STILL TAKING ONLINE ORDERS AND PEOPLES MONEY AFTER EVICTION! I ordered lunch online because I was running an errand nearby on my lunchbreak. I had never eaten here but it looked decent. Much to my surprise, I arrive and the place is boarded up with an eviction notice taped on the door. I tried to call the number and it is disconnected. I waited to see if the charge went through and to my surprise, IT DID! My bank told me they don't dispute food charges. So how am I to get my money back for food I never received? more importantly, WHYYY is RJs website still up and active if they have been closed for over a month?!? I want my money back. I will report them as soon as I figure out who it is I should be reporting them to. I can't be the only one this has happened to. read more

We order from here all the time, some of the best pizza in the area (mama nata is our favorite). We also just catered our daughters birthday party from RJs, I worked directly with Frank the owner he was so nice, responsive and was so pleasant to work with, giving great and reasonable recommendations to ensure we had enough food. Everyone raved about the food at the party, especially the eggplant rollitini - DELICIOUS. read more

Since I was in Rockaway at lunch time today, I stopped at RJ's. This is a pizzeria which I've wanted to visit for a long time. It's conveniently located in a strip mall on Rt 46. The good news was that the 2 slices of plain were delicious! This is a nice thin crust that reminded me of pizza from Queens when I was a kid. It was also very reasonably priced at just $2 a slice. The one negative for me was that this was lunch time and the 2 slices on the counter were all there was to choose from. I would have liked to have seen what their speciality slices were like. RJ's is a place I'll definitely try again. Hopefully they'll be more of a selection next time. read more

RJ's Pizzeria - First time here - Pizza Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

I like the pizza here but I wish they used crumbled sausage on them like many other pizza places do. I also wish they offered a thin crust pizza. ‍ read more

must have been an off day. I ordered a pizza thru Slice app for pick up at 4:30. When I walked in to RJ's it was empty and I stood at the counter while an employee was on his cell phone. When he finally saw me waiting I told him was picking up a pizza. I could see the one box of pizza on top of the pizza oven with my name on it. I told him my pizza was on top of the oven. He opens up the pizza oven that was empty. I told him again my pizza is right there. Very strange, bad service. read more

The Golden Eagle pizza is delish! Pesto and thin sliced tomatos. Just yum. I like all of RJs pizzas because of the crust. It's not the big, chewy slab that many pizzerias in the area serve. It's thinner and there is a good ratio of toppings to crust. RJ's delivers, too! I may up my rating to 5 stars but I need to try a few more items in the menu first. Oops. Golden Eagle pie was terrible and unrecognizable today. Overcooked, hardly any Pesto...what the heck happened?? read more

Sadly, RJ's has become a hit or miss for us. We have been regulars at RJ's for 6 years. The quality of pizzas has changed throughout the years. Some pizzas we get are reheats (we can clearly tell since the cheese is thick and overcooked) while some are lacking flavor in the sauce and seasoning. It's the chance you take on a certain day, and unfortunately we haven't had the best string of luck. RJ's was our go to pizza spot although due to the inconsistencies, we are having a difficult time being dedicated customers. read more

They make great cheese pizza and serval other good sauce and crust . Service is good . Ambiance is good as well.

Happiness is a warm slice of pizza! Inside, this place is spacious but cozy with checkered tablecloths, brick walls, and cute pizza quotes on the wall. Just inside the entrance, a board lists their tempting daily specials. By the counter, huge slices of about 8 kinds of pie wait ready to be reheated. I ordered Mama Nata's pizza which arrived freshly made and piping hot with a thin crust and square, topped with basil, mozz, garlic, and plum tomato sauce. Though the cheese sometimes slid off my slices, it was a pretty good pie that showcased obviously fresh ingredients. On another visit, I tried a slice of plain and a slice of Spinach/Ricotta/Mozz/Garlic and both really impressed me with excellent texture and flavor. I was actually full after the first slice but didn't mind having the second. All this good pizza left me ready for a nap and super happy. NOTES/TIPS: **Gender-neutral restroom. **Plenty of parking in a private shared lot. **Their menu's vast with several salads, subs, wraps, and seafood/pasta/chicken entrees. **I brought my own water bottle twice for dining-in around lunchtime and they didn't mind at all. read more

