Horrible food, horrible drinks. Steak tasted like burnt and char and idk how vegetables held their shape - they were literally liquid. They were probably frozen packages. Staff was nice. read more

Have lived in the area all my life and passed it by many times. Cannot believe I waited this long to go. My husband, my parents and I visited this past Saturday night. Was pleasantly surprised by the warm welcoming ambience once we walked in. The service was great and the food was absolutely amazing. We even had dessert, which is something we don't normally do. I highly recommend this place and I can't wait to go back. read more

No wonder people love this place. When you arrive, you are greeted so warmly, you instantly feel like family. Food is so tasty. We NEVER go out for Valentine's Day due to overcrowding & feeling as if we're being rushed but that was the not the case here. Tonight, there were lovely specials in lieu of the regular menu and they did not disappoint. I had the grilled swordfish & my husband had the salmon. We both started with the lobster bisque. Dessert was an individual chocolate cake (in the shape of a heart!) which we shared, and coffee. Everything was so delicious. Great service. This has become one of our favorite spots to dine out. read more

Erin's Isle - Cappuccino, individual chocolate cake, regular coffee - Italian Near Me - Whitestone, New York

See all

Excellent place . Friendly staff very good for you it's just a nice place to be sounds like an Irish restaurant but delicious Italian food

Great neighborhood place! Food is good and the atmosphere is lively. Cute, cozy neighborhood place.

I have passed this place for years and finally was able to have lunch there. The staff have been there for ever and are the sweetest people ever. They are very attentive. The food was delicious too. Don't sleep on this quaint restaurant. Try it read more

See all

Let me start off by saying I've been working Whitestone since I was 22 I never once ever thought about eating in this place, I recently went with my wife on a Sunday evening and we had such a great experience. The food was amazing. The service was amazing. I can't wait to go back. read more

I've passed this place literally hundreds of times in my life. Never really thought much about it until I found it listed on Yelp last night with pretty good reviews. I called before going to ask someone if there was an available table for 4 (which there was ONE table left for us at opening time, 5pm), and if they use MSG in their food. It's a common misconception that one needs to worry about MSG only in Asian restaurants. Our friend at Erin's Isle said that it was unlikely that they do, and if they do, it would likely be very limited to certain things on their menu, as they make their own homemade stock. We agreed that if my step-mom, who is "allergic" to MSG, would go to the restaurant, we would double-check to make sure that her choices were MSG-free. We got there in no time flat, were seated immediately, and the waiter (same fellow who helped me on the phone) gave us the Specials. He has a way about him that made everything sound incredible, even with his thick accent that I had some trouble understanding! His service was quite good, even though he was distracted at times with conversation with other customers, and the busboys could definitely use some more training (instead of looking around the room for anyone who needs help, they tended to look at the floor or the ceiling or each other), but they were helpful upon request. The Onion Soup wasn't the best I've had, as it was a little sour for some reason, but I enjoyed it regardless... and the presentation was actually really nice, with a big piece of bread ON TOP with melted cheese on top of it. Never seen Onion Soup that way before. And this restaurant has pretty decent bread in the basket they put on your table when you arrive. I got a Stuffed Chicken special, which was spectacular, smothered with gravy and sauteed mushrooms. Yum. My wife loved her salad, and I apologize I don't know the name of it. The step-mom got the Chilean Sea Bass Special, which was beautifully prepared. I didn't try it but it looked superb, and she really liked it. She went home last night with no symptoms from MSG, so I presume all was good. My daughter got the Rigatoni Vodka, which was creamy but not really that great. All in all, this is a place I would return to, though I think I need to save some money up to do so! read more

I was alone for Thanksgiving at Erin's Isle. The food was great and big portion, the staff very nice. When it came time to pay for the bill the waitress informed me that it was already paid for by a stranger. It's these random act of kindness that makes me choke up. Thank you, stranger for not making my Thanksgiving that less lonely. Joe read more

This delightful restaurant is deceptively tucked away in the middle of Whitestone. Easy to get to and well worth the visit. The staff was warm and welcoming and provided great service. The menu is chocked full of delicious Italian options. This is now a must visit when traveling in the NY / Whitestone area. read more

Erin's Isle - Cheese cake and Sambuca! - Italian Near Me - Whitestone, New York

Met a friend for a few drinks and some appetizers sat at the bar the bartender was called Angelo food was great and service was even better well worth the visit read more

Cozy and comfortable. The staff is welcoming and friendly. Had lamb chops and they were perfectly cooked per my request. Great wine selection. I had a delicious Pinot Noir. Will be back. read more

