Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Maggie Mays

    3.9 (99 reviews)
    ModerateAmerican, Seafood
    Closed Closed
    Updated 3 months ago

    Maggie Mays Photos

    Business Info

    MAGGIE MAYS ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Moderate noise
    Outdoor seating
    Good for kids

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Maggie Mays

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    French onion soup
    David Y.

    I always come here when I want to sit down and have the most delicious comfort meal. Although I might be Asian the food is absolutely satisfying and never to salty or overly greasy. The portions are always generous and filled with love. Service is always great and the waiters are super friendly. Ambiance is super nice and calm. Conclusion it's one of my favorites in my area. Try the shepherds pie and hot chicken pot pie you will love it. Everything is good here.

    Chicken with mushroom and tomatoes
    Jessica N.

    This is my go to spot on bell blvd in bayside when I'm looking for a local restaurant that can't go wrong. This restaurant has been around for 20 years and the owner cares so deeply for his customers, restaurant and food. He goes out every day to the market to see what is fresh to prepare the meals for the day. Every time you go, you will be served table bread with olive oil. You can really taste the rich olive flavor. The chicken dishes are great and have a wonderful sauce that does not feel heavy. It costs the chicken just enough. Even though it's chicken breast, it is not dry. You can choose mashed potatoes, fries or vegetables as a side for the entree. The pizza is a new addition. The tomato sauce is homemade and not tart. It's a great addition to the menu. This restaurant also a bar for anyone just looking to have a drink and a good time. The back of the space is the restaurant and they have a wonderful back area that is like a greenhouse. Id highly recommend anyone to come by here!

    Sabrina L.

    This is a great chill spot to have a drink with friends and catchup. I like the old fashions they have here. I came here with my friends this past weekend and I got the smoking bullet last time and it's interesting watching the bartender make the drink and adding the smoke in to make the smokiness flavor. I also got the hot toddy as that's a great drink for the winter. In the evening they have popcorn the give to the customers so that's a great snack to have with my drink. Would definitely come back to this spot the next time I'm in queens.

    Andie E.

    Great brunch w.limited menu, but enough to choose from. Brunch includes a cocktail, bread, fruit cup and coffee or tea...all for a very reasonable $11.95! I'll give anyplace a good rating if they know how to make eggs over easy correctly...and they do at Maggie Mays! (You wouldn't believe how many breakfast places don't know how to make proper eggs!). The thing that stood out for me about Maggie Mays (besides the food), is that their staff is young. Now, the cynic may say that they're just trying to get cheap labor but I say, Big Kudos to management for giving these fresh-faced young adults a chance to get some real work experience! And let me tell ya, this staff was hustling! It was super busy for Sunday brunch and they did a great time. We'll be back!

    Fried shrimp they are unbelievable

    Having dinner at one of our favorite places tonight I'm having the lamb chops nobody does them better George is the most unbelievable chef my husband is having the fried shrimp be sure to try the place you won't be sorry the food is great but no credit cards only cash or checks

    Sipping~ {My Niece's Mimosa & My Seltzer W/A Splash}
    Mercedes C.

    With so many eateries on Bell Blvd, one of my sisters, had put the bug in my ear about Brunching here for my post Birthday celebration. Maggie Mays lets out the typical Irish pub feel: the dark woods and a sizable bar. For $11.95, you get 2 Mimosas, a Fruit Cup, Entree (French Toast or Eggs any style or an Omelette), bacon or sausage (I passed on both) and Coffee or Tea. Not a bad deal. Right? On paper, Menu doesn't have a wide range of selections but for the most part, it offered really basic Brunch items. Mimosas were a huge disappointment and came up extremely short on the bubbly and felt, I was drinking straight up, iced orange juice. As was, my Seltzer & cranberry, that was chilled but tasted bland- while I waited for my sisters earlier. Luckily, my Omelette, tasted good and was fully prepared with fresh mushrooms (not canned), cheddar cheese and a side of nicely-charred, thin Breakfast Potatoes. My Niece, sisters and Mumsy, all complimented and enjoyed their burgers. All in all, No complaints on the food or from the staff as we were served by a couple young girls who were sweet and attentive (and the tall guy, also). However, inexpensive Brunch concept at $11.95......it was just too good to be true.

