Always Outstanding Service! The crust is thing and crunchy. The pepperoni is crisp and delicious. The corn meal on the bottom provides a nice contrast. And I highly recommend getting gorgonzola (blue cheese) on your pizza to contrast the pepperoni. Every time I come from Houston, Texas I stop by to get some outstanding pizza from Massey's! Truely Excellent pizza! read more

The best crust. Toppings and cheese the best. We also ordered side salads. Offers many toppings

Stopped in for a beer and pizza and when I tasted how skunked the corona was I should have left. Our server said it was too early (noon) to take our order and asked us to get up and come to the counter to place our order. We were the only ones in the place and the pizza took 45 min. It came out burnt (probably shouldn't have left it in the oven so long). The place was clean and the bathrooms were very tidy. Maybe it was just a really off day. read more

Love their lasagna special with the side salad and garlic bread. It's a lot of food for the money! Great meatball subs and fries. Food always arrives hot and on time. Pleasant drivers. read more

The food is delicious and the establishment is clean. Very friendly staff and the ambiance is cozy. read more

Pizza was ok but had a ton of corn meal on the crust which was disgusting. Sauce was not spread evenly and was non existent in some places. Pizza was overdone making the cheese on top leather like. read more

I love this place!! You get what you order!! You really want an awesome sub?? Order a double super guido sub. You will not be disappointed!! Well worth every bite!! read more

Pretty good for typical ohio bar style pizza. Nice employees. Didn't skimp on the toppings and Prince wasn't too bad. Overall for ohio bar style pizza it was pretty good. Didn't try any other foods there read more

The customer service at this place is the absolute worst. 100% of the time, they are super rude on the phone & act as if it is the most inconvenient thing in the world to have to talk to me. The food is OK, the pizza tends to be slightly overdone on the regular, but the appetizers are decent. I try them about once a year, but it's so painful to talk to them on the phone that I'm reminded why I only try them once a year. The delivery driver was super nice and polite, and he's the only reason I didn't give them a single star & gave him extra on the tip. Please get rid of the person answering the phone, they absolutely are driving away business (at minimum, mine). read more

This was absolutely the best pizza I have had in a very long time. It was fast it was hot and it was yummy with the toppings just falling off. Great value read more

Manager argued with me and was absolutely the rudest person. They made the order completely wrong but when I called to get it corrected he-the manager-said I would need to come by the shop and he'll give me a quarter, yes a quarter, to make up for the incorrect order. I make it well known to all my coworkers and anyone I know not to give this guy business. I can't imagine in these times being that horrible of a human being to a customer. Good luck! read more

Not my style of place Tried the buffet They did have beer place was clean just not my style of pizza read more

Never had a problem. Tastes like the classic pizza I had in Reynoldsburg growing up. One of my favorite pies.

New location in the Carnival Plaza shopping center by of course Carnival Foods. This new location is expansive with plenty of seating. I've been here twice now, once for the buffet and once for takeout. The buffet runs 11a to 2p Monday through Friday. $7.98 for pizza, subs, and drink. Pretty good deal. I will say go early, because we went close to 1:30 and the pizza selection was beginning to become sparse. As for their regular order to go or dine in pizza, it's Massey's, some of the best pizza on the planet. Great toppings, flavorful crust, etc.... read more

By far the BEST pizza around. I grew up with Masseys Pizza in Gahanna. Lancaster Location is just as good. Delivery is always on time and the delivery driver is very very polite. read more

Waited 75 minutes for two pizzas. Along with there parmesan shakers next to the hot pepper shakers, you know like a normal pizza place was filled with salt. Piss poor at best read more

I work in the medical field and because of my schedule I order alot of pizza. I will never order from this place again. 2 of 3 times they messed up a simple order then was VERY rude when we called about it. I just had to order another pizza from a second place so my child could eat. Ridiculous read more

This used to be our all time favorite pizza but after tonight I'm pretty sure we're moving on! First let's discuss the quality of their product. It has gotten very salty, they're using CRAZY amounts of cornmeal on the crust & tonight it was burnt. Here's what pushed it over the edge...this evening the driver called us because she was lost. She actually called 3 times & proceeded to get flustered & argumentative. So I called the shop to let them know & they got argumentative with me! In what universe is this acceptable?! I might as well mention the guy taking the order couldn't get it right without my husband repeating the order multiple times. It's clearly very difficult for them to place their employees in the appropriate positions for their skill sets. Here's to cold pizza with no offering to make the situation right! Bye! read more

Over an hour and a half for two subs on a Sunday night. Didn't get the garlic butter I ordered either.

The best pizza , we got the godfather . This was our third time to Masseys pizza . Lancaster first , Grove city second , back to Lancaster The best by far .Funny thing we went to the Massey pizza in Grove City got the same thing. The Godfather deep dish . They did not make near the pizza that Lancaster's Massey pizza did. Lots of cheese lots of meat great sauce. Sports on the TV. I'll be back to Lancasters. read more

Love Massey's Pizza in Lancaster!! Bob makes the best pizza,Brian the next best. Always done the way we request. Also love the subs and garlic cheese bread We usually go there once a week when we are in town. When we are in Washington we miss our Massey's. read more