We recently discovered Miceli Brothers Pizza down the block from our house and decided to give them a try with a to-go order. When we picked everything up, we were really impressed by how spacious and clean the inside was. Everyone at the counter was super friendly and helpful, which was a great first impression. We started with the wings, and they were amazing! They were perfectly crispy, the sauce was delicious, and they definitely did not skimp on the blue cheese, which I really appreciate. For our meals, we got the French onion pasta and WOW, this was amazing. I am a HUGE French onion guy, so I was especially excited to try this. It was such a unique and delicious dish, and the French onion flavor really came through. My only suggestion would be to caramelize the onions just a little bit more. We also tried the chicken saltimbocca, which was so tasty, cheesy, and cooked perfectly. We'll definitely be back, and we're already excited to try their pizza next time! read more

See all

Good food all around here. Love their meatballs, margherita pie and chicken Marsala slices!!!

When I visited NY my bucket list was to find an authentic mom and pop pizzeria and this is exactly what I got. This store is nice and clean, the service was amazing. Celli was attentive and made me feel like immediate family, like we had known each other for years. The food was immaculate. From presentation, cost, and of course taste. I will be returning every time I'm in the area. read more

Had tried the food catered from there for a christening. It was amazing. Decided to try Chicken Night on a Thursday. I couldn't believe how many choices you were able to pick from. The service and food were outstanding. I will be back. read more

I happened to be on a roadtrip and needed some food to tied me over. Hangry is not a good look when driving :-). Stopped here and was pleasantly surprised. The food was amazing and the vibe fun!! read more

The Buffalo wings were absolutely delicious--crispy, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. Great service, friendly staff, and fresh food. I'll definitely be coming back! Highly recommend. read more

I've written these guys up before for their killer French onion pasta, but today I tried their spaghetti bolognese. I realize why their dishes are better than others because they know how to make sauce and they don't cheat you and get skimpy with the sauce. Fantastic! Service is great! Love the vibe in there, feel like I'm in Brooklyn! Going to keep trying other dishes, 9.1 on the Bolognese. read more

Miceli Brothers Pizza - Special French Onion Soup Pasta and Chicken - Pizza Near Me - West Babylon, New York

See all

really good pizza! some of the best in NY, fast and clean! the chef was very good looking

Cheesy goodness. If you're ever craving some delicious pizzas and pastas, definitely stop by. They have such incredible food. We were obsessed with the fried cauliflower and the thin crust pizza. The pasta was amazing as well. Can't wait to try the rest of their menu! Appetizers - Hot 'n Crispy - Garlic Knots - Caesar Salad Entrees - Grandma Ala Vodka - Fiorentina read more

Stopped in on a Friday for some pizza. I love the sesame crust option so I had to grab a pie. I also grabbed some French onion soup pasta. When I arrived everything was ready. The staff is so friendly and very attentive to my food allergies which is huge for me. I even wanted to try a food special which came with pesto. They made a nut free pesto for my dish on the spot! Above and beyond! read more

See all

The food here is INCREDIBLE! The sauce is so fresh and delicious and Matt is just so friendly & inviting! You feel Iike you've been coming here for years. Every dish and side makes you wanna come back for more. It's a super casual feel inside, like the pizza you'd hang out in as a kid. You're gonna get the best service possible where you never feel forgotten or feel the need to wave for help. I HIGHLY recommend coming here whether it's for a quick slice, a nice dinner date or just to go treat yourself MB has you covered!! read more

See all

Was not a fan of the pizza at all. Ordered online and even when it said order was ready and still showed up a few minutes late I was told it's still not ready by a rude employee. For the price and "deal" I was given they should have paid me to eat that subpar pizza. And the garlic knots were horrendous. read more

Pizza was very under cooked. We had to wait for our food. We were told 25 minutes got there and still waited. Only to find out they didn't make the pinwheels we ordered. Than we get our cold and undercooked pizza, and get over charged. Had to say hey did the prices go up that much from last week. Use to enjoy the place, not planning on going back. I left off they wanted to charge me for a cup of sauce for the pinwheels. read more

Cool place, literally the best pizza I've ever had in my life! The service and staff are incredible! If you're looking for the ambiance of authentic ny pizza, this is the place to go. read more

Miceli Brothers Pizza - This pizza is insanely good - Pizza Near Me - West Babylon, New York

The food is amazing I suggest the French onion pasta It's creamy and rich and I've never had anything like it! read more