    Brunch starters ! All included
    Trish H.

    This place is a solid brunch standard and a Really good deal! The food rates a three as the cocktails that come with brunch are very watered down. Omelettes are lovey, scrambled eggs are nice and soft, not overcooked. Steak was cooked med, I asked for med rare but it is a fairly thin steak. Still a mild flavor and perfect for steak and eggs. Potatoes were cooked with pepper me and onions for that warm yummy sweetness. The bread basket and fruit cups that accompany the meal were a spot on! Nice touch but work on the cocktails folks ! That all being said this was the best most agreeable meal I've had all week!

    Shrimp with green beans and potatoes.
    Meghan R.

    Love this place! Food and service is always on point. Came here for dinner with a party of 6. The back area is so nice with the fire. We did a bunch of apps like the special quesadillas, ribs, and French onion soups. Our entrees were fantastic. Location is right next to the manciple parking lot. Will definitely be back!

    Perfect well done burgers!
    caroline l.

    Perfect well done burgers! Trust me not too many places know how to cook a "no blood" burger!we ordered the wings too..yummy taste. I had two dirty martinis, hubby had a light beer,son had water our friends introduced this place to us last month! Winner winner!We came here with my sons basketball team,after winning. We all ate and ate and ate! Nothing like a team of boys after a winning game!. On Mondays evening they have burger and wing specials! I forgot the hours : 9-11?..just double check.. but you can't beat the price!And be willing to eat late..lol Bill is the bartender on Mondays! Sweet guy!..We will become regulars!

    Dinner Menu
    Cat D.

    I am a fan of this place. They put me on to Garlic Ranch Dressing....like, WHAT?! I can't find that anywhere! The ambiance is nice. We usually go when it isn't too busy. Staff is friendly, though, they need to be more attentive. But overall, they're great. Everyone made sure we were alright. Appetizer: - Mussels in white wine, garlic and oil - House salad with garlic ranch dressing!!!!! Entree: - Shepard's Pie - a pasta dish (i forgot what it was called!) Dessert Coffee: - Irish w/ Irish whiskey - cheesecake Everything was great! I need to get back here, soon!!! So should you!

    Laura C.

    This place is okay. I have just been here for brunch, its not a bad deal. Food is fine. The service is mehhh! Probably bc its busy and their young kids but that definitely could be better. Also the lighting indoors is horrific. Its definitely an older crowd and lighting would be to their advantage.

    Fish and chips

    See all

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of B. W.
    27
    22
    1

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of J B.
    0
    42
    0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Scott W.
    357
    15
    0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Emily A.
    114
    69
    7

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Always excellent food, at an unbeatable price. Farrel is accommodating and appreciative of his clientele

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of T D.
    0
    2
    0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    15 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of R L.
    0
    1
    0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1
    Photo of John M.
    0
    283
    0

    15 years ago

    decent bayside bar. wouldn't go for the food, but drinks get the job done.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 3 of 3

    Ask the Community - Maggie Mays

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for American 27,178 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Press 195 - Bayside - May special pastrami Reuben

    Press 195 - Bayside

    4.1(1.1k reviews)
    0.0 miBayside
    $$

    Food: 5/5 We had the #45 ($20.21 +$5.05 side fries) and #46…read more($19.08 +$5.05 side fries). These were some of the best sandwiches in the area. They perfectly combine tender and flavorful meats with hot pressed bread. Service: 5/5 The staff was friendly, attentive, and genuinely welcoming from the moment we walked in. They checked in at all the right times without being overbearing, kept drinks filled, and made sure everything came out smoothly. Ambiance: 5/5 Press 195 has a cozy, laid-back neighborhood vibe. The space feels warm and inviting, with exposed brick, wood accents, and a casual bar area that makes it feel like a local pub without feeling too loud. The atmosphere feels comfortable, like a go-to spot you can visit any night of the week.

