The best doughnut I ever had; will be there every Sunday coffee had great balance and service was excellent wish them good luck

When in cape May- stick with the savory and just eliminate the idea of sweet from your mind. We went to the location Beach on Easter morning for an early morning treat. We got 4 items and while the white cream filled was fresh, light and a solid donut-- the rest were straight up terrible. The absolute worst was the $7 cinnamon roll. The roll was light on flavor, had a stale dense rubbery consistency and made me feel ill. I do not know when or where these things were made but they were not made there, they were not fresh and they were not good. Long story short-- skip the donuts/rolls. And did I mention that the total was $17 for 4 items- rip off. read more

Was in CM in July with friends for a week long vacation & had fun dropping into this bakery & enjoying all the yummy sweets. Staff is super friendly & donuts are DELISH. read more

See all

CAPE MAY: Madison's Bakery has the "best buns on the beach" and not only that, they also are a full service bakery featuring sticky buns, cakes, cookies, pastries, donuts, cupcakes, cinnamon buns, coffee & specialty drinks, pup cups, and even seasonal dog treats! Leashed and friendly dogs are allowed inside to order and you can enjoy your treats at their outdoor seating, strolling through the picturesque downtown with Victorian architecture, and enjoying ocean views from the promenade/boardwalk and beach (adhering to seasonal rules). read more

Madison's Bakery - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

If you are in Cape May you have to get a sticky bun!!! The sticky buns are so yummy! They can be plain or add nuts and/or raisins.it was gooey deliciousness! Cinnamon rolls, muffins, cookies and other yummy treats are available. Coffee/tea/specialty drinks too! Seating is limited inside and out but the promenade across the street is the best place to enjoy your goodies. It is a family owned business. Many of the staff are family. They were all super nice!! Support local family business read more

Madison's Bakery - Yummy treats - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

We stumbled into this shop since we were on a cruise. Glad we did as the staff was friendly. The decor was really cute and hubby really enjoyed the coffee. If we take another cruise this way then I will definitely stop in again. read more

Madison's Bakery - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

If I'm not obsessed with this place then I don't know who is. They've got a good selection of teas for the non coffee drinkers. An even larger selection for the coffee folks. And the baked goods, sooo good. So grateful they have gluten free options. I had a GF chocolate chip muffin. It was amazing and now I'm trying to dupe them at home. read more

See all

On a recent trip to Cape May I discovered Madison's bakery. I normally wake at 5:30 and went for a walk around 6:00. I arrived just as they were opening up. The staff could not have been friendlier. The coffee was just right and the sticky buns were better than advertised. I made walking there each morning part of my routine. I tried something different everyday and the results were always the same. Excellent! I recommend them and will be back. read more

The pastries were absolutely delicious. I liked this spot because it's a good grab and go-not many lines. They have cute tables outside to enjoy your breakfast and watch the boardwalk. They also offer coffee and breakfast sandwiches. We had a chocolate croissant which was so good and a blueberry scone. We also split a bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich on ciabatta bread. The bread was fantastic. The owner was also super nice and offered treats for our dog when we were sitting outside. What a charming Cape May gem! read more

See all

Very cute bakery that is known for their cinnamon rolls! They are huge! I was a really big fan of the cinnamon roll in the cup because it's layered with custard and topped with whip cream. It's rich but very very good and much easier to travel with than the regular cinnamon roll. read more

Madison's Bakery - Sticky bun - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

There donuts were so good it had to be my favorite donut place and they had a wide variety of pastries and the cashier was really nice. Also, the store was clean and pretty. read more

Madison's Bakery - Strawberry donut - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Went for some donuts and a bagel sandwich. Bagel sandwich was great. The donuts seemed day old and they were all cold. Cinnamon roll away the best out of what we had. Prices were high. read more

I stumbled upon this bakery because I was looking for funnel cake. Can you believe that there's no funnel cake in all of Cape May?!? Mind blowing! But anyway; I'm glad I discovered it. Madison's is known as the best sticky buns in south jersey. What is a sticky bun you may ask? I would describe it as a sister to a cinnamon roll except, ditch the cinnamon and add caramel. It is absolutely DELICIOUS. The line of the store is out the door starting at 6 AM. If you're lucky to catch them with extras in the afternoon, be sure to grab the buns because they are perfection. I wanted to try the cinnamon rolls also but I didn't get a chance. They are soft, sweet, decadent, and must be eaten warm. If you're eating it cold, you're doing it wrong. This spot is definitely a gem. read more

