At first glance it seems like another New York Pizza joint. Two things make it different. Firstly, They have achieved the feat of a hot delicious gooey chewy topping with a crispy yet not burned bottom crust. Secondly, they have ready to go pre made meals for $7 including baked zitti and a fridge full of Hagen Das! Excellent best on Long Island! read more

See all

Very disappointed- lasagna was watery - Spaghetti was watery Penne was watery- like they didn't drain the pasta before adding the sauce!!!!!!!! read more

the veggie slice was pretty good! they make their own ice creams here which is cool, but they have very limited specialty slices. they have the basic white slice, spinach slices, but nothing fancy like a mac and cheese slice. either way, i'd come back! especially since it's called Luigi's pizza. any place called luigi gets an A+ from me. ((free luigi))) read more

Luigi's Pizza - veggie slice with broccoli and eggplant - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

I love the convenience of the location . Disappointed in the taste . Nothing special just a regular pie . $ 20.00 The sause is very bland , add a little seasoning ! read more

Affordable pizza, though the selection is limited, it's delicious. They also make premade meals you can purchase for $6 or $7, which is a great deal! The service is always great, and they always have people ordering, or sitting down enjoying their meal with their authentic pizzeria vibe. I've gone there many times, and have not been disappointed. If you're hungry, give them a try! $3.25 for a slice seems like a steal to me! read more

One of the best Sicilian slices ive ever had. Went in to pick up a 2 good 2 go order, but ordered a Sicilian pie while i was on the way. I have been all over, and have done hundreds of reviews all across the tri state area, and this may be one of my top 5 sicilian slices. Perfectly cooked, crispy crust and undercarriage, perfect thickness to the dough, tasty sauce, fresh tasting cheese with a good pull. Absolutely delicious. $16.99 deal monday nights. Absolutely worth stopping in read more

Luigi's Pizza - Sicilian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

Came here for some pizza with my boyfriend for dinner. We were both greeted upon entering. Lots of speciality pizzas on display. I went with a white pizza with roasted red peppers and diced chicken, no sauce. Flavors were very good, but the pizza could have been cooked just a little bit longer. My boyfriend ordered several slices. Sicilian, bbq chicken and two regular slices. I didn't have any, but he seemed to enjoy them. We also had garlic knots. The garlic knots were fantastic. Crispy and garlicy! They also take the foodie card! For all 5 slices, garlic knots and 2 drinks it only came to about $12. Can't wait to return to try more pizza! read more

Luigi's Pizza - Variety...bbq chicken slice, chicken and roasted red peppers, plain, Sicilian, and garlic knots. - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

This has become my go-to local pizzeria since moving here. The pizza is consistently good, great prices. Their white slice and veggie slice are my favorites. The veggie slice is loaded with eggplant, broccoli and a few other items. It's like a meal on a slice. The staff has been super friendly each time I've been in. Garlic knots are great, bite size and soft in the middle. They have to-go desserts like linzer tarts, red velvet whoopie pies and other assorted desserts as well. They conveniently have premade single portioned meals of items like ziti, stuffed shells, Meatballs, Lasagna. Great for people who like to have quick, easy grab and go meal or help with meal prep for the week. read more

Great local pizza parlor and they deliver for free! Best pizza in Lindenhurst No need to deal with Uber eats read more

Pasta Norma had a vodka sauce! Yes really!! Waiter belongs in a diner because of his manners. Restaurant owner/manager sadly doesn't get that. Won't return. read more

Ordered a Sicilian slice and it had so much oregano on top that it's all I tasted. Tried to scrape it off but it was melted in with the cheese. read more

Love the food!! Love the Service!! Love the Prices!!! The People are Awesome!! I will be ordering AGAIN tomorrow , If you were open now I'd be biting into a slice right now. Have A Great Day Guys! Sincerely, Susan read more

Ordered a pizza for delivery instead of going out tonight. We live four blocks from Luige's. It took an hour and a half for the delivery and it arrived ice cold. i called to complain and was told " impossible, how can that be." Essentially called me a liar. so-so food coupled with bad customer service and attitudes. Save your money and go elsewhere. read more

I've come here for years. I remember when the new owners took over and I was impressed. It's popular in the neighborhood. Even though I like this place I can not step over what I just witnessed. When I stopped in to get some slices to go I was looking for the 6' markers on the floor and noticed there were none. I'm careful to keep my distance. I made sure to stand away from the customer who had no mask on and roamed around looking at the varieties of pizza and buying canned drinks. I wondered why he wasn't asked to put a mask on, especially in a food service establishment. Then I noticed the employee making pizza, without a mask on. I checked with Suffolk County and NYS. It is required of food service workers to wear a mask. I double checked, it's the law. Stunned I walked out and noticed no sign requiring masks was even posted. If the owners and employees of this business care so little about the health and wellbeing of their customers, and the families their customers go home to than I vote with my dollars today. And it's a landslide - my money goes elsewhere and while I have compassion for those who do this essential work during these unprecedented times you do not get a do over. Your mistakes could make many people I'll. Or worse. PS you get this 1 star because Yelp won't allow me to give you a negative start count. read more

We have been going since they first opened giving a new business a chance. Last week it was the worst pizza ever. It looked and tasted like it was sitting there for a lengthy period of time. The next day I went back and spoke with the owner. He was rude and only wanted to see a picture if it was his pizza. Told me to leave, didnt even want to hear it. Never going back!! read more

love this place great fiod and staff.. fresh eggplant super delicious would recommend

Been here a few times before. Foods always consistently pretty good (slightly chilled last time but it happens). Tried everything from pizza to calzones to chicken rolls. Location has parking and seating. Nice size tv with sports usually on is also a plus. Not over priced at all. Will be back again. read more

