Any restaurant that has thrived for more than four decades must be doing something right, and after my recent visit, it was easy to understand why. From the warm hospitality to the outstanding food, this was one of those dining experiences that leaves a lasting impression. If you're looking for a great excuse to visit midweek, be sure to stop by on Wine Wednesdays, when bottles of wine are half price. It's the perfect opportunity to gather with friends, unwind, and enjoy a leisurely Italian dinner without breaking the bank. Now, let's talk about the food. The standout of the evening was, without question, the double-cut grilled pork chop with vinegar peppers. This wasn't just a good pork chop--it was the best pork chop I've ever eaten. Expertly grilled with a beautiful char on the outside, it remained incredibly juicy and tender on the inside. It was finished with a rich brown sauce and tangy vinegar peppers that added just the right amount of acidity and depth, creating a perfectly balanced dish. The entrée included a choice of pasta or potatoes and vegetables, and I'm so glad I chose the latter. The real mashed potatoes were creamy, buttery, and clearly homemade, while the grilled broccoli and string beans were cooked perfectly--tender with just enough bite remaining. To start, we ordered the Clams Casino special. These were far from the typical version topped with a small amount of bacon and breadcrumbs. Each clam was generously stuffed with a flavorful seasoned breadcrumb mixture and baked to perfection. Served alongside warm seeded Italian bread, it made for an excellent beginning to the meal. The bread was fresh, crusty, and ideal for soaking up every last bit of sauce. My husband ordered the egg battered lemon sole in a white wine butter sauce, and it looked just as impressive as it tasted. The delicate fish was coated in a light egg batter that created a solid exterior while keeping the sole moist and flaky. Accompanying the dish was a generous bowl of penne tossed with garlic and oil, a simple preparation that allowed the quality of the ingredients to shine. Both entrées were served with fresh side salads dressed with a perfectly balanced oil-and-vinegar dressing. One bite immediately brought back memories of the simple, delicious salads my grandmother used to make--fresh, flavorful, and never overdressed. The restaurant itself is tucked away in a small plaza, making it feel like a hidden gem. During the warmer months, guests can take advantage of the spacious outdoor patio, complete with umbrellas and comfortable seating. It provided the perfect setting for a relaxing summer evening filled with great food, good wine, and wonderful company. I left happy, completely satisfied, and already planning my next visit. Mamma Assunta has earned its reputation over the years, and after this meal, I can confidently say it's a place I'll be returning to again and again. There is meter street parking as well as an outdoor municipal right across the street. read more

See all

Had a terrific dinner with family. On Christmas Eve. Special Christmas Eve menu was awesome. Our server was Anthony and he was assisted by Chris. Service was top notch all evening. Apps included fried calamari. Baked clams and burrata special. Entrees included stuffed calamari over linguini chicken scarpiello. Sole oregonata and various veal dishes. The dishes were all excellent. The ambience has an old school feel. Great energy and friendly. Desserts were shared. Cannoli gelato red velvet and cheesecake. A place we will all continue to visit. Thank you all read more

Won't ever go back. Do not recommend. They don't seem to care much about your business. Numerous issues with service and food. Wait time is crazy long. Two members of the group were sick after having the same meal and they didn't seem to care. read more

My wife and I had dinner here a few weeks ago. Truly a treat. Waiters are very after. Expansive Italian cuisine menu. Nice size portions all reasonable priced. Ambiance can be a bit hectic but always enjoyable. read more

The food here is hands down the best Italian food The fish was so delicious flavorful and fair priced The carbonara was delicious, best Italian bread Delicious olives and cheese apps I can't wait to go back The staff the vibe and food great! read more

Mamma Assunta - Delicious gin martini - Italian Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

Always wonderful food , very accommodating and friendly wait staff. Excellent menu choices and reasonable prices.

