Best Za in town, open hella late. Bigs slices, hefty toppings. Yelp's making me add words read more

My daughter was living in FC and I was up visiting her, so she took me here for a real FC pizza joint (especially for late night!). Got the pepperoni with cream cheese slice and was rewarded with a few more gobs of cream cheese before a flash heat. The slices are big, the service is incredible, and the vibes are dope. Enjoyed the place for a good pick up pizza for lunch. read more

Cosmo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Its good cheap pizza open late. Im lactose intolerant but was really drunk, Got a large for like 20$ and some change at this thing was huge, Worth the tummy ache. (Gun for scale) read more

Cosmo's Pizza - Large pepperoni (gun for scale) - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Very busy because it was the night of a CSU basketball game. Workers kept their effort up. Guy in the blue beanie knows how to toss dough. Music was super rad. read more

Cosmo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Look, Big D is gonna keep it real with ya'll...this is my go-to pizza joint. I get that 24 inch pizza that hits the spot every time. I don't got time for any of those smaller pizzas, those should be kids menu only. Big D will be a returning customer until they shut their doors you can count on that read more

Love the atmosphere. Portions are very generous. Good pizza. The party pizza is huge. Great place

Went here for dinner. Grabbed a few slices and it was impeccable. Excellent service and wonderful staff will be coming back again. Excellent ambiance read more

Cosmo's Pizza - Slice - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

Pizza was ehh. Bread sticks were AWFUL. only 4 bucks but a total ripoff. No seasoning, no oil, just rolled bread.

This is my favorite place to get 24" pizza. They are crazy generous with toppings. Just the way I like it. Keep up the great job! read more

See all

If you want uncooked pizza every time you come to a pizza shop come here. If u ask for it to be cooked a little longer they won't. "We can't once you've bitten it" some bs. read more

Went around 3 o'clock on a Monday. Place was slow. I ordered two slices of pepperoni, but they never heated up the slices. Ended up waiting like 30 minutes. I will say however, the pizza was some of the best I've had in Colorado. Actually prefer it to Krazy Karl's. read more

Food was lovely and the people were energetic. Also the pizza was crispy, hot and so tasty

Pizza is good! I like it even more because employees didn't put Dean J's pizza back in the oven after he took a bit. I saw Dean busty teeth, looked like he had Parmesan in his hair, and fingers 6 skin tones darker because of the dirt. Good call. read more

They are so busy because they're so good. They are well staffed and everyone is patient and kind. Onto the food, I'm from NYC and hands down the best pizza I have had out west. Management is professional and fair as well as prices. 10000/10 recommend read more

the food was pretty good! the pizza was huge but half of the pizza was grease. the service was terrible they were yelling the whole time and were pretty rude to everyone. the ambiance was basically like a really dirty house. read more

Waited an extra 45 minutes for our delivery. When called for estimated delivery they stated it was for pickup. When order was read back everything was correct. Are these college kids or elementary kids taking orders. Second time this has happened, they lost our business, including our hospital orders. Hire better staff! read more

Important, I did NOT eat a Cosmo's Pizza. Here's why... I ordered pizza for home-delivery. My home is in the SAME City, Fort Collins, CO, approximately (5.4 miles away) 10 to 14 minutes from their location and they refused to deliver? Virtually any order in the city will be 10 or more minutes away, given geography and traffic, etc.. Why offer delivery? Ya know? I am very disappointed and disenchanted with Cosmo's and will likely NOT ever frequent or otherwise eat at this restaurant. While I am sure there will be some to show support for/of Cosmo's, I'm simply saying, STOP offering delivery if you are not willing to drive 10 to 15 minutes away. It's not fair to loyal customers and certainly not fair to anyone looking for delivery in the SAME City. read more

Amazing pizza. Closest thing to east coast I have found out here. Great food and great prices. Get the spicy ranch !! :) read more

Who the heck cut this pizza? Ordered a half and half pizza to split with a friend but good thing they only get an inch of pizza! read more

Cosmo's Pizza - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

terrible food was very uncooked and the lady was a bitch, i do not recommend eating here

While the price is decent and it is fast delivery, the one item I ordered was incorrect. I had ordered a simple pepperoni pizza, and was delivered a plain cheese pizza. While it isn't the end of the world, I just wanted a pepperoni pizza, and was charged for one as well! read more

Pizza is such a staple in our American diet, especially those of the collegiate variety, that it arguably should have it's own food group on the nutrition pyramid. Nowhere is this more evident and pervasive than in the clustered business community around CSU. Students and locals alike have their world as their oyster in terms of selection from the myriad of different pizza shops, which all do things slightly different to make their own artistic impression upon the ubiquitous food of choice for so many. Cosmo's Pizza is not a new venture. There are already a few other locations in Boulder that have, on their own credit, done well for themselves. Looking to expand, they opened up one more. Within then recent development of a business complex on the corner of Elizabeth and City Park, there they were - smack dab in the heart of pizza central! There already happens to be at least six other pizza shops within a stone throw of this location, but fortune favors the bold as they say. My curiosity compelled me to see how this restaurant would measure up to the more well established pizza shops that already call this neighborhood home. I call them up and order a carryout. One medium pepperoni, bacon, jalapeno and pineapple pizza please ($15.00)! Oh yeah, and an order of bread sticks ($4.00)! He answers, "Ok, that'll be 20 to 35 minutes." Initially I thought, "Wow, there's a 15 minute window where I could potentially be waiting unnecessarily." So I clarify, "so it'll be ready in 30 minutes?" "Yes," he replies. Fair enough, I travel a short few blocks down the street to pick up my delicious pie. I get to the counter and I notice about 5 guys in the kitchen that all seem to be student age and apparently having a good day at work. I ask, "When did you guys open?" "Oh, we just opened at 11am this morning," He says. I was nonplussed and even a little worried about what was inside my mystery box I was about to take home. After a careful scan of the restaurant, it appears that they do a lot of pizza-by-the-slice business because they had at least six or seven very large pizzas with enormous size slices ready for the walk-in business. They all looked appetizing enough and that helped diminish my initial pizza anxiety. The moment of truth had arrived! There it was in all of it's carb-loaded glory - my fresh Cosmo made pizza! With a sigh, I gaze at the slightly undercooked mosaic of meat and cheese. The crust and cheese was not of the normal golden and brown color I'm used to seeing. The peppers and pineapple had no searing from the heat. this pie could've been cooked another 3-5 minutes. On to the breadsticks! I pull them out of the bag and to my disenchantment, they too were slightly undercooked. What's worse is that they were basically naked sticks of pizza dough, twisted with no seasoning or flavorful garlic-butter coating, cheese or other ingredient besides the dough. They seem to have been rushed because their sizes were inconsistent and the relative crispness of the dough was either good or nonexistent. Overall, they seem like a decent place and it's clear that the crew needs a little more experience with cooking pizzas, but it was their first day open. The pizza itself was delicious, despite being slightly undercooked, but that could be because my ingredient choices were a medley of amazing flavors that sang a sweet symphony in my mouth. I have faith that they'll improve, but time and business will tell how well they make their mark in CSU's backyard. read more

Cosmo's Pizza - Entrance from parking lot - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

Terrible customer service, no one took my order while I stood for 20 minutes at 1:30 to 1:50 for a slice of pizza. And then the pizza was terrible lol. Rip to this business read more

I am so disappointed because I love your pizza but my order never comes out right :( last time it was missing toppings & tzakiti sauce and this time I ordered white sauce & it came without any sauce. Dry chicken pizza? So sad. PLEASE do better because you have the best pizza in town. read more

let me just say i am NOT a pizza lover and this please is my favorite! the pizza slices are so large and you can add whatever toppings you want pretty sweet! the pizza is on the thinner side but the crust is not lacking, pizza perfection! read more

The pizza reminded me of cafateria pizza with a plain flour and water. Not a great pizza. I would reccomend going somewhere with more flavor. read more

Ordered 7:41pm - at 8:00pm, I asked how much longer. I was told at least 20 min, come to find out, they had not even started it. They were filling orders, of customers who walked in after us. They were very rude, when I questioned them. Would not recommend them. Poor customer service. read more

