Every time I'm visiting from Florida I go to the Italian bakery in Lindenhurst. Last months visit I see the strip mall got a facelift and found The Pizzeria. Gave it a try and so glad I did. Now I can make one trip and hit 2 places. Got a slice of grandmas pizza (corner slice, lol). Was going to take it back to the hotel but it didn't make it out of the parking space. It was so good, had to go back in for another for me and one for my husband. The place is very clean, very nice workers and a nice calming atmosphere. A nice variety of different types of pizza. Can't wait to come back for more. Especially since Florida pizza is lacking in taste and a light crispy crust. read more

The pizzeria is so clean and modern! I came here before a class next door with my stroller. I ordered the sausage and mozzerella slice and I could've probably eaten the whole pie it was so delicious. The staff here were very friendly. Parking for any of the Lindenhurst business is metered street parking so don't forget to bring your quarters! Definitely recommend! read more

The Pizzeria of Lindenhurst - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

Super nice place, ambiance was amazing. The guy who served me was super nice, the hospitality instantly made me want to come back. Buffalo chicken slice was decent, nothing that blew my mind though. To be fair, I am a tough critic when it comes to Buffalo chicken pizza so take that for what it's worth. Needed more buffalo sauce / ranch (or bleu cheese) action but it was alright, nothing special. Bonus points too for the insane fish bathroom. Definitely took me off guard and got me stoked. Overall I'd say check this place out. You'll leave feeling satisfied. read more

The Pizzeria of Lindenhurst - Buffalo Chicken Slice - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

See all

The staff is friendly and the service is quick! The cannoli are a must! They fill the shells to order so they always stay crunchy and fresh. The slices are huge! I made the mistake of ordering 2 and I had one left over. The cafe is clean and I love the artwork on the walls. I definitely recommend the vodka Margherita slice. read more

The Pizzeria of Lindenhurst - Vodka Margherita Slice-- the perfect slice - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

Excellent food and service like always! The uncle Benny pizza is so good!! The Babylon location was closed so came here! Never disappoints! I read some of these reviews and people who complain about the food or staff must be living in a palace or something with very high standards as they seem so out of left field what they are whining about when most of the pizzeria locations all have almost a 5 star review level. Keep up the great work! read more

The Pizzeria of Lindenhurst - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

See all

This place is cute inside. It also has a bar! The service was good. The food was also good. I'd return here. It's conveniently located on a cute little strip with other restaurants/bars. There is metered parking outside. We got the garlic knots, buffalo garlic knots, pepperoni pizza, and penne alla vodka pasta. Everything was pretty good. The pasta actually tasted better the day after! Pizza was good but a little undercooked/doughy and the pepperoni also seemed alittle undercooked. Garlic knots were good. read more

See all

Really solid pizza, nice people and very clean restaurant. We also got a chicken wrap with balsamic vinegar and it was great. Would definitely go back! read more

Aug 13, 2026 Above average taste and very good takeout service. Waking in to pick up a pie, the place looked clean, neat and indicative of a pizzeria (vs a sit down restaurant). A plain pie with tax was on the high side at $23.87. They took credit cards without a charge. read more

Amazing pizza, crispy and soft at the same time... insanely good prices too The bbq chicken was my favorite aside from the pesto pizza... and I normally dislike pizza.. read more

See all

We are frequent flyers here every since they came to Lindenhurst! This is the first time we've sat down at the bar for a real meal instead of just grabbing slices. It did not disappoint. The portions are amazing for the price and our server Andrew was so sweet, quick with refills, and offered to help wrap everything up once we tapped out. Wings, chicken parm, & the pizzaria chicken was all 10/10! read more

The Pizzeria of Lindenhurst - THE PIZZERIA Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

Great selection of pizza, great service , the "uncle Benny" is amazingly delicious..Has a bar were you can eat your pizza and have a few cocktails...very cool...Def hit them up when you're in the area! read more

The Pizzeria of Lindenhurst - The Pizzeria, Lindenhurst, NY - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

See all

Best salad slices I've ever had. So good! Update: Still delicious as ever. Everything I have ordered has been absolutely delicious, and I've tried pretty much everything in the menu. read more