I've eaten here a few times while in New York on business. Good food and service in an out of the way location. I've enjoyed my meals each time. read more

We got here at 6:30 on Friday night. The place was jumping and we were seated in the back room or they were serving two other tables at the time. My daughter and her husband ordered wine and I stayed with water this time. We shared fried zucchini as an appetizer. My daughter wrote a shrimp scampi with risotto, my son-in-law, order a pasta dish with sausage and broccoli rabe And I ordered a Pescatore and pasta dish which includes rigatoni this time as well as clams, muscles, calamari and shrimp. My daughter finished off at dessert we were in and out by 730. The fireplace was on and they were slightly decorated for Christmas. Service was great. Food was delicious merry Christmas.SalE New Rochelle read more

See all

The absolute best Italian restaurant in lower Westchester. Friendly staff, lovely decor, outstanding food. We've been dining there for over 40 years, highly recommend. read more

Good food, selectionand very friendly waiter -Guiseppe- like the decor too,-as like a real Italian family place

This IS the Italian restaurant you MUST GO To !! One of the best places for great food , ambiance and service. Upon arrival hostess is always so sweet and friendly. Wait staff very helpful and professional. Food is fresh, hot, plentiful and DELICIOUS. Can't go wrong with this restaurant. Been there many times and never disappointed. !! Five stars plus read more

Solid food good neighborhood place service is pretty decent too. Nothing fancy. Actually when they try something fancy it's kind of a fail. I think they should just stick to the basics. read more

My husband and I went here on a Saturday night with no reservations. They were able to see us with a short 10 minute wait we had a drink at the bar and the bartender made a delicious espresso martini and was super friendly. We were seated at a great table with a bustling dining area, the staff was very professional and very attentive. We've been here before and know that the food will be excellent and service as well. We ordered the clams nada for appetizer which are my favorite here and the shrimp scampi and their scallop special both delicious and fresh. I highly recommend making reservations and if you're in the mood for traditional Italian dishes. read more

Mamma Assunta - Fresh Bay Scallops - Italian Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

See all

I came here for a private event where I enjoyed a bunch of dishes. The restaurant space was spacious and definitely reminded me of an old school Italian restaurant. I had the hot antipasto appetizers (calamari, fried zucchini, stuffed mushrooms, eggplant parmesan), bruschetta appetizer (tomatoes with cheese on toast), linguine alle vongole (pasta in white wine sauce with clams), house salad, veal Mamma Assunta (veal with prosciutto in a wine sauce), and strawberry shortcake. The calamari and fried zucchini were lightly fried and not greasy. The linguine alle vongole was garlicky and the clams were fresh. The veal was thinly breaded and the sauce was flavorful. The strawberry shortcake was moist and the strawberries were fresh. The service was excellent, very friendly and attentive. I would come back for dinner if I'm ever in the area. read more

Mamma Assunta - Bruschetta - Italian Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

Had a private party for 20 people and it couldn't have gone smoother. Food and service were both excellent, staff is friendly and accommodating. It felt like we got the same service as if we were a table of 4. Reasonably priced and delicious. read more

Had the lamb chops and calamari appetizer. Everything was amazing! Can't go wrong with anything on the menu. Looking forward to coming back again soon. read more

I like that the menu is a little more unique than some other Italian restaurants in the area. Food is good, nothing to necessarily rave about but a really good option in town. Portion sizes were good. Overall would come back. read more

Pleasantly surprised at Mamma Assunta. We had an event here on a Sunday afternoon. Hungry, the first thing that arrived was some warm crusty sesame baguette bread freshly sliced and served in a basket beneath a blanket. Second some bruschetta which seemed a bit redundant, but it was still well made and you can taste the delicious Roma tomatoes and quality olive oil. Then hot antipasto appetizers (calamari, fried zucchini, stuffed mushrooms, eggplant parmesan which I was actually hoping were just stuffed shells but still good). Each item was delicious - warm and perfectly seasoned. The linguine alle vongole (pasta in white wine sauce with clams) as good - linguine was perfectly al dente, and the sauce, could just use some more garlic. Veal Mamma Assunta (veal with prosciutto in a wine sauce) was the killer. A generous portion of perfectly breaded veal, signature red sauce, salty prosciutto - I was amazed. The perfectly made potato croquette was also such a nice touch. My only gripe is that there's just one restroom for each men and women, which is difficult if the restaurant is packed. read more

was here for a baby shower party. a good place to have any party. very spacious, comfortable seating. food is not bad, service was good. All the waiter was attentive and kind. the transportation was super close - approx 5 min walk. read more

