I came here with my family to spend time with the grandparents. The only negative things that I would have to say about my dining experience is how cold the restaurant was and that the margarita pizza was undercooked. The cheese and the sauce slid off the pizza when I picked up a slice. However, they were able to turn the heat up a little but we were still pretty chilly. I split the margarita pizza with my dad and the fish tacos. I also enjoyed the shishito peppers. Our waiter was really good and professional. Our drinks came quickly as well as our food. Our waiter helped me pick apples outside of the restaurant from the trees that were growing outside. I really enjoyed our dining experience and I know that I can speak for the rest of my family when I say that they did too. I know that if given the chance, I would be more than happy to come back to enjoy another dining experience at Stone Fire Italian. read more

See all

Came here with three friends on a nice Friday evening and sat on the patio -- super cute even though it's right on a main road, but you couldn't really tell with the greenery and umbrellas. The staff were amazing from the start. The hostess was the sweetest, and our waiter was super friendly. They brought out bread with this whipped olive oil/butter spread (I think?) that was really good. I got the chicken Milanese and asked for grilled chicken instead of pan-fried/breaded -- they made it happen and it was so good. My friends had the chicken parm, deconstructed lasagna, and brick chicken, and everyone loved their food. We split the sundae and bomboloni for dessert -- the sundae was huge and super fun to share. Definitely want to come back and try more from the menu! read more

See all

Went here for a late lunch on a Monday afternoon. Our waiter Oscar, was welcoming and friendly. The generous portions of food were flavorful and fresh. The sweet potato fries were perfectly crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. The carbonara was a little too salty but the pasta was cooked perfectly. I would definitely go back for more! read more

See all

Stone Fire is a gem! Intimate setting. Friendly staff. The food was outstanding from the bread with white bean dip, appetizer and entree. As a vegan I often have limited or no real options. Here I had plentiful choices. It was a wonderful experience! read more

Stone Fire Italian - Verdure Calde - Pizza Near Me - Mount Kisco, New York

Another great experience when I went with some friends. The menu is fantastic, wait staff and all employees are kind and caring. This place is a true gem when it comes to Italian Restaurants in Westchester! I do not think you will ever have a bad meal there. read more

I have been meaning to try this place out. The menu looks incredible and I very much appreciate their vegetarian options. We ordered via DoorDash after a long 12 hour shift. I would've killed someone for pizza the night prior so that was a given. I almost lost my shit when I saw BEYOND bolognese on the menu. Of note, they also have beyond lasagne. Dead. GF, being the mushroom bitch that she is, ordered the mushroom pasta. I didn't pay too much attention to her order but remember seeing a "fungi" somewhere in the name and I can only hope that is the kind of fungi they were referring to. We were in suspense waiting for the food to arrive. It took quite a while, certainly longer than the delivery estimate. This was the first indication that things might be going awry but I have heard that good things come to those that wait so we pressed on with the waiting. The doorbell rang and GF fetched the delivery. As she walked towards me, pizza box in hand, I noticed the bag on top of the pizza box was suspiciously small. Too small to conceivably contain two pasta dishes. Our fears were confirmed when we dug into the bag. There was only one pasta. There were no fungi in the vicinity so for a few precious moments I was under the impression I actually got what I ordered. I soon discovered what had been delivered was ziti with vodka sauce. Strange, neither of us ordered that... The pizza was very good but cold. I called them immediately, at 8:41 to be exact. According to their phone's message, they should be open until 9. The was no answer. I left a message but have not received a response. I can't express how frustrating it is to wait for a while with such anticipation for an order just to not receive it. I mean, how much effort does it take to confirm you are sending someone what is on the receipt? Isn't providing a customer what they order a pretty basic, elementary function of a restaurant? The level of laziness that is clearly evident is pathetic. If you like having a choice in what you receive from a restaurant, skip this one. read more

Stone Fire Italian - Vodka sauce but not what I ordered - Pizza Near Me - Mount Kisco, New York

See all

Everything about this place is absolutely amazing! I've been here multiple times with my boyfriend and every time Has been an amazing time. The food here is absolutely amazing! My absolute favorite French onion soup is made here. The staff is always been so friendly and accommodating and the food taste amazing. Only negative about this place in my opinion is the chairs do not have a comfortable cushion on. It's just metal seat. read more

See all

Food was very good service was excellent manager as well as all staff pay attention I will go back !