I just have to say this place is amazing. From the decor, to the menu & the service, everything about this establishment is exemplary. They keep their place very clean, neat, and organized. It reminds me of a local Long Island pizza shop, with a modern twist. The floors aren't sticky, the tables are clean, and their shop opens up to allow a nice breeze when it's hot out. We got a Chicken Caesar salad "wrap" and a pizza with bits of fresh mozzeralla & basil? As well as garlic knots! The server was really friendly and professional. He heated up the chicken Caesar salad wrap perfectly. Which is basically a salad pizza rolled up with the crust acting as the wrap. It was delicious. The crust was warmed up perfectly without the salad getting too wilted. The chicken was well seasoned and not dry at all! The pizza was really good too. It was HOT coming out of the oven, the sauce was very rich & sweet I think the sweetness comes from the caramelized onions & natural sweetness of the tomatoes. Not to mention, the crust was DELICIOUS. Usually people throw out the crust because it's too hard or dry. The crust we had on this slice was thin. And flavorful with the olive oil! We ate the whole slice crust and all so fast! Our order of garlic knots came out a bit later as they were in the middle of baking a new batch. But it was worth the wait! The garlic knots were a good size, soft, FLUFFY, and had lots of parsley and garlic butter. I love that they weren't very dense. The bathrooms are very nice too. Very clean and well decorated. I love the bar in the front. You can sip on wine while enjoying your food right by the street! They have chairs & tables outside too if you wanted to sit under the umbrellas to enjoy the breeze. I will definitely visit them again! read more

See all

Ordered Garlic Bread with Mozzarella. Packaging was inefficient and ruined the item. Was to be shared by multiple people but it came one part thrown on top of another and couldn't be separated at all. Basically a big stuck together mess. Wasn't really edible and certainly wasn't a great presentation for guests. An item like this should be laid flat and delivered in a small pizza box at least. Very disappointed. read more

The Pizzeria of Lindenhurst - Garlic Bread with Mozzarella - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

See all

My wife and I always order from the Babylon location, but they are under repairs tried this one. Lindenhurst We order one personal pie and 2 slices of the Danielle pie. 30 dollars. 1. the personal pie was not a margarita sauce was not Pomodoro tomatoes.NO way more like thick pizza sauce Crust was awful more like a A frozen Pillsbury dough. The Danielle was also made with same crust, and slices were smaller than the Babylon Restaurant Awful. also, the counter staff All in all, I do not recommend this place, in fact it definitely gives the franchise a bad name Owners should check on this? NEVER AGAIN HOW CAN I FIND OUT WHO IS THE ACTUAL OWNER OF THE Lindenhurst LOCATION? Stay away don't be fooled!!! read more

I had the Meatball Parmesan Hero. I thought it was very good. The bread was toasted just as I like, and the meatballs with the parmesan sauce tasted great. I dined here on a Friday night when they were pretty busy. But service was still great and my order arrived very quickly. The restaurant has a modern vibe and they even have a nice bar at the front. read more

Super cute vibe, bar girl/hostess very helpful. Staff was friendly Bathrooms were well kept The napkins were very thick which was nice for oils from the pizza The pizza was really good! We've never been before and asked the hostess what was the pizza that was most popular and her favorite and got the u Cole Benny for half our personal pie and The Bar pizza for our other half and wow! The bar pizza was our favorite of the two read more

The Pizzeria of Lindenhurst - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

Came here for a late lunch on a weekend and fell in love almost immediately. First of all, what's not to love about pizza, but second of all this place knows how to feel a little special and a little different with the small space they've got on Wellwood. Very modern look and feel with a cool bar right in the front, that I think would be perfect to watch a game or just finish off the night with one last drink and a slice. Felt very clean. Staff were very friendly and were happy to answer all the questions I had about slices and whatnot. Parking can be a little tough, there are spaces right in front on Wellwood if you're brave, but there are plenty of spots on the side streets and municipal lots around if you don't mind a short stroll. Pizza was delicious. We just did slices, but easily could have had a whole pie! We tried the Uncle Benny (pepperoni, sausage, hot honey, fresh mozz), the tri-fecta (fresh mozz, vodka, pesto, and red sauce), bruschetta, and a Sicilian. The standard Sicilian to their specialties were all well done, but the two favorites were the bruschetta and the tri-fecta. Buyer beware though for the bruschetta, if you can eat it without making a mess of yourself, you're a better eater than I! Would absolutely love to come back and try more of their pies and even their other dinner options all sound incredible. On top of all that, prices are totally reasonable for a great portion on top of excellent quality, you really can't do better than that. read more

See all

After going to the Smith Haven Mall and having eaten at that 'The Pizzeria' location, we decided to try one of their self standing restaurants. This location is very clean and very busy. First, the parking is difficult. However, drive around. The pizza is worth it. The selections are nice, the pizza slices are large, and the price is excellent. All the slices we had: Sicilian, White, and Vodka were so good. I am literally writing this review sitting in the restaurant hoping I get a second wind and develop an appetite again from typing so I can order more. One tip is that it gets busy and tables are hard to get. But wait around or take some home. I know I will. read more

See all

The Pizzeria is 100% our favorite local slice! The UncleBenny pizza a beautiful combo of pepperoni, sausage, fresh mozzarella, and a drizzle of hot honey that gives it just the right touch of sweetness and heat. Every time we visit, we get the Benny and can't resist trying one of their wraps (the chicken cesar wrap is sooooo good!) or pasta dishes too always top notch . The service is always great, they treat you like family! If you're in Lindenhurst and you want a nice ambiance and craving something special, go for the UncleBenny. You might see me there enjoying a slice at the bar drinking a glass of wine!! read more

The Pizzeria of Lindenhurst - The Uncle Benny - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

The pizza is delicious! The prices are decent, and the ambiance is modern and inviting. The service is always friendly, and welcoming. The staff are knowledgeable and offer suggestions for my picky young son, and although not listed, they do have cannolis which was a big win for my kiddos! Great location, although there's another pizzeria on the same strip, The Pizzeria stands out with its modern, sleek, and clean look, and outstanding slices! read more

Order food here on a week basis, to be delivered. Tonight's delivery was terrible. I received a call from the driver saying he was here. I opened the door and asked him where he was as I did not see anyone. He said he could see me and then suddenly pulled up. He said I could come out to get my order. I wrote a negative review on the delivery service. About 30 min. later I received a phone call from the manager of The Pizzaria. Not only did he apologize for the delivery but he also said he would give me a gift card. that's the way you do buisness. The food here is awesome!! We love their pizza and salads. We will continue to order here. Thank you so much !! read more

Delicious takeout pies. Sweet sauce and crunchy crust. I like the bar pie and the uncle Benny pie with bits of sausage and pepperoni on it. Also delicious rice balls and vodka sauce. read more

Self proclaimed pizza snob here... This place is relatively new to the area so I had to pop in (besides the Bride told me to go). The place has a definite "younger" vibe compared to many established pizzerias... nice little bar area and several tables. In nice weather, they open up the front glass accordion doors to the street and adds to the ambience. Not a bad regular slice but the most of their pizzas are more specialty in nature. The Thai Chili Chicken is a particular favorite. Only negative for me is a small one...I had a calzone with ham and they make it with Prosciutto instead of ham/ham. I'm not a fan of Prosciutto so ... Other than that, it's a fun place with a hopping vibe. Worth stopping in! read more

The Pizzeria of Lindenhurst - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

The Pizzeria is my go to for really great pizza slices and I love love the chicken Cesar salad roll. There were a few hiccups with our order. Never hit a drink I ordered and few items were forgotten, nothing that would make not come back. Food is so good! read more

Good pizza and nice staff. They also have a full bar to sit at to drink, watch TV or order food

Great pies. The Auntie Danielle is worth trying. Their commitment to customer satisfaction is extremely high. We had a minor issue with a delivery order that they went above and beyond to rectify. Highly recommend! read more

After reading all reviews about pizza places I have to say this place has the best pizza and food in the Tri-state area. Was there for take out this evening. The place has a full bar and is immaculate in every fashion. The food has high quality ingredients and each and every staff member was amazingly nice! Come check it out! I strongly suggest! read more

The friendliest service, amazing food and a cute atmosphere. Only negative is the parking and that's only an issue when the town is busy!

Friendliest staff. Immaculate facilities with a great energy (love the open store front in the summer). And the pizza was nothing short of phenomenal. I'd been waiting for a cheat meal for a long time and The Pizzeria did not disappoint. Tremendous job all around. read more

See all

It's not very common I give a place 5 five stars across the board but this place deserves it! The food was delicious and two specialty slices were only about nine dollars. The service was amazing from every staff member which made me super happy to experience. Finally, the atmosphere was very open and chic! Love it here and will be coming back! read more

See all

Favorite pizza in the area bar none! Staff is always great and i stop in at least once a week for lunch or dinner. Very tasty

Inconsistent in pizza prep and quality. Needs to learn how to slice a pizza, pretty sure the drliver rreheated pizzas.

Love this place! I stopped at this location pretty much as soon as they opened. Pizza, salad and buffalo garlic knots. All so tasty . I typically try a new slice each time I go. Today's was an uncle Benny slice, and it did not disappointed read more

The Pizzeria of Lindenhurst - House Salad with house vinaigrette and bread? - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

See all

Ahh, a rainy, stormy day....been here a number of times, usually for their killer happy hour but have come by at all times, never disappointed by quality and service. My go-to, the homemade meatball special, a glass or two of wine....can't go wrong in any direction here. Today, the staff was coming up with ideas for mixed drinks.....Springsprungspritz...I'm so not a mixed drink guy but was offered a tasting...umm, brought me to the spring and summer on it's way. Yup, it's spring and summer all of a sudden. They were a cause of rethinking my thoughts on mixed drinks for sure. So food, all their food, super service and some well thought out creations....this speaks of people, business, caring, a bit rare these days. read more

See all

Was pretty excited to try this place because pretty much every place on Wellwood is solid in terms of food but was ultimately disappointed. We ordered pickup for dinner the other night and were pretty bummed. They're selling sandwiches with pizza as the bread, which I wasn't really expecting as it is not described that way, at least on mobile ordering The penne with vodka sauce (side dish) was strange. The pasta itself was tough and rubbery as if it had been either frozen and defrosted or dehydrated from refrigeration or simply left out. I mean how hard is it to make fresh pasta, really? At least the sauce was good. I did enjoy their garden salad but beware it comes with almost a full cup of shredded mozzarella cheese on top. Different, but I was kinda into it. My mom had the francaise and enjoyed it also. read more

The most delicious pizza that I have had in the area!!! The crust is the perfect crispy edge!! read more

The Pizzeria of Lindenhurst - BEST PIZZA!!! - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

Lot of talk about this place, but mid at best IMO. Pizza was middle of the road. Very salty tasting sauce. The knots were terrible, burnt and TINY. Rice balls were fine, but litterally 2 bites at most. read more

The Pizzeria of Lindenhurst - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

I have ordered from here many times, on Friday October 16, I ordered thru Uber eats like I always do. I am only a 5 minute ride from the pizzeria and my food was cold, never had this problem before. From the time I ordered it and it got to me was about 15 minutes. I would have to say that it wasn't heated properly to get cold and tasteless by the time it got here. I ordered 2 slices Sicilian, 3 garlic knots and 4 zeppole. The zeppole was so greasy that you can squeeze the oil out of them and no powered sugar, the garlic knots were hard and the pizza was OK but cold. Not a Happy camper. read more

Do not order from this place via delivery. I ordered from this location a few different times. The chicken wings are very pricey. With that being said, I'd expect the wings to be cooked properly and edible. I could be asking for a lot, I don't know. On three different occasions, the wings were very dry and shriveled up. Yes, shriveled up. It was overcooked to the point, the chicken appeared as if it had been cooked in a food dehydrator! The buffalo garlic knots were undercooked and doughy. I usually go to the one in Bayshore and every time I've ordered from there I've never had an issue. Very disappointed because this location is much closer to me. However, I will not sacrifice quality for convenience. read more

The Pizzeria of Lindenhurst - Dried chicken wings and didn't give me the correct amount - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York