This is legitimately one of the best pizzerias in the entire country. Some of the best if not the best pizza I've ever had in my entire life. Try the clam slice--you won't be disappointed. Also so rare to find a place that serves clam pies by the slice rather than by the entire pie! The owner, Mario, is a great guy who's been slinging pies for over 43 years, and it shows in how he's mastered his craft. Everything about his pizza is incredible from the crust to the sauce to the fresh toppings to the crisp texture and amazing wood-fired mouth feel. The ambience is very nice to suit the great pizza--it's very nice to pull up to Mario's and watch the trains go by with all of the passengers getting on and off as you sip on a cold beer or a nice glass of wine over a perfect slice. The inside is fittingly warm and rustic for a pizza place, and the outdoor patio is a great spot for outdoor dining and people watching over the busiest part of Mt. Kisco. Even when Mario is taking a well-deserved break on the patio, his well-trained, skilled, and kind staff will be happy to hook you up. I can't speak enough to the quality of the place, people, and the ambience of this place. One of the best places to grab a slice, some lunch, a nice big dinner, or even just a casual drink. Try the clam slice! read more

This pizza is divine. If it were in the City, people would be waiting in those crazy queues for it. It has a neighborhood feel and I'm going to make it a regular post-hike stop. read more

Best pizza in westchester. I have been searching for months since moving into the area and finally found the perfect pizza and eggplant parm with spaghetti I can't say enough good things. Highly recommend!!! The owner is present, friendly, funny and professional. Will be my go to place from now on read more

I think only the regulars go there bc they must feel bad for the guy. pizza is tasteless

We ordered a couple of pies for pick up and the pizza was okay at best and so overpriced. The pizza dough and sauce aren't very flavorful. We also got a mushroom pizza and they use canned mushrooms on their pizza rather than fresh ones. read more

Place is cute, and clean. Service was adequate... the food looked BEAUTIFUL! but...always a but.... had no flavor, the doughy was raw and not crispy at all. Work on the quality of your dough... then move on to your sauces... the style is fantastic but the flavor or lack of, serving raw dough, and food that was not hot even after just coming out of the oven destroyed your star rating. With better ingredients I would not complain about the cost, but knowing that he usee some of the lowest cost items I have to say $6.50 a slice? read more

See all

From Brooklyn NY came up here for business , Mario was a very nice and the pizza is instantly put in my top five in NY read more

Mario's Pizza & Pasta - Italian Near Me - Mount Kisco, New York

I can't begin to tell you I know I posted recently, but this is such a special place in Mount Kisco some of the best pizza I've had in Westchester County and the entrées are amazing as well. Service is Top notch,ambience is amazing!! read more

See all

Traveling through Westchester County, NY. In the town of Mt. Kisco. Late night in a Sunday when most establishments are closed. The chalkboard had 3 specials on it and we each ordered one. Food was prepared to order, fresh and al dente. Friendly service and pleasant surroundings. It's literally right by the train station and the floor rattles as the train passes by. The experience added to the charm of the place. The display of the fired pizza made me wish I had room for one. Highly recommended this little gem.. all aboard. read more

See all

Good pizza but insanely overpriced, owner likes to short people when giving back change

This is one of the places in town that I frequent to satisfy the good old pizza itch. You get your standard NY pizza here with a paper thin crust and tasty sauce. The cheese is plentiful. I typically walk in and order a few slices to go and the last time, whoever was working was especially friendly. Not much else to say tbh. read more

Quick and convenient basic pizza and pasta joint. Several tables outside too. Food is decent and made fresh in front of you to order and a decent pizza selection read more

Went here for a quick lunch w a friend! I got the Caesar salad and it was so good! I just wish it had more cheese on it since I left half of it uneaten once I ran out of the parm ahaha. Their wood fired slices are amazing! I tried the margarita and it was super tasty :) It's a small place so keep that in mind :) The staff were very friendly! read more

AMAZING slices last night - & just Lasagna Perfection today w/ my Take-Out!! Mario & Fernando are KILLING It, on a daily basis!! read more

Place is amazing, Mario is an absolute gentleman and actually cares about his customers. I go out of my way to come here for the grandma/margarita/baked ziti pizza. read more

Mario's Pizza & Pasta - Specialty Pizza (Large) - Italian Near Me - Mount Kisco, New York

If you like a great slice of pizza, Mario's is your go to place. Their selection of pies is extensive and the service is friendly. My favorites are the pasta slice which is pure decadence and the Buffalo chicken with its nice zing. The crust gets a bit dark during the reheat but I do like it crunchy. read more

I have to say everything is delish but shrimp parm is the absolute best I've ever tasted. Totally recommend Mario's.

