I've gotta update my review to 10/5 stars if I could cause even though I'm in the city every week, I save my pizza cravings for this spot! This particular Amore location makes the greatest Nonna and Margherita pizza ever. My parents and husband cannot get enough either. Amore is a weekly thing. Get the personal or large pan of either pie, made fresh, and their Caesar salad or spinach and garlic, and a seat outside on a nice night. Their pizza drips with this golden olive oil, a little salt, fresh tomatoes, and divine cheese. I cannot get enough and come here weekly! The best! And we adore the people who work here, too. 5 stars!!!! read more

Amore Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen - Katonah - Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Katonah, New York

Great pizza, high quality ingredients. The other establishments in area are just slinging slices. read more

Tried this place out and enjoyed their bruschetta We ordered 3 specialty pies and the buffalo chicken pizza was the best. Their square pizzas are also really really good. Give them a try if you are in the area. read more

Spectacular quaint spot in a beautiful town that feels straight out of a story book. Go here and don't think twice. The classic cheese pizza is stupidly good. read more

In my opinion the best pizza in the area. Reminds me of the pizza of my youth. Small shop maybe 10 tables tucked away on a quiet street. Limited parking but there is a small lot behind the shop. Friendly staff. read more

I had one of the best salad slices that I have had in a long time. The salad was fresh and the crust was perfectly done crispy just the way I like it. I asked the chef to please make sure that the crust was crispy. I never liked soggy crust, and he accommodated me beautifully. when I finished my pizza, the chef had given me a special treat, a dessert slice that he had made from scratch with fresh peaches and almonds. Amazing -however I was so full from the salad slice I couldn't finish the whole thing ;so I brought home the leftovers to my husband who loved it. Wish they were open late night just to go for dessert and coffee. read more

See all

Best NY pizza!! Perfect amount of cheese, perfect crunch, perfect atmosphere! Lots of options for slices and pies. Hop off the train and get some! Friendly service with eagerness to feed you! read more

Amore Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen - Katonah - Amore Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Katonah, New York

Not great. I thought it use to be good pizza. Last few times it was terrible. They've made cheap changes. Maybe they sold ... really disappointed. Improve the pizza. read more

My parents kindly stayed in our house to watch our dogs while we were away for a week. Upon our return, I figured I would celebrate the fact that our dogs, and my parents, survived the week and is there literally any better way to celebrate than pizza? We usually order from another place you may or may not know in Katonah and the menu at Amore is very similar. I could potentially just have pizza for lunch but I definitely need a little more variety for a dinner meal so I ordered the pasta with broccoli and garlic. GF ordered pasta primavera. My Dad ordered a chicken salad and my Mom ordered a veggie panini and house salad. I added garlic knots to throw everything all together. OMG how could I forget, I also ordered a standard pie. The food came when it was supposed to. The delivery man insisted on interacting with someone and fortunately because my parents are stuck in the 90s, they have no problem with that. For one of the first times in a while, I'm sad to say, we actually received everything we ordered! See my recent reviews for the tea. My pasta was quite good. The noodles were al dente. There were nice slices of garlic mingling with the oil. The broccoli was fresh and plentiful. A touch of parmesan and red pepper flakes would have lifted this to ambrosia status. When asked about her primavera, GF says "loved it". My Mom never leaves any of her feelings to the imagination and she made it quite clear that she adored both the veggie panini and her salad, which she consumed the following day for lunch. The panini comes with fries which I assisted her consume, and they were very tasty and some of them were crisp. My Dad enjoyed his as well. He says "tasty, basic without the chicken but better with it". The garlic knots were the biggest garlic knots I have ever seen. Try garlic BOATS. Not only were they gigantic but they were so soft, fluffy, and most importantly, DELICIOUS. They're literally so big that the standard serving of sauce was enough for only like 3 of them. The pizza. The, arguably most critical part of the order, was disappointing. We had just returned from Mexico and GF had food poisoning so her buds may not have recalibrated. I was also shook from what I witnessed so my emotional state had not recalibrated. She took a bite and immediately said she didn't like it, there was something off about it. Now, I have been tainted at this point, so there was no hope for me to form a positive opinion about the pizza. I will say that it was extremely soggy which I can't do. My Dad would enjoy cardboard if I told him it was pizza so the bar isn't high here and both he, and my Mom, loved it. I'm still thinking about those garlic knots. EDIT to add clarification: we have never not received anything from here or the other place in Katonah, 2 places in Mt. Kisco hmph. read more

I actually drove a stupidly long distance to come for this pizza because there was a picture of the square / grandma slice on here that looked phenomenal. I'm glad I came by because it was very good! Not the greatest I've ever had, but still really, really good. It met the pizza craving I have been needing fulfilled after years down South. read more

Amore Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen - Katonah - Square slice (grandma) - Pizza Near Me - Katonah, New York

Ran in for a quick take out to try different slices. This place does not disappoint! Greek Pizza slice is insane and the white spinach slice was creamy, garlicky and straight up yummy. read more

Amore Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen - Katonah - Greek Pizza slice and White Spinach slice! The absolute best pizza slice I've ever had. White spinach slice was so yummy and garlicky - Pizza Near Me - Katonah, New York

Kindest staff ever, incredible panino caprese on perfect crisp focaccia, great music + ambience.