See all

I had the chicken mozzarella, broccoli, rabe sandwich, huge abortion, delicious, my husband ordered a calzone again huge portion delicious love this place read more

My family and I order from RJS all the time and there service is impeccable. The workers and owner especially are very polite and friendly to all customers engaging with them and making a comfortable setting for them. The food is always brought quick and delicious, the have such a variety of foods on there menu. The restaurant itself is extremely clean and the decor was very organized. The food has a homemade taste and the setting also makes you feel at home. read more

This is by far some of the Best thin crust style pizza around. They use only fresh ingredients and toppings here and you can tell in every flavorful bite. I tried the Supreme slice which I found to be 'out of this world'. The sauce is delicious and not acidic at all while the cheese has just the right amount of perfect melted goodness. The crust has a crispness to it and makes for an excellent foundation for this very delicious pizza. Service is extremely friendly and the dining area is above what you would find in any of the local pizzerias. Really cool and welcoming vibe going on with nice decor. They have a delivery service here as well which I'll definitely be checking out in the near future. read more

See all

Have been working in Rockaway for about a year and was exhausted of the few options I knew of for lunch. After googling, I found RJ's was right down the road. We had the gnocchi lunch which came with a side salad or soup and 2 plain slices. I'm very picky when it comes to pizza but, the slices were HUGE and delicious. More of a thin crust pizza which isn't usually my favorite but, it was not super crispy so that was a plus in my book. The sauce was yummy and the cheese was real - not the artificial stuff a lot of places use now. The lunch gnocchi was a big portion and also delicious. Can't wait to try some more things off of the menu and maybe try the soup next time! read more

RJ's Pizzeria - Huge pizza slice and gnocchi with pink sauce, basil and mozzarella - Pizza Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

See all

Awesome and very flavorful food! We ordered here for the first time and couldn't have been more pleasantly surprised. Like most of us in this post Covid world, we just about had it and we're bored with all the other food choices so figured why not RJ's a try. And boy! I had some very picky eaters very happy. Here's what was ordered: capellini primavera, rigatoni al la vodka, and Stracciatella soup The capellini was just perfect and totally hit the spot! veggies were perfectly cooked, soft not mushy and with a very little cream sauce But it was a generous portion so dinner and lunch the next day for sure!!! My mom who's super picky loved the soup and to quote her, "finally some other soup choice vs just chicken noodle or another canned soup that you can find anywhere" The only downside to the rigatoni was we ordered it with shrimp but did wasn't made that way. However, when I called the restaurant, they did say that they were closing and wanted to make sure we got the food out but without hesitation took off the charge for the shrimp since we never got it in the actual order. Will definitely order again from here but next time nice and early. Note due to Covid they are closing around 9 not 10. read more

See all

Amazing pizza and service! The tortellini alfredo was so delicious and made two meals. Highly recommend.

I recently tried this place out for the first time and the food was great! We wanted some appetizers/something small to split and got a the mozzarella sticks and saw the empanada on the menu as well and said why not. When picking up I realized I made the mistake of ordering the wrong item, thankfully they were kind enough to make the correct item the mozzarella sticks! Will be back to try out the pizza(: read more

Haven't dined inside RJ's but was ordered takeout several times. It's one of those places I'm sure my order is going to be right, fresh, and on time ! The delivery is always smooth and I pay (and tip) when I order. My fave apart from the pizza is clams in white sauce and sautéed spinach. As a mom who has to eat pizza way more than I would like I welcome ordering from here cause the pizzas great and I can comfortably get something else and know it's gonna be good as well ! read more

Ordered delivery. Pizza was cold and not very good The Pizza was supposed to have eggplant and garlic. Eggplant was ok but the garlic was garlic powder. Garlic powder was a charge of $1.50! read more

