They must have changed the sauce. Not that same, flavorless. The garlic knots look like they came from a box. Not the same doughy homemade. Once loyal customer will not go back read more

Self proclaimed Pizza Snob here. Tried this place tonight for the first time. Been passing by for months and finally stopped by. Firstly, the place is nice...neighborhood kind of place. Clean and well lit. The folks at the counter were friendly and helpful! Went against habit as I was craving a Tomato/cheese slice and glad I did. The slice was very warm, not blazing hot. I like it when it's very warm so I can enjoy it right away, which I did! The crust was crisp without being crunchy. The sauce, the most important part, was not overly sweet. The cheese was yummy without being salty. This was a very yummy slice indeed! Definitely going back and soon! read more

Joe's Pizza - Tomato/cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Copiague, New York

Affordable, yummy, and a quick delivery. Driver was nice and food was fresh. Will be back.

Joes is the only pizza place my family of 6 agrees to eat. - nice people Great food, and fair prices. the portions are enough for two nice size meals. love that they are a local establishment. Give them a try you won't be disappointed. read more

Really good pizza, and bonus points for offering personal size pizzas, especially in gluten free crust. A lot of pizza places only offer one size of pie in gluten free crust. They also do a good job of segregating the gluten free from the gluten products. So a good option for those with gluten sensitivities or allergies. Surprisingly, the sautéed broccoli rabe was also very good - garlicky and bitter, a nice counterpoint to the pizza! Besides pizza, they have pastas and seafood dishes. Friendly and quick service, we'd definitely come back. read more

It's the end of the summer and we're going to our good friends house on Saturday night. I told them not to make a fuss, I'm coming over with some wine and we'll pick up a few pizzas. (To Italians, that means a 5 hour visit instead of 7 hours) They made an antipasto dish to feed a small Army, about two hours in I said let's get the pizza! Walking in, Joes is a nice family run business. Saturday night and there's a steady stream of customers picking up their take out food. We ordered two pizzas, a regular 8 slice and a grandma Sicilian pizza. Very impressive, everything tasted fresh. From the sauce, the quality cheese to the perfectly cooked crust, Joes makes a good, well crafted pizza. Now we start to argue about money, we're both throwing twenties at the cashier. Good friends sharing good pizza made this a great night. Thanks (Mr) Joe! read more

One of the best regular pies you can get on LI. Nice crispy crust with great sauce and perfect amount of cheese.

By far, the best BBQ chicken pizza around! There's no shortage of pizza joints on the island, each having their own unique thing that makes them stand out. This place is their rice balls, and their BBQ chicken, whenever I'm craving ether, this is the goto spot! Today however, in the spirit of expanding my usual order here,I ordered the Chicken Parm Entre, and man was I glad I did! I subbed out the pasta sauce for Vodka sauce and this was a next level upgrade paired with penne pasta. Overall great experience, and ordered delivery right thu the Yelp app was a breeze! read more

Was getting tired of the usual pizzerias that we frequent so I decided to Google "pizzerias near us" and Joe's Pizza was the first one to pop up. Read a few of the reviews and figured we'd give them a try. BEST DECISION EVER!!!! OMG!!! Without a doubt, one of the most delicious pizzas we've had in ages! Crust, sauce, cheese....everything was spot on! Having originally been raised in Astoria and Brooklyn, I've certainly had my share of very good pizzas, so, I feel pretty confident when I say this was on par with the rest! In addition, we also ordered some garlic knots (very tasty!) , a cheese calzone (it was HUGE!!!) and a side order of baked ziti (amazing!!! and, by the size of it, shouldn't even be considered a "side order"!) .....no complaints whatsoever! Can't wait to try more items on the menu! In hindsight, should have taken some photos but we gobbled everything up the minute the order was delivered. Which, by the way, was pretty prompt and even sooner than the time frame we were given. What more is there to say, but, from now on, Joe's Pizza will most definitely be our go-to pizzeria!!! Thanks for a TERRIFIC meal!!! read more

