I actually go in on Taco Tuesday and order the big basket with 3 large Tacos and Tortilla chips. Their service is very good and the prices are reasonable. The young server is always smiling and friendly making the Ambience happy. It's Mexican decor on Tuesday. They have really improved the past year. read more

First things first. Service!!! Korenne was incredible. She knows the menu and guided me gently into making gooood choices. Gluten Free ? Yes. Excellent GF hamburger buns. A great vibe. Highly recommended. BTW, if you're indecisive about your burger, I suggest the mushroom one. read more

See all

This place is awesome. So many things on the menu we wanted to try. We will have to go back soon to try other things. Everything we had was amazing. Our service was great. The cocktails were great. They had this sweet onion bisque that was one of the best soups I've ever had. Omg it was delicious. The burgers were very tasty as well. They have one that's literally smothered in the sweet onion bisque soup. Wow. The appetizers we had were both really good too. The pimento cheese was awesome and the chorizo fries were so good. We will definitely be back. read more

See all

I honestly wish I could give this place 10 stars. My sister is a professor at Ohio University Lancaster and today we decided to have an impromptu lunch, so of course I had to check Yelp for restaurants in the area. This week's pregnancy hyper fixation food is burgers; lo and behold the reviews had impressive looking burgers. Our server was efficient, helpful and made really good suggestions. The ambience gives Cheers vibes and honestly, I wish it was my local neighborhood pub. I created my own burger with Gouda cheese, sautéed onions, lettuce, tomatoes, and a delicious garlic aïoli. My accompaniment of choice was tater tots. We were told that the meat is local and ground in the house daily. The ingredients were extremely fresh and the bun was perfectly buttery and toasted. I have nothing negative to report and can't wait to go back and try other menu items. read more

Cherry Street Pub - Pubs Near Me - Lancaster, Ohio

Love this place! Even when there is a bit of a wait to get seated it's still worth it. The staff is always so nice and friendly. The ambience and environment are fantastic. However, the few times we have been there (which it's ALWAYS busy) it dos take a bit for the food to come out. So get ya an appetizer & a cocktail while you wait. read more

From out of town. Been here 2x. Last year and this year. There is a Round Barn close by at the fairgrounds that has a summer market that we went to, last year and this year. Last year, when we came here there were 6 of us and the hostess complained because she said they had no room and we had to wait. After about 20 mins they did accommodate us. But honestly I was put off by that. You are complaining about business in the middle of the day? That tainted that whole experience for me. This year we sat after about a 10 mins wait. This year this Pub was recommended to us by a vendor at the Round Barn. I thought it sounded familiar and it was the same place. Honestly I was disappointed I wanted it to be a different place. Anyway, our server was very nice. He got us drinks right away. We got various items for lunch I got 4 wings and a side salad. I asked for extra crispy wings and if that extra crispy then I am glad I asked cuz they were just regular. Cherry BBQ was OK. Salad was ok too. Nothing spectacular. I am told the bologna sandwich was good. And the rest of the food a burger and buffalo chicken sandwich was OK as well. So food is average. They did have a cider on tap and that is a plus. The Pub was very crowded. And this year there is construction outside making it hard to get to a bit. They have a parking lot across the street. I also noticed a patio but did not see it. It's seems like a decent neighborhood bar. The problem for me is that the first time I came here was a bad experience and I have held that. read more

We stop almost every time we go to Lancaster. The food is always amazing and we have tried every thing on the menu. If you get a chance get the peanut butter wings!!! Always have a great wait staff. read more

All the best local restaurants in town they're lobster. Mac & cheese is amazing most everything on the menu is very good. It is busy, but that's because they are good. read more

Food is delicious! Always busy, everyone who has attended to us here has been exceptional. The atmosphere is great as well. Definitely will keep coming back! read more

We live about a 1/2 hour away, and after reading reviews, we decided that we had to give this place a try, and we are SO glad we did. Amazing atmosphere, great service, good prices, and absolutely amazing food! We had a couple cocktails from their special drink menu, which were all fantastic. We had the Pollywog dip and the Disco Fries as appetizers, and they did not disappoint. The French Onion Burger is probably one of the best burgers I've ever had! My wife had the Bayou Burger, and it too was amazing. If you are in the area, definitely give this place a try, you will not regret it. read more

