This is probably my favorite lunch in Sisters. A slice of pie, and a tasty salad are a great lunch. The pizza is wonderful with a thin crust and flavorful sauce, it hardly matters the toppings. read more

Mixed feeling! Our group came in for pizza. Place was empty. The waitress was pretty indifferent. She didn't offer to seat us or take our order. We arranged two tables ourselves. Asked her to clean the crumbs off. She brought one menu. Rest of our party arrived. They asked for menus. There was ONE other one. Six of us shared the only 2 menus. Orders were placed for 3 pizzas! These aren't really cheap pizzas. They each cost about $25.00. For medium size. We got our own silverware, napkins, etc. now the positive. The pizzas did taste really good. So I guess that you balance the poor service & good food. You decide which is more important. I would like to think she might have been having a bad day!!! read more

Great pizza! Crust was delish, toppings were fresh, cheese was tasty! It was close to closing time and they were still happy to take my order. Doesn't get better than that!! read more

We stumbled upon Sisters as we left Bend and had to stop because it was so cute. Dropped into this random pizza joint on the main drag and was stunned at how good the pizza was! Crunchy crust and good toppings. read more

Our family has a vacation house in Black Butte and were very surprised to find pizza this good in a small tourist town. We got the Outlaw (pepperoni, ham, sausage, mushrooms, olives, and red onion). We picked it up for take out and chose the "half-baked" option, as a 20 minute drive back to the house would have cooled a fully baked pizza too much. Five minutes in a 450* oven and it was perfect. Thin, crispy crust, high quality toppings. If you're from the Seattle area, think Pagliacci. Best pizza I've had in years and we'll definitely make a visit to Martolli's a regular part of our Black Butte trips. read more

Though the dough and toppings were tasty, the prices were a trick. $3.50 for a slice and a $4 charge if total does not meet $4 forces you to buy another slice... It smells better than it tastes read more

We came in upon a spontaneous visit. I personally was intrigued by the smell! It's smells so irresistible when walking by! We got a slice & it was ok. It definitely wasn't bad but I feel as though I've had better. The people are friendly & is clean. Not a fan of the $4 minimum charge to use a card. It's a good way to get more money for them! read more

We stopped here for lunch on our way to Bend. Super friendly guy behind the counter and pretty decent pizza. I had a slice of carmelized onion, walnut, tomato slice and goat cheese white pizza. My husband got 2 slices of pepperoni. The crust was yummy too. Filled us up for the rest of the day too. But it was SUPER greasy and not really warmed up enough when we bought it by the slice. I bet if you got a whole pie that was really fresh and hot it would rate a solid 4 stars. read more

Decent pizza by the slice, $7 lunch special including salad and drink.

Fabulouse pizza served by the friendly people you expect in Sisters. You can even get it "half-baked" to finish at home.

Stumbled upon this randomly. Very healthy pizza, had the white veggie. Thin crust and really fresh veggies. Worth the bucks

Excellent pizza. New York style thin crust. Huge slices. I would definitely go back. Highly recommended.

Not sure what happened here but this place is pretty much terrible. Used to be good back in the day but when people ask me where to get pizza in town I don't even mention this place. I think MAYBE if you ordered a fresh pizza it would be ok but that stuff sitting out is no bueno. Might be time to throw in the towel.... read more

The pizza here is fantastic! Me and my friends were driving through sisters and craving pizza. We had never eaten here, but our server Ireland made the experience awesome!! The Barbie was the best bbq chicken pizza we have ever had. We will be back. read more

I ordered the combo meal that came with a drink, a slice of pizza and a salad for $8. The pizza was really good and so was the salad. Would definitely eat here again. read more

Hand's down LOCALS favorite, thin crust "Authentic" Pie! Freshest ingredients daily. Great rotating micro brews on tap. Service & smiles are #1. You will always find sports on the TV as well as sweet, Vibe music in the background. Try it...you will LOVE it! Cheers! K read more

Fantastic pizza. We got the Samoan and it was delicious. The crust was sooo good and I'm not a big crust person but this was so good I wanted more crust then pizza! read more

Great pizza. We picked up a couple of pizzas for my bridal party and everyone loved it. The slices were generous and I'm definitely keeping this in mind the next time I want pizza in Sisters. read more

Not so good, 5" of crust and taste like card board. Tony's frozen pizza is better. If in sisters go to takodas pizza

Great pizza, great service and super nice crew.. this isn't fast food people, it takes time to make a good pizza, so stop complaining about the time it takes to make it.. they put pride in their creations!!! I like that every time we go through sisters this place always is busy and they should be... it's delish read more

38.00 bucks for a pizza and two beers! Wow! The toppings were ok but the crust was like some kinda shortbread /cracker / biscuit thing, it broke off where you bent it . Not that nice crunch then stretch that makes a great pizza dough. Reminded me of a chewy pop tart crust or something. read more

Love this pizza. For me... it's all about the crust and this place does it up! I think it is the best pizza in central oregon.