Very nice staff and service, good pizza, good place to catch the game and meet with friends and family read more

Joe's Pizza - Margarita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Copiague, New York

See all

Perfect as always, this place always makes me feel at home no matter the order I place. read more

Joe's Pizza - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Copiague, New York

This is our family pizza place of three decades. There is no place more I would rather get pizza in this entire world. Tonight we're getting pizza and no one in the house wanted Joe's. No one wears masks there. Everytime I have been there there I think I have been the only one wearing a mask. There are customers (ones not eating), employees, and the owners all mask less or only covering their mouth not nose. A sign is posted saying CDC Recommends Masks but clearly no one inside cares what experts say about health. It sucks that people can't just do the right thing for public health. It makes me question what other practices they ignore, something I never did. Great pizza, quick service, nice folks, but either dumb, uncaring, reactionary, or some combination. read more

Always good food and good service and always a friendly staff. Anytime I stop in weather it's a slice or a dinner I've always enjoyed their food. Can't beat "The best piece in town "!!!! read more

I definitely recommend Joe's Pizzeria. The pizza is delicious and they have tons of options. Their pizza is cheaper than others in town but just as delicious read more

The owners, Mike & Terry are wonderful souls who care deeply about the community they serve, always going above and beyond to support KiDS NEED MoRE and other local causes. They also have absolutely the most delicious food and the staff is so friendly and fast. My wife loves the eggplant. Everytime I come home with Joe's Pizza I am a hero in my house! read more

Great margarita pie and zeppolis delivered by a very charming young lady. Mike and Terry as always very friendly and hard working.

Wow that's all I can say !! The owner Mike rude & loud. Actually serving half raw & burned pepperoni chips & looks like someone actually bit into one of them. Maybe next time one of your customer calls to complain loose your unprofessional attitude. read more

Joe's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Copiague, New York

This is without a doubt the best pizza near us, (Amityville) a real step up from where we had been going. Not only the pizza but the baked pasta dishes are great as well. read more

Perfect NY pizza. If you want a perfect slice of cheese . Get it here. Fast delivery too

Great linguini and white clam sauce. And i am a picky son of a b.... Been eating here for years.

I ordered a marinara pie with eggplant no cheese and the dough is raw I called up and they were rude never go there again Looks like cheese but it's Raw dough. read more

Joe's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Copiague, New York

The pizza is better than most in the area. The people beyond the counter, the owner and others do not wear masks. This is not the first time I've observed this. We are all expected to follow the new guidelines. I will not be going back there. Two stars for the pizza. read more

This is the best pizza around. I have tried all the pizzerias in the area and this is the best. The rice balls are excellent too.

We are always pleased to eat at joes pizza. Home away from home, Great people, and never disappointed. read more

One star is too much! I am so disgusted by my taco slice and rice ball that I didn't eat & came here to post instead! Why was the rice ball cut in half & microwaved to heat it?!? Warmed up lettuce & a meat paste on the taco slice? I can only imagine that this slice has been sitting out minus refrigeration since they first opened today & it was picked up at 8:30 this evening. Please go anywhere but here!! Too many other places to go if you're looking to avoid food poisoning. read more

Great pizzeria of NY style pizza of all kinds without the inflated costs of so called artisan brick oven pizzas.

The pizza here is the best in town but the food needs work it is bland and tasteless. I gave 3 stars for that reason other than that staff is really friendl read more

Copiague is very well served from a pizzeria perspective but Joe's really stands out. Not the fanciest menu, or fanciest place but consistent above average food and great service. Family owned and it feels like it. J weoe's is a great part of the community read more

Joe's Pizza - a bottle of heineken beer and a slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Copiague, New York

First time at Joe's and your greeted immediately by a super friendly staff. They had a tons of slices to choose from and they all looked great. Highly recommend this pizzeria ! read more

Oh, how I used to love this place when I was in HS! Whenever I come home, I try to make a pit-stop at this awesome pizza joint. Nothing is better than real Italian pizza from Long Island. The calzones are great too! Pasta is yummy - everything is good. You can't lose. The staff is a wonderfully selected group of HS kids, and some old timers too. I love you guys! The boss even has his own sauce - THE BOSS SAUCE! Make sure you try their zeppolli - delicious! read more

Only halfway done with my meal and already love this place. Great pizza! White slice is legit!