See all

Omg!!! Just moved to Lancaster about 3 years ago from Ireland, The fish & chips are the best I've had here since I've been back. Omg I'm so happy I have found my new local Service was excellent & I felt like I was back home. Good food, good people! read more

Visiting Ohio and a friend recommended this place. It might be a little unassuming on the outside but I really enjoyed the decor inside and the food. I got my traditional fried bologna and my friends got burgers. While the bun was a little over toasted I was delighted that the sando was served on a brioche. Really gave it an extra something. Great ranch and If you know me you know that I place a lot of value on a good ranch. This one was great. Other notable was that I did taste the burger and wanted to point out that the beef was very flavorful on its own. They dress their burgers uniquely and have some interesting options. I would absolutely go again if good pub food is what I was looking for. read more

Surprisingly crowed at 2pm when we came in for a late lunch. Got seated in the bar at a 2 seat high top. We both ordered burgers with no buns. Both were disappointing. I order a Mushroom Monster with barely any mushrooms. The fries tasted like they had been sitting out a while too. Would not recommend for a good meal, but service was fine & friendly. read more

Staff was very inviting, food off the chart, fresh! Highly recommend! When traveling through it's a great stop! read more

See all

We've visited Cherry Street Pub many times in the past and it's always been a good experience. There was a new item on the menu that I wanted to review and it's the Mongolian Beef and noodles. The flavor was outstanding with a sweet and salty taste. Decent portion of beef and broccoli. I thought the overall portion was small for the price point of $18 however. Also at reception desk, they seated the couple ahead of us and told us it would be 10 minute wait when we could clearly see four empty tables. Then when we were seated another couple behind us were greeted by their server before we were. I'm hoping it was a one off but if it continues we probably will stop going there. read more

We came here after a coworker recommended this spot. Food, service, ambiance & staff were all amazing! Staff is welcoming and knowledgeable, food was timely & so delicious! read more

Cherry Street Pub - Rainbow over the restaurant - Pubs Near Me - Lancaster, Ohio

My husband and I take an annual trip to Hocking Hills, and the Cherry Street Pub is always on our must-do list. The food is amazing! I highly recommend the Peanut Butter and Jelly wings for an app. The Nashville Hot Chicken Mac and Cheese is my go-to entree. This year we stopped by for Sunday brunch. I got the Chicken and Waffles Sammie which was also fantastic. We love the vibe of this place, and the customer service is always top notch. read more

See all

Great food, great service, friendly atmosphere. Stopped in for a brief lunch and had a great meal - southern simple chicken sandwich was delicious and cooked to perfection, the beer battered cod sandwich was also delicious. A must stop if you're in the area. read more

We got lucky last night they had 2 bar seats open with no wait. This place is a great place for a date night or just to hang with friends. The atmosphere is always spot on. We love the drinks they always have unique ones. The food is amazing and just different. They have a great chicken and waffle. Mac N Cheese is spot on. Last night a customer made a rude comment about a waitress and the leader went and addressed it right away. Love seeing strong leaders who stand up for Team. read more

Cherry Street Pub - Chicken N waffles. - Pubs Near Me - Lancaster, Ohio

See all

This place is always so good! The atmosphere and inside design is the best! I definitely recommend this place for any type of outing.

Food and service are always great here. Disco fries and PB&J wings. I've driven here multiple times from Columbus and it's always great, the food appears to be scratch made in house which is always a plus. read more

Cherry Street Pub - Disco fries and PB&J Wings - Pubs Near Me - Lancaster, Ohio

Lauren always kills it, service is great, food is hot, and of course the extra spicy dill pickle bloody Mary's are to die for!