I enjoyed the Diavalo pizza, and finished my meal with the bread pudding with salted caramel gelato. The sweet potato part of the dessert wasn't sweet, but the bread portion and gelato was good. Maybe the sweet potato wasn't blended very well. I decided to go while waiting on my relative to come out of surgery. The restaurant is a short walk from the hospital, but they do have parking. read more

Stone Fire Italian - Diavalo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mount Kisco, New York

See all

I had a great brunch here! We started with the tangy deep fried cauliflower which was delicious! I ordered the chicken and waffles and my friend got some type of bacon egg sandwich. Both were absolutely perfect. My chicken was extra crispy, the bacon was crunchy and waffles were tasty. The sandwich was gorgeous with homemade home fries with lots of peppers and onions. We enjoyed everything and our server was excellent. read more

See all

Really authentic Italian cuisine, the bar is small yet intimate. I've had several pasta dishes and they were all amazing.

Had the pleasure today of the service of Norca. Who made an amazing cocktail which was the mango margarita which was out of this world, . Norca is a great server/bartender who makes an awesome drink l. Thank you for making this holiday weekend even more wonderful.The photo is of Ms Norca at work making this wonderful cocktail.. happy eating and drinking. Very nice peaceful establishment. Also had the pleasure of ordering a pepperoni pizza which was fabolous by the way. You can check out Norca at this establishment. Happy eating and drinking ... read more

Stone Fire Italian - Mango Margarita made by Ms. Norca - Pizza Near Me - Mount Kisco, New York

Excellent food and service . Oscar our server / bartender did an outstanding job . Perfect for a good meal , many beers to choose from too.

Great atmosphere and food. Reasonably priced, friendly staff, and clean. Pizzas were awesome as well as the burrata with fresh peaches. Also had brunch there and that was also good. If I had to be picky the service was slow. Other than that, pretty good read more

Delicious food all around. Would definitely recommend getting any of the pizzas and salmon. We loved the sundaes as well

Was there the other week for an event and the chicken platter came out completely Raw. Thank god I looked before I started eating read more

Stone Fire Italian - Raw chicken - Pizza Near Me - Mount Kisco, New York

I had a nice lunch here with a bigger group and we got a table upstairs which was cute and had lots of windows. I think it would be a great spot for a private party too. the staff were patient and helpful while we ordered and food came out quick. we had a mix of pizzas and salads, including gluten free options. I got the cauliflower appetizer too and really liked it. read more

We went to Stone Fire to celebrate Mother's Day and 2 birthdays. The staff was pleasant and accommodating in letting me decorate the table prior to the rest of the party arriving even though the place was packed. Our waiter was very attentive and helpful. The food was wonderful and came out very quickly. We will definitely be back. read more

I had dinner at the Stonefire Italian restaurant this evening. The food was excellent and the service superb. Our waitress, Diana was the best. Very, very friendly, courteous and attentive. My pasta dish, White, Bolognese was absolutely superb. The best I've had at any Italian restaurant. If you have not yet had dinner at Stone Fire Italian you should definitely check it out. The best part is their prices are affordable and their portions are quite large. I will definitely make this my go to Italian restaurant. I ate downstairs by the bar, but I do know that there is an upstairs dining area and I'm not aware of the ambience on that level. The ambience at the bar level was typical of a bar eating area. read more

Food was average at best. Service was not great. We had to wait even though we had a reservation. The entire experience was very disappointing. read more

Cozy bar but there are enough tables to eat a full meal. Food is excellent for this neighborhood gem.

