Stopped by on our way up to New England from Virginia. We always love trying new places when we travel and the pizza was perfect. Greasy and floppy in the best way. read more

Iconic local pizza place with onsite owner that really cares. Get a slice & a coke. Then some ice-cream for dessert. You'll feel like a kid again. read more

1 time, the large pizza I bought did not look freshly made. The cooked dough, sauce and cheese were extremely dry.

Great pizza Stopping by for a slice Or calling in for pies Also a large variety of salad options Friendly, local!! read more

Heading up 684 from LaGuardia and needed NY slice right away! Yelp reviews were positive so we gave it a try. Not disappointed in any way. First, they were open at night and served by the slice. Just a short drive off the highway, their pizza was exactly what we needed, kept it simple, just a slice of cheese and they did it right. Crust was perfect, everything else was correctly portioned. There are a few tables and a counter for dine in. Service was friendly, nice variety of pizzas to choose from including Sicilian. read more

Brought home two special slices and a chicken cutlet sandwich. Right on the money and friendly service. I'll be back read more

I LOVE FRANKS!! I live right here in croton falls too. The thin crust is to die for. I'm super suuuuper picky about pizza and they never fail so to satisfy. 100/10! Also they have amazing ice cream choices.. it changes though so you don't get stuck with the same flavors each time. read more

Pizza was decent but a bit overpriced. 1 of the 3 Pizza's I got was small, w/Mushrooms, Sauce, no Cheese. $24? I spent $94 for 3 small pies and 2 house salads. My old coach used to have a sign in his office: "Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me." read more

Great Italian food , fresh hot and delicious ! Very convenient and great location.. good prices .

Pizza is out of this world and best pizza around. its worth the 30 minute drive. id rate it more than a 5 star if i could

I went cause me and my bf wanted to try it plus it's right next to the metro north so easy dinner. I have to say 50 bucks for some half decent food made me upset. I also left a tip so it came out to 60. I will not be coming there again unless I need a quick slice and im starving... read more

Incredible pizza and sandwiches - the bread is the best I have probably ever had - eggplant - roasted peppers - broccoli rabe and fresh mozzarelle - don't miss this place - we jumped off the highway for a quick lunch and were blown away! Super nice owner and staff! read more

This spot was bomb. Among the many pizzeria and Italian spots we got the most flavor and bang for our buck. I'm pretty sure we were ordering with Frank himself as he was super helpful in asking questions and pointed us to a menu to help out with deciding - we just couldn't decide! My husband got a slice of Chicken Bacon Ranch which was SO GOOD. Try it if you are curious. I'd never think to put ranch on a pizza like that, maybe to dip, but it was goooooood. The garlic knots (which was claimed to be a special) were ACTUALLY really special. They had buttery goodness and garlic within each bite. And the flavor was actually there - I feel like some garlic knots are just bread. Oh, and the marinara sauce. Damn. A little spicy but not too overwhelming. Lastly the Margherita pie. Sheesh. That's all I gotta say. read more

See all

If you're looking for the best pizza in the area, look no further. It's obvious after tasting their food for the first time that they use quality ingredients; which has not changed since the beginning of the pandemic (which unfortunately; I have found to be the case at other places I frequent often) The staff is top notch, very friendly, knowledgeable, and most importantly; customer service oriented. I had a special request this time around, chicken francese pizza! They were more than happy to accommodate. I will continue to frequent Frank's when I am in the area, its best to shop small, and it's a great feeling to support local business during these trying times. Keep up the great work Frank's! read more

Frank's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Croton Falls, New York

We decided to try a new pizza spot since Mahopac pizza scene is pretty old. My son told me about Frank's since he frequents the train station. I had my son order, when we went to pick him up, pizza was ready. We took it home and the presentation was great and it tasted even better. I definitely found my new pizza spot! read more

Frank's Pizzeria - Chicken bacon ranch Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Croton Falls, New York

I finally decided to try out this place. This grandma pie was soooo good! I definitely recommend this pizzeria! read more

Frank's Pizzeria - 8 Slices Grandma's - Pizza Near Me - Croton Falls, New York

Food and service is Excellent! Best Pizza I've ever had!! Everyone is Super nice and Polite!!!

Fabulous pizza! very accommodating staff. So easy to order ahead online or by phone. You gotta try them, the best local pizzeria!

Food and service is very good, Frank and his staff do a really good job, definitely recommend.

Crunch! Crunch! Pizza lunch! We stopped in for a pizza and an Italian sub on our road trip based on yelp reviews and we were not steered wrong! We got a half cheese/ half pepperoni pizza. I don't know how to explain this any other way; my 7 year old ate TWO slices and actually ate the crust! It was amazing. Side note: They do not have a bathroom which I was going to ding them a star for as a deal breaker, but I can't. It was just so good and it was worth taking my five and seven year old out of the car twice and using the gas station bathroom. Thanks for being so kind to us! The extra plates and napkins were very appreciated! I wish we could have stayed for ice cream, but the road calls! Family approval: 4/4 (3/4 of us is considered a "win") read more

Frank's Pizzeria - This is what was left after 15 minutes! My kids are usually not big eaters! - Pizza Near Me - Croton Falls, New York

I'm over Frank's. I used to order all the time for every occasion. Salads, pizza, soups, wedges, trays all delicious. But then, I received a pie with a hole in it, yes you read that right. It looked like a donut. So the next time I went to place an order, another rather large order, I mentioned to the manager about the incident and could he make it right. He proceeded to tell me there was a hole because it got stuck in the oven and pretty much it was my problem. I asked to have Frank call me since he was not going to help and I never got a call. I even stopped by to leave my number in person and I got nothing. So from that day forward, they lost my business. read more