Everything!! The hush puppy was total grease. Covering with cinnamon butter didn't help. I ordered the pasta mushroom dish and it was disgusting. Tasted OLD ....and I could tell by the mushroom in the dish, it was. Some of the Noodles were actually dry...so I could tell they had been sitting and reheated. Not that it was hot. Barely Luke warm. My son like his burger. But then again I think he was just being nice. He ate 1/2 of it. read more

been here three times so far, the menu is so enticing that I ultimately change my order at the last minute every time. so much to choose from. Nashville hot chicken is amazing and so are the drinks here. this place is always busy and with good reason. this is the third brand that has operated in this location, after Johnson's and Snead's, and they have all been excellent. a go to spot in Lancaster for good eats at a fair price. Eat Local! read more

Good food and service. A large variety on the menu. Nice decor and staff. Good to go for lunch.

Great food and excellent service! We sat on the patio this beautiful evening and it was cozy and clean. Our server was very friendly and personable. The food was delicious - the burrito, the quesadilla, the bread and the hush puppies. Perfect! We will be back to try the mac! read more

My wife and I went in to grab a bite to eat on Tuesday evening. We sat at the bar, Charity was very friendly and attentive as our server/bartender. We always enjoy the food and atmosphere. We went back for lunch today and were seated with Kylie, who did a great job also. Very friendly staff and wonderful food! read more

Lancaster Ohio is a juggling act of either great service or great food , you can't have both . The food here is great . read more

Food was excellent. Traditional pub food done well. We had Fish and Chips which were good. Good selection of local craft beers on tap. The pub atmosphere was great, loved the older building. Our server was wonderful and gave us some helpful hints on some local places to visit and eat. Highly recommend if you are ever in Lancaster Ohio! read more

Our first time here, visiting area from out of town! We were so pleasantly surprise, the food was great! I had the best chicken tacos ever! perfectly seasoned and the added corn salsa a delight! My husband had the Pecan Chicken Salad that was fresh, cold and delicious! also shared an order of onion rings that even though were wonderful. at $10 a bit over priced. our waitress, Cassi was supurb! Recommend giving this place a try....totally worth it! read more

Scoped out CSP on Yelp before heading to Lancaster with the in-laws to browse around the Olde Shoe Factory. Reviews were honest & the menu seemed to have plenty of crowd pleasing options & since I was traveling with three picky Ohioans I convinced them to come here for lunch. We arrived around 1:30 on a Friday to a busy dining room but surprisingly no wait. The atmosphere here is excellent as the decor is wood panel with contrasting colors & upholstery everywhere. Great old pub vibes but lively as well. We were seated quickly with our drinks & an app on the table within 5-10 mins, Our party had two burgers, Thai chicken wrap, Southern sun salad (me), & polliwog dip for the app. The dip was okay but not anything special basically just melted cheese with some bbq sauce and minced pulled pork. Probably would opt for something else next time. The salad I had was the perfect portion & very balanced. Wife's wrap was pretty good (I had a bite). In-laws seemed pleased with their burgers as well. Our server was really good & very patient with my mother in law who had made a lot of alterations to her order. Would recommend for service, availability of options, & aesthetics if you're in the area. read more

See all

It's really neat that the bar at Cherry Street Pub is quite old -- it was built in the early 1900s! This is just one example of the history that you'll find inside this restaurant. If you want to see more local Lancaster history, just gaze upon the objects on the walls: you'll see an assemblage of memorabilia, magazine covers, photographs, maps and other things decorating the restaurant. This pub is family-friendly, even though they don't have a kids menu, which is a bummer. But I brought my children, and I saw many other kids, as well. They also have high chairs. My kids got a cheeseburger and a plate of mac & cheese, and because the food portions are not kid-sized, the meals were huge for my kids. My children have tiny hummingbird stomachs and can only eat so much food in one sitting, so they left a lot of food on their plate. My mac-and-cheese orderer didn't care for the mac & cheese because it was a bit loose and soupy. I got the Quite-A-Gouda Burger, which was a double burger with gouda cheese, bacon, caramelized onions and lettuce. It was tasty but very big! One of those burgers where you need to have a jaw that unhinges, or use a knife and fork. We also got the Pub Club, which is turkey, ham, bacon, lettuce, tomato, American cheese and mayo on toasted bread. Again, tasty but huge. Are you sensing a theme? If you enjoy huge portions, this is the place for you! Sandwiches are served with fries and a pickle, but we substituted the fries for tater tots. It was busy when we visited, and almost all of the tables were full, but we were seated quickly and the service was great. read more