Miceli Brothers Pizza - (This is the French Onion Pasta) - Pizza Near Me - West Babylon, New York

An absolute must-try pizza place in the area! Friendly staff, delicious food and a lot of unique menu options. You would be surprised to find that their chicken wings are incredible! The garlic knots are also delicious and I love their pasta and chicken night menus. They offer a full dine-in menu, as well as a pizzeria counter for grab and go options! read more

See all

Id rather eat a 711 pie than this rubbery shit. There was no flavor and i paid 75$ for 2 pies 1 personal and 12 knots i feel like i been robbed. Dont waste your time or money on this place. Undercooked garbage. I will not be returning to this place. read more

Miceli Brothers Pizza - Tried to pick up a slice and this happened - Pizza Near Me - West Babylon, New York

Came here last night and wow. Everything we ordered was absolutley delicious! We had the fortunate experience of meeting Matt and his father Frank and they were super sweet and very attentive. You can tell the food is made with love. The wings were a personal fav but everything from the pizza to pasta was sooo good. One side is very New York pizzeria and then the other side is perfect for sit down dining. The vibe was casual and friendly, Will Definintely be back! read more

See all

The best pizzeria on Long Island, hands down! This place is a must visit if you are near West Babylon! Order the garlic parmesan wings, the rigatoni fiorentina, or the Nonna Vittoria pie! read more

everything i've eaten from here has been absolutely delicious! between pizza, pastas, salad you really can't go wrong. the prices are very reasonable and the portions are great as well. the staff is always super kind and pleasant too! i have only gotten takeout from here but i'm looking forward to going and dining in sometime - definitely becoming a regular favorite of mine! read more

By far one of the best Italian/pizza restaurants on Long Island. Everything is excellent and high quality. If you're feeling like having pizza, they do all different kinds of fun pizzas, all of which are awesome. The classic and grandma pies are exceptional as well. My favorite though, is their restaurant menu. I love to come here and sit down, order some appetizers, pastas, and a drink. Their chicken dishes are out of this world too. The dine-in service is always friendly and on point. This is a must-visit restaurant. One of my favorites ever! read more

I had an amazing experience here the food was incredible!! French onion pasta is a must. There's items not listed on the menu so don't be afraid to ask for more wing flavors & pizzas! Owner/chef Matt is super passionate about food and it shows through his food! read more

Miceli Brothers Pizza - Pasta Fiorentina - Pizza Near Me - West Babylon, New York

** VERY LONG BUT PLEASE READ*** Normally I would never post anything like this but I feel strongly that EVERYONE should know how horribly I was treated by Miceli Brothers on Little east neck road. I ordered through Yelp (or grub hub) for a delivery for rigatoni ala vodka pie that in the description says it comes with chicken cutlets and bacon for $30 along with a soda and 6 fried zepolis. After the pizza was delivered (late), the pizza was missing the chicken and bacon. I call Miceli's to let them know my pie was wrong thinking they'd apologize and rectify the situation. Instead I was yelled at by a grown man, who I suspect is the owner. He proceeds to tell me that he does not make a pie with chicken and that grub hub has access to change their menu items. So I respond with "so you're telling me you charge over $30 for pasta on a pie?" He proceeds to blame grub hub again and said that they change the prices of the items so they make money and that if I'm expecting a refund that I am not getting it. This harassment goes on for another 5 minutes until I hang up and call grub hub. THEN... As I am on the phone with grub hub, the man calls my cellphone on his personal phone and leaves me a nasty 3 minute voicemail telling me I am just trying to get things for free. AND THEN.. I receive a text message from the same number asking me how many times have I done this before and how I am good and not to leave a bad review. I have never in my life been treated and harassed by anyone like this in my life ESPECIALLY by a business. I really hope everyone does themselves a favor and orders elsewhere because people like this do NOT deserve our business. read more

See all

This place has the best sauces on Long Island, the Marsala is my favorite. Matt's a really friendly guy who always wants to make sure his customers are accommodated. great service! read more

I've been coming here for years. Not on a regular basis but once every few months since we're not really pizza goers. But when we do or when I have a craving for pepperoni pinwheels I only go here. I never use third party ordering apps like Uber eats or grubhub because I know they charge for random things. So I usually call ahead and pick it up myself or order on the spot. The owner has always been friendly and ALWAYS did his job right. Never had overcooked, undercooked or burnt food. It's always been pretty damn good. The place in itself is also really nice. They recently renovated it a few years ago. And it's always clean in there. read more

