Magic Brain Cafe

4.5 (223 reviews)

InexpensiveCoffee & Tea, Internet Cafes

Closed • 7:00 am - 5:00 pm

Add Review

Directions

Website

Magic Brain Cafe Photos

Magic Brain Cafe - Iced hazelnut coffee with cream - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Magic Brain Cafe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

+178

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Magic Brain Cafe

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Reviews With Photos

Emily C.

Some of the better coffee I've had! I got a half-caf iced latte and the taste was spot-on...not too acidic, not too milky. Cool spot!

Chastity R.

Cute (almost hidden) cafe tucked in the Carpenter's Square Mall. It was morning during Labor Day weekend when I went so, needless to say, the line was out the door. It moved fast with only two people at the helm so kudos to them. Picked up an Iced Matcha although I seriously, not really but humor me, heard the huge scones calling my name but I passed. Next time, definitely! $7+ for the small. Kinda steep but it's Cape May. Love the nook under the stairs & the bench for 2!

Jose P.

Magic Brain Cafe was such a nice find. This cafe has a very cozy feel, a few tables and seats, and is nicely decorated. The Barista is an artist, takes his time creating the "Magic," and my Frozen Hot Chocolate was just as good as NYC's Serendipity 3. If you're looking for a quick pick me up, or just want to unwind while strolling through beautiful Cape May, come into Magic Brain and enjoy the zen.

Small iced coffee with English toffee syrup and Lactaid milk

Candice S.

This is a delicious little coffee shop in a building with several other small boutiques. They have more syrup options than I've ever seen in my life, and this is the first coffee shop I have ever seen that had Lactaid milk available. As someone who is lactose intolerant, I greatly appreciate the options. The service was great. I love that you order and then they make your drink immediately.

Jason M.

I was walking around Cape May absorbing the sights when I suddenly felt a thirst. I had bookmarked several coffee shops in preparation for my trip here, so I whipped out Yelp and noticed I was super close to Magic Brain Cafe. That was all I needed to know, so I made my way over. Magic Brain has its own dedicated entrance on Perry Street, but it's also part of the Carpenter Square Mall which is a super small collection of stores in a mini mall on Carpenter Ln. Walking in, I was immediately greeted by aesthetics - very coffeehouse with medium woods, shelves with trinkets/merch, and touches of green to keep it fresh. The menu had typical coffeehouse items; on a hot/humid day like it was I would typically go for an iced coffee, but I already had 3 cups so I went with their iced tea. It was black unsweetened which was exactly what I was looking for. The tea was good - refreshing with just enough tea flavor; it hit the spot. Service was fast and friendly - overall this is a solid spot in Cape May for a beverage. I noticed they also carry a selection some baked goods, so I would definitely return for some of their bakes as well as more liquid peps.

Mel L.

Came here as our first stop off the Lewes-Cape May ferry. The place is so cute and welcoming. The two staff members were very kind and answered all our questions and more! I received a perfectly temped mocha latte, which was tasty. My friend had a chocolate scone and an anise biscotti and her very first mocha latte. She really enjoyed everything! Not a ton of seating, but we all made it work. They have lots of options for bagged coffee, which looked good but I couldn't make a decision. It would appear they also have yoga upstairs, which is fun. Sad I missed this, but in the corner by the window they have games! Would definitely come back if I am in the area again.

Elizabeth L.

Cute funky space, friendly staff and solid cups of caffeine. Upon entry you see a little nook with seats and books alongside a few other seating options by the window and a bench area on the right. The counter is small but offers a number of baked goods including vegan options. We opted for: London fog (5/5) Dirty chai with oat milk (5/5) really delish and what I wanted. I even bought the last container of chai they use on site 2 vegan chocolate chip scones (5/5) hit for the kiddos It's within a little "mall" next to the famously pink store with a yoga studio upstairs. The man working that day gave the littles cute little magic brain temporary tattoos and as folks were filing in you could tell it's an adored gem in the neighborhood. Can't wait to try to replicate the chai at home and will come back!

Frank N.

What a cool little hidden gem of a coffee joint. Tucked in one of those indoor semi malls. Great selection of coffees, espressos etc. A few people working on the laptops, ha ha I was on vacation. Fast service and espresso had a nice crema!

Lauren D.

Love it go Everytime I am down here 10000/10 must go to only coffee store to go to go

Coffee, Scone & Chocolate Croissant to go

See all

Klaudia W.