Food is very consistent! LOVE their pasta fagioli. I have been looking for a place with the same great soup Almalfi Cafe in Madison had years back (closed down). Their salads are fresh- Love RJ's tropical with the pineapple vinaigrette! Love their grilled shrimp too in the salads. Buffalo chicken wrap is HOT but oh so good. Super fresh bread out of the oven. Obsessed over how good it is, and comes with the soup. They have convenient curb side pickup. Very happy with everything we've ordered from them. read more

A gem in Rockaway! Great pizza, broccoli Rabe, and calzone; will be trying more on the menu soon! The ingredients are always fresh and the pizza crust is perfectly thin. Everyone there is really nice, the place has a great vibe even if you're just taking out. Try this place, you'll be happy you did! read more

Fantastic food! I've had their catering (vodka sauce is perfect) and pizza delivered, their buffalo chicken pie is great not overly heavy like many other places and they were on time and had a great price point. I would highly recommend ordering from here. read more

Finally, a nice pizza that is NOT laden with salt and artificial tasting mozzarella. I was reluctant to try this place because the previous owners made horrible pizza and the place was a dump! New owners are using quality ingredients and make delicious food. Clean store!!! I notice cleanliness. This is now our go to pizza place. Keep up the quality products!! Thank you read more

We decided to try RJ's again recently. It seems like from our previous experience several years ago, their food has improved. Everything was delivered on time, hot, and accurate. Great service! Highly recommend and will be repeat customers! :) read more

Feel deceived after dining in restaurant and won't be going back. Reviewed bill and found we were charged $1.65 for a glass of ice water (!) and price charged for both entrees was higher than prices stated on menu. When asked about high cost for a glass of water, the server (who appeared to be owner or manager) said they serve bottled water. If that is so, he should have brought the bottle of water to my table and he should have told me about the charge when I asked for a "glass" of water which is usually free at most restaurants. Regarding being charged prices higher than on the menu, when I asked why, the server pointed to a letter with fine print up by the register saying they raised the prices and the menu prices were not correct. We sat at a table and were never going to see that letter. They should put a sticker on the menu saying prices are higher than stated or server should disclose this to customers. Not being cheap about the extra $5 in charges but felt deceived. There's so many other good choices for Italian food in the area. Had been there a few times and enjoyed the food for the most part. Considered making this our regular place but left with a bad taste in our mouth. Disappointed. read more

We ordered for the first time from RJ's yesterday. We love pizza and we always try different places to compare. We ordered the Scarlet Knight square pizza and it was by far the best pizza we have ever eaten. It was perfect. Pizza is usually considered cheap to eat, junk food, but with this pizza we were able to actually taste the quality. It was more like a high quality meal instead of pizza. We ordered for delivery between 6:30 PM and 7:00 PM on a snowy Sunday night and the pizza arrived hot at 6:45 PM. The person that answered the phone to take the order was extremely polite, helpful and friendly. We look forward to ordering a few more different pizzas, salads and for sure their entrees. We would order just about everything on the menu. Everything is fairly priced. read more

I stopped in for some lunch today and decided on the caprese salad and side of meatballs since I'm on a meatball kick! This is a tiny but cute pizzeria tucked into the strip mall on Rte. 46 west near Franklin Road in Rockaway. I thought the salad was very good although it would have (and I'm big advocate of balsamic vinegar) been just as good with a little less dressing. The cheese, basil, and mozzarella were fresh and it was very satisfying. The meatballs were also quite good and I dug the sauce. The meatballs were pretty big and had a nice flavor. They were appropriately dense without being too full of breadcrumbs that tend to detract from the flavor value. The salad came with three rolls and although I didn't eat them (I gave to my friend at work) they looked and felt fresh! It took a little longer than I expected to wait for my order so next time I'll call ahead. I haven't dined in yet so I'll do an update on this review when I do. I like the little chalkboard of specials and the warmth of the simple but welcoming atmosphere and decor. read more

