From the moment you walk in, it feels like a real neighborhood Italian spot--not pretentious, not…read morerushed, just warm and welcoming. The food is the star here: fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. Everything we ordered was spot-on, from the perfectly cooked pasta to the rich, balanced sauces that actually taste homemade (because they are). Service was attentive without hovering--exactly how it should be. You can tell the staff genuinely cares about the experience, not just turning tables. Portions are generous, prices are fair, and the quality punches way above what you'd expect for a local spot. If you're in Mahopac and want legit Italian food done right--this is the place. Trattoria Sei just gets it. We'll be back.

I've been here a few times with my in-laws and every time it's been great. It's a quaint little…read morerestaurant, but a great ambience and great service. Easily the best Italian food I've had in Mahopac and always my go to when visiting. I would recommend the chicken vodka parm. Just look out the portions are huge! Great spot!

Chop salad with chicken was wonderful at Oscars. We also had fresh rolls…read more Service was great.

I love their salads and appetizers. Due to my special dietary requirements I order mainly grilled…read moresalmon. I must stop ordering from Oscar II due to the fact that whenever I order grilled salmon (medium) the inside is mush. There is absolutely no consistency to it. This is a rather expensive dish. I always order a dinner salad and dessert with it. I am a long time customer but I give up. The WORST thing was when I called to talk to the manager about the salmon (food), they text me telling me to text Grubhub (delivery service). Too many places serve grilled salmon and other wonderful dishes. If you can't cook grilled salmon correctly then I will not recommend you further nor will you get my patronage.

Went in on for Easter, and all I can say is wow. Amazing ambiance right when you walk in. We…read moreordered fried calamari which tasted like it was caught yesterday, the bread was so warm and amazing! Ordered the bolognese and it came out so fast and was absolutely fantastic. Will be coming g back!!

Music performance by "Sounds Familiar" 5/5 Food Quality…read more 5/5 Beverage Quality (Iced Tea & Cappuccino) 2/5 Ambiance 3/5 Friendliness of Staff 5/5 Valentine's Day - Wait for Drinks 1 hr. 0/5 Valentine's Day - Wait for Dinner 1.5 hrs. 0/5 Apologies after apologies but no accommodations were offered.

Recently came here for a work holiday party. The service here is 10/10. The bartenders and staff…read moreare so friendly! I loved my espresso martini and my hubby loved his blue Hawaiian. The food here is pretty average. I got the salad with broccoli rabe and the rib eye.

The service was exceptional and the food was very good…read more Dined here on a Friday night with friends for the first time. The two women had chicken parmigiana but were slightly disappointed with the sauce and chicken quality. My friend was happy with his chicken francese as was I with the boneless pork chop.

My wife & I went out for an early Valentines Day meal. We were sitting at a booth in the bar. At…read morefirst, when we walked in, the service seemed promising. Our waiter was accommodating & friendly. My wife & I ordered cocktails, which were delicious. We got an appetizer & some oysters. My wife didn't care for the appetizer. I ate it. I also ate the oysters bc my wife doesn't like them, in general. She ordered the petit filet mignon from the bar menu. She ordered it "medium." When it came out my wife cut it in half & it was extremely rare. Gelatinous & dark red. The waiter never checked back in with us, so I ate about half of my meal. I had to flag down another waiter. We aren't difficult customers, so we asked them to take it back & cook it more. It came back, with our original server & his apologies, but it was hardly cooked at all & was now closer to medium rare, but I'd say still closer to rare. It was smothered in new sauce. We were disappointed, and asked another waitstaff to send it back & cook it more. While it was gone, I finished my meal & someone offered us dessert menus. We explained we were still waiting for our entree. When it last came back, the entire steak had been cut into little pieces & was well done. No one checked on us. The waiter never came back. I was kind've upset & decided to set a stop watch & I left it running on the edge of the table so that everyone who walked by would notice a timer running. We waited & waited. I finally got up & walked into the restaurant, hoping they were really busy & that's why the service was so unattentive. There was 1 table in the whole restaurant apart from the bar. It's Super Bowl Sunday today. I saw the waiter, standing in what I presume to be a server station area, & once I saw there was only one other table I had seen enough. From what I could tell he was on his phone & didn't notice I came within his field of view. To be honest, I can't say for 100% he was on his phone, but it seemed like he was staring at a wall. I'm assuming a shelf was there & he was looking at his phone. I came back to the table & my wife went to go ask for the check. She never ate more than a bite of the steak, & she ate a couple fries. She asked them to take it away. By & large, her meal was completely untouched, other than by the kitchen. When the server brought us the check, we asked him if the steak had been taken off & he actually said "yes," & showed us a discount of $26. That made us feel better. We weren't happy with the place, but at least we weren't paying for something they couldn't get right & she didn't eat bc of it. So, fine, as long as we aren't paying for it, we'll just leave & won't likely ever go back. No big deal, except as I looked at the bill, the steak WASN'T taken off the bill. The discount was for our happy hour drinks. I went back to find him & said, "let's figure this out here. What is the $26 discount for?" He said "it was the happy hour drinks." I said, "she never ate the steak," and he said "she didn't?!" Yeah, Brohan, she didn't. You would've known that if you'd came anywhere near doing your job & actually served us instead of playing on your phone in another room, & giving tepid service & assuming by putting on your tie & being friendly you'd land a 20% tip. Which I actually still gave him a 20% tip, but not bc he earned it. I did it bc he seemed like a nice guy, but he was a nice guy & a mediocre waiter. He was knowledgeable about the menu, & seemed like he meant to do well, but... IDK what happened, but it was a bad experience. They took the steak off the bill. We left, having paid over $100 with the tip included & my wife only had a couple of french fries. From the outside, & walking in, the place looked promising. The service was mostly lacklustre. I say that bc when we needed something, there were enough other servers (2) walking by that we could flag them for assistance. You know what would've been nice? Start over. Get her a new piece of steak and get it right. Or hire someone who can do a better job. The steak came out black & blue to begin with. It was a 6 oz piece. I get it, you don't want to have food waste, but now you've got disgruntled customers & a bad review. Check in with your table! It was the lack of communication that killed our business with you.