So , I am pizza guy , and I understand everyone has the right to make a living. But honestly feel I was screwed. So here it is ... For 1 large pie , ( 2 toppings ) 2 -20 ounce sodas , and a Chicken Parmigan Wedge the price was $ 51.00 !!! Now for the exact same order the guy down the street charges 42.00 ..that's a 9.00 difference. So I go to the website to check prices .. Naaa , no menu costs @ all , only that they will penalize you 4.50 for a light order. Then , the kid who delivers the food thinks I'm giving him $ 9.00 tip on the 60.00 I gave him for a 1.5 mile delivery. I delivered thousands of pizzas in high school , I always give a good tip too ... But this crazy. Is this some crazy employee building an Ark or something ? Or does this guys think his pizza is that much better than the guy down the street. My answer ... Naaa , Parm gets a 6.5 , Pizza gets 6.3 , total score = 6.4 / 10.00 .. I'll tell you what .. that's an honest score , even with the price gauging . I'm done with this place.YeahNoThanks read more

We got our usual pizza tonight - roasted red peppers and sausage - and as usual it was FANTASTIC. What was different tonight is we also ordered cannolis and they were beyond fantastic. So good and freash!! Now we will probably order cannolis everytime we get pizza from Frank's. there goes the diet. p.s. delivery is quick and perfect. read more

Pizza and sandwiches are amazing. Everyone there are very friendly. To bad they're closed on Sundays.

The best. End of story. I have tried just about every pizza place in mahopac. Franks wins. When you go to the location the place is so clean. SIMPLY THE BEST , BETTER THAN ALL THE REST. read more

Best garlic knots hands down! Marinara sauce that will make you want to lick the bowl. This place has some awesome food. The owners have really put their heart into this place and it shows. Can't wait until our next visit! read more

See all

Franks is our go to pizza place in the area for takeout or delivery. The pizza is delicious and I highly recommend their chicken parm meal. The salsa are wonderful and come with a generous portion of grilled chicken. This is more of a take out and go place than a sit down and dine restaurant because they don't have a bathroom. If you eat there and need a bathroom you have to go next door to another bar/restaurant to use theirs. This was a problem when I was there with my kids having dinner and one had to use the bathroom because that meant everyone had to stop eating and walk next door to use the bathroom. I read more

If you have the opportunity to go to Frank's, just do it! You will not be disappointed. Great pizza, great wedges, great service. Their sauce is amazing and staff is very friendly and efficient. Enjoy! read more

A nice little pizzeria in Croton Falls. Bought a single plain slice. It was pretty good. Not too far off from city or Long Island pizza. Tasty, cheesy, thin slice with a great tasting crust. Clean place that doubles as an ice cream shop. Excellent for a quick slice while I was fishing in the area. It was $3.10 Though for a single slice! read more

Frank's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Croton Falls, New York

Stopped here for the first time looking for a quick late lunch. I had a slice of the chicken and ranch pizza. My companion had the hot cherry pepper and chicken slice. Both were good! Would have liked it hotter temperature wise but will ask next time. Small place, yet efficient and clean! read more

Frank's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Croton Falls, New York

See all

Frankly, the best pizza in our area! Wonderful staff and service very high quality food.

They just started doing cheesesteaks according to the menu and it is this writer's opinion that they got lots of room for improvement. Inadequate meat to bread ratio, steak overcooked, not enough peppers. onions or mushrooms and the American cheese was tasteless. Had a side of Marinara sauce to compensate but t it was way too salty. All in all Not worth the $9 asking price. On a positive note they were getting plenty of pizza business and Wifey sorta liked her slice. Hope they read this and work on improving the cheesesteak. Stars mostly for the genuinely courteous service. Be your own Judge. read more

Good food and good people. My wife especially likes their spaghetti with meat sauce. I have never had a bad pizza from there. Yo do need to remember to order early on either Friday or Saturday night as that is when they are very busy. I highly recommend it. read more

Great food - great smells - great atmosphere. This Family-owned business is the greatest I have ever visited. Everytime I am in town I stop for a quick bite because of how good the food is. I am always greeted with a smile and a warm welcome. Food is an 11/10!!! A must stop if you are driving by! (The pizza is heavenly) They also have super yummy Icecream!!!! read more

Frank's is definitely a go to place for pizza plus!! First of all, while many places no longer offer zucchini sticks, they have the best I ever tasted!! They also have amazing pizza! When my son visits from school, this is where he gets his pizza,....and he has tried many! We are so happy to have you locally!! read more

Best pizza around!! Consistently good. If you're ordering for Friday dinner be ready to possibly wait a bit longer. We'll worth the wait!

Recently moved to the area and had a hard time finding good pizza until...we found Franks. Don't be shy. Give it a try.

In Brewster for hockey and had an hour between games. Came to Franks for pizza / pasta. Friendly staff, Frank was making a pizza as we walked in. Had one slice of the Arthur Avenue (sausage and cherry peppers) at their recommendation and the pasta with sausage. Both were great. Pizza has great crisp crust, good sauce and good balance of heat and flavor. Pasta was prepared fresh and had great tomato sauce and good portion. read more

The sandwiches are good and the pizza is okay. The staff is quite pleasant and the outdoor seating is a plus. The large pizza is really a medium so be ready for that. It's eight slices but very small ones. read more

Really very good pizza, meticulously prepared by two of the nicest folks in town. And did I mention its in town. What a joy to welcome real pizza to the food desert that is Carmel and Somers and Croton Falls. Super convenient and super good. And it's right in town.... read more