Traveled from Long Island to do lunch with a friend and was extremely disappointed. Onion soup tasted "weird". Hot antipasto was covered with sauce. Baked clams with sauce? ugh! Fried calamari tasted like it was previously frozen. Save your money. read more

I have such a love hate relationship with this place that's been a staple in whitestone for the longest time. The service is a hit or miss, you have quite the characters in here as waiters so you'll either die laughing or be completely appalled. there's nothing in between. The food itself is actually delicious, most dishes are excellent (although the waiters will get them wrong or at least one order incorrect) so that's annoying. The dessert options aren't that great - it all frozen cake that they take out earlier in the day and heat up in a microwave - not ok! read more

good food, big portions, and a friendly waitstaff that'll remember you from the last time you visited

Everything from top to bottom was perfect. Started off with the baked clams & stracitella soup. The baked clams sauce was to die for! For an entree we had the shrimp franchese & a side of broccoli rabe. The service was great. We had a dessert that was so good! I don't know exactly what it was but it was a light chocolate foam. So good. I came here twice now & I will continue to do so. read more

Erin's Isle - Shrimp franchese & broccoli rabe - Italian Near Me - Whitestone, New York

See all

Great!! Service + food. Busy on weds. Night. Bartender Jim was very accommodatin & personable. Overall great experience!!!

Highly recommend this restaurant been going there for the last year and a half just every time experience great food outstanding highly recommended read more

Went here for the first time 1 month ago. I should be ashamed of myself lived in the neighborhood my whole life and never been. Really good old fashioned cooking, service was great. Took a very long time for the food to come out don't come super hungry. The restaurant is well taken care of with a nice home like feeling. read more

From the name I thought it was an Irish Pub. Pleasantly surprised at the Northern Italian menu. Have been back several times with different people and everyone liked it. Just wish they were open for lunch mid week. read more

Great food and great service. The staff was so attentive. We had not been here in years because we moved out of the neighborhood, but to attend some family business and stopped in for a bite to eat. Happy we did! Thank you for a great meal. read more

Every time we would drive past Erin's Isle we would say we have to check that place out...well, we finally made it there. And I am so glad we did! The atmosphere is friendly and homey. The staff is so welcoming that we felt like we had been dining there for years. Loved the piano player, he really contributed to the atmosphere in a positive way. Cocktails were good, the Cosmo was probably one of the best I've had. For apps we had baked clams & stuffed zucchini flowers. The clams were tender & flavorful. My husband really enjoyed the zucchini flowers, I thought they were good but a little too oily. For entrees, I had chicken parm with spaghetti (my go to in any Italian restaurant I've never been to before) and I thought it was fantastic. (So now next time I will be more adventurous lol) The chicken was tender and both the chicken and the sauce were well seasoned. The portions are generous, so I ended up taking some home and it did not go to waste! Tom had the Seafood Combo (fra diavolo), which he said was delicious - no doggie bag there! Unfortunately we didn't have room for dessert, maybe next time. A new favorite...we'll definitely be back soon! read more

See all

Came here for a date night. Was very much look forward to it, but everything was a bit flawed....I ordered one martini and woke up with a huge hangover. This is very odd for me, so I can only assume it was cheap vodka, which explains the $9 pricetag. I ordered salmon (a go-to when out) and I could not eat it. It was so so so so salty!!! I took it home and "cleaned" it for next day leftovers which helped a bit. That brings me to the worst offense...leftovers! My husband ordered a veal entree, but we were full from appetizers and he decided to take it home even though he liked it (but since i wasn't eating the salmon, we just decided that the meal was over). Well, next day, turns out that they did not put in his veal leftover. It was literally the entire $40 plate!!! We called the next day, spoke with someone and they said they would get right back to us.... days later and no call. I understand if restaurants are busy, but to not wrap up our leftovers and give it to us and then not even call back is horrible customer service. I really wanted to like this place....and I could deal with ordering only top-shelf and saying "no salt" in the future...but I cant support such poor customer service :( read more

A small place but always has been very good. I've had many occasions here as well being a Whitestoner for most of my life. I love the surf and turf. read more

We went to this restaurant Saturday night. Our reservation was honored and we arrived on time. We were seated and had a bread basket delivered. The bread was good, but could have been better if warmed up. We then waited about 20 minutes just to get menus. A short time later, we placed our order. The lobster bisque was very good and hot. The salads were small, but tasty. We then waited about 35 minutes for our entrees. I ordered a pasta dish but the waitress never asked if I wanted Parmesan cheese, and I didn't ask for it. We had to get the attention of a busboy to get our water refilled. After the table was cleared, the waitress asked if we wanted coffee, but she didn't ask if we wanted dessert or presented a dessert menu. By now, we just wanted to leave and it took about 15 minutes to get the check. The food was pretty good, the service was very mediocre, and the restaurant is NOT handicapped accessible, and we had one person using a walker. There were stairs at the front entrance and the rear exit. read more

Been here a few times and food was always good. Service was ok most of the time. Quite a few times the service was VERY slow. Try the burger, it's great! read more

It is very cozy!! The food is very good,portions are large and the waitstaff and bartenders are always friendly,efficient and welcoming.