    Press 195 has 3 locations: Bayside, Rockville Centre, and Plainview. The Bayside location is always…read moremy go to location and it's been a few years since I've been back, but the food and service is still as great as I remember it to be. Parking can be found on Bell Blvd or on one of the side streets. I walked in on a Friday night about 6:45pm and my friend and I were seated right away by the kitchens window. Press 195's atmosphere is laid-back and friendly. Our waitress came and took our order without writing anything down. Everything came out correctly. I ordered the #26 - Turkey & Gouda that comes with turkey, Canadian bacon (I took out the Canadian bacon), smoked gouda, fresh tomato, and roasted garlic spread. My friend ordered the #29 - Steak & Chimichurri that comes with grilled marinated sliced steak, tomato, provolone, red onions (she took out the red onions), and homemade chimichurri sauce. We both added a side of Belgian fries for $5.05 each. The sandwiches were very tasty and a good portion. The ingredients were fresh. I really liked the side of cucumber salad as well. Press 195 is your go to place for handcrafted panini press sandwiches, crispy hand-cut belgian fries, and more! Though it was a Friday night, we weren't rushed out and it was getting busy.

    Photos
    Press 195 - Bayside - The small bar/pub.

    The small bar/pub.

    Press 195 - Bayside - Fried chicken sandwich

    Fried chicken sandwich

    Press 195 - Bayside - Meatloaf Knish~ thick & dry :(

    See all

    Meatloaf Knish~ thick & dry :(

    Baraki - Don't forget the meat-- medium rare with chimichurri on the side and fries

    Baraki

    4.4(128 reviews)
    0.2 miBayside
    $$

    I went here for brunch with my girlfriends and we had such a great time!…read more The food was delicious - from the apps to entrees, and the service was great. Our server kept checking on us and making sure we had everything we needed. The calamari and shrimp ceviche were both delicious - the calamari was well battered and the ceviche was fresh. My entree, chicken baraki, was a large portion (had to take it home) and it was delicious. The drinks looked amazing but we didn't try any this time - definitely on our next visit! The spot is somewhat busy but not super noisy, which I liked. Parking is street parking and it does get busy in this area. Overall, a great spot with cool drinks and good food!

    I went to brunch here the other day. We had a reservation and got seated immediately. The spot is…read morevery cute. There is so much decor and many things to look at. We got the bottomless mimosas. They gave us two glasses and a picture of mimosas. Everything was really good. As an appetizer we ordered the focaccia grilled cheese bites. The vodka sauce dip was so amazing. Honestly, that was hands-down, the best thing. For our main, I ordered the Mediterranean Benedict. They made the Benedict. Perfect, I love the prosciutto with it. It does come on top of a focaccia bread. The only thing I wasn't crazy about was the sweet potato fry squares. I'm not crazy about sweet potatoes and I didn't read the menu to see to get something else. Also, the Greek churro was so good with the feta whip. This is definitely a really cute place. Everyone who works there is so kind and polite. It is definitely worth a stop in for brunch.

    Photos
    Baraki - Gold-Digger

    Gold-Digger

    Baraki - Prosciutto eggs Benedict with sweet potatoes.

    Prosciutto eggs Benedict with sweet potatoes.

    Baraki - Amazing grilled cheese - must try!!

    See all

    Amazing grilled cheese - must try!!

    Chicken Lovers

    Chicken Lovers

    4.2(925 reviews)
    0.2 miBayside
    $$

    Just based on the wait time to get food, and the fact that it's packed anytime you walk in, you…read moreknow it's good. This restaurant does just two things- and does them well- chicken and ribs. When you walk in and see the amount of staff cooking the amount of food that they must have to prepare every day. It's remarkable. The smell is amazing. And the smokiness on the food is like being at your favorite backyard barbecue. They fully load the sides that they offer as well. If you go home hungry that's your fault. Because the food is really good here. Just a word of advice even if you order in advance, there's still maybe 45 minute wait before your food is ready to pick up. But believe me it's well worth the wait!