Joe's Pizza, I am SO disappointed in you. As much as we love your food, I cannot in good conscience, patronize your establishment knowing that you willingly refuse to enforce mask wearing not only with customers but with employees. ONE girl wearing a mask. I won't go into what I was told over the phone by the owner but suffice it to say, it was bs. So tired of people not taking this pandemic seriously. So sick of the bs from people who don't care about others. So Joe's, as much as I like your pizza, this customer of 16 years will no longer be a customer. read more

Everyone I go into joes pizza I'm greeted with a smile. Their homemade soups are the best around and the rice ball was amazing!!! Very satisfied!!! read more

I live in the city but work on the island and have to say this was one of the best slices I've had in ages. Joes had a sausage slice which you rarely see and I asked for it hot and it came out near perfect. The crust was crispy , but not overly done, the sausage done but not over and the sauce was the kicker . Tomato, savory and not sugary like most sauces. Kudos. read more

Honestly Joe's Pizza was the best pizza i had in long Island, between this or Mama's Pizza, i prefer Joe's Pizza, the workers were so kind and funny, the pizza was Amazing Cecelia pie is the best i had all my life. I was worried because of the one and three star reviews but those were just mistakes or rare bad moments with the owner. He likes to joke around and is actually a really nice guy if you see him two or three times. honestly the workers say he is a great guy. Joe pizza is a great pizzeria, and if you bring your friends to sit and eat there you will have a great time read more

Great pizza, cleanest most sanitary food establishment around. During hurricane Sandy and following weeks he was open basically around the clock for the community who had no power for over two weeks meanwhile on the other side of town you had Mama's pizza price gouging. Mike, the owner, always takes care of the town without thinking twice. read more

Great pizza, heroes and salads! Staff is always pleasant. I started coming here because it's in walking distance from my house. I quickly realized that their food was ridiculously good. The calamari is fresh and tender. Their heroes are overstuffed and delicious and of course their pizza is made just right. So many specialty pies as well. They are open late which is great for after the beach concerts or night owls. The only drawback is they don't have their own delivery service, but that didn't stop me from giving 5 stars. read more

I eat pizza a lot. I'm doing a big renovation job around the corner from Joes and was in the mood for a slice the other night. We stopped at Joes after finishing up for the day and I have to tell you, Joes pizza is amongst the best. Not sure if everyone that works there is family, but it truly seems like they are. The pizza was flavorful, and had a nice thin crust which is a huge deal for me. Pizza should be thin but easily folded without losing its toppings...this pizza is great. I will be back despite it being 20 mins from my home. Huge plus, they don't serve you your slice on a paper plate. It's served on a real plate with a fork and knife. I had a white slice and a chicken bacon ranch slice...amazing. thank you read more

Mike does not honor his posted prices. This is a bait and switch pizzeria. I went online to view their menu. Called the number from the website. When I went in to pick up my pies and was charged way more for each pie. When I brought this to their attention, they tried to deny that they even had a website. When I showed them their website with their name, number, address and logo on it, the owner then told me that they didn't update their website. Mike would not own his mistake on the website nor would he even try. Instead he let me leave without anything. He lost a lot of customers in Amity Harbor because of this. read more

I have never tasted a chicken bacon ranch slice as good as Joe's pizza. My God, I can't even believe it. Chicken bacon ranch is my favorite slice, Ive tried a million of them, I get it everywhere every time. Joe's is hands down absolutely perfect. Not sure how any of the other food in the place is, ok environment, would recommend just for that slice alone. 10/10 for the slice. read more