Absolute best calzones I've ever come across. One calzone can last me for 3-4 meals -- not only are they as big as my laptop, they are incredibly tasty, full of ricotta cheese and delicious meat and veggie choices. The delivery service is pretty reliable and quick. Cosmo's became a household staple during our recent kitchen remodel. Incredible value for the price. We ordered their pizza once but it didn't hold a candle to their calzones. read more

CJ went above and beyond to deliver our pizza! He was so sweet and even went back to grab our spicy ranch! This guy definitely deserves a raise. WE LOVE YOU CJ read more

Called and Johnny the manager answered and said they aren't taking orders for deliveries which was fine since I was planning to pick it up he then just decided to tell me no and just said he was too busy and I asked if he could just take my order and I will happily wait and he just said no. After he hung up on me in the middle of that I called back and he said if I kept calling he would "black list" a customers number. Sad to say this was my favorite pizza place in the Ft Collins area despite how expensive they can be they made good pizza but after the poor careless treatment from a "manager" a customer who lives close by has been lost due to a bad attitude from a poor manager. read more

Seriously it's just to be our favorite place two years not the same menu not the same food and certainly not a good pizza, Nothing like what we used to eat it's a good thing it wasn't for me and kids aren't hard to please read more

Aw man, what happened to this place?! Going downhill. Ordered a pepperoni pizza and it only had cheese. Manager said he wouldn't add pepperoni because we ordered a cheese pizza. Offered him my receipt that said 1- topping pizza but he dug in. Guess I need a new pizza place. read more

Cosmo's Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Zero stars if I could. Ordered a pizza, was told it would be an hour wait. Two hours later, no pizza, they are now closed, not picking up the phone and they did not deliver the pizza. They charged my credit card and never delivered. Disappointing, as I've heard good things, but this is just a disaster. Add I'm still hungry. Boo Cosmo's. read more

Slices are huge and pretty darn good! Had a couple of cheese slices late on a Thursday night. Beat the drinking crowd, and since this place is open pretty late they definitely get the college drinking crowd during the week. read more

I LOVE Cosmos! My favorite pizza is pepperoni, cream cheese and jalapeño with spicy ranch! They are always kind and fast! Tonight I ordered two pizzas and one was slightly damaged... did they put in the box and send it home with me anyway? NO THEY DID NOT! She noticed it, showed me and they made me a fresh new pizza without me even having to ask. They even brought it out to my car once it was ready! Be patient with them, you can't imagine the amount of online orders they received in a 5 minute period of time! Thank you COSMOS, happy new year!! read more

Soooo delicious, it reminds me of New York pizza!! You have to get their house made spicy ranch, It's to die for!! read more

Had lunch here today and thoroughly disappointed - this was the worst pizza I have had in over 20 years. How does this place survive with so many good places in vicinity? Crust - burnt in middle, doughy outer edge, terrible garlic flavored sauce, uneven sauce (a lot in middle, none on outside edge), cheese was transparent in spots. Location needs training on how to make pizza. Don't waste your money. A top notch pizza is available within 6 minutes or 1.9 miles away @ W. Drake and Shields. read more

When I received my pizza tonight this was the amount of sauce on it. After calling them back and letting him know he said the guy who made it is not going to make it again and theres nothing he can do. Same guy who delivered the pizza and gave me the worst attitude. Probably won't be ordering from them again. This was the sauce on the entire pizza. read more

Cosmo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Amazing pizza shop that serves whole pies or by the slice. It seems like most people try this place for the first time after a night at the bars and then find themselves going back sober time and time again. The spicy ranch is divine and a signature Cosmo creation. I've never ponied up for a whole jar of the ranch, but one day I'll give in. Get a hot slice and relax in one of the booties. Great thin crust pizza that is fresh and delicious! read more

Cosmo's delivery service is 5 star quality. I live in the dorms and the driver pulled right into the access way and made it extremely easy to get the pizza. He was friendly and the worker on the phone was friendly as well. My one complaint is that I asked for a lot of Parmesan cheese and was given only three packets. Otherwise, cosmos is the best delivery pizza, price and service wise, in FoCo. read more