The pizza was absolutely phenomenal! Traveling back to NYC, and this place offers some of the best pizza I've had in a long time. Everything was fresh, well-balanced bites of both crispy and slightly doughy. Pops of well-seasoned saltiness, fresh light EVOO. I will be back!! read more

The food is amazing Music too, especially!!! You guys rock!!! All the time, something different different flavor!!! Always read more

Amore Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen - Katonah - Eggplant campanata pie - Pizza Near Me - Katonah, New York

See all

Once again, Vinny and his staff provided delicious food for a college soccer team home visit. Vinny is literally the first call I make when expecting a large group. The food is always fantastic and Vinny is so easy to work with. Still hoping he finds another space in lower Fairfield County! Love you Vinny!! read more

Best pizza in Westchester- no one even comes close. So so so happy I fnally found 5 pizza! The owners are fantastic and Go out of their way to make you feel welcome the moment you walk in. This is not a typical run-of-the-mill Pizza joint. read more

Amore Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen - Katonah - Specialty Slices - Pizza Near Me - Katonah, New York

Amore Pizzeria is a welcome addition to the changing but steady restaurant scene in Katonah. Before Amore, there were only a couple--and substandard at that--options for pie lovers. When Amore announced its opening, I was beyond thrilled. My expectations were high based on what their website described. Though they are a good pizzeria, they need to tweak their operation to be great. That said, it is fantastic to see a steady stream of people entering a business on a block that used to be utterly silent. Here is what Amore can do to improve its good base of operation. I know this sounds like a whiny consultant, but I want Amore to be in Katonah for years to come. 1. Consistency. The slice in the attached photo was excellent, the right proportion of toppings to dough and each other. I ordered the same slice a week later and it was a messy, greasy, and honestly difficult-to-eat flopper. 2. Proportions. Some slices are overloaded. They cannot be picked up without flop and slop. I almost used a fork and knife! 3. Communicate orders to the register operator. Otherwise, the customer is left describing what they ordered, and the chef inevitably hollers the order while this happens. 4. Napkins. There are none in the seating area, only behind the counter, and asking over and over is tiring. Doing the above will elevate an already great addition to Katonah, one of my favorite towns. Keep up the good work, Amore! read more

Amore Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen - Katonah - Dried tomatoes, yum. - Pizza Near Me - Katonah, New York

Fantastic! Easy on/off from the highway. We selected from the premade slices, which is not something we normally do, because it looked great. The pepperoni calzone was PACKED in glorious excess with pepperoni. YUM! Bookmarked for the future. read more

My favorite pizzeria in Katonah and surrounding areas. I like their gourmet pizzas. I tried the gourmet broccoli Rabe and Sausage pizza and the vegetable pizza. Both I will order again. The store is immaculately clean. Staff is friendly. Highly recommend. read more

Amore is a fabulous addition to Katonah's restaurant and takeout selection and I am happy to see the place picking up more and more business also on weekday nights. They are still in the process of developing their slice selection as there's new options available from week to week, but that's also a great opportunity to try different options. Some pies are hidden under the counter so don't be shy to ask what else is available! read more

Amore Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen - Katonah - a slice of pizza on a red and white checkered paper - Pizza Near Me - Katonah, New York

See all

I haven't had the chance to dine in just yet, but I've ordered delivery a few times from Amore and have really enjoyed my meals. I've had cauliflower crust pies from here, as well as the regular. Both are very good, very fresh-tasting. My favorite though has been the soups (the minestrone) and the pastas. I had a aglio e olio pasta and could have warded off vampires for eons. The perfect amount of garlic. And the soups come with incredibly fresh and perfectly baked focaccia. I'd definitely consider dining at the restaurant with my toddler and husband, the menu is super kid-friendly and the location is perfect. read more

After (Finally) Stopping in a few days ago for some (SLAMMING) Slices w/ a Lake Lincolndale Bestie? I got Delivery of one of the BEST Lasagnas I've EVER had - & I'm a Chef - From the girl who took my order, Maren - A Happy, helpful & Smart Camper - I'm in Love, Already! Seriously - Homemade Pasta Sheets? A Solid Bolognese? NOT too much Mozzarella? Over the TOP great. Spoke to Vinny, the Owner after the Slices from Heaven ( Amazing Texture & Crunch on the Dough as well). - Great Guy! This Clean, Mean, Awesome place he has created is really special. 5 read more

Good not great. Crust was chewy with no crispness. Sauce is darker than I prefer. Pizza is a preference. For someone else this may be perfect. The staff was nice and service was fast. We had both the thin crust and a Sicilian. Neither had any crispiness to them. read more

Amore Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen - Katonah - Cheese pizza, thin crusted, "baked well" - Pizza Near Me - Katonah, New York

Good food and amazing server with vibrant atmosphere. My favorite is the pizza because the crust is the best I ever had...