Madison's Bakery - Sticky bun - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

The cheese danish were awful, the sticky buns were dry. The blueberry muffins were good, the creme filled pumpkin muffin was a bit dry. It's so hard to find a good bakery any more. read more

Cute bakery with great pastries!! I don't the k they are particulartly known for their cannolis but it was really good! Fresh crunch and not TOO sweet. The staff is really friendly as well. Sticky buns are ginormous!!! I LOVE DESSERT !!! read more

Madison's Bakery - Great strawberry sprinkle donuts!! - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

The sticky bun was to die for! I absolutely loved it - it was especially good with the added raisins for like 50 cents. The chai was delicious. I was initially nervous because it looked so milky and sometimes you get a chai that just tastes like the milk but once I stirred it up it was an excellent combo of sweet and spiced. Service was friendly and prompt considering how busy it was. Would definitely recommend for breakfast! read more

This least are 4th time going there n there food is always good fresh food a must try when you come down to cape May if could I would say 200/10 star rating place read more

Is it sticky buns you want? Then come here. They won't share the longtime family recipe with you, but can you blame them? Pastries you say? They have the best. Donuts- they have won local awards for them. So why aren't you here? I know parking can be a challenge, but if you take a short walk, you can justify the calories you just consumed. In all seriousness, family run bakeries are for the most part a thing of the past that many of us miss. You'd be doing yourself a favor by supporting this mom and Pop operation. read more

BEST CAKE EVER!!! If you need a cake for any occasion and want an exceptionally delicious chocolate cake, I HIGHLY recommend Madison's Bakery. I ordered a half sheet cake for my daughter's graduation and worked with Sammy to custom design it. She was SO wonderful to work with! She was attentive, responsive, and made sure every detail was perfect. The cake was chocolate with chocolate mousse filling and white frosting. Not only did we have more than enough cake for our party, but everyone was fighting over the last pieces to take home -- it was truly that good! It was a cake to remember in every regard. Huge thanks to the entire Madison's Bakery team for making our celebration so special! read more

I'm a first time customer here at Madison's Bakery at the Carpenters Lane location. The service is great! The bakery goods are delicious! They have a nice selection of bakery goods. The bakery is clean and organized! The only thing I didn't see in the display case was glazed donuts. I asked if they had any. No glazed on my first visit. You know I grabbed a dozen. They also have a sale on day old doughnuts. If you're ever in the area. GET SOME!!! read more

Madison's bakery is my new favorite coffee shop stop in Cape May. I ordered the decaf iced coffee with coconut milk and a touch of coconut flavoring and it was on point. I got my two year old a purple flower sugar cookie and she was on cloud nine. When we took a selfie together the barista offered to take a picture of us and she was super sweet. read more

I pre- ordered my cinnamon rolls because I was staying at North Cape May and Matt and Sam were very helpful and my order was ready in the morning when I got there. Delicious Cinnamon rolls, great coffee and courteous service read more

Bought chocolate croissant pastries here and they are wonderful! The bakery staff members were pleasant and helpful. Tip: if you want almond croissants, it is advised to arrive before 10a since apparently they sell out fast! read more

We stopped in Sunday, the last day of the season before closing. Grabbed a couple of very fresh donuts and 2 lattes. Service was fast and efficient. Latte was hot...a bit too hot. Could have easily burnt my mouth. Took awhile with lid off in 40 degree weather for me to be able to drink it. Donuts were super fresh and delicious. read more

Madison's Bakery - Donut - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Great Donuts. I'm a donut connoisseur and I can say without a doubt these are great donuts. I'd say some of the best I've had ever. Fresh as can be. I even put mine in the fridge overnight and they were fresh the next day. I don't know how they do it but they are simply the best around. The staff were also friendly and cool! Thank you! read more

Madison's Bakery - Pumpkin Donut - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Bought a sticky bun from here. It was flavorless... Also asked for the white sugar coating, the sign on the counter said 50 cents, the young boy said it costs $1.50?? Super inconsistent pricing, they couldve just been racist too. Avoiding this place like the plague read more

