I got an iced chai tea with coconut milk, it wasnt as good as I expected but the 2 other people that ordered with me loved their drinks so it wss probably just my choice! The cashier was very nice and this cafe is very involved in taking care of the beach. Overall good coffee as long as you know what you want, great customer service, and a very great company! read more

Really amazing selection of beans to bring home to your family. Would try the hazelnut and the apple pie ones if I could. The coffee is very smooth and delicate. Great location if you're walking around the mall or heading to the beach. A little pricey but that comes with the location. read more

Finally discovered a coffee shop on the east coast that makes a perfect dirty chai!!! Seriously, it tastes just as good as the ones I'm used to from Washington state. Cute small coffee shop with nice folks working behind the counter. If you're looking for a place to grab coffee in Cape May, I recommend this place. read more

They have oat milk. End review. Just kidding... Oat Milk Iced Dirty Chai for the win. Their medium roast Honduras was great. Even hours later at room temp. And even cold out of the fridge the next day. Please don't ask why it took so long to drink a 16oz coffee. But it did. And I'm glad it did. Cheddar Chive Scone toasted, yes to the please. Had the same dude help us on both our visits. Super welcoming and chill. read more

Loved this little cafe! We popped in before going to dinner and a show a few blocks over later in the evening. The owner was super friendly and helpful and the place was cozy and warm, sort of like your own living room at home. My friend and I sat in the window and chatted while sipping our delicious coffees. The big comfy chairs were just what we were hoping to relax in after our drive out to the coast. With the sun shining in and the doors of the cafe open, the nice breeze coming through really provided us a perfect respite from the day. This is definitely a great spot to grab a cup of joe or bite to eat when you find yourself in Cape May! I will be back the next time I'm in town for sure! read more

Low-key coffee shop with typical shore (read: inflated) prices, a hour of free wifi with any purchase. Has a proper espresso machine and the man made me a fine latte but $3.79 for a 12 ounce (called a "short" here) was spendy. I was happy that it was open on an early Sunday when much of Cape May was sleeping. Modest pastry selection, chocolate and almond croissants were actually very very good, about $3 each. Only 4 tables and 2 armchairs downstairs, the upstairs loft seems to be shut (?). Recently remodeled and still a bit raw around the edges with unfinished woodwork and a smell of sawdust, it ain't no cyber cafe with computers for rent no more, just a cafe. read more

See all

The best Iced Matcha Latte I have ever had. The flavor was rich. I didn't take any pictures because I finished it so fast. 10/10 would recommend. read more

Friendly establishment with the most delicious coffees, teas, and select pastries. Open, airy, and welcoming. I come here every time I visit Cape May, and usually take home several bags of coffee to last me until my next visit! read more

Great coffee shop and boy do they have their COVID mitigation figured out for such a small space. Ordered a caramel latte and plan black coffee. Both were great! read more

Neat little place conveniently located a block off the beach and a half-block from the Washington St. Mall. We were here in the off-season so the crowds were at a minimum. Went with a regular latte. Tasted fine. They keep to coffee and pastries, which is fine, too. Will stop by again next time we are in the area. read more

Magic Brain Cafe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

A must visit ( several times) during our yearly vacation in Cape May. Great coffee and pastries- quick, efficient and very friendly . A definite stop several times during our yearly Cape May vacation. read more

Great place to relax and have a cup of coffee. Also offer a bunch of other drinks and food items. Great service and love the atmosphere. Can't wait to visit the area again. read more

Magic Brain Cafe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Very good coffee, cozy ambience, healthy snack options, board games and a yoga place just upstairs! What else could you ask for?

Have been wanting to try the Magic Brain Cafe after hearing about it from a friend. Was finally able to get there earlier this afternoon. Loved the atmosphere! Nice young man behind the counter! Had a skim latte and tried the cranberry and orange scone. The latte was hot and not heavy on the foam and the scone was delicious. I highly recommend folks to try it out. I definitely will head back there when I am in Cape May. read more

Magic Brain Cafe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Came all the way from Arizona and this was our first stop! No Starbucks could compare! Of course, there is nothing that can compare to Cape May! The scones here are wonderful as well as the coffee read more

This is the best coffee shop in Cape May! I spent many mornings in Cape May this past summer browsing stores and walking the boardwalk and I always made sure to get a coffee from here. They use their own blend and have so many different flavors to choose from. They also have a wide selection of creamers/milks to choose from including almond, oat, etc. I love the toffee flavor iced coffee with almond milk! The staff is always really friendly and the inside is super cute. It's an awesome place to chill and chat with a friend, read a book, or scroll through Twitter. My only complaint is that the staff wasn't consistent with prices and I would often get charged different prices for my same order. read more

Magic Brain Cafe - Cute pillow with their logo! They also sell shirts, mugs, and their own coffee beans!! - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Best lattes in Cape May. The place is very warm and inviting. The service is excellent. Adorable! read more

Magic Brain Cafe - Yes! - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Charming spot and good lattes - very small inside so plan to stroll with your coffee.

Every time I have been to this coffee shop the owner has always been super nice! Coffee is pretty good!

This place is so cute and cozy but the dirty chai was so creamy and delicious just what I needed on a rainy Sunday afternoon....felt like hug in a cup read more

Cute little coffee shop with character! Lots of flavored syrup options! We got two lattes to-go. Kind, quick service!

