Delicious! Same taste from 40 years ago! When I am around Dover/Rockaway area, I have to stop and get a large pie! Price is still cheap at $13.50! The taste of the mozzarella is so creamy! And the sauce is perfect! Not too salty! Service is great! Been stopping by M&S since high school read more

M & S Pizza - Large Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dover, New Jersey

M&S is our go to spot for pizza. The pies are always done well and cooked fresh immediately after order. The ordering and service is straight forward. The restaurant itself is a no thrills pizzeria that's dedicated to cranking out a great product filled with smells of pizzas and dough. Expect good food on almost all the items on the menu served straight out of the oven. We haven't found better yet. read more

Old Style NYC Pizzeria.... Hard working & curtious .... They know their trade, and how to take care of there customer. read more

Very very satisfied. MS1 makes a quality pie. Not saying there's a competition, but if there is.. hands down better than MS2. read more

Remarkably good pizza. Got two slices for an early afternoon lunch on Monday 12/30/2024. I chose the traditional, but they have varieties. Friendly service. A good pizza parlor vibe, a comfortable place to sit and enjoy great pizza. Best pizza I've had since moving here a year ago (from New York City). Parking in an adjacent lot. On route 46. It is now my go-to pizza joint. Highly recommended. read more

Best pizza in area when I was in high school and still the best today. I drive a half hour nowadays just to get there...

As anyone who sees my reviews knows, I'm always on the lookout for pizzerias I haven't been to. Not sure why it took me so long to hit M&S, but this week I had a chance to stop in for lunch. I always love old school pizza places and that's exactly what this place is. No frills, just solid pizza. I ordered a slice of mushroom and it was delicious. Plenty of other pies to choose from on counter also. Private parking lot, lots of seating, reasonable prices. Good stop if you're in the area and looking for a slice! read more

See all

Pizza was really good using fresh ingredients. Sauce was just right and the size was great! Recommend if in the area.

Great Pizza and Stromboli. Definitely coming back. I ordered 8 pizzas and two Stromboli for a party and everything was marvelous

If you're looking for fancy don't come here. If you are looking for amazing Sicilian pizza come here I think it's the best I ever had. Thick not gooey just the right amount of sauce and cheese. Grandmas pizza excellent regular pizza excellent. Paper plates paper cups nothing fancy but great pizza so if you like great pizza stop by a get a pie. read more

I have been going here for decades. I moved to Florida 25 years ago, where all pizza sucks, but every time I go back to NJ, I hit them up first thing. If I am back for 5 days, I will go there between 4-6 times. Best pizza anywhere. They also have great chicken parm sandwiches and Sicilian. read more

I Don't live in New Jersey anymore but M&S pizza is the first place I like to stop and grab myself a pie or a couple of slices to enjoy! I enjoy sitting inside at one the booths and enjoying a piece of home. The pizza is nice and thin but not paper thin to where they fall apart and can't hold a fold. The crispiness of the crust paired with the fresh red sauce and of course that famous stretchy flavor mozzarella cheese on top! Cannot go wrong at all with anything on the menu! The service is always great. Always greeted with a large smile and quick service! read more

See all

If you're looking for a good pizza or sub, you won't be disappointed. A local, old school pizza shop with a high reputation. They serve a mean pie, quick service, with a price that is on point. Sundays they run a special for their pies $9.75 plus tax. Locals claim it's the best, and it doesn't disappoint. Location is good and makes it easy to find. Parking is available in the front and side of the building. They are an old school pizzeria so the dining area isn't updated or date-night worthy but if you're looking to eat in, quick bite, or just enjoy a slice and make some memories at a pizza spot, dine in and enjoy. Many loyal customers love that it's stayed the same since the 70s and because of their pizza, I always go back. This spot only offers delivery from door dash and grub hub and you can place your order form online. Overall rating- A: for pizza and subs B-: for interior read more

See all

Pizza was delicious! Prices were extremely reasonable! Reminded me of my childhood pizza in NY!

Great EVERY TIME. Fast delivery too. We always get pizza here and have for the last 20 years

Best Pizza in the state hands down. This place has been a staple in the area for a long time. Same employees since the beginning. Same great taste. Not affiliated with M&S 2. Bar Stool Pizza review should come here and do a review! read more

This is truly the best place in New Jersey in my recommendation when Dave cooks the pizza the Sicilian or the regular pies the sauce the cheese the crust the bread everything is delicious is definitely the best round Make sure Dave cookie pie when you go there! read more

M & S Pizza - This pie made by Dave one of the owners! - Pizza Near Me - Dover, New Jersey

Stopped here for a quick lunch and had the BEST spicy mussels!! The sauce was delicious you could eat it with a spoon. I also got an order of the fries & asked for well done and they were perfectly crisp! I will definitely be back to try the pizza next time read more