The pizza was excellent , but too, too rich in oil , had to dab the oil out with a paper towel .

Their pizza was so good! Fiancé had a delicious spinach roll with tons of very garlicky spinach, I had a pepperoni/ricotta slice and a veggie slice. All three things were fabulous and the wait staff were quick and kind. Very nice place for a slice, good calm ambiance and a clean space. read more

Loved this pizza and place. They have excellent pizza service and cookies that were as fresh as the pizza they put out

Ordered a chicken parmigiana hero and was surprised to see it was a pre made frozen cutlet Took 2 bites a gave it to my dog Come on guys you can't fry a real chicken cutlet read more

I absolutely love and recommend Amore!! State of the art pizza creations like their Teriaki mushroom slice Lasagna so delicious and fresh...... Sorry I didn't take some pics to share Never a wrong choice read more

First time I tried Amore and they did not disappoint!! Not only was the food fresh and delicious but they are so kind! There was a mix up with delivery, (not their fault), but they went above and beyond to rectify it. Incredible customer service!! So happy and grateful we have an amazing local Pizza place. I highly recommend Amore and can't wait to order again! Thank you! :) read more

The Katonah salad with chicken is our favorite. Slices to go are good as is a whole pizza. Add the chocolate chip cookie to your order every time! read more

Just tried for the first time and loved! We got a calzone, the vodka pizza, and the calabrese. All three were amazing. Dough is fluffy and crispy. Sauces are full of flavor. Found our new pizzeria spot! read more

Parents live in Katonah and they wanted me to pick up Pizza and bring it to them so I researched and settled on Amore. Everything was terrific! The girl who answered the phone for the order was professional, the Pizza (Pepperoni) was perfect, The salad (forgot what they call it but it had apple and good quality lettuce, etc. in it...Not the garbage "Iceberg" that most pizzeria's use), Side of meatballs and the calzone were both very good as well. The place itself is clean and orderly. My only complaint and I mean it constructively is the sauce that came with the Calzone was too sweet not the same sauce served with everything else which was great. Easy on the sugar guys. We'll happily go to Amore again next time we are local and in need of good Pizza!! read more

Welcome to the neighborhood! Tried this newcomer for the first time tonight. Hubby and I fought over the option to order thin or thick, well done or cooked lightly and We both loved having the control to order it "our way". He won with "thick", but I got "well done" so crust was perfectly done and LOVED it though I think Amore is talented enough to get it right no matter how you order it. Love to see what they do with a salad. . . Next time. read more

I finally found good local(ish) pizza! Cute little place. We had personal pizza's that was so good. I have been searching for miles and miles and years for decent pizza and finally found something better than decent. This is good pizza. I'll have to try other things on the menu now to see if I want to give it 5 stars. read more

Great pizza! So fresh and cooked perfectly. Nonna's best of Westchester is impossible to beat. Salads are also delicious. Super fresh ingredients in everything. Vinny has the patience of a saint-gold standard! Fast service. What's better than fab food and awesome service? read more

Absolutely amazing pizza and great staff!!! A group of us came from out of town for the day to visit. We got pizzas by by the slice. All six of us agreed that the food was beyond delicious. I had a giant slice of meatball pizza and a slice of chicken parmigiana pizza. All I can say is wow!!! If you are coming to this area, you must eat here!!! read more

Amore Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen - Katonah - Meatball and chicken parmigiana pizza slices. - Pizza Near Me - Katonah, New York

Awful service, they never pick up phone, when they do they just put you hold. When you finally order whatever time they say you need to double the time. Honestly overrated not worth the hassle, you take one bite out of nonna pie and all the cheese comes off. Completely disorganized, the main guy yells at his staff constantly. read more

What a lovey new addition to the community! They really did a beautiful job with the facility and the pizza was hot, fresh and made to perfection! The staff was super friendly and reminded me about customer service ( or lack thereof in other places). All in all I'm looking to try all Amore's other yummy offerings! Congratulations and all the very best! read more

Vin has some of the best Artisan Pizza around. They have incredible wings and burgers as well..