We've been coming here for years, so this review is long over due. This place is great because my husband and I can have a great dinner, while my picky daughter can have pizza... without feeling like I'm in a pizzeria. The place is beautiful, clean and the staff are great. You can have a drink and apps at the bar while catching the latest sports games (multiple TVs), sit upstairs for a romantic dinner, or out on the patio with the family. Drinks are fresh with specials changing seasonally. Can't say enough good things about this place. My kids would rather eat at home with their Italian heritage, but this is the one place that really checks all the boxes!!!! If you haven't eaten here already....change that!! read more

Pizza good. Entrees bad. Had the eggplant and bolognese; wouldn't order again. Cheese pizza was solid, but probably not good enough for me to go there again. read more

Second time in a week! The weather was amazing and we wanted local - the patio was so comfortable great Zen music and wine for starters. We enjoyed the clams casino so much the only pix was an empty plate. Our pasta dishes were amazing! Calabrian shrimp scampi over black linguini and linguini with clam sauce and shrimp. We could not have left happier. Too full for dessert! read more

See all

This place is a little hidden gem that if it wasn't for a word of mouth recommendation I would have never found. The food was absolutely amazing! The service was fantastic and surprisingly very quick. It's an old house that was converted into a quaint little restaurant, downstairs has a nice bar area with seating and upstairs is a more private intimate dining area. It's very clean and well lit with natural light. If you are looking for some unique Italian dishes other than your standard plates give this place a try and you won't regret it. read more

See all

My new favorite Italian Restaurant. "Let's go somewhere different ". I hadn't been to Stone Fire in a long while so that was my suggestion. We were celebrating a birthday and a reservation for 3 was booked on a Wednesday evening. The restaurant is 2 floors, the bar being on the entry level. A nice room with a lot of windows and tables along the perimeter. Several specials enhanced the menu which is extensive. Instead of ordering an appetizer we decided to split an order of Carbonara. The bucatini was al denti, the sauce was made as in Rome, no silly peas, onion, or cream. I don't remember eating one better. I would give this dish 10 stars if I could. The Pork Chop Scarpariello was delicious. Cedar roasted Norwegian salmon with quinoa and crispy brusssel sprout salad was perfectly done as requested. For dessert we had an order of zeppole that were light with a lemon flavor. The staff couldn't have been more attentive. The food was amazing. As we walked to the car we agreed that a return visit very soon was required. read more

Food is absolutely delicious! Some of the best pasta I've had in a long time. Love the vibe as well!

Great deal on the dinner specials where you can get a full tray of the entree, pasta, salad and a bottle of wine for $55 which can feed for about 6 people or become leftovers for a few days if a smaller group. We tried the chicken parm and penne vodka which were both good. Haven't dined in but the takeout was efficient. read more

Stone Fire Italian - Chicken Parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - Mount Kisco, New York

See all

Great food and very nice bar! The brick oven pizzas are excellent. The service is great; everyone is very nice. read more

We've been living in the area for years, but only recently (thankfully) discovered this place! The ambiance is really great and sophisticated, we don't often get that in restaurants in Westchester. Hands down, we loved the truffle Mac and cheese and the Szechuan cauliflower! As vegetarians, we tried basically all their veggie options. The Spaghetti Squash Pomodoro was just OK, I don't understand why they couldn't just use regular pasta. The Beyond Bolognese was disappointing, it was watery and had almost no taste. Especially after the Mac and cheese and Szechuan cauliflower, the main courses were disappointing, but that just shows how good the first two were. Will be back! read more

See all

My favorite Italian place in Mt. Kisco. Friendly service and always accommodating. The arancini are excellent. For entrees, you can't go wrong with the Margherita pizza or the Diavolo. The real star is the slutty skillet dessert. It's a must have. read more

Always Great Food New Choices Flavors and Spirits to Match. Staff is the Top Professional in the Business and Always Know how to have a Lovely Meal with Family Friends and Loves!!! read more

See all

I cannot agree more with Chaz B's review, except maybe the Viagra part :) The space has seen a number of owners and cuisines come and go. As the parking is ample and the space comfortably laid out on two floors, it seems like it should be a winner. Stone Fire just reminds me of a half-dozen other dining spots in Westchester - pastas, pizzas, a daily "special" or two, and a crappy wine list. Don't get me wrong, the pastas were good, albeit a bit over salted. But there was nothing that stood out. read more