271

39

101

3 years ago

Super cute coffee shop if you're in the Cape May area, the staff is sweet and the coffee is great! There's chairs where you can sit and chat with your friends while you drink coffee and eat their pastries read more

Magic Brain Cafe - a cup of coffee with a brain on top - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Magic Brain Cafe - stairs leading to second floor - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dazz D.

1

33

0

2 years ago

Excellent coffee cute merch, awesome barista 10/10 would definitely come again. Caramel latte was excellent. They also have nitro cold brew

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Nikki C.

Elite 26

18

310

453

7 years ago

This has to be one of the places where I received the best caramel macchiato ever. Right off my head, the place is decorated with aesthetically pleasing photos and furniture. It reminds me of a secret library with endless ideas & coffee; Heaven. The service here is friendly and warm. My iced caramel macchiato is very sweet; which I love. My friend got an iced latte which was really strong; Perfect. Will come again! read more

Magic Brain Cafe - Inside - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Magic Brain Cafe - Caramel macchiato & latte. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Yang H.

1

68

47

3 years ago

I had a life-changing cinnamon scone here while on vacation! I don't normally get cinnamon scones but I'm so glad I took a chance on it when I visited this cafe. Theirs is made with cinnamon chips(?) throughout, and the cinnamon tidbits just melt delightfully in your mouth! The scone itself is perfectly airy yet crumbly. Bonus if you get here early and can grab one that's fresh and toasty! I loved it so much that I had to go back the next day for another one before we headed home! Coffee is also consistent here. I also love the cute little DIY bookshelf/library painting on the staircase inside, very sweet! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ashley L.

0

33

18

2 years ago

Coffee is really great here! No loose leaf tea but if you like tea they serve mighty tea which is a great brand!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ray A.

29

39

22

5 years ago

Great and dependable coffee. Love this place whenever I visit my favorite beach town. Just across the street from Congress Hall. read more

Magic Brain Cafe - Hot mocha with oat milk. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Glenn S.

Elite 26 All-Star

332

637

7963

6 years ago

I found myself in Cape May on a nice afternoon and was really looking forward to a good coffee so I did a quick Yelp check. Magic Brain Cafe was just a few blocks away and had some great reviews so off I was. The "cafe" is located in a small pedestrian mall filled with specialty shops and a few nice art galleries. When I entered Magic Brain Cafe it looked like it wasn't even open. Perhaps it was due to COVID that they had to remove the tables but the inside looked like a wreck. There was a shop vac in the middle of the floor and furniture and signs piled up against the wall. Anyway, despite the mess I thought a decent cup of coffee was going to be had here based on all the positive reviews. I approached the plexiglass barrier and perused the blackboard menu. No espresso option, no cortado option, nor a macchiato option. I don't drink milk so had to decide on a non-daily option and they had them all. Coconut, oat (for a 70 cents up charge), soy, and almond. So, I decided to order a coconut milk latte. The drink was $5 and I left $1 in the giant tip jar on the counter. I asked the barista how many shots were in my drink and he told me there is 2 in a medium. In 2 minutes my drink was ready. Unfortunately, it was not very good. The milk was flat (no froth) and I could barely taste a hint of espresso! Maybe I came at a bad time or someone made a mistake making my drink but this was one of the worst coffees I've ever had. I'm sorry Magic Brain Cafe, maybe I'll try you again one day. read more

Business owner information

Stephen G.

During a crisis that has left the hospitality industry in an…

Helpful 10

Thanks 0

Love this 12

Oh no 2

Laurel C.

1

157

258

6 years ago

Happened upon the Magic Brain Cafe by chance. It's not on the main thoroughfare, but very close by on the next street over! They offer an enormous variety of latte/coffee flavors (listed under Syrups on the menu board). We tried the Lavender latte & Toasted Marshmallow latte. Both were excellent from first to last sip. Just the perfect coffee to ease into the day. *Note: 10/10 customer service - We saw the staff offer to remake a drink for a customer who wanted less cream. It was done very courteously and quickly. read more

Magic Brain Cafe - Lavender latte 12 oz - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lena F.

1

36

51

5 years ago

This cafe is the place to go! The matcha latte, iced coffee, and the frozen hot chocolate was super delicious. I could just tell they made it with care! Not only that, but the shop itself was soooo cute. I just had to visit after looking at the adorable logo! I would definitely visit again when in the area!!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jocelyn N.

