliged. Needless to say, Murphy McGrath restored our faith in humanity and in friendship. Would recommend to a friend :) read more

Really enjoyed our visit. All the food ordered was delicious, but I screwed up in not ordering the stew, which is their specialty. I had the onion soup, which was fine. Fun place, we watched a Word Cup match there. Great selection of whiskeys and scotch At first you think you're walking into a motel.. you are, don't worry, turn to your left once inside and there you are. Worth a visit! read more

Interesting place for dinner while in Killington, VT. I had the small Caesar salad with McGrath's Guinness stew. The salad had fresh romaine and good quality dressing. Croutons were a little scarce. The stew had beef, potatoes, carrots, and peas. It was very good. I had the "half and half" to drink. It is half Guinness and half Harps lager and was quite good. The interior of McGrath's is lined with Irish memorabilia as well as an unexpected Washington Redskins banner. read more

One of the best Irish pubs in Vermont. Great pour and very good Irish stew and Reuben sandwich.

If Owen doesn't remember your name it is because you have never been there. The best bar in Vermont. Owen and Bob are fantastic. Great food. Great pub. No reason to go anywhere else. read more

Owen, the bar tender, greeted me personally. He poured me a perfect pint of Guninness and was attentive all evening. The shepherds pie was fantastic and I left happy! read more

I really wanted this to be a terrific review with five stars. We stayed at the Killington Lodge while visiting the area and some guests we met told us about this Irish Pub. She was from Ireland and said that the Guinness stew was by far the closest she has had since being in Dublin, since I have also been to Dublin and loved that stew we decided to stop in McGrath's for lunch the next day. At first we found the atmosphere very true to the Irish pub culture, its dark and cozy and filled with trinkets and memories of past places and guests, the music was lovely and we were excited. Our bartender who was the ONLY person working was very rude and snappy. I couldn't understand why since no one else was seated at the bar. I ordered the Guinness stew and it was amazing!! That's all that saved this stop from being a total fail! The bartender was so rude to my friend that he never even poured her a beer, and when I said something to him about the beer he just said, "sorry I had a phone call", we ate our stew and left. It's too bad ....I've never met an Irish Pub server who didn't put effort into making guests feel at home. read more

Hands down our favorite part of the trip. My husband and I were hiking the Appalachian Trail and decided to stay a couple of nights at the Inn at Long Trail. This pub is located inside. Our first stay was after an exhausting 5 day hike. Owen greeted us with a smile and poured us the perfect Guinness. During this visit we met many locals and visitors like ourselves looking for the perfect drink and meal. It is not just food or drink or service that make this place unique...it is all of the above and so much more. The history of this place alone is worth a visit. We tried many new dishes during our stay in the area...our favorite was the Shepard's Pie hands down just awesome food. Other great dishes are: Guinness Stew, Irish Spuds (we had bacon and cheddar), Bacon Cheeseburger, and the Paddy Melt. If Murray is there make sure to get his advice on Irish Whiskey. We are whiskey fans but were blown away with his selection, details/info on each, and recommendations. Our favorites were the Tullamore Dew and Powers and of course RedBreast. The entertainment should not be missed and if you have a chance to see/hear Donal O'Shaughnessy play you are in for a treat. His paddy jokes are the best and he even found a way to throw in a little country for us (we are originally from TN). If you are in the area this is a must try...but you have been warned...you may not want to leave. read more

My favorite place for a drink pretty much on earth. I was born and raised in Rutland, vt , and have been to many other places across the globe and now live outside NYC. But I hAve yet to find a pub/ restaurant with the "charm" and rustic feel of this place. It's built into the side of a mountain, has a few boulders for tables, rock ledge for several walls, has Gaelic bands on the weekends and Owen makes excellent drinks. He also puts the shamrock on your head of Guinness. The shepherds pie is great too. A great place to chill out with some brews forget about life for a while. read more