See all

Another review, so much to say! I ordered take out many times throughout the pandemic, some favorites are the pizzas: Zucca, Caprino, Arugula & Prosciutto, and my favorite the Napolitano. My "go to" dish is the spaghetti squash pomodoro! Light, healthy, delicious and lasts me for three servings! I was back on the outdoor patio, spaced for social distancing, the first day they re-opened outdoor seating. I came with a friend and we were so impressed with the personal attention we received from the wait staff, the manager, Justin and the owner Gianni. We felt safe and so happy to be back to some feeling of normalcy. I arranged to bring nine teacher friends to the patio where they set up two tables for us to share. We had every appetizer on the menu and delicious drinks as we celebrated the end of remote learning. A few even brought take out home to their families. The deconstructed lasagna was a huge hit! Jaleel was our server, super sweet and attentive! I also ordered a Family Feast to celebrate Father's Day. We had Chicken Francese, a pasta, a salad and a bottle of wine, along with the New Yorker Pizza and the Caprino Pizza. It fed seven, and we had left overs, too! I have been back three more times in the past few weeks. I tried a new dish: Raditore Tuscana, which was incredible! Even the bread they serve is unique, fresh, and yummy! Attention to detail is so great at Stone Fire, they bring a water bottle to each table, and refill it so it is never empty. Shout out to Jordan, Lisa, Stephanie, Lillian, Brenda, Teak, and all the bar/serving/kitchen staff! Love your food Chef Tommy! Thanks Justin & Gianni for creating such a friendly, well run, clean & safe place where I feel welcomed, and I know I will have a delicious meal every time! Love you! It is a beautiful environment where I feel comfortable and safe. You can take a picture of the QR code at the table and see the menu, all in photos with descriptions right on your phone. read more

See all

The service was very attentive and the menu varied with many choices. I had a salad and a pizza which was very good. The pasta was just ok. The kiss of death was when I went into the restroom and the soap dispenser was empty. Ew. read more

Had a very pleasant first visit at Stone Fire this afternoon. I would definitely come back to this restaurant based off of the service alone - the food came out fast and the waitstaff were incredibly attentive and efficient. The food itself was pretty good for the price point (worth it given the neighborhood, ambiance of the restaurant and quality of the food) but I was a bit disappointed by the chicken meatballs, I felt they could've had more flavor and I found the red sauce to be on the thinner, watery side. The rest of the food, however, was great. The burrata was delicious. My girlfriends ordered the rustico pizza and fungi pizza, while I didn't try it looked good and they were happy with their food. I loved the Calabrian shrimp scampi, the spice was not overpowering and the black linguini was delicious. All of their pasta is homemade and you can tell! Overall a really nice first time dining here, hope to be back in the future! read more

See all

I enjoy coming here with my family, all the food is really good and everyone is really nice and hospitable. The ambiance is lively with a happy atmosphere. They have the best chicken parm of any place I ever had it. I would highly recommend the chicken parm. read more

Visited this establishment a couple of days ago and absolutely loved the pizza and the truffle mac & cheese. The service was excellent and prompt. I, personally, am not a fan of overbearing wait staff and here the staff was polite. Slight tick down for the check being brought the moment we were done eating despite the restaurant not being busy at all. However, after we paid there was no pressure to leave. Well lit and clean. Would definitely recommend. read more

This was some of the best Italian food I have ever had. My three dining partners agree. Each of us had something different and all was absolutely delicious. The service was warm and friendly. We can't wait to go back. read more

First time visit..wont be last. Googled restaurants in Mt. Kisco and this one looked interesting so..we went. Excellent service and food! Res. At 630 sat downstairs in bar area. Nicely appointed. At around 7 pm the place came alive. Full. Had a chicken special which was excellent..she had unstructured lasagna which was also good. Prices were reasonable. Would definitely RECOMMEND! read more