See all

Another one of those many restaurants that I've either walked by or driven by for years which I never dined in. Well, for my wife's birthday, she wanted Italian food so something made me want to try Mama Assunta, and bluntly put, I'll be eating here more often. For starters, this place is much larger than I thought and I'm happy I made reservations because this place was packed with locals and by the taste of their food, it's no wonder why. We started out with their fried calamari and "Burrata Con Prosciutto which was arguably one of the best appetizers I've had in years, in fact , all of Westchester. Their calamari is plentiful, succulent and juicy and not remotely greasy. For our main course, my wife had their lasagna which she took some of it home being that she was full from the best appetizers we've had in years. I had the "Vitello Mama Mia" that also came with their delicious pasta marinara. Coupled with their house Chianti, I must say that I ate every single morsel gleefully while complimenting my great server Anthony. This is so far the best Italian restaurant I've been in all of Westchester County or perhaps anywhere. If you haven't eaten here yet, what are you waiting for? I'll definitely be eating here again soon and bringing some friends with me . It's very rare that I give a place 5 stars on my first visit, but after such a great meal coupled with outstanding service, that's the least I could do. read more

Best choice in New York area for a an authentic, well prepared and reasonable Italian dinner. Food, service and ambiance are outstanding. Choices very good but not excessive. We keep returning when we want a great meal. read more

The place is a hidden gem! I now go there often and look forward to the incredible food and attentive and friendly people

I wish I could give this place 6 stars. For starters, the food was absolutely to die for! I ordered the mussels & the chicken scarp, both excellent. I tend to dine in New York City most of the time, but knowing this place is right around the corner in Westchester County (Tuckahoe) makes me NEVER want to dine anywhere else. As for the service, A+! Anthony is a fine young gentleman who even took the initiative of refilling my drink without ever asking. He is also very cute (for the younger ladies out there). I support this place 100% & will certainly be back! read more

This is the BEST italian restaurant in the area! Their food is super tasty and very well made. The fact that their food is consistently good is what makes them special. My favorite is their fettuccine alfredo, they also make really nice veal. They have random specials on the weekends which are sometimes good. Definitely check this place out if you're looking for great italian food. Their owner is super nice and welcoming too. read more

Great food, service and atmosphere. This place has been the family business for close to 40 years. Thats staying power people. read more

See all

LOVE THIS PLACE!!!! food is fantastic service is impeccable. These guys never miss a beat !! read more

Mamma Assunta - Italian Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

Wonderful spot for authentic Italian cuisine done tastefully. Nice quite atmosphere; patio dining available (CoViD?). Food was in good portions and was delicious. Food was not overly-seasoned and you could taste the food itself. Even the pasta sauces were delicately applied so as to enhance the flavor as opposed to providing the flavor. My wife had the Brodetto Del Pescatore and was very pleased. I had the Vitello Sorrentino; my son the Pollo Rollatini. No rush to dinner; service was attentive and the prices quite reasonable. We'll be back! read more

Incredible. Claudio was our server. Incredibly friendly and put us on to one of their rare ocasional dishes Pasta Rosa . The food here is amazing. Chicken scarp is the best I've had in Westchester so far. The two gents in the kitchen know what they're doing. They've been in there for 25+ years. I'm coming back to try more. Service here is top notch. read more

I have been coming here for almost 30 years. To my surprise the menu is completely different out of the blue. I don't know why they would change a winning formula. The food was still very good but not what I expected. Hopefully they will put some of the favorites back. read more

Can't say enough great things about this local, family owned Italian bistro. Outdoor seating in the warm weather? Check! Great attentive and engaged staff? Check! Delicious food that is not over priced? It ain't cheap but worth every penny!!! I hate to share this one as I'm still annoyed I wait an hour for Pizza at my joint in Mount Vernon... but perhaps you will be too lazy to seek this one out. Your loss is my.... not waiting for a great meal. read more