Elite 26

108

407

660

6 years ago

I was happy to find this spot in Cape May -- plenty of coffee and other drink options. My boyfriend's frozen hot chocolate was amazing and my iced coffee with cake batter syrup was delicious-- they had so many flavoring options, including sugar free varieties. I also had a cheddar chive scone based on other yelp reviews and it was really good-- I wish there had been more pastries available, though. read more

Magic Brain Cafe - Iced coffee and cheddar chive scone - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Business owner information

Stephen G.

Hi! When you were in we just reopened from a 2 day power outage; we…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Paul L.

Elite 26

27

269

218

4 years ago

After spending the last 25 years searching for a good coffee shop in Cape May, I found not one but two good ones during our visit this year. This shop is not like the typical Old Tyme coffee shop that serves colored hot water and calls it coffee. Magic Brain is the real deal - quality coffee and food served by friendly employees. So refreshing. My family loved their espresso drinks, especially the iced chai. I had a delicious carrot cake loaf. My drip coffee was good too, but I like the version across the street a little better. I'm very happy to have found this shop! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Julia F.

0

25

7

2 years ago

Nice ambiance, cute cafe. Good fast service even with only one employee working. Iced coffee was Made well, delicious, and reasonably priced. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Paul W.

26

89

10

4 years ago

The good: the baked goods are delicious looking and don't disappoint. The staff is super friendly and the experience overall makes me want to come back. The drip coffee was tasty while the espresso in my latte was average and a bit on the weak side. The milk was well frothed, though, which made up a bit for the pull. In spite of slightly disappointing espresso, I'd still come back and try a different drink. the bad: we weren't planning to stay, but the cafe is super small. I think I recall seeing 4 seats total. the ugly: nothing. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Roslyn C.

1

63

18

4 years ago

Glad to come across this hidden gem on a morning walk to explore Cape May! Fast and friendly service with a great spicy chai customized to perfection!! The warm baked goods smelled amazing as they fogged up the display case. Will be back again to try some other items. The ambiance is quaint and eclectic! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Russell D.

1

105

9

3 years ago

Great staff, fantastic service and great coffees and teas! This place checks every box

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Janet D.

0

13

10

3 years ago

When in Cape May, this is a must stop for your coffee and beverage needs. They have many options for syrups, SF too, many choices of milks to use as well. Small business run, fun and a need spot to sit and recharge. LOVE IT HERE...PS, loved my "dealers choice" pick for my SF ice coffee read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Lacey S.

Elite 19

258

203

1092

7 years ago

Wow!! After searching about 20 minutes for a parking space around the area at 7:00 pm on a Saturday. We searched this place out and gawked at all the flavors to choose from for our make shift lattes. As I tried to once again explain my dislike for milk and the amount that goes into coffee shop lattes. The lady working the register was very enthusiastic that they had oat milk and they could make these drinks called "cortados"! Anyone who knows me, knows that's my drink! They just don't normally put it on the menu and no one knows how to make them, so I usually walk them through it and take what I get. This 1 required no fib to say it's good because IT WAS AMAZING!! Best coffee we've had in a minute! We would definitely recommend this place to any consumer. The coffee was rich and deep in flavor and just a touch of caramel and oat milk was the perfect blend for that afternoon kick! read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Mary S.

2

44

3

3 years ago

Stopped in during my walk for a chocolate croissant and decaf iced coffee and ate it out front. It was fantastic! Always a pleasure there - good service and excellent food and beverages. Well done!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jennie E.

3

45

96

4 years ago

My favorite coffee shop in Cape May the coffee is so good & my go-to choice compared to the other coffee shops nearby. definitely recommend if you're looking for a good latte read more

Magic Brain Cafe - Oatmilk Latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Brooke B.

Elite 21

82

254

426

7 years ago

Great coffee, super cute space and love that they take credit card. Most other coffee shops near the beach are cash only. Definitely try a crumpkin if they still have some. read more

Magic Brain Cafe - Large and small anericano - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Heather O.

273

13

14

5 years ago

Love this place. Bummer there's no seating in a Covid-year, but it's a small space so it's understandable. Still a great Chai Latte. read more

Magic Brain Cafe - Love this place. Bummer there's no seating in a Covid-year, but it's a small space so it's understandable. Still a great Chai Latte. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Diane L.

