This was once a place I regularly recommended, which makes its recent decline particularly disappointing. While the specials remain one of the few bright spots, the broader experience is less than impressive. The kitchen was notably slow, the pizza arrived with a burnt bottom crust, and service is inconsistent. Most concerning is management's response to a routine question regarding a service charge... rather than addressing it professionally, the matter was handled with unnecessary hostility and followed by an inappropriate private message. A restaurant's leadership sets the tone for the entire operation, and based on recent experiences, that tone appears to be contributing to the establishment's downward trajectory. I hope they are able to make meaningful changes. Update: After posting this review, the owner texted me: 'Don't EVER come here again. You are not allowed and police will be called. Have the day you deserve.' Screenshots retained. Readers can draw their own conclusions regarding professionalism read more

See all

We were so excited to learn that Roma now delivers.This is our favorite pizza. Unfortunately the pizza was burned. That was the only thing we could taste. Tried, but could not even eat the pizza. Very sad. read more

Sadly will no longer be giving Romas any of our business. We called to ask about their menus and order a few pizzas for delivery. They dont deliver and use door dash which is fine. So we spent the time to order online and got it done , paid and confirmed. 30 min later @ the delivery time we were notified that Romas cancelled our order because they were too busy. Now, I'm not sure why they didn't tell us on the phone that they couldn't take our order and why it was confirmed and then canceled. We had a house full of family doing a move into a new house. Waited the 30 min and have no food . Unfortunately, business that have no concern for their paying customers.... I won't support. There are a lot of other great place for good food and good customer service. read more

The food is disgusting!!!!! Wings are so fatty, lasagna is Salty. Waited about 30 minutes waisted $30 on just Lasagna full order and 6 wings. read more

was driving to find a pizza place and found roma pizza place everyone was so nice and respectful and the services was amazing and the we did a custom pizza half bacon and half sausage and two drinks was for me and my husband only $24 read more

Original Roma Pizza - 16th St. Greeley - pizza - Italian Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

Excellent calzones, love the nutty idea. Great old school atmosphere. Good beer and service.

The pizza here is fantastic! This is such a cool little spot, the games always on, the beers always cold, and the service is friendly. They make some great cocktails too. Please support this place and let's keep em open, the recent construction in the area has made parking tough and it would mean the world to those that work there to keep this place alive and thriving. read more

Chefs Kiss!!! Pizza taste, temp, and presentation was excellent... and the pizza crust is also amazing. This isn't your average corporate pizza place- it's an experience, fun environment for a date or casual business meal. The service was on point- accurate- and pizza was made faster than other restaurants in the area. My visit was for lunch. read more

Original Roma Pizza - 16th St. Greeley - Cheese Pizza - Italian Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

I have not been to this location in almost 25 years. With our kid playing baseball for UNC we had to make a stop in. It was a holiday so it wasn't super busy in our waiter to great care of us. From the appetizers to the main meals were very solid and I can't wait to go back and have a couple cold ones with them. read more

Food was great, atmosphere was great. There was only one other table with people as we ate at 2:30pm. I assume it's much busier during the regular lunch and dinner hours. The restrooms were clean and stocked well. Our server was fantastic! She gave us space an was very personable. My family enjoyed our pizza and salads. When in Greeley, we'll be back! read more

Original Roma Pizza - 16th St. Greeley - Sitting at the big table. - Italian Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

This pizza is not good and the wings were even worse. The pizza is tasteless and mushy - even with jalapeños and pineapple as the toppings. The pizza was soggy but the crust was rock hard. The hot wings had no sauce, I'm assuming they forgot to dress them. Which was a shame because the chicken is funky and needed sauce to cover it up. read more

Original Roma Pizza - 16th St. Greeley - They forgot the sauce. The chicken was funky and not edible. - Italian Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

See all

My boyfriend and I ate at Romas on a slow Monday night, the food and service were both amazing! The restaurant was empty but as soon as we walked in we were greeted and the server helped us right away. We ordered the cheese bread appetizer and the hot house pizza, both were delicious. read more

This place is horrible, the manager of this place is rude and ignorant. The food came to be cold and soggy, the place stinks. Making the trip out here miserable. read more

The pizza is really good and they homemade cari olí is really good. Had there cheese bread and the t-Rex pizza both were delicious.

