Fresh and delicious bagels offered in every variety. Great seasonal cakes and sweets as well. Delicious flavor coffees. Great and friendly staff! New egg white salad is perfect on a bagel for a lite lunch. read more

How difficult is it to get an order for a bagel and cream cheese correct?? At this place ... very difficult. My husband and I have come here several times, the last few times our orders have been completely wrong. I'm talking about very basic orders, toasted bagel with cream cheese etc ... If the staff at the front counter wasn't so busy gossiping and discussing the latest shopping trends perhaps they could focus on giving customers the correct order. read more

Don't judge a book by it's cover. This is usually describes hole-in-the-wall joints. But in the case of Lynbrook Bagels; don't be fooled by the nice packaging, the product is a let down. My wife and I both found the bagels a bit dry and lacking flavor. The coffee was very tasty, with a nice selection of flavors. But the nail in the coffin was the chocolate chip muffin. We went splitsies on it, but when we chopped it in half there were ZERO chips inside. They just sprinkle them on the tops. Beware the business that cheats my wife out of chocolate. Again, the staff was courteous and the shop is nice, but bottom line is... I'm there for the bagels and they were ehhhhh. read more

VEGAN BAGELS! They also offer vegan butter! The most tasty best iced coffee in FUN flavors: smores, birthday cake, cinnabon, etc. They have almond milk! The owner is awesome and all of the workers are super friendly and REMEMBER who you are and what you like to order. The addiction is real :-) read more

Overall this place is just ok. For the price the bagels are not worth it. I've had their specialty sandwich the "californian" and it was pure disappointment. It was tuna with swiss cheese and avocado. The avocado was already mixed almost like a guacamole and did not taste that fresh. For more than $6 it was a true rip off. The coffee has depreciated in taste for some reason. Maybe the new staff members are making it incorrectly. Who knows! The bagels are ok as well. I have had better. read more

Coffee while self serve is always good I like their bagels

This place usually has a lot of customers so I decided to try it today. Honestly, it was a pretty bad experience! There was all relatively young girls working behind the counter, the one that took my order looked very young. I ordered pumpkin cream cheese on a toasted bagel. After I left I saw that only one half of my bagel had any cream cheese on it, the other half literally had nothing I didn't even finish it! It's a shame because the cream cheese was good but I'm a firm believer in a good staff being key. Definitely won't be returning. Also, definitely felt it was too pricy for what we ordered. read more

This is probably the best bagel store in the general area around Lynbrook (not that we have much selection). I go to Lynbrook Bagels strictly for their Everything bagels with cream cheese and a cup of coffee on the go. I haven't personally tried their muffins but I hear they're top-notch. The staff is pleasant, it's kept clean and they do seasonal & holiday specials. read more

Lynbrook Bagels is the only coffee/bagel place I find myself going back to. The iced coffee is exactly what I want from ice coffee. If you are not into sweet/flavored coffees I wouldn't recommend, but if you are cookies and cream is my favorite flavor. The bagels are always fresh and yummy. The service is excptional- they all get to know you if you become a familiar face. They go out of their way to serve you fast, correct, and with a smile. The atmosphere is cute and pays homage to their local community. I always run into somebody I know here- it is a great spot to gather to catch up with an old friend. I love this place! read more

Updated review from my 5/26 initial review. All "The Good" remain the same and I have one more to add: Customer Service The owner of LB contacted me directly, apologized for my bad experience, and offered to take care of me on my next visit. In addition, the owner explained that certain promotions/discounts were modified because of rising costs and other business considerations, which make perfect sense. Apparently, the process for hot breakfast orders is a work in progress and may soon be improved. So, while I stand by my review, I feel much better about my one bad experience that I wrote about, and I was so impressed by the owner's response that I changed my rating to 4 stars- please try LB. I especially encourage patrons to try the Greek yogurt cream cheese. As a big fan of Greek yogurt, I can't say enough good things about it! read more

