Stopped in to the Greeley location to order a few pizzas to take home. We were looking at the posted menu board and one of the items listed (a pizza) was way cheaper than the others so we asked if that was accurate and the guy had a snarky, rude tone and said give me a break - isn't it obvious that is an error! Actually no, I would expect the business to have the correct menu and prices displayed and that they would correct it if there was an error. So condescending and rude! If this was the only pizza place available, I'd never have pizza again because I don't like being treated poorly when I'm spending my hard earned money. read more

See all

So rude!! We got there at 9:20pm after a really bad day actually and they would not serve us because they were closing soon. Still 40 minutes open!! read more

I like the pizza, but let me tell you our delivery tale: We selected contactless delivery, an option on the website. I know some people are probably like, "Ugh, you're too good to chat with a delivery driver," and I'm like, "Look, I tip at least 25% on a delivery, which is a hefty sum at this place, so I think the driver is probably just fine." Anyway, we make the selection, and the dude shows up at the door and keeps knocking. He knocks, knocks again, and we figure, "Okay, there must be some issue." When we answer, homeboy says, "I know you selected contactless delivery, but I wanted to talk to you and see if you read your Bible." The dude was using pizza as a Trojan Horse to proselytize. Not cool. If someone knocks on the door, and I'm not expecting, say, a delicious pizza, and I see they're standing on the porch with a Bible, I can choose to just leave the door closed, or I can choose to open the door and politely say No Thanks. It's kind of annoying under the best of circumstances because I know where you all are, okay? When I'm interested in religion, I think I know where to find you. Still in those big buildings with the huge crosses on the front? Cool. But when it's the pizza guy, it's much worse. Because I paid this dude to come over and ask me about my reading habits. But, hey, let's do this properly and quote Pete's Top Bible Verses Relevant to this Situation Where a Deceitful Guy Pulled a Fast One In Order to Preach: Psalms 101:7: No one who practices deceit will dwell in my house; no one who speaks falsely will stand in my presence. Proverbs 29:11 ESV / 102: A fool gives full vent to his spirit, but a wise man quietly holds it back. Proverbs 25:17 ESV / 32: Let your foot be seldom in your neighbor's house, lest he have his fill of you and hate you. Kaisarion: It's the truth of candor shone through the prism of deceit It's the continence of bishops with their choirboys en-suite It's the tongue soiled in adulation that licks to no avail It's the noise of the righteous dogma that hides the handmaid's tail Oh, wait, sorry, that's a Ghost song about how Catholic priests were treating their choir boys. Whoops! Tell you what, Marco's: We'll buy our pizza elsewhere, but if you'd like to have us back as customers, I'll send you a book that I LIKE, you can read it, write me a report, and then we can resume our previous relationship where we just exchange money for pizza, no reading required. read more

Ordered 8 pizzas for a company meeting online and everything was done perfectly. From ordering online to the pizza quality, everything was satisfactory and everyone else thought so as well. I would highly recommend the deluxe pizza for those that enjoy vegetables and ordering online as they have many specials listed that are quite the deal! read more

Great pizza! I'm southern girl, and if you're southerner you've probably heard of mazzios pizza. Marcos is very similar to mazzios to me. Great food. read more

After one employee walked away from me greeted by another employee that was probably the rudest person I've ever met in a restaurant, and I've eaten a lot of restaurants too bad. The food's not too bad. I will never go to this location again.k read more

Always fantastic pizza - best in town. Fast and courteous. No complaints or negatives. Been hitting this place for years. read more

Food poisoning alert, last night my wife ordered a pizza from here, it showed up warm not hot but didnt think much of it as it was delivered by doordash. Unfortunately I ate this pizza and I have been throwing up, having diarrhea and feeling horrible for 7 hours. Beware I may go to the hospital if it does not end soon, Its finally getting a bit better at 3:30 PMS but I started throwing up around 8am read more

Pizza arrived cold. Still made the best of it and ate it because we were hungry. Husband ended up getting food poisoning and has been up vomiting all night. Never again. read more

Sloppy, greasy, undercooked mess. Disgusting. I grew up on great pizza... this stuff was inedible. Just plain gross.

Little cups of pepperoni heaven. Add variety to your monthly pizza cravings and you'll know why their old world pepperoni is making the industry take notice. read more

we love the pizza from here. it's our go to place. I don't really know what else to say. we get our pizza to go and have not actually eaten there. the staff is extremely nice. read more

This place is a joke. I asked the employee who took my order if the Jalapeño's were fresh or pickled and he said they were fresh. I wanted fresh not pickled. I pay 50 bucks for 2 pizzas, they are bland and the Jalapeño's were pickled. Ugh!! I guess the guy who took my order does not know much about the product he is selling. read more

Love this pizza. Solid crust and quality ingredients all the time. Best pizza in Greeley.