Very good!! I ordered a small pepperoni pie, well done. Excellent fast service and fresh food. So good!!

Was absolutely disgusted to find a bug toasted into the slice of pizza, the hygiene of this pizzeria is terrible, I walked in for a late lunch to find flies flying everywhere, there were also flies all around the back part where they make the slices. My hunger stupidly disregarded this and I went forward with buying a slice and after coming back to work and having one bite I see that there is a insect baked into slice of pizza. I immediately spit up the one bite I took and closed the box. I have NEVER been through as disgusted experience as this to the point where I felt the need to post something but this is a PSA for all customers in the area STAY AWAY, I have been to all other pizzerias in the area and they are much better. PLEASE CLEAN UP YOUR RESTAURANT, You ARE BETTER THAN THIS. read more

Mario's Pizza & Pasta - Old fashion slice with a topping I didn't order - Italian Near Me - Mount Kisco, New York

Pizza tasty. Guy tried to rip us off- charged us $97 for two pies, 3 slices, and two beers. After arguing to see the bill breakdown he refused and spent 15 minutes going over the bill with his coworker (it's actually not hard math- just addition). Anyway charged us $8 a beer and the "new" total was $75. Insane and never even told us why we were initially charged $97. Not friendly and bad ambience. Locali right next door is friendly and has delicious pizzas. read more

I wish I could love Mario's because I do think they make great tasting and unique pizza options however the hygiene is so abysmal that I can't overlook it and will no longer revisit and have warned family and friends about it. On two occasions I have come here and witnessed no glove use. Two different gentlemen who were helping me, took my money and then proceeded to touch my pizza. I was hungry and timid to say anything but that's unacceptable. I work at a bank, money is the most disgusting thing you can touch. On average it carries around 43 strains of bacteria on it, and you're touching money then wiping your apron and touching peoples' food?!? NO! You guys need to abide by proper sanitary laws and use disposable gloves for each customer and not handle money with the gloves. It's very disturbing that you take no caution to people's health, and for that, you get 1 star. read more

Stopped in as we had a local job in the area and instantly loved the classic cooking style of the pizza in a brick oven nice cozy place with a great selection of food to order. Place an order on 2 special slices chicken / bacon and a pasta slice which were delicious and warmed just right. My buddie also enjoyed his food. We arrived a bit earlier from lunch time so the place was quick to serve. Over all looks like a clean place and the seating area was great. Well check out the pictures and I hope you enjoy. read more

See all

Love Marios food. I especially love his Margarita Pizza. Best in the area. I have referred all my co-workers and friends to to there.

Mario's never disappoints. Always fresh, diverse and friendly. His chicken dishes are also terrific. My son thinks its the best pizza in the area. read more

I see other customers have already left negative reviews for the same reason I am. I went in to pick up an order this evening and not a single employee was properly wearing a mask. Each had it down below their nose or not on at all. They didn't pull it up to interact with me to run my payment either. It's just extremely irresponsible considering the severity of the virus, especially right now with the new strains and double masking being recommended. On top of that the food was also bad.. overall a really disappointing experience. read more

Solid pizza joint that is literally less than a 5 minute walk from my new place. I love how it's near the train station, so I can grab a slice before or after a train ride to/from GCT. The pizza is heated up in seconds since they use a very hot wood-fired oven. The pizza crust is a bit doughy, but still crispy. The place itself is small, so I don't mind taking out. They have seats outside but it is too cold now. This is my new go to pizza spot in my new hometown of Mount Kisco. read more

I'm giving Mario's one star because they don't follow proper guidelines while doing business! They are not wearing masks or gloves!!! Every other pizza restaurant is following the guidelines. So beware when you are ordering food. Corona virus is not one of the things I want to pick up while ordering pizza! read more

Horrible. Placed an order an 8pm and got a text at 10pm saying they were canceling our order. Everything else is closed near by. Absolutely absurd. read more

I have been going here for years. Such a small pizza place and yet has the best pizza. Staff are friendly. Clean place. Highly recommended.