Great pizza loaded with cheese on top! I've been coming to this place for years and it never disappoints! The drinks are tall and strong and will definitely get the night going! read more

Original Roma Pizza - 16th St. Greeley - Bazooka - Italian Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

See all

Was really impressed by the staff and how tasty the food was. Had the Caroli and spaghetti plus shared a side salad. Lots of food and hand made noodles, the side salad was large! The marinara was tasty! read more

Romas has always been our go-to place for Carolli's- I have been eating here since high school-where my best friend got me addicted to them. As expected, their prices have gone up, so make sure you print out a coupon from their website that allows you to save 40% off. Another tip...order spaghetti sauce instead of the Carolli sauce-you won't regret it!! read more

Pizza was okay--I've had worse but I've also had A LOT better. Customer service was pretty good, we had ordered a bunch of pies for a party we were having and the order was handled pretty quickly and we were given a lot of cheese/red pepper flakes to go along with our pies. Also had their Italian salad which was pretty standard for a big tray of catered salad from a pizza place-- okay, had a good amount of toppings and dressings included. read more

Original Roma Pizza - 16th St. Greeley - Veggie pizza - Italian Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

Best pizza and Caroli's. Coupons are awesome for those on a budget. Been going here for years.

Love this place! Outstanding pizza. Fresh ingredients and friendly staff. Excellent beer selection. Walls and tables covered in music memorabilia. A UNC landmark for 30 years. Try the Fightin' Feinstein: Chicken, jalapenos, bananna peppers, garlic, red onion, fresh basil, and provolone. read more

Original Roma Pizza - 16th St. Greeley - Enjoying the Fightin' Feinstein and Manuel's Favorite. - Italian Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

Had pizza rolls and a taco pizza delivered. The pizza rolls were fantastic and was a very generous amount. They dough was so tasty, not too thick, soft hot and just the right saltiness and buttery flavor. Generous cheese and pepperoni on the inside. And the marinara sauce was incredible; couldn't get enough of it. The taco pizza was fine; no wow factor but good. I think maybe a bit more of the seasoned taco meat and lettuce would have made the difference. It was supposed to come with fresh salsa but wasn't, but that's ok. I would do this meal again. read more

I have been coming to Roma since I was a kid. I cant tell you all of the experiences I've had inside those walls, from bazooka maragritas to pizza and Carolis, I have great times at Roma. I even wrote a wedding toast at Roma after college. It has been well over a year since that last time I went to Roma and after 2.5 hours of waiting for our food, I remembered why. As much as I love the Downtown location, this places is not run well. It was too busy for the kids woking to keep up with. I was taking my whole family here for dinner, from my grandmother, parents, brother, boyfriend and a kid. We came early enough to get a table without waiting and the first round of drinks and the appitizer came out quickly. It all went down from there. My parents and grandmother both ordered the chicken parm, My brother and I Carolis, My boyfriend the meaball sandwich and the child had spaghetti. To be candid, after 2 hours of waiting for food, My parents were over it and asked for theirs to be boxed up so they could leave. It still took 30 mins for that to happen. The carolis were amazing as usual. The meatball sadwich didnt come with any sauce so my boyfriend took most of my carolis sauce. If you order the sandwich, get a side of spaghetti sauce. The staff forgot to bring us forks, extra plates for the appitizer, napkins, drink refills or anything else that would make this a positive dining experience. Thank goodness we could see where the plates and silverware were to just get our own. They did take some of the drinks off our bill but it was nowhere near enough for the overall dining experience. I wont be able to stay away from Roma forever but I think Ill only go to the West location from here on out... read more

Tried to go in for a drink as it looked insanely busy and we walked in and told they were closed but it was full of drunk college students handing out shots in plastic cups. Very unprofessional. read more

We went on a Saturday. We had a great time great pizza . It was really nice. Server was wonderful. We will come back

Just ate here. On the positive the sauce is great and the pizza is decent. They lose points for me because when we ordered fillings for the calzone they missed 2 and then really didn't fill it at all. Mostly cheese and bread. I think this is a ripoff and they should be ashamed. I would go back for the sauce but buyer beware. I will praise the waitress as she understood and was super sweet. read more

First time here and last time. Only reason I stopped in is because my friend lives across the street. Ordered a drink that came with rotten limes. The food is extremely gross.... Seriously a Italian restaurant that buys in their meatballs... do yourselves a favor and walk across the street to 711 and buy some pizza rolls. read more

Used to absolutely LOVE this place. The atmosphere is great for having a few drinks and italian food. Sadly, the quality and service have gone down a LOT. It's also mildly infuriating that they list things on the menu but then don't bother to keep the ingredients in stock. When I was in the mood for a BBQ Brisket Caroli, I'd convince the whole family, and then they somehow are out of Brisket, so the whole reason for going is gone. Brisket is not a rare commodity in any way. Today I ran into the same issue with a Corned Beef Brisket Caroli. They say they don't have cabbage?! Again, cabbage is not in short supply. Either take it off the menu or keep ingredients in stock. Why is false advertising suddenly OK?! For takeout, I recommend avoiding this location completely and go to the other locations. The quality, service, and specials are all better. read more

