My favorite ice cream place in Edgartown! The flavors really pop! I had a scoop of pistachio and a…read morescoop of blueberry and they were awesome! I also enjoyed a latte. Friendly service and fun atmosphere. Colorful decor, spacious interior, nice seating, and clean bathroom.

Mad Martha's is a really solid ice cream place with some classic flavors and exciting specialty…read moreflavors. I loved the Shark Attack and especially the Catboat Crunch, a delicious chocolatey toffee ice cream that I will be thinking about for a while! Good size portions but still felt a little overproduced. Overall, if you're looking for a sweet treat this place won't disappoint.

Wow! This ice cream is incredible. The service was awesome too. They let me try like 50 flavors,…read moresorry to be that annoying person, but there were so many good choices I HAD to sample them. Again, they were so patient and kind. Awesome service. A little pricey, but worth it. I ultimately bought 3 pints (no regrets!) of the carrot cake (I still think about this one), the salted caramel truffle, and the mocha Joe (I don't even drink coffee and I liked this, it's filled with Oreo chunks but not overly sweet). Notable mentions were the heath bar crunch (yum!) and the brown sugar banana (aka bananas foster), I was outvoted otherwise that Heath bar would've been grabbed as well. The ice cream was rich and creamy, deeply flavorful, just dreamy. I was impressed with the texture too. After being in the freezer for several hours (and then 24 hours later) it was never rock hard, it remained easily scoop-able. I imagine that's a signal of the quality. I have no confirmation, but I'm thinking higher fat content and good quality fat so less ice crystals and hardness? Idk and it doesn't matter. The point is this is flavor town & you should check it out. The carrot cake was my favorite. It took me back to thanksgiving and my grandmas famous sweet potato pie. Hope you love it as much as I did. Pro-tip: Go grab a pie from pie chicks & have it with your ice cream!

Massive line but totally worth the wait. This is not your stereotypical ice shop with regular…read moreflavors so do be mindful of that. However, this is the creamiest and BEST ice cream in Edgartown. Another note - A little tough later in the night (after 9pm) because a lot of the flavors were out by the time we got there so come which multiple flavors in mind. HIGHLY recommend the strawberry (it was the real, not syrupy/fake kind). The maple walnut was great with big chunks of walnuts. And the cookies and cream had the most cookies in cream I have ever seen.

Nice staff, good prices, large variety of items to get, nice view of water, and very cleanread more

Fudge is the only decent option on the island outside of the farmer's market with Murdick's closed,…read morebut SO MUCH AI SIGNAGE. We did okay with 3 kids getting candy for under $20, but I hate seeing the AI everywhere.

Well, TEN STARS!! Just an incredible experience from beginning to end. The place was jampacked and…read moreI felt like we were the only ones in there. The ice cream was so good. Cody was lovely! He communicated crystal clear that we were only allowed to try two flavors. The two flavors I got I actually enjoyed. Peanut butter and cake batter. I appreciate people who are clear and kind. I would definitely go there again because of him

I got 2 chocolates: 1 dark chocolate mog bar and 1 milk chocolate whisky truffle.Both were super…read moretasty. Came out to $5 which is very affordable for hand made chocolate. The staff here is also so friendly.

PROS: Several places to sit, menu variety plentiful, they make your orders fast, friendly staff,…read moreprices were good CONS: This place is cash only OVERALL: I would definitely come back here. However, bring cash. They do have an atm which is helpful. Also, street parking is scarce

Stopped by Vineyard Scoops yesterday and I liked it! The location is convenient in downtown…read moreEdgartown and the girls working the counter were kind and attentive. The ice cream store itself is adorable and has many pictures from the Jaws movie. I will say that the establishment is cash only so be aware of that before you go in. Vineyard Scoops had a variety of ice cream flavors and there were atleast three I wanted to try. I ended up with the ice cream that had m and ms, fudge, and cookie dough. It was good! The ice cream tasted fresh and overall everyone seemed happy with their ice cream. I'm only giving four stars because I felt the size of the ice cream was a little on the smaller end for $7. I know it's Martha's vineyard but I'm used to a lot of ice cream in my scoops when I order.

I genuinely cannot emphasize enough how insanely good this ice cream is. I'm not kidding when I say…read morethis is one of the best ice creams I've ever had in my entire life. The ice cream itself is unbelievably creamy, and the toppings are just as good. They don't skimp on the mix-ins either--the way they load the ice cream with toppings is honestly insane. Every bite is packed with something delicious. My two favorite flavors were Shark's Tooth, which is a blackberry-based ice cream with white chocolate chips, and Sweet Cream & Nuts, which is a sweet cream-based ice cream with walnuts. Both were AMAZING. I would genuinely do anything to go back and have those two again. We also tried a couple of the cookie dough and Oreo-based flavors, and those were incredible too. I especially don't know what they do with their cookie dough, but it is so decadent, soft, and delicious. It almost melts into the ice cream. I seriously don't know how they make their ice cream, but whatever they're doing needs to be studied lol. This place is SO good, and if you're in the area, you absolutely have to try it. They also have two locations, which makes it even better!