Another great meal chicken palm was so light and soft tender. He did I got it with the spaghetti…read morethat was in the mood for spaghetti and meatballs, but I went for the chicken Parm.

Pizza was good, but being originally from the Bronx (best pizza back in the day) I am picky about…read morepizza. I like a crisp thin pizza, the slice I had was cooked fine but didn't have that snap! A little too much cheese. Will go back and try something else ( a different pizza variety $

Tasteless veggie pizza. Crust too chewy and doughy. Seemed almost not cooked enough. For me to toss…read moreleftover pizza instead of wrapping up for another time it was not worth it. No real Ambiance as it seemed tomorrow they pick up and take out place. Wanted to like it due to proximity and nice staff but will skip next time.

I'm looking into restaurants where I can host my daughter's graduation party. We recently heard…read moreabout this place so I wanted to try it before considering it as an option. We went last night for dinner. Made a reservation for 6:30 and were seated immediately upon arrival. We tried the Eggplant Stack as an appetizer and were blown away! It was delicious!! Our entrees were just as good. All of the staff were very friendly and the ambiance is beautiful. We will definitely be back soon.

Service was not good. Can't blame the staff. It seemed like the owner (son Michael, not Lisa)just…read moregot them off the street. No experience. We were rushed through the entire dinner. Not good. Very disappointed. We come here a lot Lisa the owner was not there. That explains it Although her son Michael was there. Not up to par Lisa you need to oversee everything. Michael was not checking on tables like you do.

We have been going to Mario's for over 25 years. One of our favorite restaurants in the area…read more Everything is very good. A++++

A cozy Italian-American in Mahopac on Route 6, that is worth a trip from anywhere!…read more The review, may sound like hyperbole, but it's not! A friend mentioned it had good food, great prices, and table service and he was going down there, so we all stopped in for lunch. Great decision. The prices are very reasonable! One of the best Italian-American restaurant/pizzerias I've found in years; and I've eaten more than my share of pizza in many countries. Only top quality ingredients are used! We each ordered a different 12" pizza, one for each of us. In hindsight, we could've ordered one pizza that the three of could have shared and would we have been satiated! My significant other ordered a prosciutto and arugula pizza. She had one at Cancino's in Mexico City November 2019 and LOVED it. We've never seen it on another menu here. So, when she saw it on their menu, she ordered it right away! It was perfect! There was about 4 ounces of arugula and the $20 something a pound prosciutto on it. See the photo. No crispy cremated prosciutto chips nor wilted arugula arrived to the table. My friend had the red meat pizza. It looks like about a pound of sausage meat and a whole pepperoni was sliced and put on his pizza. He kept picking pepperoni off his pizza and putting it on ours. What we had looked like a normal pepperoni pizza; there was that much on his! There was a small group who ordered pasta dishes. They looked great also. Yelpers get a 10% discount.

Great pizza Stopping by for a slice…read more Or calling in for pies Also a large variety of salad options Friendly, local!!

Heading up 684 from LaGuardia and needed NY slice right away! Yelp reviews were positive so we gave…read moreit a try. Not disappointed in any way. First, they were open at night and served by the slice. Just a short drive off the highway, their pizza was exactly what we needed, kept it simple, just a slice of cheese and they did it right. Crust was perfect, everything else was correctly portioned. There are a few tables and a counter for dine in. Service was friendly, nice variety of pizzas to choose from including Sicilian.

I had not eaten in this restaurant for many years, mainly because I had forgotten about it. Well,…read moreI'm glad the couple who joined my wife and me there last Saturday night mentioned it!! The atmosphere is very alive, and it grows in intensity as the place fills up at the bar and the tables. We were all very pleased with our drinks, my Chianti, and our meals. I asked the waitress about their bolognese sauce, and she, being a bolognese fan herself, raved about it. She didn't steer me wrong! It was "molto bene"!! The whole experience, from atmosphere to service to the food, was very well done. We look forward to returning...many times! Ciao!

This place is ALWAYS busy seemingly ALL the time! Be aware that the parking area does NOT…read moreaccommodate! Terribly difficult to navigate back there. Small but specialized Italian menu and the 'Specials' never disappoint. Pretty generous portions and great drinks! Never did their pizza but have sampled a variety of their dishes. Excellent warm fresh bread brought to the table. Would have liked fresh pepper and crushed red pepper without having to flag someone down. That's the only other negative comment. Most of the wait staff is excellent, but there are one or two people we look out for to run from.