    I've known about Chicken Lovers in Bayside for the longest time and have had it bookmarked forever,…read morebut I'm rarely in the area. Today I finally made the effort to go try it for myself. We ordered one whole chicken with three sides (rice, corn, and macaroni & cheese) and a half rack of ribs with broccoli and mashed potatoes. The total came out to $50.08, which I thought was pretty reasonable for the amount of food we got. Of course, I had to try everything immediately in the car because grilled food is always best fresh and hot. Overall, I thought both the chicken and ribs were good, but I actually preferred the ribs. They are definitely on the sweeter side, but incredibly soft, tender, and literally falling off the bone. The chicken was juicy, but I personally think both the chicken and ribs could have benefited from a bit more marinade or just a little more umami flavor. The standout for me was absolutely the green sauce. It honestly elevated the meal from an 8/10 to a 10/10. It's very cilantro-forward, which I personally loved, but if you're not a cilantro person, this sauce may not be for you. As for the sides, the steamed broccoli and corn were pretty standard. The rice had a stronger bay leaf flavor than I prefer. Surprisingly, the mashed potatoes were delicious and came with gravy, which was a nice bonus. I also enjoyed the macaroni and cheese, and highly recommend trying it with the green sauce because that combo was unexpectedly so good. Overall, I'd definitely come back again. It may not have been perfect, but the food was solid, portions were good, and that green sauce alone is worth the trip.

    Photos
    Chicken Lovers
    Chicken Lovers
    Chicken Lovers - Thanksgiving Eve

    See all

    Thanksgiving Eve

    Valdari NYC - Fresh Pasta

    Valdari NYC

    4.0(193 reviews)
    0.0 miBayside

    Had a great Mother's Day dinner at Valdari on 5/10/2026! Manager Beatrice is truly a gem -- very…read moreattentive, super sweet, and made my family feel so welcome. The atmosphere was warm, family-oriented, and comfortable. The prix fixe menu was excellent from beginning to end. For appetizers, my mom had the burrata with heirloom tomatoes, and my sister and I had Nonna's meatballs, which were delicious. My sister had the rigatoni, my mom had the salmon, and I had the short rib of beef, which melted in my mouth like butter -- that's how tender the meat was. For dessert, I had the cannoli's while my mom and sister enjoyed the chocolate lava cake. Everything was flavorful and beautifully prepared. The bathrooms were also nice and clean, which is always a plus. My family and I will definitely be coming back again -- even if it's just to stop in for a lychee martini and the grilled octopus, one of my favorite meals. Highly recommend for a family dinner, date night, or casual night out

    It was a very quiet late lunch on a Wednesday, with only one other table occupied. The restaurant…read moreis nicely decorated, featuring an open kitchen and a wood-fired oven, which gives the space a warm and inviting feel. Our server was very pleasant and happened to be the only one working at the time, though with so few guests, it seemed to be all that was needed. We ordered the three-course lunch special. One set included the meatballs to start, followed by the chicken Parmesan and bomboloni for dessert. The other included a Caesar salad, tagliatelle Bolognese, and tiramisu. There was a bit of a longer-than-expected gap between the appetizer and the entrée, especially considering we were essentially the only table being served, as the other guests had already finished their meal. That was a little frustrating. Aside from that, most of the food was solid. The only real disappointment was the chicken Parmesan, which was quite overcooked. It was unfortunate given that the kitchen was only cooking for the two of us. That said, the mashed potatoes, an unusual pairing with chicken Parmesan were excellent: perfectly creamy and incredibly smooth. The tiramisu was also quite good, but the real standout was the bomboloni. I was genuinely surprised by how much I enjoyed them, since fried doughnuts wouldn't normally be my first choice for dessert. I would definitely return.

    Photos
    Valdari NYC - Inside

    Inside

    Valdari NYC - Chicken Parmagiana

    Chicken Parmagiana

    Valdari NYC - Red Wine

    See all

    Red Wine

    Maggie Mays - tradamerican - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...