Luigi's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

$4.99 for two slices of pizza and a can of soda! Although I thought the pizza might not be good because of the price, I was wrong. The pizza is evenly sauced and they even make it crispy for you. The owner is accommodating and will help you with anything you need. It's a nice and tasty local pizza shop. I'm a regular. read more

Luigi's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

Pizza taste Like it been sitting for days ,no flavor, frozen food sittin in fridge not worth it read more

true long island ambience and pizza. my personal favorite slice in lindenhurst. if you're looking for a super thick crust and loads of sauce and cheese, this isn't your place. the slices are tasteful and not over done. and a reasonable price. the lady at the counter was super nice. I always feel like i'm reliving a childhood memory when i grab a couple slices and eat in. it's not flashy, not pricey, not pretentious. it's down to earth, handmade, and homey. my go to spot. read more

The Zeppoles were old and raw and smelled and taste fermented coming from me that I'm Chef I would never come back there , pizza was disent but pizza is pizza ,for them to sell something they is know is no good makes them a bad business , place was dirty , I asked for my zeppoles first and I was ignored twice , they have 25 dollars in their pockets but they lost a customer, if the zeppoles are no good and the place is dirty I will not trust the to go meals. read more

This pizza place at first was amazing (but you can tell they cut corners where they can) them they declined so much we stopped ordering. But then one day I wanted to pay a reasonable price for a pie so we tried them again and BAM!!! I'm not sure if they got a new chef or new recipe but the pizza is AMAZING!! The prices are AMAZING and the staff is AMAZING! read more

We ordered two pies,one Grandma and one Neapolitan and a dozen mozzarella sticks. Almost 40 dollars. Grandma was cold and greacy. Neapolitan tasted like it was reheated . read more

I like this place , good food and good service .. and if ya want some pizza through the week the carry out special every Wednesday is spot on in taste and value. I was amazed at the hoagie rolls and size of their sandwiches , wings are good too. I don't eat seafood but my boyfriend ordered their fried calamari appetizer and he complimented it repeatedly . I said I like this place umm no I love it actually.. read more

Great place, the staff is wonderful. They take care of the customers. Help out local BSA troops. They take care of the community. My father would take my son over for pizza when he watches him. The owner noticed he Vietnam veteran hat and always thanks him for his service. What more can you ask for? read more

Pizza tastes like cardboard dipped in olive oil. Owner is rude & crude with a temper if you criticize the food or the poor service. Do yourself a favor and skip this grease trap for any other pizzeria. read more

Seriously im like addicted to this place. Its so fucking good. And cheap as hell. AND nice people to boot. I love coming here and come from Bellmore all the time just to get my fix. read more

Enjoyed our dinner out - quite reasonable- tasty- staff very friendly. We had 4 specialty slices - 2 cans of soda & 6 zeppolies all for $15.00. read more

Luigi's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

The prepared frozen meals are very reasonably priced and tasted great. Did I mention convenient? So far I've had the veal and chicken parms. Their specialty pizzas are above average and worth trying as well. Service is fast paced and there is usually a few customers on line so call ahead for the fastest in and out. read more

This is THE place if your picky about pizza. We unfortunately ordered from another pizza place tonight because we had a coupon. Won't be making that mistake again. Never going with anything other than Luigi's again. It's just the best around. Highly recommend. read more

been going here for years and recently stopped along with a few of my other friends....reason being....pies are much MUCH smaller now....the quality of food has changed so much. the sauce is very different from Lous sauce which was amazing! The new owners have def lost a lot of business in town. Myself and quite a few others i know used to order more than once a week from here now we all go elsewhere. i wish the new owners would have just left things the way they were. 0 stars read more

New place in what has been a deli location that has repeatedly turned over in the past 30 years. The pizza is good, but by no means the best. You need to go to Alitalia for that. The decor/ambiance is definitely lacking, not very warm & inviting. Sortie sparse. However, a lot of money for a friggin pizza read more

Super delicious! My favorite is the buffalo chicken slice yum they even have premade quick dinner options for you to take home! 4 for $22

Love this place!!! Food is great and the staff is so nice. Portions of dinner meals are very good and enough for two days worth of dinner. Prices are very good too. Makes life easy for me since I'm busy and don't have time to cook for myself and my family. read more

Food started off good until a cockroach crawled out the box of pizza! When we called to tell them they said impossible and refused to give us a refund. We brought the cockroach to show them and they called the owner. Only refunded us $40 when we spent over $100! Too bad all this food is going to waste because everyone is toodisgusted to eat! read more

If I could give this place zero stars I would. I just watched the woman at the register give an attitude to the couple in front of me. They were asking a question respectfully. She yelled out, "Nuh, uh, that never happened here!" They didn't give her an attitude back. Good on them. I walked out and didn't buy anything. I looked up their health violations through the Suffolk County Health Inspector site after I observed this and spotted a few health violations that they were supposed to have corrected. That sealed the deal. https://eco.suffolkcountyny.gov/#/pa1/detail/FA0005493/PR0005429?City=LINDENHURST read more

Food is great! My family orders from here all the time. Pizza is good and pasta dishes are amazing and they put plenty of food for the price. I grew up in queens and my pops owned a shop for a long time so I know my pizza and pasta dishes . Definitely recommend. read more

Good pizza, they do the sauce on top of the cheese on their Sicilian and we love it. When Im on on the south shore....I try and go there! Carmine! read more

Really good pizza and nice staff but the lady kind of has an attitude , I was really polite and never got any you're welcome back or any acknowledgement except for when I was paying , not a really good way to get customers coming back read more

I love the pizza here. They have great fresh baked bread every day and excellent service. The staff is super friendly. I've been going for a few years now, and I've never had a bad experience. We order catering from them once or twice a year also, and they do a great job each time at a great price. read more