Pizza was burnt. Cheese so overdone you could not even tell it was cheese. A 12 year old boy ran into get two slices to go. I guess they thought he would never no how bad the pizza was until he got home. I assume they never expected him to turn around and come back to return it. Awful pizza and awful business practices that they would take advantage of a child. Mario said their pizza was not burnt. They however replaced the two slices with much more acceptable looking pieces. Unfortunately my son said it tasted funny. I was not going back again. Bad pizza bad experience . read more

Mario's Pizza & Pasta - Italian Near Me - Mount Kisco, New York

See all

Mario, the owner, welcomes everyone to his restaurant. The food is EXCELLENT!!!! One of my favorite dishes here is penne a la vodka. It is DELICIOUS!!!! I highly recommend this fine little restaurant by the Mount Kisco train station. read more

My wife and I used to love the pizza here. I would order 6 slices for myself every time. We stopped by yesterday, the restaurant wasn't as clean looking as it used to be, I ordered 2 slices, my wife had one. We ate left and as soon as we left the restaurant we both agreed, it was horrible pizza. The sauce was eh, the crust was flavorless, and not fully cooked. We both had indigestion for the rest of the day. Sorry Mario, your pizza is now just like most of the pizza in Northern Westchester horrible. read more

Maybe I'm a pizza snob, but I don't see it. And trust me, I REALLY wanted to. And while I agree, the people are great and the brick oven is nice- the sauce and the crust leave me underwhelmed. Even the toppings/ingredients are nothing special. Not so fresh it will blow your mind or inventive by any stretch. So, now I'm sure the next question will be, what pizza place do you like? Well, in Upper Westchester, that's hard. In lower, I'd say Polpettina in Eastchester. And The Cookery in Dobb's Ferry (which isn't really a pizza joint, but they have great everything- pies included). After that, I'd say Isabella's in Tarrytown. But as for Upper Westchester, the Belizzi from Belizzi's, is actually surprisingly good. Sure, the "place" is a playground, arcade nightmare- and the other pies are a significant drop off, but you only need one- and this one is solid. read more

I don't know what took me so long to finally eat here but I found a true gem. While many places were packed with their Friday evening crowds, I couldn't believe this place was empty but something told me to give it a try. The owner Mario was very personable and appreciative of our business which goes a long way but you probably want to hear about the food (which was excellent). My girlfriend and I shared a personal margarita pizza and a sausage & peppers wedge, both of which were made fresh. In conclusion, I'm looking forward to going back for a real dinner! read more

How did I NOT know this place exists till now? To be fair, I would never walk into a pizzeria next to a train station. But thanks to Yelp, I bypassed my bias. Pizza is sooooo good... not greasy at all and felt so healthy... I know, that doesn't make sense, but it also doesn't make sense to have a really good pizza joint in westchester right next to a train station. I should know, I used to live in the city! read more

Just had lunch at the Old Town Tea House Asian cuisine. Left there still hungry, as the portion was very small. Took a walk and spotted Mario's Pizza. As my friend and I walked in we were amazed at the beautifully displayed selection of pizzas. We just had to try the pizza. I had the meatball slice, it was amazing. My friend had the margarita slice, absolutely loved it, and ordered another one!! We may be from Mahopac, but we will definitely be coming back to Mario's Pizza real soon, and will be trying many other pizzas and dishes. Try Mario's Pizza and thank me later!! read more

Let me first give a caveat, you really need to know what to get: start with the Margherita and Prosciutto pies, and branch out from there. Mario's is so good sometimes, it's astounding. It really is on par with a Grimaldi's or Totonno's, which other people have said, and it's the best pizza I've had in Westchester. This is a gem that needs to be cherished. read more

Consistently good pizza. Brick oven baked, thin crust, tasty pizza. The only negative thing I can say is that it is a bit expensive & they don't deliver. read more

Excellent pizza - tender chewy crust. Not too heavy with the cheese, fresh ingredients. All top notch. My fave - the arugula & prosciutto. Get it if it's there! read more

Mario's Pizza & Pasta - A slice of margarita pizza. - Italian Near Me - Mount Kisco, New York

See all

This pizza is incredible, tons of flavor from the wood pizza oven. Better than 99% of the pizza in the city. Highly recommend!