My husband and I went here for dinner on Epiphany. We had heard it was a bit pricey, but since it…read morewas a special occasion, we decided to give it a try--and we're so glad we did. This is not your typical Italian restaurant. The food is truly authentic, and absolutely amazing! We started with the calamari as an appetizer, and it was delicious. All of the pasta is homemade, which really makes a difference in both flavor and quality. The restaurant itself is beautiful. It was decorated so tastefully for Christmas, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. We were seated in front of the fireplace, which made the evening feel especially romantic. The drinks were excellent, and the waitstaff were attentive and friendly throughout the entire meal. This is the perfect place for a date night or any special occasion. We will definitely be back!

The ambiance is very nice, the services themselves are very kind, the food is alright, but the…read moremanagement failed the restaurant. On Valentine's Day, I made a reservation for 8:15 and arrived 10 minutes early. Tell me why it took 20 minutes to get "checked in" only to be told to wait another 10-15 minutes at the bar for the table. After ANOTHER 20 MINUTES ON TOP OF THE 15 THEY ASKED US TO WAIT, we were seated, and immediately put our order in. At 10, we didn't even have our appetizers. At 10:30 we decided to leave. Will not be returning, if I make a reservation, I expect to be served timely, don't take on more than you can handle. Stay away for big holidays, even though the prices would make you only want to come for one.

Valerie is a waitress and she is excellent all the specials what they're about…read more OK, so let's talk about appetizers Nonna meatballs are unbelievable, then we move onto the Cajun calamari oh my god what a twist it is absolutely a new taste. That's unbelievable. Then he had a special was kinda like an egg roll with sausage and broccoli Rob and something else I wasn't paying attention but when they tasted it, oh my goodness so good. My meal was Catelli and sausage with ricotta. So between the appetizers and the main meal, there was so much food. I'm definitely haven't leftovers. Now we move onto the chocolate martini I've never seen anybody put this whipped cream with some chocolate syrup on the top of it and it is excellent and then we move onto the rainbow cookie dessert cake it tasted like a rainbow cookie unbelievable.

Amazing food, great service and beautiful ambiance. Consistently good food. Best penne vodka pasta…read moreand shrimp!

The 10th time was as good as the first! This is my go to restaurant when I'm in this area. You…read moreare greeted before you are even completely in the door and the staff is attentive to your needs. What keeps me coming back is the friendly ambience and the delicious food. I don't have a favorite meal (maybe the osso Buco!). This last visit there was a new addition on the dessert menu of cheesecake and it reminded me of a well loved bakery in Germany. The cheesecake was extra fluffy and I can't say enough good things about it. The restaurant is family friendly, and my niece loves the pizza here (I do too!) Luigi and family, thank you for many delicious meals and we will see you soon

Let me tell you a something!! We looked at several pizza restaurant reviews, yes they matter to…read moreme. I am so glad we paid attention to them because we would have missed out on the ABSOLUTE BEST PIZZA we have had. We are a group of 7 friends visiting from Ky and Ohio and we ordered the Americano (my personal favorite) the pepperoni was so delicious, the crust was such a compliment to the flavors on top! Also the Margherita was appreciated by our vegans. Then there was the 'make your own' pizza that had the most delicious pepperoni,mushrooms and onions. I can't say enough...then there was the salad.....what a salad. Luigi you gave us a wonderful memory of New York pizza!! We did a carry out but once I stepped inside, I wished we had chosen to eat inside...nice atmosphere. If you don't put forth the effort to eat HERE....YOUR LOSS :( Luigi....Thank you...Thank you...Thank you! Kentucky

3.5 stars rounded up…read more The pizza was fantastic, loved the sauce and the crust. It almost made up for the mediocre service and the terrible parking.

I got meal of stuffed shells delivered , food cold, sauce was watery and tastless. I have had…read moremostly good expeirenecs with them now compleetely displeased.

My Cousins -- Sunday night, belly full, world makes sense again…read more You know it's good when everybody's quiet at the table. No arguing, no complaints--just chewing. Food comes out hot, portions are serious, and nobody leaves hungry or emotionally unsettled, which after a long week is a miracle. This is real comfort food. The kind where you lean back, loosen the belt, and say, "Alright... that hit." Service is solid, no rush, no attitude. They let you eat like a human being. Five stars. If this place didn't exist, Sundays would be a problem.