Awesome food, great staff!!!! Very accommodating Love the variety of food and btw nice size portions!!!! read more

Bustling little Italian restaurant. It was a busy Friday night and we waited over 50 mins for our food. The waiter in charge was very apologetic and did not charge us for our drinks or dessert, but the long wait will probably put us off from going again any time soon. Food was decent enough once it arrived. read more

Quaint, friendly with a sizable, varied menu. We had hot antipasto, chicken parm and shrimp franchase .... All good! Thank you for the great service Angelo! read more

Just had dinner here. Waitress was great. Food was delicious. Ordered the hot antipasto and the stuffed mushroom was soooo good. The baked clams were also great. We will definitely be coming back. It's one of those small neighborhood places that is so underrated and no one would think the food was that good. If you're looking for a little gem close to or near Whitestone look no further than Erin's Isle. People should be talking about this place. I would give it a 4.3. read more

See all

Terrible place poor service food absolutely disgusting stay away. Waitress a disaster took so long even to give us the bread basket which was completely stale. Do yourself a favor stay home and cook Negative zero read more

Colorado rack of lamb is the best I ever had. I'm always looking for a restaurant closer to my home that is as good but no success (I'm not from NY). read more

Slightly, only slightly above average. Soup of the day was lobster bisque. I could not detect any wine but was assured they used sherry in it. Then result had to be masked with a healthy amount of black pepper (they never offered offered fresh ground, so it was straight from the shaker). It was way too fishy tasting. A dollop of creme fresh or sour cream might have helped, as would a couple chunks of lobster. The linguine with red clam sauce was salty but good. I should point out the service was good, which puts an average rating just over to above average. read more

We rented out the back room of Erin's Isle for a birthday party. It's a great room the only downside is that the entrance to the kitchen is back there so servers will be coming in and out of the room while you're eating there. We had some appetizers, my favorite was the Gigi salad. It had shrimp, delicious green beens, and crispy bacon. The bacon was the highlight and the house made vinaigrette was addicting. For my entree, I had the linguine vongole (white clam sauce). I had this dish for the first time in Italy and fell in love. The sauce for this pasta was really good, filled up my dipping my bread in it. My only critique would be was there was lots of small clams on top out of the shell and only a few big clams. This dish would have been made much better if they used more smaller clams. We brought our own cake but their dessert tray looked delicious. Will have to come back and try them next time! read more

the Penne ala Vodka, Marinated steak, Calamari, spinach salad, and seafood are easily the gems in Erin's menu. I've been going since I was very young and it is a favorite of my parents. The bread basket features brick over baked bread and nice flat bread crakers and seasame sticks. The cream sauces can be heavy so dieters beware but the fish dishes are nice for lighter fare also, The shrimp are monstrous and the french onion soup cannot be beat. Check out the desert tray they're usually beautiful tarts and treats from Saint Honere bakery in port washington. The ambiance is nice for a date or family dinner. Most weekends feature a live piano player and roaring fire in the back. read more

Erin's Isle - Italian Near Me - Whitestone, New York

This place is absolutely amazing so you should probably make reservations because it gets very busy. I always get the Erin's chicken but go with a group that usually ends up getting the specials of the day. The food, especially the fish, is always super fresh. The service is amazing and it's great for whatever you have in mind whether date night, a small get together or a large family party as I've done all of them. You won't be disappointed. read more

This place is so under rated. The food is amazing. I got the vodka with seafood in the half portion and it was still a huge portion. The hot anti pasto was also amazing get a little taste of everything. The service was amazing. The bartender and waitress Theresa was so good. She was beyond attentive and very sweet. Highly recommend and will be back again read more

I have dined here many times and always enjoyed the food and the atmosphere. However my last visit to this restaurant was a disaster. There was a very loud, rowdy group at the bar which is adjacent to the dining area. Not only could we not converse but we couldn't hear the waiter tell us the specials. Even the waiter thought the group was loud but nothing was done to lessen the din. Since this was supposed to be a special occasion, we had no choice but to leave the restaurant. read more

Had the sirloin (marinated) last night and I don't think I have ever had a better steak. It was heavenly. Also have had the veal parmigiana and that too was top notch. The customer service is old world - true charm and hospitality, and that's not all that common these days. Will keep coming here! read more