0

22

24

2 years ago

Such a hidden gem! My daughter lives for coffee shops and this on did not disappoint! The owner was welcoming and his employee very friendly and knowledgeable. We will definitely be back read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Whisker P.

Elite 24

74

588

96

4 years ago

Great lil place. They sell $6 earrings too! I was delighted! Ben was charming, funny, and a pleasure to work with. Their coffee is great! I would totally come back. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Libby B.

53

87

24

6 years ago

I love this place! I've been coming for 5-6 years, and I introduced my friends from PA a few years ago. The service is great, friendly, and the product quality is high. I just had to go non-dairy a couple months ago, and their decaf espresso and chai lattes are great with coconut milk. They even have a loyalty card. My only gripe is there is zero seating since COVID became a thing. It's really sad and also a pain if I just want to hang out and sip my latte for 10-15 minutes. Since it's gotten colder, I've been taking my coffee drinks to sit by the fire in Congress Hall, but I do feel that Magic Brain should offer something, even if only 2-3 seats. I'd give it 5 stars because I'd know they are trying to accommodate as the weather gets chilly. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Neha P.

0

18

8

6 years ago

Best Chai Latte/iced chai latte's around. Cool hole in the wall with great fresh scones.. love the cinnamon ones and the cheddar chive scones. i can eat and drink there 3 times a day. nom nom nom. thanks. read more

Magic Brain Cafe - Chai - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Carissa D.

Elite 19

198

102

270

6 years ago

This was my first time coming to this coffee shop which was recommended by my mom who had enjoyed this coffee a few times during visits to Cape May. She's a coffee snob so I trusted her. And it was just as wonderful as she described! I especially loved the options for sugar free and non-diary options even in their specialty espresso and latte drinks. The staff was super friendly and helpful with any special requests. I recommend trying the giant peanut butter chocolate chip cookie with your drink! read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

John L.

Elite 26

29

417

197

6 years ago

First--it was open, automatic minimum 3. The coffee was flavorful--up to 4. The breakfast pastries were very very good and the service prompt, efficient, friendly. Solid 5 and a thank you!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rebecca L.

Elite 19

253

278

1717

8 years ago

Huge fan of the London Fog Latte (choice of vanilla or lavender) but not a fan of the coffee. When I was half way through my coffee, I got a mouthful of coffee grounds. Very gross and unexpected. Overall friendly service with okay amount of seating. The place is cozy and the prices are good. There are some board games available for use. read more

Business owner information

Stephen G.

Hi! So glad you enjoy the London Fog!! Grinds in coffee is…

Helpful 5

Thanks 0

Love this 4

Oh no 0

Colleen A.

4

61

8

6 years ago

They have Lactaid lactose free milk!! This makes me SO happy! I rarely ever find places that offer lactose free options other than almond and soy milk (which I am not a fan of AT ALL). The coffee was delicious and the service was quick and staff was friendly! read more

Magic Brain Cafe - Menu - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Susie W.

113

41

10

4 years ago

Good coffee, personable coffee dude who gave good recommendations for local dinner options, and yummy anise/almond biscotti. I'd go back!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Annei B.

43

179

894

6 years ago

Lovely coffee place right in the center of Cape May High Street. Service is good, drinks are awesome. read more

Magic Brain Cafe - Cold brew with soy milk. 7.23.2020 - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Magic Brain Cafe - Lemonade so good 7.23.2020 - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Joanna L.

Elite 23

58

141

24

4 years ago

Magic Brain is a great cafe. It's simple, quaint, and smells amazing. The staff here is very friendly and helpful. I love their iced coffee, and the pastries all look amazing. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mallory M.

Elite 24

573

1221

156

7 years ago

Magic Brain is a cute whimsical little coffee shop in Cape May. I thoroughly enjoyed my visit here and definitely thoroughly enjoyed my scone! Magic brain has lots of flavor options for their coffee. I really liked the toasted marshmallow. My only slightly issue was that they had ran out of the first three flavors my friend and I requested. I don't recall what kind of coffee they are brewing here, but whatever it was it was delicious. I also highly recommend the cinnamon scone, it was the perfect accompaniment to my brew. read more

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 4

Oh no 0

Sefi R.

13

8

10

6 years ago

I absolutely loved this coffee shop! Everyone was friendly the pastries were delicious! I love coffee and I'm very picky about giving a great review on coffee but I must say the Magic Brain coffee was sooo good! I enjoyed a latte by the beach and my daughter loved her iced coffee with chocolate peanut butter syrup! Amazing!! Oh and they were soooo clean! Will definitely be returning! Thank you Magic Brain read more

Magic Brain Cafe - Food - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Auzi K.