Very nice bar, friendly people. They had an Irish band actual Irish they sounded good. Own the bartender is great at his job I highly recommend it read more

Was in Rutland on business and did not feel like another chain restaurant, the hotel suggested this place. Really good meal and good music, and a huge dose of charm, and good service which was surprising considering how packed the place was on a Saturday night-- the waitress was running from table to table and still managing to smile. It would be hard to do any better on short notice, will come here again next chance I get. read more

This past weekend was my first in Killington and I was there with my BF and 2 of our friends. On our first night there we were trying to decide what to eat and wanted something a bit low key. I turned to my trusty friend, yelp, and discovered McGrath's. No one had heard of it and they had all been to Killington previously. We decided to give it a shot and are glad we did! There is a pub portion with open seating (no reservations) and a more formal dining room. The pub is more casual and has live music so we waited about 10 minutes for a table to clear in this area. The menu has some irish classics (shepherd's pie, stew) and more American classics (patty melt, burgers) - something for everyone. I had read that each Guinness comes with a shamrock on the head so I went with this. It is small touches like this that I often remember. I decided to go with a rueben and my BF got the Irish Chili. We started with spuds topped with vermont cheddar and tomatoes. The spuds still had most of the potato inside (not just a crispy fried piece of skin). Everyone enjoyed their meal - no complaints. The food is very good - steps above your standard "bar fare". For dessert (which my BF can't skip) we shared a bailey's cheesecake with maple crust. It wasn't too heavy for a cheesecake and split between 4 gave each person a couple of sweet bites to end the meal. My BF and I were just in Ireland this past November and the service and vibe of this pub brought us back to Dublin. I definitely recommend checking out McGrath's! read more

See all

Drove here from CT to give it a try and fell in love with the place, the food wowed me and my wife and can't wait to go back, great friendly staff and nice decoration. read more

This is a nice little pub in town. We kind of passed it by at first because it is inside of an Inn. Once we walk inside it's really old school irish pub very cozy and welcoming. We had two soups two sandwiches and a couple of beers. My lady had French onion soup which was really good and I had some type of Apple squash soup which was okay almost like apple sauce but it was different. I had an Irish Ruben which was great it was the perfect amount. They had live entertainment that was ok he would tell some jokes from time to time to keep the crowd engaged. Overall it's a really cozy place especially in the winter time when it's cold outside. read more

While I'm sure this place probably doesn't need another 5-star review, I can't help myself! It's amazing! Not only is the food fantastic, but there the interior is like something out of the Hobbit (if it was filmed in Ireland!). One would think that the basics can't be improved upon, but I had a patty melt that was knock-your-socks-off incredible. The salads, soups, and stews as well. My wife had a in-house smoked turkey sandwich, that if she had given me a taste earlier on, I would have eaten it on her!. We were up in Killington for two days and ate here twice. I can't wait to go back during ski season read more

Very comfortable - both decoration and people were nice and homey. Seems very popular with the multi day hiking crowd. We had veggie & dip (simple yet yum) and their version of potato skins. Good. Lots of historical photos on the wall. If we were around at night I would definitely go for the live music. read more

What a great find! Dinner was yummy and the atmosphere was wonderful! A real Irish pub with live music and story telling. We could have stayed there all night! We haven't left Vermont yet and are already planning our next visit! read more

Great bar service. Great pub food. Nachos were good, but never had them with salsa on before. Shredded chicken would of been better than the small cubes of chicken which we received especially for the added cost. French onion soup was excellent and burning HOT when it was served. Irish stew another big +. Husband had Rueben.. Would definitely recommend and do a return visit again. Close to Killington VT ski area. read more

Fantastic staff! Owen was a great server and Showed us around the place. Food was good and just what we were on the mood for. Would definitely go again. read more

Owen is the best guy! This is a super nice sport. They have a good selection of beer and wines. Save room for desert. The apple pie is delicious. read more

Great atmosphere (especially if there is live music playing), good bar food and perfect pint of Guinness.

