Nico's charred pies are about the best crispy pizza you'll find in Suffolk county. It's a little…read moretricky to find. You have to park under the train trestle & walk through the brewery but it's worth it. Beware: Google Maps will take you to the previous street where you can't enter. Seemed like they put a lot of TLC in their operation. It's a trip for me but I'll have to go back to try some of their other pies.

I finally got to try the pizza. Came Thursday at noon when the open. It was beautiful out so…read morepeople were sitting outside It was still a line for pizza. The pizza did not disappoint. Super crispy can't wait to try their other pies

Two pizzas, cheese calzone and Greek salad were bought for our gathering. Pizzas were good, one…read morecheese, one with mushrooms. The cheese calzone was stuffed and delicious. I guess you have to ask for a small container of tomato sauce with it ... that would be wonderful with the calzone. The Greek salad was disappointing. Yes they had some olives, red onion, cubed feta cheese, but the iceberg lettuce.... Not helping.... We'll skip the salad in the future!

This is our go to place For catering all of our events. If…read moreyou order a regular dinner. They include salad a past and a desert and the portions are huge. Everyone who works there are wonderful

Really solid pizza, nice people and very clean restaurant…read more We also got a chicken wrap with balsamic vinegar and it was great. Would definitely go back!

Amazing pizza, crispy and soft at the same time... insanely good prices too…read more The bbq chicken was my favorite aside from the pesto pizza... and I normally dislike pizza..

This is my new favorite pizza place. I had a meatball hero and it was delicious. I was craving it…read moresince the Italian fest at Town Hall. Thst meatball guy was selling 1/2 heros for 20 bucks. I made the right choice waiting. All of their speciality slices are delicious as well. The service is great, the staff is friendly and the restaurant is always clean

I have been using Villa for a few years now. When we moved to Lindenhurst I asked about a great…read morepizza restaurant. Villa was #1 hands down. In April we were disappointed with the food. Decided to try some other pizzaries. Some were very good, but not Villa. We decided to try Villa again. The disappointment returned. Driver couldn't find our address. 10 minutes on the phone, Driver finally asked if we spoke Spanish. Finally got the food, pizza was cold and they must have run out of cheese very little on pie. You could hold upside-down and no cheese moved, even after reheating. I remember when cheese would run off pie. Also woman on phone was no help when I called to complain. No way to run a neighborhood restaurants. Guess it's back to trying more Pizzaries any suggestions.

Recommend you go to Alitalia. They got the best food there and that pizza is great. Their food is…read morethe best.

Had the pleasure to be able to stop and have an early dinner yesterday at Alitalia, we used to live…read morein West Babylon over 30 years ago and haven't been there since. We had a party of 4 and arrived at about 3pm, we didn't realize that the dining room didn't open till 4pm but they let us sit down in the dining room and we had to order from the counter which was no big deal. They did have a young lady in the dining room but she said she was not a waitress, this is just my opinion but they should let her wait on tables when something like this comes up so she can get the experience to become a waitress. Food was delicious, we all had different chicken dishes and all of us loved what we had. Prices were very fair. Definitely will be going back soon. They also do a pasta night and a chicken night the was very reasonable.

The food is delicious! Prices are reasonable and staff/owner are friendly, pleasant and…read moreprofessional. I Always get my Italian food from Mr G's, from Friday night pies to Catering my events. Would absolutely recommend MR. G's!!!!!!

This place should be considered a lindenhurst landmark. Best crust around by far in my opinion. The…read moreowner is super nice and the food is always great. Can't recommend enough!

Gino's is a location with good clean display which makes it easy and quick to order up the perfect…read moredesired slice. They have always been very good about not skimping on toppings and being super cheesy regardless of what you order. They also have a unique Garlic Cheesy Bread that is super flavorful and addictive. It's made more Sicilian style, being pillow soft, airy with just enough crunch. Like with Garlic knots you can order just one or three, six plus. They also offer giving some extra side tomato sauce for dipping. Service has always come quickly with a smile. So whether you pop in for a quick slice and eat it there, or order over phone and pickup, the happy good feels always delivered! :) They have a small parking lot, as well as some street parking, so never an issue trying to get and give what the stomach desires. Enjoy!