M & S Pizza - Mussels Marinara - Pizza Near Me - Dover, New Jersey

inedible pizza here...I opened the box and it looked like a gallon of buffalo sauce was poured over a whole pie with boiled chicken on top. This is disgusting. After 2-3 bites, I had to throw it away. Worst pizza I ever had in my life (NOT AN EXAGGERATION) I had M&S II and thats one of my favorite local pizzerias. This "Original M&S" is the polar opposite. I honestly cannot think of a single pizza that was worse than this one. Looks like I just wasted my money. You could not pay me to eat here again. read more

M & S Pizza - This is really disgusting. Theres so much sauce I had to throw away the whole pie. It's not edible. - Pizza Near Me - Dover, New Jersey

Ordered a plain slice Dough - thin and crispy Sauce - on the sweeter side Cheese - average amount of cheese Crust - crunchy Overall good slice. Would give 3.5 if I could. read more

I love this place. The food is great it never disappoints. I love the pizza the hot subs, just tried the chicken Caesar salad for the first time the other day it was amazing. The service is fantastic they are nice. staff is friendly, the ambiance is clean, family oriented great place to eat. Always! I will come back here every time read more

Was working in the area and a friend of mine suggested this place and it did not disappoint. Very great quality in the slices... soft bread, the sauce taste like actually pizza sauce again the quality was beautiful and great. 5 stars and great customer service. Enjoy read more

Best pizza ever! I drive all the way from Sparta for their pizza. Love this place! Only thing that would make this place better is if they moved to Sparta! Please never change your awesome pizza! read more

I'm surprised I didn't get around to reviewing this place yet. I have to be honest, I haven't found much in the way of pizza places that impressed me at all in Morris County. This place, on the other hand, offers genuinely good pizza, as well as other tasty dishes, genuinely good prices. Add to that friendly service and you can't go wrong. If you're looking for pizza in the general area, here is your spot. Go and enjoy! read more

Really good pizza and they deliver fresh hot pizza. I love that they have a cauliflower pizza option which is just a delicious as their regular pizza. The only downside is that about 98% of the time when my pizza arrives, they don't cut the pizza all the way through. read more

This is an old school pizzeria, it's been around since I was a kid! It has moved but it's still the same. So onto the food.. The pizza is soft and cheesy! My children love it and if they love it you should because they are super picky! The menu is simple! The food is Good and not fancy The hot sandwiches are big and tasty The service is quick and friendly! This pizzeria is for a quick pizza or hot/cold subs! To sum it up it's a pizzeria with good prices with no frills attached. read more

See all

Here's the deal: it was national pizza day & I was craving some good ol' fashion slices! I yelped this place & decided to give it a try. This no frills pizzeria has some damn good slices!! Loved the crunch of the crust & the cheese stayed on the slice but has enough stretch to it! I would've taken a picture, but they were gone too fast!! Really good pizza I'd go back !! read more

The pizza from here is amazing! I'm not from nj but i love this place and everytime i come up this is a must have! They also have the best grape soda hands down! The guys who work there are super nice and friendly. read more

This is your typical pizzeria. If you want a quick bite and eat within a budget this is your spot. Personally, I think there sandwich are pretty good. read more

M & S Pizza - a cheese pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Dover, New Jersey

Great pizza. The sauce is authentic and one of a kind. Their cold sub sandwiches are good and they make great salads I can recommend the chefs salad (yeah I eat salads).The meatball parm sub is great, as is the chicken parm sub. Plus everyone knows Coke is better than Pepsi. Now, this is an "old school" pizzeria so don't get your "feelings" hurt if they don't hold your hand or walk you to your car, but the bottom line is you get some of the Best pizza in the area at a very fair price. read more

M&S is our go-to pizza place and has been for years. My wife and I usually go on a Sunday night for a couple of slices and have never, ever been disappointed. In fact, we usually look at each other and say, "Gee, this is good pizza!" - really... The restaurant looks like it was built from my memory of how pizza places looked in my youth. Nailed-down tables with attached benches, a front counter with the purple and orange mystery soft drinks circulating under glass (who drinks that stuff?), huge pizza ovens cranking away behind the counter and an Italian looking fellow (direct from central casting) making pie after pie. As for the taste? Well, the sauce is wonderful, the cheese fresh and applied expertly - not too much, just enough and of course, the crust, not too thin, not too thick and crisp enough to hold up to so you can enjoy a folded slice (the way God eats his pizza). I'm not sure why there is an M&S AND an M&S II - about a mile apart - but after trying them both, we definitely prefer the pizza at M&S. And, if you try their pizza, I think you will too. read more

Love their pizzas, chicken wings and meatballs sub. They have the best pizza in all over Dover. I use to worked around there and I always go there with friends late night after work to get pizza and they close late, so it was convenient and always our go to pizza place. They always have specials time to time. If I can eat a whole cheese pie to myself, that means the pizza is delicious, lol.. whenever I go to rockaway mall or visit my friends in the area, I always stop here to pick up pizza. read more