333

10

11

6 years ago

I chose this coffee shop based on Yelp reviews, but I didn't care for it. We ordered 2 hazelnut iced coffees with cream, one medium and one large - I think those were the sizes? It tasted watered down for my taste, so I wasn't a fan. The staff was very friendly and kind. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Isabella C.

0

21

8

4 years ago

If you are an avid matcha lover and coffee shop searcher, this matcha isn't true matcha. It is made with mix that Dunkin' Donuts would use. I'm sure the coffee is great but this matcha is too sugary and not authentic for me! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Samantha P.

94

10

0

4 years ago

One of my very favorite coffee shops. Great coffee, comfortable places to sit and relax, and super friendly and helpful staff.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Amanda E.

Elite 20

30

101

123

7 years ago

Good coffee !!! Stopped in for an espresso and iced coffee. I also grabbed a croissant. The coffee was smooth and creamy. The espresso had foam on top (I had an espresso at another place the night because and it tasted like coffee) This place has their coffee game on point !!!!! Croissant was also really good to! Not as light and fluffy as I like but still very good read more

Magic Brain Cafe - Espresso, croissant - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Magic Brain Cafe - Artwork - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Magic Brain Cafe - Espresso - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Magic Brain Cafe - Iced coffee , croissant, menu - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Vince P.

Elite 26

10

87

62

7 years ago

Great spot for coffee, delicious selection and Well Done by staff. It could stay open longer, ni other spots to enjoy some coffee like this. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sarah S.

0

6

1

4 years ago

I have to say this is a chill hang out. Couches and books and free Wi-Fi. A place I frequent to get work done and enjoy the coffee bar.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Back

Page 2 of 6

31 Perry St
Cape May, NJ 08204
Directions
Visit Website
https://www.magicbraincapemay.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does Magic Brain Cafe open?

Magic Brain Cafe opens at 7:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Magic Brain Cafe close?

Magic Brain Cafe closes at 5:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

Mon-Sun 7:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Magic Brain Cafe take Bitcoin?

No, Magic Brain Cafe does not take Bitcoin.

Does Magic Brain Cafe take credit cards?

Yes, Magic Brain Cafe takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Magic Brain Cafe have catering options?

No, Magic Brain Cafe does not have catering options.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Magic Brain Cafe have bike parking?

Yes, Magic Brain Cafe has bike parking.

Does Magic Brain Cafe have outdoor seating?

Yes, Magic Brain Cafe has outdoor seating options.

Does Magic Brain Cafe have parking?

Yes, Magic Brain Cafe has parking options. Street Parking

Other Amenities

Is Magic Brain Cafe wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Magic Brain Cafe is wheelchair accessible.

Does Magic Brain Cafe have free WiFi?

Yes, Magic Brain Cafe has free WiFi.

Review Highlights - Magic Brain Cafe

“This is a delicious little coffee shop in a building with several other small boutiques.”

Mentioned in 7 reviews

Berry Sweet Cafe

5.0

(7 reviews)

66.6 mi

Great service great care friendly staff, tasty food I got the waffle with fruit was worth the trip.read more

Passes the vibe check with Bad Bunny playing in the background…read more One of the few places in DE with the viral Dubai chocolate covered strawberries.

Photos

Fruit waffle

Straw station

See all

Dubai chocolate waffle

Out There Coffee

This place is a cute coffee shop with good coffee and some pastry options. We got an iced…read morecappuccino and a pumpkin muffin, the coffee was actually the best I've had in cape may. We went on a Friday midday so it was not super busy. It's a bit off the main Washington st mall strip so it's less crowded.

Seriously some of the best match I've ever had! You could tell the ingredients were quality. It was…read morecreamy like ice cream! And just the right shade of green. The women taking orders took her time to walk me through the menu and answer my questions, even with a long line behind me. The line moves quickly though! There wasn't much seating indoors, more of a grab and go place, but perfect to grab a cup and walk around downtown cape May. If I'm ever back in the area, I'd absolutely go again.

Photos

Register

Strawberry mango peach smoothie & iced latte (metal straw purchased here as well!)

