Tired of paying all those excessive tasting fees to get a measly 4 or 5 pours of Dry Creek Valley wine? Looking for a spot to taste wine before walking (unsteadily, perhaps) a few steps away to order wood-fired pizza, halibut fish tacos, pasta fazool, and house-cured meats? Ever want the wines to come to YOU, rather than the other way around?
If you answered "yes" to any of those things, then Locals Tasting Room is totally right for you. It is probably the best wine country tasting room of its type that I've ever encountered in all of California, with not only some of the most interesting local wines. but also a complimentary pour policy that makes it possible for each and every member of your party to personalize their tastings to their specific preferences.
But how, you might ask, does one choose? There are basically three ways to play it:
(1) The "Vaya con Dios" shotgun style method: close your eyes, grab a pencil, and point at the printed, 2-page tasting menu (front and back, nearly 65 choices!). Once you've reached 4,5,6, or 7 pours, stop! After sampling them all, pick some of your favorites to take home and don't forget to thank the wine tasting gods for their beneficence.
(2) The "college kid" test prep method: download the tasting menu ahead of time from the LTR website. Do research on the wineries. Make a list the night before. Stick to your choices, even if tempted to wander. If you did your research well, you'll discover a few really good bottles to buy.
(3) The "horizontal mambo" method: pick a preferred grape varietal, or wine style (Rhone blends, sparkling, oaked whites, 15%+ alcohol, etc.) and try wines across the spectrum of winemakers. 4 Pinots. 5 Zins. 6 Chardonnays. If you have enough friends with you, and it's close to the winter holidays, you could even sing the "12 Nights of Christmas" with wines substituting for all those birds, barnyard animals, leaping lords, and golden rings. (Eg. "Fiiiiiive Pinot Noirs ... four Alexander Cabs, three French blends, two sparkling wines, and more 'Struttin White' in my empty glaaaaass ..."). Have fun with it. It's not the MCAT®.
Truth be told, I sampled from a little of all three methods (but I kept my singing to myself). I chose three wineries of interest - Arbios/Praxis, Pendleton, and Peterson - and also saved room for a 3-flight tasting of Petite Sirahs. I also stole a few sips from a friend who was trying the Kitfox blends (Mattress Police, One Time Spaceman, Voodoo Vixen). With names like that, how could one not?
While there was no consensus winner here, we weren't picking a President, and none of us were named Robert Parker, so there was no need to reach a majority or assign 90+ scores. I liked the Praxis wines a lot, esp. their rare bottling of 2012 Central Coast Lagrein (an Italian red variety from Alto Adige, genetically related to Teroldego, Pinot Noir, and Syrah). It was superb, like an Austrian Zweigelt, with perhaps a little more black fruit and wet earth and a bit less spice. So, too, the Praxis 2015 rosé of Pinot Noir from the Sonoma Coast, a lively pink, rose-petal of a wine with some intensity that will compliment autumn vegetable dishes like kabocha squash soup. Rosés like this are not just for summer sipping anymore!
My other favorites were made by Pendleton, especially their Alexander Valley estate Petite Sirah and Mourvèdre. The elevation of their vineyards is 2000 feet above the valley floor, so this tempers the fierce heat in summer and results I think in more complex, earthier, mineral-driven wines where the rich fruit has something to play off against, making it less jammy and pulpy than lower-elevation Alexander Valley fruit.
There are no Costco or Trader Joe's wines here that you can pick up for less than $12. Most are fairly priced in the $20-35 range with reserve wines and Cabs and some Pinots pushing into $50 territory. Staff here provide snacks to accompany the tastings, also complimentary: sliced Columbus dry salami, chips and dip, crackers. Just enough to hold you over until lunch at Diavola, right next door. How could your average Sonoma County wine taster be unhappy about any of that?
Note: there is also a lovely $5 used book shelf to the left of the tasting bar where you can pick up some good reading if you're staying here for a few nights, plus gifts and clothing for sale. The vibe is laid-back, but passionate. These folks like to share their wines, and it shows! read more