They have very good bagels and have a very well established place, their staff is very friendly and professional, they only except cash, but their is a ATM just incase you forgot. Overall a place I go to several times a week. P.S Come early in the morning between 5:00 and 6:00am, the Bagels are still hot and extra soft, plus there are no cars around so you can pull right up and grap the bagel to go!! I lived in all 5 boroughs of NYC and now reside in Long Island only a few blocks from this store and i strongly have to say one of the best bagels places in NYC or NYS. read more

I've been coming here for years. It's definitely my favorite bagel on Long Island, by far. The ambiance is not like other bagel stores (it feels more like a coffee shop you'd find in a vacation town!) All this, not to mention that the coffee and bagels are really, really tasty. (I love getting bagel sandwiches from here...definitely my favorite). read more

I ate here last weekend with my husband. Worst cinnamon raisin bagels! It was hard & tasteless.

Lynbrook Bagels is the best My daughter got married on March 17, 2018 and they did her wedding favors. Since they got married on St Patrick's Day they wanted to give out Mini Irish soda breads. We thought of making them but then decided it would be tough making 300 of them.. so we had them make them and they were delicious. They were great to work with and I would highly recommend them.. And their bagels are good too!! read more

This is a beautiful bagel shop on Atlantic Avenue. I love how they decorated the store for the holidays. The bagels are decent. Service is nice and attentive! read more

Very good bagels at a nice local shop. Great iced coffee with a wide array of flavors that change daily. Everything bagels only have the seeds on the bottom of the bagel. I prefer it on both sides with more onion/garlic as opposed to the heavy poppyseed ratio Lynbrook uses. Bagels are always fresh and many times still hot when served up. This makes the cream cheese a little messy. I would prefer if they tipped me off that the bagel was still hot as I dont love a bagel straight out of the oven, especially if I am adding cream cheese. Still vastly superior to other bagels in the neighborhood. read more

Real simple, "we don't take credit or debit cards". Not a good business strategy, I was a new customer and you lost my business. They offered me to pay $3 to take my own money out of the atm to pay them. Good luck read more

Lynbrook Bagels has not only great bagels, but a huge variety of other food as well! A couple of my favorites are the chicken salad and the low fat veggie tuna. YUM! The ambiance is great and super home-y. They decorate for every season and create a fun look no matter what the season is. It's also really clean and nicely-kept! The staff is friendly, welcoming, and fun. Very professional and willing to help. They are extremely accommodating and willing to adhere to any unique needs no matter what they may be. The bagels are fresh and dense on the inside with a delicious crunch on the outside. The coffee is to die for! I come all the way back to Long Island from Manhattan just to bring back bags of their coffee to make at home. It's better than any other coffee I've tasted, and the flavors are delicious. Ultimately, this is a must-visit whenever you are in the area! read more

Cash only, a little weird but ok. I have been a couple three times, nicely decorated clean looks like a nice atmosphere to sit and eat. The bagels however are not very good, are they really filtering the water? Because they do not taste good, sort of a sour taste with an aftertaste, someone else commented on the small side this is also true. I also ordered a ham and egg on a bagel and you can tell they use the cheapest marbleized rubber ham. I wanted to like this place because I pass it all the time but just can't overcome my distaste for the way they are making the bagels. read more

Well, nothing like waiting on line to grab breakfast ask for a bagel and be told they don't have what you want. Then ordering a different bagel with the spreads you want to be told they don't have it. Fist time ever in a bagel store that did not have what all bagel stores should have. read more

Skimp on cheese. Sesame chive bagel and small coffee, $5 and change. Cash only. Kids employed. read more