See all

Exterior

The Buoy Coffee Shop

4.7

(32 reviews)

0.4 mi

Loved everything about this place. Its cute overall, staff was so friendly, and the coffee itself…read morewas delicious, I'm in love with the coconut mocha. Added bonus is that its on the boardwalk, literally steps away from the beach. Its adorable and has good coffee, just go already!

Perfect iced coffee for a mellow beach day. Fun range of flavors for iced lattes. Highly recommend…read moretrying seasonal flavors Chunky Monkey and Blueberry Pancake. Also, the overnight oats hit the spot. Friendly staff.

Photos

Specials Menu May 2026

See all

Inside

Madison's Bakery

Quite simply the best donuts and cinnamon rolls you can possibly imagine eating are served at this…read morefriendly establishment run by a family. You won't find any of those design your own donuts like you might get a duck donuts. These are your classic donuts done with superiority. There's something that they do with that dough that makes it so much better, lighter, tastier; you really do just have to try one to know the experience of eating a Madison's doughnut . Devotion to their donuts starts at 3 AM every day to start making these wonderfully tasty delight. Every year my family comes to Cape May, and we look forward to getting Madison's every morning that we're here. We could not imagine coming to Cape May without Madison's. I hear there are crazy people out there that have negative things to say about Madison's. I have no idea why you would ever say something other than - this is the best donut ever in your review.

Excellent donut made fresh on premise. Light and fluffy. Not cake. Good iced coffee and nice,…read morefriendly counter gal.

Photos

See all

Store front

Coffee Tyme At The Beach

Great little coffee shop! The coffee was delicious and the atmosphere was really nice. Winnie was…read moresuper friendly and gave us some great recommendations on what to try. Everything we had was really good. Definitely a spot we'd come back to next time we're in the area!

This is a great setting and wonderful people watching from the outdoor tables. On season I have…read morenever been here without a line. They have a nice selection of bagels and a serve yourself coffee station. I have found the acai bowls to be very disappointing. First of all they are HUGE. No one needs to eat that much, especially with something that is frozen and is going to melt. I have found the ingredients to be icy and a few minutes in the bowls just turn to mush. I have had other acai bowls on island that are much better.

Photos

Ordering area

Quiche

See all

Avalon Coffee - Cape May

First time here, my sandwich was just right, tasty and hot. They also have a good variety of fresh…read morecoffee. I recommend the Costa Rica coffee. Service is a little slow, I do think they can do better but it's fear. Parking is on the street but it's not a proven if you get there before 11am. Cape May get pretty crowed and I believe this place is a hidden gem in town. Definitely recommend.

If I give zero stars I would. $20 for a sandwich,drink,chips it not like they give you your money…read moreworth either . Is nuts. Dirty place, tables were dirty, no napkins on my table. Service was rude. If you don't have the right change they round up instead of rounding down since it there fault for the change. Plus over charge on the credit card service.

Photos

Pork roll & Cooper sharp with hot sauce on an everything bagel

Everything bagel

See all

Everything bagel

Ostara's Coffee House

Ostara's is always a 5 star experience!! I've been a big fan of the Clue drink specials. I ordered…read morea Pistachio & White Chocolate Matcha. I love almost every syrup and flavor choice they have so it's hard to narrow it down. I also ordered Avocado Toast and added Bacon. Very good idea and highly recommended. The baristas and staff are always great and really make the experience! Food and drinks are always on point. I love all of the local art work & products for sale. As well as the bookstore!

I love this place! I was there this weekend and went Saturday and Sunday. Saturday we ate in and it…read morewas super busy, but not a long wait to get your stuff. Su day we did an online pick up as we were heading back home to PA. The coffee was delicious, sandwiches were all good and fresh ! Everyone was nice and friendly! They sell books and little earrings, paintings etc. outside they have a food pantry bin & a book nook ! When in cape May I'll be back!

Photos

A pride flag waving in the wind in front of the coffee shop

Gotta love everyone! Or anyone who is a good person :-)

See all

Cape May coffee spot

Bagel Time Cafe

So Bagel Time Care was super busy and pricy but my smoothie bowl tasted great and was HUGE! So if…read moreyou don't mind a little wait in line and a wait for food, it is worth it!! I got the Exit 0 bowl and it was so so good! Perfect to start my beach day!