It seems like this is THE spot for ice cream in the area because we showed up 15 minutes before…read moreclosing, and there was a line of cars waiting to go in and 30 or so people waiting in a line outside. The line inside goes by so much faster, so I definitely recommend going there instead of waiting outside. I was pleased to see many nondairy flavors and not just fruit sorbets. I got the chocolate pudding which was quite creamy and satisfying. About $7 for a scoop. Plenty of seating inside and outside. The staff here work hard--there were still people in line even 45 minutes after closing when we left. I'll definitely be back if I'm in the area again!

So September is definitely a way better month to come get icecream when the line isn't down the…read morestreet! Whatever flavor you get (super yum for the highly recommended Nantucket chocolate covered cranberry or cinnamon roll) you must get a homemade warm waffle cone!! This is not the place to get a plain boring dish of icecream- indulge in one of the unique flavors and the waffle cone or cup whatever you do!!

Sticker shock. Menu doesn't show prices clearly, or else the line would be shorter. $13 for an…read moreice cream cone and $16 for a frappe?!? Plus tax. Wow. Great location near the bigger ferry dock. Service quickly explained the bill when we figured the total must have been a mistake. Tasted good, but wow.

The best creamery in the area, no competition! Our entire family has been going to Somerset…read moreCreamery for years, and it has always remained our favorite. Their quality is consistent and unmatched, from their diverse flavors to their homemade waffle cones. There are no bad flavors - it all depends what you're in the mood for! Our favorites are their Kahlua Chip, Carrot Cake, Cookie Dough, Red Velvet Cake, Peanut Butter Oreo and Banana. Be sure to check out their speciality flavors that rotate throughout the season!

This is my all-time favorite ice cream place. I do not even live super close to here, but when I…read morewant a good ice cream, I will make the drive over. I now live on an island - and you bet that when I went off-island last week I requested that my dad stop here on the way home from Hyannis. My dad had to say yes; having worked in the ice cream industry in his youth, he knows a good cone when he sees one and Somerset Creamery tops his list as well. Embarrassingly, we got there 10 minutes before they opened. We camped in the parking lot. When it was time to go in, I already knew what I was getting. Chocolate mint ice cream in a waffle cone. First of all, it is the best ice cream flavor ever created. Chocolate and mint ice cream with Oreo cookie pieces. What else could you ask for?? And then their waffle cones and made fresh and they are oh so good. The service is always great, and they now take credit cards!! I cannot recommend this place enough. The only downside is that they do not have any dedicated seating, inside or outside. There are some planters of sorts that you can sit down on. Once I sat on one for three hours for a first date - can't say I recommend that. But if you want good ice cream, come here! (Yes, it is better than the Barn in my opinion).

What a hidden gem in South Chatham! We stayed at a Cape house just down the block from Short N'…read moreSweet, and I am so glad we did. This ice cream is awesome! We visited twice. The first time was a Sunday night in May and the line was literally out of the door! And I quickly understood why. Their ice cream is soooo good. Like seriously AMAZING. And even better? The bang for your buck! This is some of the most price favorable and high quality ice cream I've ever tried. Their XXL, which is 6 scoops and huge, is $8.90. I am shocked! Staff is also super nice and explained all of the flavors we had questions about to us. I tried their chocolate, strawberry, raspberry chocolate chip, s'mores, and phantom berry ice cream. All were amazing. My favorites were definitely the chocolate, s'mores, and phantom berry ice creams. All amazing options, I would seriously recommend this place!

First time trying this ice cream spot in my 23 years on the Cape- so glad I did! My mom and I…read morewalked, which I recommend with how busy the parking area can get. Also be sure to bring cash, or use the ATM inside. I love the flavor selection and the amount of different areas you can order from. Service was very fast even with a line! The school house interior was super cute, but I really enjoyed the outdoor seating areas! Plenty of room to sit and enjoy your ice cream! The coffee khalua brownie is something I'd definitely come back for!

I love this place. They never miss. The portions are huge so i always recommend ordering a small…read more Love the smell of the fresh waffle cones! Definitely need to try this place!

I have been a few times years ago, and lately there's been so much hype that I had to go back…read more I ordered an apple pie & pb oreo Sunday with whipped cream. It was ok, I was definitely expecting more of a flavor bomb with the apple pie. It was sort of bland. I wss hoping for crazy cinnamon and apple flavor.