Always excellent food and great wait staff. Not a Place to go if you're looking for a quiet evening as it is a little noisy. Tables are not too close together so you will enjoy a meal with private conversation. Drinks are always made well (usually apple Martini for me). Pasta with fish is a favorite of mine, but you can't go wrong with any of their dishes. Parking is never a problem either. Enjoy! read more

Came in for a family dinner, and man, do I have complaints. The waiter was short and abrupt, not personable, warm, or inviting at all. No joke, the seeded Italian bread was the best tasting thing I had the entire evening. I'm convinced this is "Italian food" for the elderly population because everything was bland, nearly tasteless, and VERY soft, which for someone young and with all their teeth is super off-putting. No depth of texture. I ordered the salmon with vegetables and potatoes. First came the salad course, which they found a way to ruin by having it be over saturated in a dressing that only tasted of olive oil with the tiniest hint of lemon juice. Gross. The salmon had an unappealing presentation and a pathetic portion for its hefty $29 price tag. It was mushy, and their method of "seasoning" was to drizzle balsamic over the top. The vegetables tasted like they were boiled in salt water with their texture to match. They turned to mush when I pressed my fork to them, so that's also disgusting. The potatoes were dry but at least had some rosemary. Didn't try dessert because it looked so unappealing. No enticing colors or flavors, just a monochromatic platter of browns. Took forever to get any of our food and the check. Save your money and go literally anywhere else. I'd literally pick Olive Garden over this place. read more

My family and I have been here many times and have never been disappointed. Food, service and the portions are excellent. Prices are reasonable for comparable restaurants. Recommended. read more

It is in a strip mall and doesn't look like much. Once you are inside it is a nice Italian restaurant with good food. The decor is warm and welcoming. The staff is nice and accommodating. My husband likes the squid stuffed with crab meat and I enjoy the pastas. The salads are very good. read more

This will be my first and last time at Mamma Assunta I ordered Pizza Personale Fresh mozzarella & basil Pizza this was awful it was frozen pizza that you stick in the microwave at $11 each. Also I ordered Gamberetti Deliziosi Fresh gulf shrimp sautéed with extra-virgin olive oil, garlic, red pepper flakes at $13 They were swimming in the butter awful. After going in to try to speak to the owner he wouldn't come out.The only thing he said he will speak to the chef it's shows me this owner is a cowed. read more

Generally really like this restaurant. Ordered takeout tonight. Spedino as usual very good. Asked for the stuffed squid fra diavolo instead of marinara, which they did and it was good. However, they did not send it with the penne at all. Also, we ordered polpette della mamma, and they sent something completely different. In short, the order got a little screwed up. The food is still good. However, if you are a true fan of caesar salad, skip it here...boring salad with a sweet creamy dressing. read more

My family, 24 of us, celebrated grandma's birthday on 11/25/22 at Mamma Assunta and the service and food was excellent. we highly recommend this restaurant and we will go back. read more

Nothing but delicious from start to finish. Warm greeting at the door and it only got better from there. On my request gave me the quiet table in the corner. The waiter Anthony was friendly and knowledgeable about the food and as attentive as you would want. The appetizer of clams oreganata and the dinners of veal sorrentino and lemon sole were all mouth watering. The dessert of black cherry gelato was a perfect topping. Strongly recommend and will go back read more

Mamma Assunta - Italian Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

Food is great but be aware there is a price fix special they don't tell you about unless you are a regular or you look them up online. There is also a half bottle wine special on Wednesday's. So as long as you know about it you can eat there economically. read more

It's a great place to go if you want yummy food and a nice atmosphere. I have to tell you that you should order without a doubt the cheesy garlic bread. This restaurant is filled with old world charm and fantastic waitstaff that you would feel like your at home. We discovered this restaurant just by painting at the now closed place and I am so glad. Everything here is cooked to perfection and you might have to bring some home because portions are sometimes bigger that 1 person can eat. I highly recommend anything and say hello to the owner he's always there with a smile. read more