The service was absolutely amazing: friendly, attentive, and made us feel very welcome from the…read moremoment we walked in. The only downside was the food and coffee. We ordered toasted bagels, but they were barely toasted and tasted more like plain bagels. The coffee was unfortunately very disappointing as well. Even after adding half-and-half, I couldn't finish it because of the taste. The outstanding service is the reason I'd consider giving this place another try, and I hope they can improve the bagels and coffee because the staff truly deserves recognition.

Photos

Exit 0 Bowl- Acai, strawberry, banana, pineapple, raspberry, granola on the side

See all

Beach Plum Bakery & Cafe

4.1

(50 reviews)

0.4 mi

This is hands down one of my favorite coffee spots in cape May, I love their quiches and I always…read morehave to get a maple latte from there. They have a lot of yummy options for freshly baked pastries and breads. Also in a really cute spot where you can do some vintage shopping while you're there.

Recently visited Beach Plum Cafe and enjoyed our treats. They were good. They have a lot of good…read moreoptions to choose from. We sat outside in breeze to enjoy our coffee and snacks. We tried cranberry slice cake, strawberry scone and biscotti. Strawberry scone was okay, but rest of it was good. Biscotti was the best!

Photos

Outside view

See all

Inside

Dockside Dave’s Seafood Market

Seafood market that sells fresh seafood for you to prepare at home and reasonably priced, delicious…read moreprepared meals! The crab cakes are naturally gluten free (no filler). Another favorite is the Seafood Fra Diablo. It comes with scallops, shrimp and crabmeat. Family owned and operated with consistently courteous service.

Enjoyed my experience eating at the countertop inside. Had a po boy and a clam chowder that were…read moreboth tasty! I found the prices for their take out to be a bit high... but most prices in Cape May are.

Photos

Inside market

New England clam chowder

See all

Hush Puppies $14

The Pier House

Came here for breakfast and everything was great! They even have bloody mary and mimosa carafes…read more Belgian waffles, pancakes, avocado toast, healthy options like breakfast bowl and parfait - something for everyone here. Servers were kind and attentive. Inside is renovated and modern, with large windows overlooking the outside. Would recommend!

This place is delicious and highly recommended. It's a great casual beach vibe and the food is…read moredelicious. Great drink list as well, servers are quick and efficient. Only thing is, because of the outdoor area and the door frequently opening (possibly) there are flies throughout the main dining area, but other than that, great spot!

See all

Westside Market

It's my favorite elevated deli. Every time I eat one of their breakfast sandwiches, I say, "Wow!…read moreThat was the best sandwich I've had in my life." It's always a great experience at Westside Market.

Very fresh hoagie with thin sliced meats and sharp provolone. Touchscreens were easy to use and…read moreservice was quick and friendly. Store has many different snacks and an excellent selection of fresh meats at the deli/butcher counter.

Photos

Baked goods and deli.

Old World Italian

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

16 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

John S.

332

5

2

9 years ago

If you want coffee in Cape May, you go to Magic Brain. From sun up, to sun down, their coffee stays fresh and has the ability to make even the grumpiest of people smile. I spend my days sitting in the cafe, catching up on reading and working on my portfolio. When I need a break, I talk to the Magic Brain crew and there's never a dry conversation. Please make this your spot to grab some coffee and soak in the aromatic scent of a fresh brew. read more

Ann E.

0

3

0

12 years ago

Love their baked goods and tea! Has a great friendly atmosphere (they'll chat if you like or just serve you well and leave you alone if that's what you want). Very convenient to the Washington St. mall and just off the beach. Open early in the morning and late into the evening. 60 minutes free wifi with purchase. Now that it's off-season, I do miss the Tue/Thu live music in the evenings. read more

Ellie B.

0

1

0

6 years ago

to the barista with the rick and morty hat and a cool arm tattoo, the lg. iced latte w/ cookie dough flavor and extra shot was the best coffee i have had in years. i work in cm for the summer and have tried so many coffee places (including the one i work at) and none have come close to your latte. thank you so so much. love, picky coffee addict with red hair read more

Tina L.

1

7

4

11 years ago

Love this place... Started coming for the coconut island coffee stayed for the vegan baklava. The vibe is great and just today I had the most delicious chocolate filled croissant--and it was still warm. It was fantastic. Yoga upstairs coffee and some meditation what more can you ask for... Highly recommend! read more

Meg R.

0

1

0

14 years ago

New owner this year, and some decor changes are nice. It feels very comfortable in there. Coffee is great as always, and the pastries are amazing! Chocolate+ croissant=delicious! I would recommend this place to everyone! read more