We had dinner at this place for pasta night without price on menu. I asked for fettuccine w/ clam sauce , but got spaghetti w/ muscles lol after 30 min later finally. It took a very long time to cook it. So I told her this wasn't clams. It's muscle lol. Then retuned to kitchen, got spaghetti again w/ clams sauce ( on menu was fettuccine) after 15 min later. My husband finished his dinner when I got my dinner. Waitress told me she would take off my dinner but she didn't. We won't come back! Restaurant is very unorganized and the cook doesn't know what he's doing or follow the menu. read more

Chicken Ala Matthew.... Sounds really delicious in the menu but....I ordered and paid $22 for that. It was the worst Italian food I've ever had. They call it " white wine sauce" on it but Pasta was like swimming in the water, has no taste... I paid $22 for a tasteless boiled pasta swimming in a water they called " white wine sauce " and chewy grilled chicken. Disgusting! read more

Well first it was late.. had to call and then my chicken was undercooked.. not happy at all! Dissatisfied completely read more

Good food, comes fresh and hot! I really enjoy the flavor of the pink sauce in the pasta fiorentina, grilled chicken has amazing flavor! You can't forget that grandma pie=perfection from the sauce to the crust! Go tonight if your reading this post! read more

I wish there was an option for NEGATIVE stars, because giving this place one is way too generous. I can understand messing up one order, if it was taken care of. But after giving this place numerous tries, and dealing w this owner who has ZERO customer service skills I definitely won't be back. Being in the restaurant industry , customer service is number one. Especially if your product is sub par like theirs. Between the rude owner, half assed pizza which is never cooked, hour and a half for delivery, and even screwing up chicken parm with undercooked chicken, not to mention unwilling to correct their mistakes when you are paying , just wanting to yell and argue.... I don't know how this guy has any customers. After looking at past reviews I guess his same attitude hasn't changed over the years . I'm not one to post reviews but he needs a lesson in professionalism. Do better. read more

I was very very satisfied with the food here it was exquisite, I had very great and welcoming service, I had the blackened chicken Cesar salad and enjoyed it very much, the Ambiance of the restaurant was very good and welcoming as well. The lighting made me feel very calm I highly recommend you try coming here and eating. read more

DO NOT ORDER ONLINE THEY RIP YOU OFF! Just received my order. Everything was hot and fresh. 1 stars because they charge you higher prices if you order online in addition to the delivery fee. Almost an extra 5.oo on the hot antipasto online. The menu I have was delivered yesterday. They should tell you before hand they are going to charge you extra if you order online. I would've ordered else where if I was going to be ripped off and not given a great tip if I knew they were making an extra 10.00 off me. Will never order from them again!! I guess I'll have to complain to the BBB!! read more

Amazing food, amazing staff, and a classy environment. Chicken Parm Sandwiches,Chicken Marsala, Pinwheels they got it all.

Local pizza got nothin' on Miceli! This is the best slice around! Ol' boy is always in there making things fresh. Grandma slice is killer. Dare to try vodka pie for a very decadent treat... He's got something really special there! read more

Came for lunch with two coworkers because one of my friends lives near by and this is their pizza place they always go to. Speciality slices today included: bacon pineapple, Sicilian, grandma vodka, white, baked ziti, buffalo chicken, chicken marsala, BBQ chicken, chicken bacon ranch, pepperoni & sausage I think that's it? I tried to remember all of them ! They also had large garlic knots, pinwheels, rice balls, stuffed pizza, and beef patties (odd). Pizza: Most slices have a sesame seed crust so if you're not into that, I wouldn't come here. Chicken Marsala slice: lame, not really good at all. The flavor/seasoning was so weak it barely tasted like Marsala wine/sauce at all. Grandma vodka: great little slice, tasty vodka sauce with fresh mozzarella on a crispy crust. Downside was this is a fairly small slice for $4. White slice: if you love a lot of ricotta this is your slice. The whole slice was spread full of ricotta and mozzarella cheese sprinkled with basil. Good slice, but similar to most pizza places. Chicken bacon ranch: this slice had the most flavor. If you're looking for a filling slice go for this one. Crumbled bacon, mozzarella & cheddar cheese, chicken bits, and ranch. I mean all of those ingredients are good alone so of course together they are delicious. (This slice does not have a sesame crust) Overall: their pizza isn't that memorable compared to other pizzerias I've been to. Slices are $4 and slightly smaller than other pizzerias. Go for the vodka & chicken bacon ranch. read more