The food, our server and the atmosphere was amazing. We will come because of that fact. The biggest disappointment was the bartender, Gracie! She needs to learn how to deal with certain situations and not be so rude!! The incorrect drink was made and I questioned her about it, since it was a drink for myself. I ordered a Screwball whiskey drink and received a vodka and orange juice. Those are totally different drinks!!! I told her I was just going to drink the incorrect drink and was told I had an attitude. I am very disappointed with this experience!! read more

I'm a huge pizza eater and I had high hopes for romas pizza but they fell flat. If you want a decent pizza go to parry's and stay clear of this place. It's worse than eating a frozen pizza... but way more expensive. I'd give 0 stars if it was possible. On top of the terrible pizza I was extremely uncomfortable, men approaching me inappropriately and was even grabbed trying to use the restroom, thankfully my husband saw and stepped in or I'm terrified to think about what would have happened. read more

This place is gross AND Unsafe. My mom was grabbed by some man and when going to management they didn't care or try stepping in. Additionally their pizza was like eating tomato sauce with soggy toppings. This place really needs to be shut down for every possible reason. read more

Took my wife here to eat the other night hoping for a good slice and few minutes of relaxation during a meal...... and what we got was grease soaked sloppy pizza and an environment that made my wife so uncomfortable that we had to get up and leave mid meal. I don't know who runs this establishment but this place is unsafe for women from the servers to the lurking men who continued to approach my wife inappropriately until I had to step in and make a scene. This place needs to be shut down before something bad happens to someone. Unbelievable!!!! read more

Shout-out to Jon H. who took great care of my post workout pizza needs. I've ordered for pickup and dine in, and have tried many of the specials. I've come to realize the most tasty, most fresh favorite of mine is the chicken bacon ranch pizza. Damn that is some good ass pizza. Thinking of if makes me want to lift heavy and head there now!! read more

See all

Went to UNC - this place was awesome back in 1990 - best pizza - $3 bazooka drinks. Loved it. Wind the clock on 30 years ... driving the next generation cross country and had to stop at Roma. It meant a 15 hour day (and an hour out of way) - but it was totally worth it! It is just as great as ever. Still in love with Roma pizza (Manuel's Favorite) after all these years! Who was Manuel anyway? We finally made it to town well after closing and sled if they could save a pizza for us ... they said: how about we just stay open for you? (An extra hour and a half!). The staff is awesome! The good is awesome! The drinks are awesome! The decor is old school and still cool as ever! Great value to boot. Love Roma! read more

Original Roma Pizza - 16th St. Greeley - Italian Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

2 hours for pizza and a carrolli because "the internet went down"!?! I've always preferred the original Roma. The food is fine, but the service is abysmal. Service quality or "internet", something has got to get fixed before we would consider coming back. read more

Absolutely the worst food we have ever had! Went there a few weeks ago and ordered a meat ball sub.... meatballs were old tasting and bread was hard... sauce was so bland...! Went with co workers again today and was hoping it was just a bad day for the cook last time... but NO... I ordered a chicken parmigiana sandwich... the chicken was so hard and old and yep the sauce was still terrible! My boyfriend ordered a meatza pizza and he was not happy... and our other friend ordered wings... they were nasty... soggy and sour! They discounted our meal but we left hungry! We went to another restaurant straight afterwards.... we will not come back!!! read more

Seemed really understaffed. Ordered two salads, a veggie pizza, and an appetizer. Our appetizer didn't come until the rest of our meals did, which took a very long time! Forgot dressings for salads, forgot to put meat in the salads, and gave us the complete wrong pizza. Didn't put any toppings on it and didn't put sauce on it. Very strange. After talking to our waiter we were able to get another correct pizza, but not for 20-30 minutes. We were also not offered refills until after finishing our meals. Customer service was just difficult. Won't be going back. read more

Roma's is Greeley - it's not nice per se, but nothing exemplifies Greeley quiet like Roma's. It's got half-priced carolies - with a coupon. It is dirty, dingy, sketchy, but a wonderful experience. If you've never tried Roma's, you must. It is the Northern Colorado experience. - Try the Hot House caroli. read more

Original Roma Pizza - 16th St. Greeley - Italian Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

Roma is a tradition in Greeley, especially the original location. But I'm old enough I remember when it was Santeramo's (before Santeramo's moved). It's an 'ok' divey, hipster, collegiate locale. The food is decent, but not extravagant. They could try to clean it up once in a while -it's a bit grungy with old grease and food particles all over. They could also try to have at least a little better service. It used to be better, it's like Roma's - at least at this location - is just getting tired and in a rut. They need to revitalize. read more

This place is great! I wish I lived in Greeley. I do live in Denver though, so not too far. Every time I come to Greeley I come here and it is great! There is nothing bad on the menu and the service is always great! I recommend this place to everyone. Thank you! read more

This is a must every time I come to visit Colorado. Their nutty pizza is my absolute favorite.