Lynbrook Bagels - Skimped on cheese. - Bagels Near Me - Lynbrook, New York

Great neighborhood spot. The bagels are smaller and a bit different (more dense, maybe?) than what I was used to in a NY bagel before moving out to LI. Some people don't like them, which I can understand due to them not being exactly like every other bagel. However, they make my favorite onion bagel, hands down. It's great with butter, great with a slice of munster, and great in breakfast sandwich form with sausage and cheese. Flavored iced coffee is another great selling point. The flavors rotate so you never know what you'll have to choose from on a given day, but more than likely you'll find something to drink. The hot coffees are flavored as well, generally offering different flavors than the iced. Oh, it's not syrups that flavor the coffee, it's infused in the bean. This is great if you're like me and hate sugar in your coffee! It's a lucky day for me when they've got Snickers Iced on tap! This us a CASH ONLY spot, but they've installed an ATM if you don't know, forgot, or didn't bring enough cash. read more

One of the best bagel stores on Long Island ! They have great bagels especially Everything and Salt, and unbelievable selection of Ice coffee as well as regular. Everybody that works at the store is nice and pleasant with great service to boot ! read more

After just dealing with this nasty girl on the phone, I had to post this review. I ordered two bagels with lox and cream cheese and wanted it delivered to Avalon in RVC. The girl then tells me ,it's a 20 buck min. I said ok ill have 2 more bagels with Lox ,then she said she won't deliver it till 9:00 am. it is now 7:30 am when I called. So Lynbrook bagels stop leaving flyers on my door cause your a joke.... read more

Good bagels and a nice selection of coffee, but they don't take cards and it isn't well posted, so we had to run across the street to the ATM, when we returned a couple minutes later we were ignored for 10 mins while they helped everyone else in the line and chatted with another customer before cashing us out. When we interrupted the conversation to pay, the excuse was "oh I wondered what you were doing there" ...really? Ok bagels but crappy service, next time I'll make the drive out to West Hempstead. read more

Great food, great service, great people. The bagels are as good as they get, the sandwiches, muffins, soups, etc. are really quite good, the place has a great vibe to it. read more

I've been enjoying Lynbrook Bagels since they opened the joint. I am a die-hard NY bagel fan and they've definitely got the formula right! It's tough since I no longer live on LI but whenever I'm in the area, I make a pit-stop there and bring home a couple dozen. I love the ambience of the shop itself and used to hang out there and try all the different coffees of the day. Nice management too! read more

I was really looking forward to trying what I was told were reviewed as "the best bagels on Long Island." Really disappointed. I was truly ready for greatness, but... Pleasant service and great cranberry muffins, so I put 2 stars instead of one, but the sign reads "bagels" and that's what they brag about...all over the place. Why? The bagels are ALL much too small to compete with better bagels very close by. Dozens of places with awesome bagels are all within blocks to a mile from this place with less bragging. You want to brag? Be at least as good as your competition. You're in New York, for G-d's sakes! I know bagels. I have them at least once every week. That size is an insult to NY bagels and to me. Their bialies were wider, but flatter, so it's no better, really. . They ran out of Pumpernickel Raisin, so they offered me plain Pumpernickel. It was not dark brown and moist, but light beige and dry...white spots where I bit in...I had a scrambled egg with salt and pepper, but the bagel absorbed what little flavor there may have been. These are not the best bagels on L.I. or anywhere in the NY metro area. Some starving news crew must've been passing by, so they enjoyed the service and the carbs a bit too much...Either that, or my experience was on an off day or off time, but a "best" place should never be off, especially at 9:30am. My server also was the food preparer and there's only one cash register, so their time is not spent efficiently, which keeps us waiting. Duties should be delegated in a small place. After finishing the bagel & egg in the back, she then began my lunch wrap behind the counter...those should have been ready simultaneously. Good thing I didn't order for other people, I would've been there all morning. Oh...and an ATM machine? Really?? What're you, a bodega? I had cash, but the guy in front of me was essentially told "if you have a debit card, first step away from my counter, go to that machine on the other side of the store, pay the fee, then return when you're ready." Instead of punishing your customer for being "unprepared" why not either just charge a little more for debit or credit... Better yet, if your food is so popular, work your credit/debit expenses into your pricing. Either way, take whatever payment your customer can offer and get that tacky ATM out of your store. I might give them another chance, but no bagel from a "best bagel" place should ever suck, whether on purpose (small) or by accident (dry/tasteless). read more