Ordered pizza at 7:00. It is 8:15 now and they say it will be another 16 minutes for delivery. An hour and a half to get a pizza delivered? We won't be ordering from them again. read more

If you ask them to "hold the onion" prepare to bite into onion. 3 of our last four orders where we indicated an edit on a specialty pizza when ordering online, it was prepared incorrectly. Lots of other fine pizza places in town, time to start going elsewhere. Sad. read more

Good pizza but they don't stand behind their mistakes. They screwed up a pizza, offered me a free pizza to compensate with no mention of a timeframe to claim it, and then told me I waited too long (90 days). I have been a faithful customer for years. Will be finding a new pizza place. read more

Finally - Third time's the charm I guess. After a delayed opening and trying to order online before they were listed, we finally obtained a couple pizzas from Marco's. We ordered for delivery - the app said 45 minutes, it took 90. I'll cut them some slack since it was a Friday evening about 6pm, but double the time? It's proving really difficult to get a pizza from this place. About the pizzas - thin crust option, one meat, one other specialty I can't remember. They were good. They were certainly gobbled up with no leftovers. The kiddos certainly think they're good. For the pizza sizes and options, the prices are a bit of premium to other pizza vendors around town - so for quality/taste/size/price I'd say they're on par - if you want to spend a little more and get a better tasting pizza, go Marco's. If you're feeding a herd and need to do so on a budget, perhaps consider the more traditional delivery places. All in all, I'd give them 3 stars and say they're A-OK. The ease of online order for takeout (or delivery) and the time promised versus actual will likely determine if I buy a lot of pizza from them, continue to alternate between pizza places, or give up. Finally, the store seems nice - I'm not much of a pizza-shop in-store diner. I prefer carryout/delivery, so I cannot comment on the interior/atmosphere. read more

Was told this was the place I should try. Not impressed with quality. Too many onions and green peppers so the center of the pizza was and soggy. I doubt I'll be going back. read more

We don't have a Marcos in our hometown so it's our go to when in CO. They've always got my order correct and the pizza and wings are consistently great. I love the pizza bowl also. read more

Horrible customer service, horrible, kayden if that's her "name", I ordered a salad with extra ingredients, had a very small amount of chicken, according to her a handful, I asked for triple chicken, but she kept saying it was weighed, I didn't know a handful is a weighing tool like a scale, I gave her multiple times to provide great customer service, but she could not, being vague with her answers, I asked for a new salad, even a refund and I'd give it back. But nope not possible. What happens to great customer service? Or any customer service? I don't ever complain, don't even post much. But I work in the industry, and that is unacceptable, if I did what she did I wouldn't have a job. With out customers there is no business. And I have had several friends say how bad this place is. I love the pizza bowl from marcos. To bad customer service is so bad. Don't worry kaden I'm not going tomorrow, I'm never ordering from marcos again. read more

Love the pizza && salads!! But I didn't like the wings at all!! They were also really hot!! Will order pizza again though!!

I'm editing my initial review now that I've calmed down and have actually ate their food. Over an hour wait time and 2 wrong orders before getting my dinner to me I can now sit down and eat. The small Greek salad is actually quite large and is a meal unto itself. Generous portion and condiments grace the salad and the Greek dressing is actually quite good. The pizza was slightly overcooked and crunchy for my tastes; however lots of toppings and just the right amount of cheese. Staff looks overwhelmed and confused. Perhaps wait a while till they get settled in but as of now I can't recommend this place at all. I upgraded my review from a 1 star to 3 star review. Perhaps in time they'll get over their initial growing pains. read more

One evening I decided to give "Undercover Boss" a try, although the previews I had seen had dissuaded me from viewing the show. The episode we watched was the one about Marco's Pizza. The very next day, driving along 20th, we were surprised, to see a Marco's Pizza in a storefront that had changed businesses several times over the years. It really was the memory of the show that moved us to give the place a try. The gentleman in charge said they had been opened for a little over a week. I'm sorry we missed their grand opening. I have a favorite pizza place. I don't expect it to be replaced. But I am always open to new experiences. We entered to a loud "Welcome to Marco's Pizza!" The place was clean, with adequate tables and seating. Shakers of red pepper flakes and (presumably) Parmesan, along with honey were at the tables. There was a soda/drink dispenser, and a couple of wide screen tvs mounted high. We ordered the Garden Pizza. The young man who brought the pizza to us was obviously and sincerely enthusiastic, and proud of Marco's Pizzas. He is a credit to the business. The ingredients were substantial and fresh. They were good. The crust was . . . come to think of it, the crust was pretty darn good, better than most pizzas I've gotten from a pizza shop. I know they can coax a little more flavor out of the sauce if they try. And they might sprinkle an extra seasoning or two on the pizza itself, or give more body to the sauce. On the other hand! - you can easily ask for a side order of extra pizza sauce, garlic butter, ranch, or jalapeno ranch and add that to the pizza. That would bring things together more cogently. Everyone who shared the pizza thought it was very good, and we will all probably be getting another Marcos' pizza in the near future. For students at UNC and AIMS, Marco's is close enough to go for a lunch break (if you're driving). And for students at Greeley West High School, it's only a few hundred steps further than the King's store that many go to for their lunches. read more