See all

First time ordering from here I just got my delivery: Let's start with the initial phone call Grace answered the phone, she was so full of Energy and pleasant on the phone. When I said " this is my first time calling you guys she said great". My order was easy this time Large pie, Penne and Vodka dinner and Fries. The delivery time was pretty on or about 45mins. That's the standard until you start tipping very good(Lol). Okay on to my Pizza thin crust is the only way I like it The sauce was flavorful and the cheese very good. The Penne and Vodka was very good the only complaint I have is that I thought the Garlic bread that came with the dinner was more then One slice. It made me wanting more. I eat pizza at least once or twice a week this place named RJ's is gonna definitely be my go to pizza spot. I'm actually looking forward to trying different items that are on the menu. read more

First the friendliest owner Frankie and the other workers. Started with a fresh antipasta and garlic knots that were full of flavor. It was accompanied by a home tasting tomato sauce. Then came the delicious pizza with very very fresh ingredients. The decor inside is warm and friendly. Do yourself a wonderful favor, make sure you visit RJ'S PIZZERIA in Rockaway NJ read more

Decided to try RJ' s pizzeria for the first time. Got the Supreme pie to go. It was fantastic! It was completely covered with many obviously fresh high-quality ingredients . I was completely full after two slices and believe me I have a big appetite. I will definitely become a regular customer! read more

Really good, we ordered for pick up, okay eat in is not possible at the moment. When stopped a guy came and asked for our name and some moments later we had our pizza. It was really delicious. We will order again, definitely ! We had the by golden eagle pizza! Wow! So good read more

Our first time ordering for the family. Wanted to try the new place.... well, average at best. read more

RJ's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

See all

This is hands-down the best thin crust pizza around. The crust is so perfect; lightly browned on the edges, slightly crunchy but still has that nice flop to it. The people who work there are consistently friendly and greet you with a smile. I wish I lived closer because this place would be my go-to! read more

Best muscles in hot sauce around. Eggplant rolatini is outstanding and Grace's empanadas are a must! Plus who doesn't like Grace?! She is as awesome as the food. Relaxed, informal and your go to neighborhood Italian pizzeria and restaurant. And BYOB. This place is a keeper. read more

If u love Italian Food then RJ's is the place to go. I took my mom here last week and now she can't get enough of it. I would recommend the Garlic Knots. They are out of this world. A family friendly restaurant. I haven't had a bad meal yet here. read more

Great place, great food, great people. Very friendly and attentive staff. Food is made to your liking. Excellent service all around. I had spaghetti and meatballs platter and asked that it is made in specific way. It was perfect! Thanx guys, you'll be seeing me here more often. read more

Did some takeout tonight from RJ's. Pizza is above average. Their sauce was plentiful, and if you like pizza with a little extra sauce, you should like the pizza from RJ's. We also liked the chef's salad. The chicken parm was ok, I would say about average. People that own / work here seemed nice. I would return if up for a good pie in Rockaway. read more

This is in the space formerly occupied by Paradiso. Soft opening last night, February 7th. Great staff, wonderful interior remodel that makes the space cleaner and more inviting. Had veal saltimbocca and a chicken entree, both of which came with house salads. Nicely prepared with top quality ingredients. I'll visit soon to try the pizza. They are earnest, friendly, and skilled. It's a promising start to a local place that may wind up in the regular rotation! They expect to have a Grand Opening in the next couple of weeks. read more

Late night just getting into town and not much near my hotel. What was close? A quick slice of za is hard to mess up. What I found far exceeded what I expected. A simple house salad and two slices of cheese and I was on my way. The staff inside was not only helpful but friendly, asking where I was from and what I was doing in town. Evidently this place is new but the food was great. House salad had a house made dressing that was a vinegarette, it hit the spot. The cheese pizza was a thin chewy crust with just the right amount of cheese. I couldn't have been more pleased. This place is worth the stop. read more

RJ's Pizzeria - Cheese pizza is really good - Pizza Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

My girlfriend always complains that the pizza isn't as good as the pizza in her neighborhood when she comes to town. Now whenever we get pizza, we're going to have to get it here because she loved it. There's that, great service, friendly workers, and my chicken parm was delicious. read more

Pizza tastes amazing and has great prices. I did not have to wait long for my food either