The bagels use to be good, but now they are tasteless and not a big deal. I do not think they have the best bagels in Long Island...are you kidding me?? The staff are ok, except for one of the owners (the woman)- sometimes she can be VERY rude. The wait time is OK- but sometimes it's annoying when they (staff) start to get very chatty and then take forever to get the orders ready. We use to go here alot before, but now we rather go to either to Hewlett (awesome bagels) or Baldwin. read more

This is the place I go to when I visit the area. Everything bagels are great and coffee is solid. Wish there was a place half as good where I now live. read more

Whenever back in the area I am at this place for breakfast. Simply the best bagels in th earea-hands down. They also have excellent service. Well worth the extra drive. Definitely a routine that I will be continuing so long as I have family in the area. read more

Delicious food and friendly service. We go to Lynbrook Bagels weekly and always have a great experience.

The BEST bagels on LI, especially flats. Great soups. Wonderful muffins and baked goods. Delicious egg, chicken and tuna salads. Everything is always fresh. A bit pricey but not terrible. Now if they could only get their counter staff to pay any attention to customer's orders... Anything more complex than "bagel with cream cheese" WILL be screwed up in a new and creative way. Do yourself a favor and watch what they do and check your bag before leaving the store. I periodically swear off the place but then drag myself back because the bagels are so delicious. I guess you can't have everything... read more

Lynbrook Bagels in an adorable little place. You can really tell it is family owned with plenty of regulars. The bagels are smaller than a typical Long Island bagel, so you don't feel quite as bad about eating carbs. There's always a variety of flavored coffees (and I mean that, the coffee itself is flavored, not a flavored syrup added in). They seem to work hard to accommodate all kinds of diets, especially in their soup selection. Friendly, helpful staff as well. Definitely a place worth stopping by, especially as it's pretty close to the train station, so you can grab a bite if you're early for a train. It's located on an adorable street with other shops and restaurants worth perusing as well, better done on a full stomach of bagels! read more

i recieved a wonderful note from a rep from Lynbrook Bagels and have since been to Lynbrook bagels and the Bagels are excellent. more than that it is an establishment that most Lynbrookers look forward to having a coffee and bagel at. I would definitely recommend Lynbrook Bagels NOW, over anything else in the area. read more

Maybe slow down and complete one order before starting up the next one. The employees there are in such rush to ring up everyone, they always mess up orders because they have too many items on the counter. Half of my order is wrong and im guessing someone else's order is missing whats in my bag. After calling and talking to them, all they can say was 'oh sorry'. Way to resolve the mistake. read more

Best bagels ever Best egg sandwiches you'll ever try Do not eat a bagel from anywhere else The staff is always friendly The service is phenomenal read more

I don"t usually comment on restaurants, unless I am thrilled with a place and want to covey my review to others, or am so disappointed that I must let people know. My family has been going to Lynbrook Bagels for years, however, recently we"ve had some upsetting experiences there. last week I ordered a tuna sandwich on a roll. The roll was not too fresh. Inside was aprox. 3-4 tablespoons of tuna! I am not exaggerating when I say that the tuna did not cover 1/2 of the roll. One pickle, over $6.00. They told me that is the amount they always put on. No offer to correct this or care whether I was happy or not! Other people I know from town have said their attitude has changed. It"s sad that they don"t care if the locals a pleased anymore! read more

Aesthetically this is one of the most unique bagel shops around. The decor is charming and shows the owner's strong ties to the community. The bagels are pretty good, nice and dense with a firm, crusty outside. Most flavorful plain bagel around. However the prices are simply too high for a bagel. I also have issues with their everything bagels in that they are not as well covered (typically only half) as others. Still a great shop, though I am surprised that their switch to cash only has not hurt them. read more

Local favorite in Lynbrook. Been coming here for years and I am always content with my food. They have a nice variety of bagels and like to switch things up based on seasons. If you're looking for soup, sandwiches, bagels that is fresh then come here. read more