I ordered Christmas Eve dinner for my family. We ordered several appetizers, 2 large specialty…read moresalads, 2 large pasta orders and a large cheese pie & 1 specialty slice. I assumed the slice would be from a pie made earlier but the whole pie was terrible. It clearly was a pie that was left from the day. The crust was burnt, the bottom was blackened, the cheese congealed and completely dry. When I ordered I explained that I would rather wait for the food when I picked it up than have it sitting on top of the oven. They didn't even recognize the order. someone had to explain that the order was called in earlier. $200 later my family was very disappointed. Most of the leftovers were tossed. I will not order from them again.

Was getting tired of the usual pizzerias that we frequent so I decided to Google "pizzerias near…read moreus" and Joe's Pizza was the first one to pop up. Read a few of the reviews and figured we'd give them a try. BEST DECISION EVER!!!! OMG!!! Without a doubt, one of the most delicious pizzas we've had in ages! Crust, sauce, cheese....everything was spot on! Having originally been raised in Astoria and Brooklyn, I've certainly had my share of very good pizzas, so, I feel pretty confident when I say this was on par with the rest! In addition, we also ordered some garlic knots (very tasty!) , a cheese calzone (it was HUGE!!!) and a side order of baked ziti (amazing!!! and, by the size of it, shouldn't even be considered a "side order"!) .....no complaints whatsoever! Can't wait to try more items on the menu! In hindsight, should have taken some photos but we gobbled everything up the minute the order was delivered. Which, by the way, was pretty prompt and even sooner than the time frame we were given. What more is there to say, but, from now on, Joe's Pizza will most definitely be our go-to pizzeria!!! Thanks for a TERRIFIC meal!!!

They must have changed the sauce. Not that same, flavorless. The garlic knots look like they came…read morefrom a box. Not the same doughy homemade. Once loyal customer will not go back

Mama's catered my daughter's first birthday party and they were absolutely phenomenal from start to…read morefinish. The entire process was seamless -- the staff was so kind, professional, and communicative throughout every step. The food was delivered with such care and everything was fresh, hot, and delicious. We ordered the shrimp, oregano, penne alla vodka, and the chicken Parmesan, and every single dish was outstanding. My guests could not stop talking about how amazing the food was -- people were genuinely raving about it all day. Mama's helped make such a special occasion even more memorable, and I would absolutely recommend them for any event or catering needs. We will definitely be ordering again!

Had 3 specialty slices…read more 2 were chicken pesto and one was a cup and char grandma style w sausage meat. All looked great but were way over salted and not edible by my taste. Mommas has an excellent reputation and i will only try it again because of Mommas good reputation. I did not enjoy my meal nor did i finish it. Disappointed! Mommas do better! But Great professional counter service!

Best pizza i've had in years. Also the cheese steak is to die for. Actually, all of the items on…read morethe menu are great. Thanks Mike!!!

What I tasted last night was pretty incredible. I've made these claims before but it's only because…read moreI haven't tried every pizza on Long Island. Mikes Underground Pizza just slid into my Number One Spot for the best pizza on Long Island. There's a lot of quirks to piss people off to get at this pizza. My father in law in Florida wouldn't have the patience to pull off this caper. -Coming from the north shore to drive south, *1000 Montauk Hwy* on the Tesla Nav will not bring you to the location, I was at the hospital in Islip. You have to put West Babylon at the end -And it's *Cash ONLY*. Now that we have the pleasantries out of the way, let's continue with the review. The 14" Clam Pie is a game changer. I've waited on very long lines at Frank Pepe's in New Haven to get their clam Apizza. It's good but Mikes Pizza is far superior. Simple with freshly shucked clams, garlic and breadcrumbs, now add the crust that a comes from a true New York pizzaiolo who doesn't cut the pizza Connecticut style (like it came out of a slasher film) and now you have a competition pizza that Dave Portnoy would give a 9.4. The Vodka Round was equally impressive. The sauce was so complex, first bite I could tell it was a home run, out the box (see what I did there) a winner. Here's my issue, I drove from the North Shore to the South Shore to an abandoned bank parking lot to get at this pizza. I know the business model is working for you but it doesn't for the customers. I have a plan! Listen, I'm ready to retire. I'm thinking about the next few years driving on the Belt Parkway to Bay Ridge and it gives me night terrors. Let's do this together! By Stony Brook, the college kids will go wild! All kidding aside, Number one pizza on Long Island. March 2026