YE Gurl Says: Speck Had the Scene, But Did It Feed the Girl?…read more
Place: Speck Italian Eatery
Date: June 30
You know a restaurant is popular when you've been trying to get a reservation and keep losing the battle.
So when a girlfriend chose Speck Italian Eatery for girls' dinner, I was ready.
Italian food is one of my first loves. I was expecting good food, a good atmosphere, and frankly, a little "this is where everybody is trying to be seen" energy.
And on that front?
Speck delivered.
The space is airy and attractive, the atmosphere was lively, and despite the seating being a little tight, our table toward the back had plenty of room.
My girlfriend had been raving about the focaccia, so obviously we had to test the theory.
Housemade focaccia with olive oil and sea salt?
Yes, ma'am.
We shared a few things, including the Crudo--hamachi, blood orange, Castelvetrano olives, fennel, and basil--and the Gem, a crunchy vegetable salad with pistachio, Parmesan crumb, and vinaigrette.
Our waiter deserves a shoutout because when it came time to settle up, he was gracious enough to split the shared dishes down the middle for both the portions and the bill.
That's good service.
For my entrée, I ordered the Cacio e Pepe--except this version uses gnudi, peppercorn, and pecorino. It was good enough that I immediately thought about the beau, who loves cacio e pepe, so half went home with me.
I also ordered another focaccia to go.
And naturally, I had my Peroni while I was there.
So here's where my Italian grandmother's spirit entered the chat.
The food wasn't bad.
The value is what lost me.
For a pescatarian dinner, I felt like the portion sizes and prices didn't quite meet in the middle.
Maybe I'm spoiled.
I've eaten Italian food made by grandmothers and grandfathers in Little Italy, New Orleans, and Italy itself. I'm accustomed to Italian food being generous, comforting, unfussy, and--most importantly--filling.
Speck feels more like consumerism Italian to me.
Beautiful room. Beautiful plating. Trendy ingredients. Great atmosphere.
But I'm still sitting there wondering when dinner is coming.
And the bill didn't help.
There's a 3% charge toward team member healthcare, and my portion of the dinner came to about $57. My girlfriend also had a basic Pomodoro pasta, around $17, which means the two of us were already north of $100 before drinks on her side, dessert, and my 20% tip.
For two people.
And we weren't exactly leaving with the kind of leftovers that could feed us tomorrow.
That math gave me pause.
YE Gurl Insight:
There's a difference between expensive food and expensive dining.
I'm perfectly willing to pay for an exceptional meal. But when the experience is carrying as much of the price as the food itself, I need the food to make me forget what I paid.
Speck didn't quite get me there.
And that's unfortunate because the restaurant absolutely has the atmosphere and popularity to become a regular destination.
Final Take:
Atmosphere: 1/2
Service:
Food: 1/2
Portions/value: 1/2
Pescatarian Experience: 1/2
Would I return? Maybe--but the bar is now considerably higher.
YE Gurl Says: Speck is a great place to be seen.
I'm just not convinced it's the place to get fed--at least not if you're a vegetarian watching your dollars.
I was generous with that 20% tip because the service deserved it.
Consider that my chef's kiss goodbye... at least for now.