See all

I rarely give 5 start reviews so here it goes... This pizzeria/restaurant is AMAZING! I went there for the first time yesterday with my boyfriend for dinner. My friend suggested it to me since she went there for an event a few weeks ago and said the pizza was delicious. I asked the chef what the specials were and he suggested the Veal with prosciutto and melted mozzarella in sherry wine. It sounded delicious so I tried it and....OMG. Amazing! So mouthwatering and fresh. My boyfriend had the buffalo pizza and regular slice and he said it tasted like authentic NYC pizza.... maybe better! The owners are really friendly- they had us cracking up laughing! Also, you can't beat the prices. I would DEFINITELY recommend Miceli's to anyone who is looking for a delicious and affordable meal!!!!! read more

Miceli Brothers Pizza - Veal with prosciutto and melted mozzarella in sherry wine. AMAZING! Chef Matt made it for me!! - Pizza Near Me - West Babylon, New York

This place has a rude, disrespectful, cursing pizzeria manager/ apparently self proclaimed owner. Regardless of us getting a "$5 special surprise bag" deal on the TooGoodToGo app, luckily we didn't have pork in the "surprise bag" but the pizzeria's manager was reluctant to even understand we cannot eat pork due to our religion & was dismissive of our first concern. Secondly, once we asked them to heat up the cold pizza as we were going on a long drive they did not want to accommodate us despite us offering to pay extra for this. The manager got disrespectful and resorted to continuously calling us cheap, verbally harassing us and saying to pay for "actual pizza" and "regular slices" If we want hot pizza. He also said we're not paying customers which makes no sense. Ordering through this app is like ordering through any other third party app like Uber or Door Dash. This food is still from their establishment at the end of the day. However there was this one employee in the back who was kind enough to accommodate all of our concerns despite the appalling behaviour of the manager/owner and helped to mediate his erratic behaviour. He was very understanding and for this reason only do we give the establishment two stars. Additionally I want to add that despite the terrible service the food was tasty. read more

I've been quoted in the past as saying a pizza restaurant is the best. But all that changed today. Other pizzeria's are second to "Miceli Brothers Pizzeria & Restaurant." I met up with my brother and it was easy parking because they have a lot on 9th behind the building. Coming inside I was impressed with the dark wood trim and off color walls plus beautiful floors. It's half a restaurant and the other side is the pizzeria. At the counter we were greeted by a wonderful woman, who was eager to help. She let us pick the slices we wanted. She was very polite. If she didn't know a price, she asked the man sitting behind us eating a salad. That man turned out to be part owner of the restaurant, Antonio, a very charismatic guy that was in love with his business. After we ordered and sat down he walked over our rice ball and conversed with us for a minute. Antonio told us his brother Mathew and him own the building. They tried different crusts but went with the sesame seed in order to help the town workers (Ask Antonio the story). Once he walked away it was time to eat. Now, here it comes, the statement I'm about to make will be open for much debate, but I will be the one to say it......The bacon, chicken, ranch slice at "Miceli" is the best on Long Island! Let me explain why. The bacon they use has a deep smoky taste. Add the creamy ranch sauce and the tender chicken you have a winner. The icing on the cake was the crunchy crust with sesame seed on the crust. I never had it that way before and don't know if I can live without it. Don't forget the rice ball. That too was melting in my mouth. They have the right portions of rice and cheese. This made it a complete and tasty ball. I was pleased with the food, price, service, and atmosphere. Can I go as far as to say give them six stars? I will leave that up to you. Definitely come and try it out. You will see I'm not wrong. read more

See all

Order a pizza - guy on the phone was talking over me so I repeated - did you hear me say WELL DONE? Yes - said 45 minutes - ordered at 5PM and it arrived at 6:33!!! On my 4th call they said he was in front of my house - nope - another 10 minutes - it arrived NOT well done and cold - in addition I calculated the price from the menu + tax - $18.00 - cost was actually $20 - NEVER AGAIN!! read more

I stopped in on my lunch break and wasn't disappointed. Had a sweet chili chicken slice with sesame crust and it was one of the best specialty slices I've ever had. It wasn't too big or overloaded so it was easy to hold. Nothing worst than a slice of pizza you need a knife and fork for. I also had a grandma slice, which was great too. I took a glance at some of their food and it looked and smelled delicious. I'm Italian and these guys are too. You can tell they know what they're doing. I'll definitely be returning. read more

Miceli Brothers Pizza - Sweet chili slice - Pizza Near Me - West Babylon, New York