One of the best cookies I've ever had! Ate a chocolate chip one in the store waiting for coffee then ordered 4 more to bring home to the kids where they quickly disappeared. Love this family owned spot right on the beach & the staff is incredibly kind. read more

Madison's Bakery - Chocolate chip cookie - MUST order - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Went in this morning to celebrate Memorial Day with a beautifully made red white and blue delicious donut and got there amazing sticky buns and also a cinnamon roll!! Absolutely love this place your nuts if you think this place isn't 5 star quality bakery even my gam gam ain't makin sticky buns like these suckers!! read more

Okay. Cinn. Roll okay. Good flavor. Could be more tender. Coffee pretty good. Maple donut could have been from dunkin.

grandfather ordered 2 half dozens and the price was $100. He relooked at the receipt and said he gave a $25 tip which he never did. At first the female cashier stated he must've pushed a button but he said he never pushed anything. A male worker gave my Poppop a $25 refund which was nice. The food is good but overly expensive for no reason. I would never go back due to the automatic $25 tip and it makes me wonder if it was on purpose due to him being older. Just as good food at other places for a way cheaper price. read more

We started out trying to get several items at the Madison's location on the mall. We only saw 1 employee who seemed overwhelmed with a coffee order, and when we asked, told us the sticky buns were sold out. So we decided to go to the beachfront location. There we were greeted just inside the door by an employee loudly announcing almost everything was sold out. We saw sticky buns, and when we asked, they told us they did have those. We got 2 plain ones and an orange soda. The cost for this was $17.50. I laughed--and thought it was a mistake. Nope. Each bun is $6.50 now!! So we paid that money and went back to the first one to get a donut. The service was poor and the negative attitudes coming at us from the workers was even worse. You need to learn how to manage your inventory better!! And it would help if your people had customer friendly attitudes. The orices speak for themselves. read more

Madison Bakery has the friendliest staff very warm, welcoming, and always ready with a great recommendation. I came in for a quick treat and left dreaming about their incredible sticky buns! Easily one of the best bakery experiences I've had in a long time! read more

You must get the cinnamon roll or the croissant or the crumb cake. It's all good. They have a good selection of all.

A place that calls itself "The Best Bakery in South Jersey" better have a pretty damn solid proof. Can't vouch for South Jersey as this was the first time I'd been to Cape May and the lower half of the Jersey Shore. But by god if it's not "The Best Bakery in Cape May." Lemme explain. Cape May, we love you but you're kinda sucky when it comes to two very critical things: bagels and pizza. However, you more than make up for it in ice cream and donuts. Everything in balance. Well, the donuts at Madison's for sure. And the chocolate croissants were The Best I've Ever Tasted and I've Been to Old Hapsburg Cities in Europe Where That Kinda Pastry Is Practically A Religion. My sister absolutely loved the gluten free choc chip muffins; she just wished there were more GF choices... And the service was fantastic! Very friendly and fast. I also got there at a great time. For some inexplicable reason (must be that Cape May magic) I was up really early the entire week and headed over to Madison's just about every morning. So it wasn't too crowded and crazy, which I noticed started around after 8:30. So def see you next summer, now that Cape May has officially become a family tradition! read more

We just had The Best Sticky buns I have ever had (and I have had many, ). Family recipe, I was told. The latte's were perfect as well! Highly recommend. read more

Everything is amazing ! From the donuts to the Cinnabons ! Would highly recommend it! We will definitely be coming back to Madison's bakery next time we are in cape May for the fresh coffee and donuts ! read more

Madison's Bakery - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Treats are good but the customer service is lack luster. They did not know when they would have more sticky rolls (their specialty) and they just plopped our donuts frosting down into bags.. needless to say all the frosting fell off the donut by the time we got home. read more

Madison's Bakery - This WAS a glazed donut until the person working at the bakery plopped it upside down in a to-go bag - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

I came for an iced coffee. Pretty standard. They have a lot of pastries and donuts. Their cinnamon buns looked out of this world, but I did not get to try. Next time! read more

Madison's Bakery - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Their cinnamon buns are good and they have a good variety. Great service and nice workers

Amazing Gluten-free chocolate chip muffin!! Great Service! Awesome coffee and thru have almond milk woohoo!!