Reasonably priced, great food. Good variety of options for everyone. Friendly staff. Great bar and drink options

I absolutely love cherry street! The service is always amazing, Kylie is a hustler and always making sure our drinks are full, and that everything is meeting our expectations. read more

By far the best restaurant in town. Food and service is always top tier. Just went last Tuesday and trust me, it will stay at the top of my list. My daughter asks for extra cherries every time she orders a Shirley Temple and our waiter, Dusty, made sure he spoke directly to her which is a big deal for her (she's 6 and dramatic). If you go to Cherry Street at least one person at your table needs to order the specialty Mac because it's the best thing on their menu and if you need a good drink rec, a cherry street mule is always delicious! Love this place! read more

We were looking for a place half way between Athens and Columbus. Furthermore, it had to have a patio. So of the 3 options we were given to pick from (one person was nice enough to do the research and select the 3), this one won out. For me who voted for it - it was the menu that nailed it for me. I'm a salad person and there were several to pick from. So one person called ahead to try and make a reservation as there was supposed to be 6 of us. No reservations. No problem. We figured we'd go a little early and it would all work out. We agreed to meet here at 11:30 AM on a Wednesday in mid-September. I found a parking spot on the street as I totally missed to lot right across the street. Regardless, it was an easy walk and a safe neighborhood. I did, however, use my steering wheel lock as I have a Kia and we'd be here a couple hours. I was the first to arrive and we had our pick of tables on the patio. There was already a couple tables pushed together that would fit our group of 5 (1 called off sick). The waitress was excellent and attentive. She took my soda order and brought it out. One by one my group arrived and she greeted each and got their drinks. We finally put in our food order and continued to chat. Our orders came out in good time and they were all perfect. No mistakes. Almost everybody ate every bite - except for one person who got their leftovers to go. I got the SW style salad with grilled chicken - dressing on the side and hold the tortilla strips. Someone else got the same with tortilla strips and they were quite impressive looking. The salad had nice mixed greens and corn, cheese, red onion and tomato. Also a fair amount of chicken. I didn't really notice the onion until afterwards when the taste stayed with me a while. Regardless, it was very good and didn't need the dressing. The waitress mixed up all the bills except mine. She was super nice and got them all fixed - no big deal as we were not in a hurry. Our group is all retired women except me - so I left first as I was on the clock and needed to get home and back to work. I definitely recommend this restaurant for lunch or dinner. It's a big pricey for me for lunch time meal but since I only go out occassionally with friends, it was well worth it for the meal and companionship! read more

See all

The triple bacon burger is the bomb. We also can't go without getting one of their fantastic soft pretzels. Rain is a fantastic server there. She really takes great care of us. read more

All of us enjoyed our lunch here. We felt the prices were a little steep for pub food, but it was all really good. My daughter got Mac and cheese and my son got a cheeseburger and both were great! I got the Thai chicken wrap and it had good flavor, but maybe a little heavy handed on the peanuts. My husband enjoyed his breakfast quesadilla. The place is very small, so expect a wait! read more

OMG!!!! First time here and will not be the last. Fantastic service and incredible food. My husband and I shared the Peanut and Jelly Chicken Wings and Pecan Chicken and Waffle with Spicy Maple Syrup. Loaded with flavors. Highly recommended!!! read more

Wow, well I'm blown away. If you're passing through Lancaster, this little pub is a must. The staff were very friendly and the environment I can't rave enough about. The vibrancy of the decor and furnishings can't be understated in this very fashion forward spot. Even the bathrooms are lovingly painted! As lovely as the decor is, the food is even better. I adored the crispness and peppery yet sweet taste of the fried pecan crusted chicken and waffles. The amount of fun and unusual dishes here makes it all the more fun and dining experience. The initials even being marked on the fantastic pimento "Polliwog" Dip being a nice touch! All that being said, the service was very quick and accurate and our waitress was accommodating! Definitely give this place a try! read more

See all