We discovered this restaurant while in Killington in January of this year. They had a great Irish band and the food was excellent. The chicken pot pie is definitely work the trip and the Irish soda bread is the best I have ever had. Burgers were also excellent. We enjoyed it so much that we returned a few nights later and again during our most recent trip to Killington. Service is great. Only down side is the limited seating and the first come serve policy since it can be difficult to get a table. Overall this place is great. read more

Bob and Owen were amazing bartenders/ hosts. The wife and I came here for dinner during a trip to Killington and were not disappointed. The food was amazing. We had the Guinness stew, Shepard pie, and turkey apple cheese melt. All were superb. The stew and Shepard pie had amazing flavor and the apple cheese melt was an interesting (and delicious) concoction. The soda bread was also delicious. Soda bread and delicious are typically never placed in the same sentence but they have tweaked the recipe and have something special. They also had some of the bust Guinness I have ever had outside of Dublin. If you drink a lot of the stuff you know that some places taste better then others. We will make it a point to return anytime we are in the area read more

Yummy! Good food, service, and price! With a party of 5 and everyone loved their meal.

Ambiance is cozy, warm, and Irish. Staff were super friendly and attentive. Food was perfect! I couldn't decide between the Irish stew and corned beef and cabbage so I got both. Yummy and very satisfying! It's very likely that I'll be back tomorrow night! read more

Came to killington for the weekend to meet up with old friends. Needed to kill some time until they got here and stumbled upon this place. Everything was awesome: the environment, the live music, the food, but what really made this place awesome was the bartender Owen. He welcomes you with a handshake and introduces himself. He won't forget your name and will make you feel like you've been there before. read more

Stopped in here on friend recommendations, the day of the Dirty Girl run here in Killington- the pub was open, design inside is well done, - just 1 other table of a couple older folk, and our party of 8 with 2 children (5 & 8)- Waiter bob completely skipped me on the drink order, no biggie, so I went to Bar to get a drink, - was very rude and confrontational, kept at me about he was the only one there and was "getting to it"- looking at me saying " What? What?" -- rudest incompetence I've experienced in any Pub, anywhere, ever. I didn't eat, paid my $14 for a double rum (serious?) and left, and will never go back. Beware the pissy Waitstaff-- Pathetic and Disappointing . read more

Great spot to stop in after a hike of Deer's Leap. The most amazing Guinness served with a shamrock even(my favorite part). The cheddar ale soup and Guinness stew are to die for and the owner's/staff make you feel like family. read more

Just stopped in for a pint and an appetizer. I had the potato skins with bacon and cheese; and, the wife had the French onion soup. Both were accompanied by a pint of Guinness. Might have been a little pricey for the pints, but everything was top notch. Friendly and efficient bar staff. read more

The beer, the food (absolutely delicious), the staff (Owen and Bob), and atmosphere make this place what it is. A perfect place to end a cold day on the slopes or a hot day on the trail. A hidden gem between Pico and Killington! read more

This pub is a definite stop any time we are in the Killington area. Consistently great food, friendly staff and amazing ambiance. The inn is built right into the side of the mountain and cushions on a protruding rock make for a comfy sofa. Other boulders provide more ambiance and functionality throughout. Furniture is all wood. Casual, with live Irish music on weekends, fun decorations, comfortable for families (except on St. Patrick's night when it gets very crowded and noisy). Unique, warm, charming and good food, too. read more

I went here with my 12 yr old son for dinner after skiing on a thursday night. I had a burger and a beer and a cesear salad. Only two guys were working and it was busy but not packed and we had a fair wait to get our drinks and food orders. Burger was average but nothing special and salad was sub par with wilted lettuce. Interior is interesting cozy pub decorated and the game room next door in the Inn is great. Food was "meh" atmosphere was better. Might go back for a drink but not for food. read more