One of my favorite pizza places in Greeley! I love the chicken fresco pizza (without chicken and bacon, now, but it's equally as delicious without!) and it's something I crave regularly. Plus they give you awesome email deals! Awesome addition to Greeley. read more

Great pizza! Has the flavor I've been looking for. The online ordering directs you to Colorado Springs though and I couldn't figure out how to change that so I called and the girl working was super nice but had a really hard time taking my order.. I had to repeat it several times But I will continue to order from them! read more

I love Marcos Pizza, imo its the best around.. the problem is the staff... I am a block outside the delivery area so I've driven the 10 minutes to go get it... every time I have gone into the store (3 times) the staff has been completely aloof, unwelcoming, and rude. So I don't go here anymore.. which sucks because I would all the time if the staff weren't a bunch of jackholes read more

First time having Marco's and not disappointed. Had order delivered on a friday around 7:30pm and only took 25 mins! Easy to order online. Pizza crust was absolutely perfect (I did check "well done" as crust option for a little more crunch). Best pizza I have had in the Greeley area. Will be ordering again soon! read more

Marco's Pizza - Small cheese, "well done" crust, 100% perfection - Pizza Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

Went to CSU Basketball game - bought 4 slices and 2 sodas..... $42.00...you're kidding me right? Last purchase for our family from Marcos. read more

Been here twice now... First time was about a week after opening and the second today. Both times I have need very pleased with the service and how friendly the staff is. I have met the owner and he is very up front and personal with each customer and I believe that is what makes this store great... Their pizza is very fresh and has great flavor.. there crust is awesome and overall just a well made pizza... read more

Marco's Pizza - Medium - Create your own - Bacon and Meatball - Pizza Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

Probably my favorite pizza in Greeley. They always have fast delivery times and online deals that get you a lot of food for not much money.

We love eating in the store-comfortable and the food is always really good. My only complaint is home delivery. They get it to you fast, but rarely is the order right. But we do love the pizza. So we just go and eat on site. It is clean and well lit...staff is very friendly. Just a side note...they do have the cleanest Restrooms anywhere. And, I am one of those people that checks corners and behind toilet :) The kitchen is in view and it is also spotlessly clean-my advice go out to Marcos for Pizza. Side Note: the garlic bread it a little too thick for my taste. But my grandkids love it. read more

Their new philly steak pizza is very good. I AB jalapenos to it. Staff is very friendly and the owners are excellent people. I have recommended place to several of my friends and they have enjoyed the food as well. I highly recommend it to anyone who likes pizza. I've eaten up many of the pizza places in town and I find this to be the best pizza going. read more

This is a great place to go for a N. Y style pizza. They have a pizza called pepperoni magnifico, which has a buttery garlic crust, and 2 different kinds of pepperoni. There cheese bread is light and fluffy. The service is great, they welcome every customer as they come through the door. There is a 10 to 15 minute wait when ordering, which was not bad at all. It has been the same every time we have gone. A must try!!! read more

Marco's Pizza - Pepperoni magnifico - Pizza Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

See all

Nice pizza, not quite as good as Fonta's but definitely worth it. Has a great flavor and is quite pleasant. The sauce is mellow, the crust very pliable and it's pretty good overall. Will order again. read more

Congratulations Marco's! You won the pizza tasting contest! You had the best cheese pizza and you beat the competition of 2 other national Pizza companies in Greeley,Colorado read more

Marco's Pizza - Congratulations Marcos for being the winner of the cheese pizza contest we had with 2 other pizza companies in Greeley! You Rock! - Pizza Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

See all

Great pizza - I always get the Deluxe & my elderly mom always orders the Hawaiian. The owner remembered me today & asked I give his best to my mom (which she loved to hear!) thanks for wonderfully consistent pizza! read more

Excellent!! #1 pizza joint in Greeley! Fantastic pizza overloaded with deliciously fresh toppings in every bite! Great company, awesome staff, couldn't be better! read more

Marco's Pizza - Snapshot of a couple slices of the incredible Chicken Fresco we ordered! To die for! Practically licked the plate clean - Pizza Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

See all

Wowza! First timers here. Ordered a couple pizzas delivered that wrre amazing! Quick delivery and great service. Next time we'll have to go into the resturant and try more on the menu! read more

It's so hard to find a good pizza spot, thanks Yelpers for helping us find this place! We tried the chicken florentine, the garden pizza, and a cheese pizza. All three were really really good!! If I lived in Greely, this would be my go-to spot. All ingredients were fresh and tasty. read more