I'm a sucker for coffee shops and this place did not disappoint. It's located inside a small shopping mall. I ordered a 20 oz chai latte with coconut milk topped with fresh whip cream. It was a little thick but I think it's because I used coconut milk. Still delicious! The whip cream was honestly my favorite part, it's hard to find places that use fresh whip cream. They also have interesting spices to add in your drink, make sure to check that out. read more

Lovely cafe! I had ordered a chai latte and it was perfect. I'm glad I got the 22oz because it was absolutely delicious on a chilly October morning. I wish I had found this place as soon as I arrived in Cape May and will definitely make another visit before I go! read more

Once we found Magic Brain Cafe on our vacation, we did not go anywhere else! Their dark roast drip coffee was our favorite! read more

Magic Brain Cafe - Dark roast brewed coffee - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Warm and friendly coffee shop. They have oat milk here. I ordered a cappuccino with oat milk. I'm a coffee snob, and I can say that it was perfection! Their space is also conducive to reading and writing, which I did a little of when I visited one Saturday afternoon. I could tell the owner cares about the business and its patrons by the way he smiles and warmly greets everyone to make them feel welcome. Lovely place. I will definitely come back! Keep up the service and quality! read more

Awesome coffee and ambiance. GREAT SERVICE and fun games. A hidden gem for coffee lovers. read more

Magic Brain Cafe - Awesome Ice Americano and great service. A little gem in the heart of washington mall. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Nestled in the side of Carpenter Square mall, this is a fully fledged cafe where you can sit comfortably with internet and a warm brew. I ordered an americano and the espresso was delicious! read more

See all

Very good coffee spot if you find yourself in Cape May. I liked the vibe here, everybody was very nice, and the coffee (of course) was equally delightful. Even in the off season there was a steady stream of people coming in & out so you know it's legit. read more

The coffee was fantastic and so was the service. I had a great time at this place. The atmosphere was the perfect little coffee shop to bring a book and read or to catch up with an old friend 10/10 would recommend as the place to get coffee in cape May. read more

Magic Brain Cafe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

So good. Chai latte and vanilla latte slap I would 100% recommend!!!!!! :) Also in such a cute location!!

The Magic Brain is a super cute place to get coffee and a pastry to start your day. They have almond milk, so I was already very happy about that. The pain au chocolat was very delicious and I highly recommend it. I got an iced coffee and they have sippy cup tops, so you don't have to worry about using a single-use straw and hurting the environment! It does get really crowded, but if you have a chance to grab a seat at a table, definitely place Trivial Pursuit and remember how hard that game really is. read more

Cute little coffee shop right near the Cape May Mall and close to the beach. The ambiance was charming and the staff was friendly. Nice selection of hot and iced, coffee and tea drinks. Best latte I have had at the Jersey Shore. read more

We wish we could move to cape May just to wake up and get Magic Brain everyday. While on vacation I think we may have gone two to three times a day. Such a friendly crew, I felt like I was at my home town cafe. read more

The café is a great place. I spent almost 3 hours there in a really cold day. Tbh, I didn't mind spending this time there instead of walking around the town, since it was a cold day. They have a veriety of coffee and snacks. The price is good, imo. The coffee that Ihad was great, better than the last coffee I got from Starbucks. They don't have many tables or seats, so don't trust some of the photos on yelp! haha Also that's the only real café that I found in the downtown area. All the others cafés that showed up when I was looking up a place are restaurants rather than cafés. I'd go there always! read more

Excellent iced coffee tucked away in a little mini-mall of shops and galleries just a block off of the Washington Square Mall. Friendly service. Didn't get any crap or attitude when asking them to make change so I could feed more quarters into my parking meter. Perhaps that outcome would have been different had I not been spending $3+ on iced coffee, but alas, I needed the caffeine anyway. 60 minutes of free wifi with any purchase might draw a mixed reaction, but I think it's fair and makes sense, especially when you have a small space like this. All in all, a nice find. read more

No internet for 2 weeks is hard enough, but no Yelp? That is just torture. The place we were staying has no internet access, so I had to stop at the Magicbrain Cafe while I was visiting Cape May. Glad that I did because I had a message waiting for me to join the elite squad! Yippee! Magicbrain seems to get the job done, although no free wifi here. Course it's not DC. You can use their computers - $4 for 15 minutes I believe. Or bring your own laptop, it's $6 for an hour. You can also buy a day's worth of internet or a whole week. It's pretty cozy inside, nicely decorated with bright colors. Mostly wooden or plastic chairs. They have plenty of room upstairs to get comfortable too. Outlets easily available. I had a delicious chai tea and a scone that was a bit too dry. Perhaps I should have gone with the glazed cinnamon roll. Very friend and helpful staff. read more

Great coffee! I'd stay with confidence, best in town. Looked forward to my two cups a day here - Honduras very good

Great service and cozy calm atmosphere! The people who run it are truly amazing! I love the dairy free options also! read more

***this review is for coffee only! No, I haven't used the internet here.*** Magicbrain is like the Dunkin Donuts of Cape May with two exceptions: their coffee isn't that great and neither are their prices. I usually go with a Chai which at any American coffee chain is liquid squirted into a cup and filled with steamed milk. If that's what you want, then that's what you'll get here. However, if you want an iced red eye, be prepared that you actually know what that is because there's a chance that you'll have to explain how to make it to the younger girls who work here. The owner knows how to make everything and handles the situation when stuff goes down, but just know what you're in for. The pastries all look good, but I can only vouch for the oatmeal cookies which are pretty tasty. The only downside to this place is that I pay Starbucks coffee for 7-11 quality. That said, this place is there when I need an ice cold coffee in the summer or a warm chai in the fall (not winter) and for that alone they're A-Ok. read more

Very good coffee with a beautifully decorated area to enjoy it. They have live music on Saturday night. Definitely a hidden gem in the neighborhood. We have ordered an iced mocha coffee and we love it! read more

Magic Brain Cafe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey