This local pizzeria with plenty of parking around and in the middle of everything. The food is fantastic. I went in for one slice. I ended up with almost 2 pies no exaggeration.! there's a large selection of all kinds of food that is visual. If you like crunchy large pizza, this is the place. The night of Roma of garlic makes you want to have another slice. Very nice read more

See all

We had a coupon from a free newspaper with $16.99 dinners. I ordered spaghetti in clam sauce, my friend had sausage & peppers. The ad said it came with salad, garlic knots & cheesecake so it sounded like a good deal. My spaghetti with clam sauce was swimming in oil. My friend liked his sausages. The salad was small & had maybe a teaspoon of dressing on it, just a slice of tomato & iceberg lettuce. The garlic knots & cheesecake were delicious. When we went to pay the bill the employee didn't know how to apply the coupon, I guess no one had ever used one before! The place was busy. It's tiny with only 4 tables & people came & went constantly so I assume the pizza is good. The bell rang every time someone entered or left & it was annoying to sit there hearing it constantly. For that reason I recommend take-out rather than eating in. They also served everything as if take-out (i.e., plastic, paper, no permanent dishes/utensils) & I had to replace my fork as the tines died the minute I tried to stab a piece of tomato! read more

The food is delicious! Prices are reasonable and staff/owner are friendly, pleasant and professional. I Always get my Italian food from Mr G's, from Friday night pies to Catering my events. Would absolutely recommend MR. G's!!!!!! read more

This place should be considered a lindenhurst landmark. Best crust around by far in my opinion. The owner is super nice and the food is always great. Can't recommend enough! read more

pizza was so good really nice people but charged me basically $20 for two reg slices one w sausage one mushroom sausage. got a soda and ranch side. $19 that's insane and it doesn't match their pricing. should have been $15 what did it get charged $3 for ranch? menu said 4.50 a reg slice topping were supposed to be 75cents each. a whole pie is 19.95 . didn't mention it just won't be back. slices were huge but still it's wrong to charge ppl more than you say on your menu read more

I used to love this place but they got really stingy with the prices... I ordered 2 slices of pizza 6 garlic knots and a 6 ct of fried Oreos .. they told my fiancée the total was 24.99 on the phone . Then when I got there I grabbed 1 soda and the total was $37!!?? I didn't know at the time so I just paid so when I was on the way home I was like why I was that so much money that I paid ??? Probably never again. I miss the old Mr Gs ): read more

Stopped by here last year, but never penned the review. To my surprise, they are share the block with one of my new favorite places, Black Forest Bakery and The Village Lanterne (see my separate reviews of both). Whenever I return to the area, I will visit at least two, if not all three of them! Tale of the tape: Garlic Knots Small - medium-small sized, they have a light texture, but the garlic flavor is scant. With just a bit more garlic this could have been a good, if not great knot. Drunken Grandma slice Plenty of vodka sauce covers the entire surface of the slice. The sauce itself is more savory than creamy, but that's ok, as it's decently good enough to merit getting it in a full pasta dish. Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad slice Plenty of grill chicken decorates this slice, which is fortunately not drowned in ranch dressing. It truly is the equivalent of a decent sized side salad with an accompanying dinner roll. While satisfying enough, it would be better served by a more savory Caesar dressing. Final note What really stood out to me across both slices (and the garlic knots) was the dough. The crust on both slices was thin, and crisped up with the crunch of a saltine, yet with the accompanying slight chew that together made a great base for the pizza. I will definitely return for more of Mr. G's fare! read more

See all

Pizza is Mid. I purchased a pepperoni slice and a 20 oz soda, $10. Over priced, and not worth it. How much could the soda have been, $3..?? So, the slice was $7.... read more

I love this place. The Drunken Sicilian Pie is the single best pizza I've had from any of the many pizza places in Lindenhurst. It's absolutely delicious, and if you haven't had it, it's a must try. The inside of Mr. G's gives you that classic Brooklyn pizzeria vibe, and the workers are all friendly and helpful. This is my go-to spot for pizza in town. read more

one star for Mr. G's. My visits here brought mixed feelings. The first time, the pizza had an odd smell and aftertaste, not an ideal experience. Strangely, the quality seemed better during a different visit with a mostly white group. However, the third time around, the service was uncomfortable; the staff seemed pushy about payment, resulting in confusion and a strange incident where they initially overcharged. The pizza consistently had a greasy texture and that same weird aftertaste. Inconsistent quality and unsettling encounters impacted my visits. I am a student so saving money is ideal but i don't mind tipping, but that experience was not worth such high tip they were demanding. read more

We ordered pizza and salads and the whole order was a total mess. The girl up front was screaming at the owner about messing up our order.we picked up the order the salad was all brown my pizza was supposed to be white with broccoli I got all white it tasted horrible we threw out the whole order. We will never order from thus place not ever again Terrible food terrible management. A disgrace for Lindenhurst. I don't recommend anyone going there at all. read more

I called and asked for food to be delivered and was told delivery doesn't start till 5. The phone was hung up on me before I even asked to have it picked up. Then my GF called bc I wanted nothing to do with that horrible attitude and then she had received a bad attitude over the phone as well. Service absolutely horrible everyone but the young kid with blonde hair had a horrible attitude! We ordered a pizza @1205pm Sunday was told it'll be ready in 25 min. Went there was told it'll be ready shortly. My GF and I walked around for 20 min and came back @12:45pm and our pizza was just thrown in. I've been coming here since before I can walk. And now I will NEVER step foot in this shithole again. Great customer service! read more

Stopped in to order a pie. Was told 10-15 minutes. Was ready in less then 10. Pizza was delicious.

We ordered from this place on a whim and lord stay away! We ordered Buffalo wings - they gave us plain chicken wings. We ordered a mushroom pie - they gave us a plain pie and charged us for the mushrooms. They completely got our order wrong and when we called them about it they told us "well you gotta understand we're very busy with other orders" and they hung up on us. Thank god we got our money back thru Grubhub but STEER CLEAR of this awful pizza spot. read more

Terrible pizza. Ordered the pie and picked it up in 10 minutes. It was on top of the oven waiting for us..... seems we were given a reheated burnt pizza. Called to talk to the manager. Didn't care at all. Never ordering from here again. Go to Stella, a better choice. read more

Mr G's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

Delicious!! We ordered take out - large pie half regular half pepperoni and it was sooooooooo good!! Friendly staff when we called, speedy delivery and the pizza was still piping hot when we opened the box. read more

Mr G's Pizzeria - I couldn't wait - I ate a slice before I remembered to take a pic! - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

I have to say, Mr. G's is pretty okay. It's not the best pizza on Wellwood, but the service is amazing and the variety is nice. Some things just come down to personal taste, but the Sicilian slice didn't "wow" me. Not quite enough cheese and the sauce was just a little too tangy for my palate. The white slice, however, was really excellent and almost a meal on its own. Very filling and heavy, so make sure you're not going to play football or go swimming immediately afterward. The owner, though, was super nice and very welcoming. I'll go back as convenient, but man, he has a lot of competition just a few doors down. So, you really have to bring your A Game to Pizza Town. read more

Bad service they take for so long to cook a friking orders they don't care about customers orders online and no place to park

The pizza is good, not too oily. The garlic knots are also good. The owner is friendly. Found out we were both from Brooklyn. The best part is I was unaware that I lost my wallet at the restaurant. They called me and returned it with everything in tact. Honesty and good service matters. I will always love this place. read more

Stopped in Today for a Quick Lunch with my wife, The Owner Vinny helped us, He was Very Nice. I just met him today for the first time but I felt like I knew him for years. I ordered a Salad with Chicken Cutlet and Mozzarella on Top, AMAZING A DEFINITE RECOMMEND read more

Mr G's Pizzeria - Small Salad with Chicken Cutlet and Mozzarella on Top - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

Ordered a Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad.. Chicken on top was good but that salad was premade at least that morning if not the day before. Limp, soggy and gross. How hard is it to chop some lettuce and make a salad to order. Pizza was ok, garlic knots had a lemony citrus taste.. with Spazzos across the street, I will not be back. read more

Update: we just ordered the Mac attack...it was soon good. My elderly parents loved it. My mom who has a thing for cheeseburgers said she never tasted anything like it. Hit soooo many spots. Thanks Vinny for the time and effort put into your food. Loved your Mac attack!! read more

Saturday we purchased 6 pies. All of them were different 1/2 eggplant w/1/2 ziti, grandpa pie, white with spinach, white with broccoli, sauteed onion and mushroom, and spinach Alfredo.WELL can't tell you which one we loved the best. OMG they were sooooooooooooooooo good. The crust was perfect nice and crispy. The toppings were plentiful and the pies were HOT. We normally get the standard pies but this time we wanted to see what else Mr G's had to offer and I tell you it was a mouthful of yummyness . YEAH for leftovers!!!!!!!! Mr G also threw in two 2liter's of Pepsi. THANKS Mr G. read more

Absolutely delish pizza! Have tried numerous specialty slices but I continue to go for the white slice. Best in town for sure. Highly recommend! read more

Visit Date: April 4, 2015 I came here desperately hungry after having my hair done at lemon tree. I had hair dye on my neck and I didn't realize it was awful looking until I got home and my husband asked me what happened to me lol. So anyway the guy behind the counter was being really nice to me and another guy who came in to order a hero was joking around with me. I think they thought I was a victim of abuse because of the hair dye so they decided to treat me nicely lol. I had a baked ziti slice and some garlic knots. They were both pretty decent. Nothing horrible but no wow factor or any memorable tastes really screamed out to my taste buds. I bought hubby home a pepperoni slice and a slice with mushrooms on it. He felt it was pretty good. I'd be back here again for a quick meal if I needed it but if you have time and you want some German definitely go to the village lanterne a few stores down the street for a wonderful sit down German meal. read more

Hot and fresh pizza delivered quickly!!! Mr. G's has been around for so long and it's easy to see why! Our new go to pizza delivery place! Definitely give them a try, you won't be disappointed. read more

Best pizza in town. Today we had pizza with tomato sos, onion and mushrooms. Very good. Thank you Mr. G read more

Favorite pizza on the island but i gave it 3 stars because they mess up my order every single time without fail. There were about 5 different occasions i ordered a pepperoni pizza and they gave me just cheese. Very delicious though will still order despite always screwing up the order. Pizza is that good. read more

Mr. G's is pretty good. I like a slice or sicilian........ keep it simple This place has 10+ fancy pizzas everyday if that's your thing. The owner Vinny twisted my arm to try his Big Mac Pizza Dammmmmmm it was gooooooooooooooooooooooooooooood!!!!! read more

Avoid this place. The kitchen standards are non existent. Chicken Parm Pizza Chicken was spoiled. Took one bite and my body rejected it and i had to spit it out. Pizza was undercooked dough was flavorless i cant rate the sauce because i spit it out before i could taste it. Really horrible. I just want to give you fair warning. Also prices are through the roof. Too much good pizza on LI to ever go here. read more

I love this pizza. There are many shops here in Lindenhurst and I've been to them all. My personal favorite is Mr G's. Hands down the best. I got three shops closer but this is my choice. read more

The man I usually speak to while over the phone is a sweetheart , this time I called and asked for well done ( had a feeling it wouldn't be ) due to the lady on the phones nasty disrespectful attitude towards a CUSTOMER . Received food and wasn't as ordered . read more

I'm new to the neighborhood and was excited to finally find any restaurant in area that offered a gluten free menu. Mr. G's was recommended to me by a friend and the first time I ordered I had the GF baked ravioli. They were ok. I know you can't expect much from a non-dedicated GF restaurant, but it was nice to be able to order delivery with my family. Tonight we decided to order again and I had the nerve to ask if the meat sauce was GF. The guy who answered the phone didn't know and asked the manager on duty while I was on the phone. The manager unleashes a particularly colorful array of expletives stating, and I quote "what kind of idiot asks if meat sauce is gluten free?! Tell the a**hole on the phone, NO the f'ing meat sauce isn't f'ing gluten free! People are such f'ing morons. F'ing idiot!" I was stunned. I placed my order without saying a word about what I heard. But called after it was delivered to say something. What awful customer service. I will NEVER order from them again. Oh and just as expected, the food tonight matched the service. Tasteless. Skip the attitude and bring your business elsewhere. read more

I order from Mr G's 6-7 times a month plus I stop by to get slices for lunch, great food and staff. Throughout this pandemic they have been awesome, the drivers respectable and friendly and I want to thank them all for doing this job when this is all going on. If you have never tried Mr. G'S stop in just like i did and I've never ordered from anyone else since. Awesome sausage pie. read more

Excellent pizza. The owner Vinny and staff make you feel right at home. Pleasure eating here. Would highly recommend. read more

Mr G's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

Update: threw the pizza away before it made me sick. Something is wrong in this kitchen. Ordered a chicken parmesan pizza and I feel like i was robbed. It's absolutely aweful. Pure floppy crust, grey chicken with a terrible texture. I won't be eating anymore of this for fear of getting sick. Not to mention delivery took almost 2 hours. read more

Great pizza. Restaurant is clean and well kept. Fast and friendly service. Food is always ready at estimated pickup time. Owner is a nice guy as well. read more

This place is great. There is a lot of competition in the area, but the gluten free (if you are into that) completely dazzled me. This place is definitely a hidden gem in Wellwood. read more

"best pizza ever" -sam "the pizza pie was a touch down"- Joe These are quotes from my fellow pizza comrades in the fight for a good slice. let me start by saying I'm from Medford. I was in the area for my grandfathers wake. On my way, passing Mr. G's, I smelled the pizza as I drove by. I said to the fellow pizza lover's, "were heading in on our trip back." we did. the pizza here is like no other I've ever had. honestly has to be the most delicious slice I've had. we ordered a half pepperoni half cheese. wow. the sauce was great and the garlic crust was better. I am willing to travel from Medford to hit this spot again. the owner is a jokester and a very nice man. 10/10. would recommend. read more

Mr. G's pizza is outstanding! Pick whatever slice or slices you want and they'll heat it up. They have many different varieties and some are unique to the pizzeria. For overall taste and quality, Mr. G's is among the best around. However it's a bit on the pricy side. For a whole pie, Domino's is a better deal. read more