Local pizzeria growing up, I still love coming here for pizza or a sub. Same staff and owners as 30+ years ago, they make an awesome pizza with crunchy but chewy crust, good tomato sauce and gooey cheese. Sunday pie is only $9.75. What a bargain! Submarine sandwiches start with great bread, which you can order toasted, and fresh ingredients. At $6-7 per sub, you'll have enough left over for another meal! Love coming here! Brings back great memories and I get delicious pizza!!! read more

I am so happy to be writing this review right now! I have been on a search for some good pizza and finally found M&S. I've tried most places in the area and none have come close to this pie. Perfect amount of cheese to sauce ratio. The crust is crunchy and not doughy. They even put more pepperoni than most places! read more

M & S Pizza - Large pepperoni pie - Pizza Near Me - Dover, New Jersey

See all

I moved up in the area about a year ago and have been slowly trying new places for various items, including pizza of course. I knew early and have confirmed a few times: THIS is my place! I LOVE their Sicilian pizza. It's an old-school, fresh, golden crust, with a silky tomato sauce very similar to Dickie Dee's the place I used to go to in Newark (Italian Hot Dogs!). Same type of old plastic booth seating. Fountain drinks with a basic, simple menu. That's OK by me. My only disappointment is they do not deliver! That bums me out. Some days, I don't feel like going out so I have to have a delivery backup. I'm still looking for that..... If I want good, tasty, delicious pie or sandwiches, I'm going to M&S. And yes, this is their only location, I asked....twice. Thanks, M&S, see you soon! read more

M & S Pizza - Sicilian slice and Grape fountain drink. So good! - Pizza Near Me - Dover, New Jersey

Soooo worst experience with service we've ever had anywhere. After calling ahead and waiting on line for a whole pie, was told I wasn't waiting on line and then treated rudely. My whole family has been coming to this place forever. Never had this type of interaction. It was always friendly and nice even if they were busy. It has totally changed. Then the real kicker-the pie was cold. Not going back. Thanks. read more

Today was the first of two installments in the M&S comparison test. My Rockaway friend swears by the original, so I visited the original first. I consider myself a pizza snob to the core, so here is my comparison against the best that the NYC area has to offer. * Crust: Appropriately thin. I wouldn't call it "soft" like others have, but it's not too crispy. To me, it strikes the right balance. It doesn't overpower the pizza (i.e. too doughy or too much of the slice). I noticed other people ripping off the crust and dipping it in tomato sauce, so it's popular. * Sauce: Reasonable. It seemed a little on the sweeter side as opposed to the savory side, and I prefer the savory side. It didn't have a depth of seasonings to it, no leaves of oregano or what have you within. * Cheese: Too much. A regular pie tastes like an extra cheese pie. And while sometimes too much cheese can be a good thing Okay, let me rewrite that. And while too much cheese is always a good thing, in this case, the cheese isn't cooked enough to where it gets that nice golden crust to it and that umami really starts to percolate. The cheese melts but it's still that pale whitish-yellow of mozzarella that results in the cheese dominating the flavor profile instead of playing nicely with the other elements of the pie. Verdict: A weaker 4/5, but then again, lightyears ahead of pizza outside the NYC tri-state area in general. There is room for M&S II to win this comparison, and my hometown favorites (Mario's in Bloomfield, Pasquale's in Boonton, even Marino's in Parsippany) still place ahead. To be continued... read more

Ordered a veggie pizza. It came with canned mushrooms, bug chunks of broccoli, a crap ton of onions just thrown on and not cooked, and day old olives. The vegetables were not cut to easily bite into and you couldn't pick up the pizza it was so mushy. The pizza was not edible. We ended up placing an order to another pizza place that nt and throwing away the pizza we ordered from here. read more

If you want classic, traditional pizza along with an environment that transports you to the 1960/70 era, this is your place. This is Northern New Jersey pizza done right with no frills. I stop in to get a couple of slices and a small soda.. $4.40. The slices are fresh, the sauce is magnificent, the cheese is tasty, stringy, chewy, and not salty. All of this is presented on a perfect crust. The owners/employees seem to be Italian, though I'm not sure where they're from based on a unfamiliar dialect. They're often watching Italian TV broadcasting soccer. Go here for some great old school pizza parlor experience! Love this place! read more

M & S Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dover, New Jersey

See all

Heard great things about this place. Ordered half tomato/onion ended up with literal slices of fat sandwich tomato slices on one side. Pizza must have been in the oven for 5 minutes because the flop on each slice was unbelievable. Mushy center and had to reheat it immediately. Unfortunately there was absolutely no flavor in the sauce or crust, so bland. Bummed out, hard to mess up a basic pie in NJ. read more

M & S Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dover, New Jersey