The very first thing we noticed on entering, and even making a reservation, was how friendly and…read moreaccommodating the staff was. Our service throughout the meal was excellent with both our server and the manager (or owner?) checking in consistently. I really liked the decor and music as well. The decor is minimalistic, but I really liked how clean everything felt. I asked about the music -- it was 80s and 90s rock like Journey and Elton John and it matched our tastes perfectly for the particular moment in time we were there. They said they use pandora and the music varies from night to night, but we were fans. The food is where things weren't quite up to 5 stars, which is why the rating. We started with an autumn (squash) soup and wedge salad. The soup was good or maybe even a little better than good, but not great. For me, the salad was the same way. It comes with candied bacon and that just doesn't fit the profile of bleu cheese and iceberg. I ended up eating the salad without the bacon and then having the bacon at the end as an "opening dessert." The salad was super fresh and the dressing was well done. And the bacon alone was delicious--just not great together for my palate. We went with a couple handmade pasta dishes as our mains and they were both good. Again, not quite great. I liked mine better than my wife's. That is sis's new favorite was well named to my mind. It was spicy, but not overly so and the tomato and broccoli added depth to the dish that was missing from my wife's pasta. I would 100% come back. If we do, I think we'd split a pasta and a main. Some of the fish dishes we saw go by looked fantastic. The one negative to me was an occasional whiff of marijuana. I'm totally fine with someone taking a break to calm themselves if that's what they need. I just don't want to smell that while I'm eating, especially in a restaurant that is otherwise very very nice.

From the moment you walk in, it feels like a real neighborhood Italian spot--not pretentious, not…read morerushed, just warm and welcoming. The food is the star here: fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. Everything we ordered was spot-on, from the perfectly cooked pasta to the rich, balanced sauces that actually taste homemade (because they are). Service was attentive without hovering--exactly how it should be. You can tell the staff genuinely cares about the experience, not just turning tables. Portions are generous, prices are fair, and the quality punches way above what you'd expect for a local spot. If you're in Mahopac and want legit Italian food done right--this is the place. Trattoria Sei just gets it. We'll be back.

I've been here a few times with my in-laws and every time it's been great. It's a quaint little…read morerestaurant, but a great ambience and great service. Easily the best Italian food I've had in Mahopac and always my go to when visiting. I would recommend the chicken vodka parm. Just look out the portions are huge! Great spot!

Mezzaluna was a great place to catch up with friends. The space is quiet enough to have a…read moreconversation with others across the table. The food was very good. Chris, our server, made great suggestions, as well as being was warm and attentive.

We came here for my sister's birthday over the holidays. Very cute restaurant, nicely decorated…read morewith welcoming ambiance. We got a table for 6 set up easily day of. We all got different entrees and everything was very tasty and enjoyable. The staff was friendly and helpful. We had a great evening.

Our first time there. .FANTASTIC. Tim was our server, and to keep it short, we will be back.read more

Cutillo's is still a very nice place but 11 years later, the online menu still has different prices…read morethat actual, and items that are no longer available. Is it that hard to fix an online menu? I really don't know but it is funny that that is what I wrote more than a decade ago. In any case, here is what we thought- Cheesecake- A- (made in house and quite tasty) Strip Steak- A (good portion, flavorful, and perfectly cooked) Risotto - C- (flavorless, tasted very much like plain rice) Ambiance - A Noise level - C (only because of a large cackling party) Service - A- (efficient) Shrimp Scampi - B (a bit overcooked but a good buttery sauce) Value - B+ Overall, we will return.

Chop salad with chicken was wonderful at Oscars. We also had fresh rolls…read more Service was great.

I love their salads and appetizers. Due to my special dietary requirements I order mainly grilled…read moresalmon. I must stop ordering from Oscar II due to the fact that whenever I order grilled salmon (medium) the inside is mush. There is absolutely no consistency to it. This is a rather expensive dish. I always order a dinner salad and dessert with it. I am a long time customer but I give up. The WORST thing was when I called to talk to the manager about the salmon (food), they text me telling me to text Grubhub (delivery service). Too many places serve grilled salmon and other wonderful dishes. If you can't cook grilled salmon correctly then I will not recommend you further nor will you get my patronage.

We order from this Northern Italian restaurant frequently for our family events, and it never…read moredisappoints. We've dined in, ordered out, and hosted many family parties with their food--every experience has been excellent. Everything on the menu is absolutely delicious, and we've truly never had a bad meal. The service is always great, and the chef is incredibly friendly, often checking in on guests and making you feel genuinely welcome. Some of our favorites include the calamari, shrimp wrapped in bacon, NY strip, stuffed salmon, rigatoni pastarella, and penne alla vodka. And whatever you do, don't skip the homemade tiramisu--it's a must-try! Highly recommend for both special occasions and regular family meals.

The food is wonderful, such good Italian food. Their service is wonderful, they are very attentive…read moreand accommodating. The ambiance is comfortable, romantic and very welcoming