I drive through Sisters Oregon all the time for work and rarely stop despite the charm of the town. Today I stopped because I was with my family and we had some pretty awesome pizza. I usually dont like thin crust but this was just delicious. Restaurant was clean, staff was friendly and food was tasty. I'm going to have a hard time not stopping from now on. read more

Great quick bite for lunch in Sisters. Lunch special (slice, salad and soda for $6.25) is a great value. I would gladly return.

This place used to be really good, but it's gone downhill over the last several years. The last time I was here it was just for a quick lunch so were planning on grabbing a couple slices. Big mistake. The pizzas had been sitting out for what looked like hours and seemed entirely unappetizing. That being said, I opted for a caesar salad. Bad choice. It was like the lettuce was completely wet when they tossed it with way too much dressing, so it resulted in a big, gross mess. After a couple bites I just completely lost my appetite. The others in my group ate their slices but said they weren't very good. I'll be skipping it next time I'm in town. read more

Delicious pizza with crust that's the perfect combination of thin with crusty & chewy edges. I had the margherita which next rime I'll ask to swap the whole roasted garlic for arugula. The boys had pepperoni and sausage and said the sausage was awesome! It was gone too quick or I'd play pics. We'll be back for sure next tome we're in Sisters. read more

The pizza was no better than something you buy in the frozen food section. Maybe I'm spoiled by handmade dough baked in a wood-fired oven, but it was not worth it. read more

This pizza is NOT a 5-stat! Waited an hour; Messed up our order; Slow service; pizza was terrible! Never will go back! read more

Best Pizza in Sisters. wood fire artisan pizzas I have had places get my 5 star vote, but Martolli's does a good job and is by far the best in Sisters, and most likely leads most pizza in Bend and Redmond overall. We are fans. read more

Drove into town hungry and found this great pizza place. Friendly help, tasty thin crust pizza, great salad. Sat outside and enjoyed the town. Great for the kids because we ordered by the slice. No worries about what type of pizza to order. read more

Unlike most people, I never think about ordering pizza but if I'm with someone who wants to go to a pizza place, I'll get a slice. Well, traveling through Sisters, we stopped at Martolli's and I had a slice of the best pizza I've ever eaten! Perfect crisp crust with just the right amount of sauce and cheese - if there was a Martolli's back home, I'd be craving pizza on a regular basis. Yummy! read more

Ok. Let me help you out here. This is the worst pizza I've ever had from a pizza joint. Think of the cheapest frozen pizza from you local super market. Thin crust and very very skimpy on the toppings. Manager must severely limit the amount of cheese and topping employees are allowed to use per pizza. To top it all off, pretty darn expensive! read more

Great pizza. Atmosphere is so so, but they have a tv, and a few beers on tap.

I haven't visited enough Bend pizzerias to proclaim this the best in Central Oregon, but this is my favorite Sisters pizzeria! Don't trust the Yelp map, though... it is located along the main drag (Highway 20). read more

Best pizza, hands down. Crust was amazing, I ordered a strega nona and it had roasted rosemary potatoes which they make in the shop, it was to die for, I'd definately recommend this pizza if your going through sisters, great costumer service and fast pizza!! read more

Great family place. Good pizza, friendly service and a small town mom and pop atmosphere. Great if your stopping through!

The staff was so great and nice! They have really good margarita pizza's and the best staff!

I went here with my family and thought it was very good for a pizza place. We had this really great pizza (veggie something) with musrooms, sun dried tomatoes and chevre. It was very good. The are about 20 different types of pizza there. A lot to choose from. Also tried a salad there. It was pretty good as well. read more

Customer service is seriously lacking. Wait time is ridiculous; if you're really hungry go elsewhere. Prices are NOT current on the menus, they're a few dollars higher. Calzones are not worth the money or the extra wait time. Pizza sauce is from a can and has zero personality. We should have read the reviews before we spent money here. Avoid this place if you value your time and money! read more

Most overpriced pizza ever!! Decided to call in a pizza on the way home. It was a small 3 topping pizza and when I got there it was almost $20.00!!! When I commented on how expensive it was for what it was their response was "well if you had ordered one of our regular and taken toppings off it would have been cheaper" How would you know this when calling an order in?? They didn't bother to tell me that and to top it off there were so few toppings on it you could count them, had no flavor and it was tepid at best. Won't be going back there and will stick with the usual pizza place in Sisters read more