Went to Limoncello for dinner on a busy Saturday night. The service was great. The server and bus boy were very attentive to our needs. We were a party of 6. Half of us ordered the chefs specials, and the other half off the dinner menu. Two stuffed shrimp specials, and one NY Strip with crab. The presentation on these 3 plates were AMAZING. The strip was cooked PERFECTLY with such a beautiful presentation. The other 3 dishes were only subpar. Next time we will all strictly order from the dinner specials. The creme brulee was delicious. Overall good experience. read more

Held my daughter's bridal shower there---couldn't have gone better! Carly on staff was amazing in planning as I live out of state. Guests raved about the food. Wait staff were attentive, professional and worked hard to make the event perfect. I highly recommend! read more

Worst meal ! We had reservations for 6 pm...4 adults and 1 child which we requested high chair. We were seated and had to wait for high chair. We ordered appetizers meatballs and fondue. The meatballs were tasteless and the fondue started smoking and burning. No one came to our table to put it out until the whole room was smokey. At which time they opened a window and covered the sterno. When the waiter came to take our order it was discovered we were given the lunch specials, not dinner, and no child's menu. Off he goes to return with the correct menus. We placed our orders at about 6:35, we needed to get the child with us fed and home at a decent hour. Needless to say our meals did not arrive for over an hour, the waiter never came to let us know why such a delay. Other patrons in the same dining area came in after us and were already served and ready to leave. When the food finally arrived my medium filet mignon was raw and my husband's medium filet was burnt. Neither of us could eat it. The children's order of ziti we got could have fed 2-3 adults it was such a large portion, shame it had no flavor. The other couple with us both got chicken dinners, but said they were nothing to write home about. They removed the steak dinners from our bill as well as the ziti order, but the manager never even came to the table to apologize. We used to go to Lemoncello all the time when it first opened, we loved it. Then we had a so so meal a few years ago and vowed we wouldn't go back. We were given a gift card from a friend so thought we'd give one more chance. NEVER AGAIN! Most restaurants try to get your meal to you quickly when you have a toddler with you since they only stay calm for so long. Not here. Over an hour and a half and then we received inedible food. read more

We moved up here from NYC. Although there are several good restaurants up here, none of them have that sophisticated feel that we're used to. Until we found Limoncellos. We have quickly become regulars, we probably come once a week at least. We usually sit at the bar in back, for just drinks or a quick bite, but when we have family or friends in town we eat in the main restaurant. The servers and bartenders are very attentive and nice. The food is delicious. They are very accommodating of special diets and will make dishes nut free, Vegan or whatever changes you need. That's huge for me. I always really appreciate that! And they have the outdoor seating, too and last summer we had a delicious meal sitting outside with family and our senior dog. When we go to Limoncellos we feels closer to being in NYC. We always recommend it and we'll always be back. A special thank you to Carly, the bartender with the most amazing knowledge of craft beers! read more

Wonderful lunch spot! Lovely experience, white tablecloths, skilled service, excellent food. Romantic setting, extensive menu. Nice wine selections. I will be back! read more

Disappointing for sure. Service was slow due to the fact that we'd go 20-25 minutes between actually seeing our server. They missed a lot of little things too. Caesar salad served without the offer of fresh cracked pepper but worse, the lettuce was brown. We asked the busboy (since we couldn't get the attention of the server) for more balsamic glaze for the mozzarella caprese and it took two tries and 20 minutes to get that right. Dinner food wise is very very good. Piano player was too loud and you could barely hold a conversation. But really the worst past of the experience was the server who was in charge of way too many tables. My suggestion would be to add more servers and cut down on the busboys. This place could be so much better if you could actually get the attention you deserve for these prices. Crossing this one off the list as it was a one and done with that experience. read more

Most recently my family went to celebrate the holidays and there was about 20 of us. The service was good and we were setup in the back room near the fireplace which created a nice atmosphere. We started with fried calamari, eggplant rollitini, and stuffed mushrooms. The calamari was the best out of the three although all were tasty. Then salads and penne a la vodka. For dinner we had limoncello chicken, veal Marsala, and a salmon dish. Everyone seemed to enjoy all three dishes. We finished with tiramisu and a cannoli. Amazing company, good service, and good food made for a lovely night! read more

OK bread overdone , dipping sauce no flavor& this time African lobster tail tough,SCALLOPS GREAT smaller portions than before, saffron sauce not great, veal even smaller than last time, Italian cheesecake good, now they r putting barely any cherries on side but presentation great .Soda good size,lol PLEASANT WAITER, but i think next time another place to try! read more

I have never experienced such poor service. This WAS one of our favorite places to eat, but after this Mother's Day experience, we will not be returning. read more

Food was decent, however the descriptions were a bit vague. I order the shrimp and scallops that was under the seafood section (not pasta section). I thought it was going to come with a vegetable and some type of potato. NoPe. It came over a pound of pasta. If I wanted pasta, this would have been great, but I wasn't eating pasta, therefore my dinner consisted of 3 shrimp and scallops and a pound of pasta that I had to throw away :-( read more

I always liked this restaurant, but in the past few years their prices have gone up and the service has been going down. Had reservation for 5:30 and our appetizer, entree and desert took 3 hours. I understand it was parade day in GOSHEN and also Huson Valley restaurant week, but we waited so long that we were the last served. Even others who came in after us left before us. We had my very well behaved 2 year old grandaughter, maybe if she had acted up we would have gotten served faster. Service was so bad that I actually decided to mention it to the owner as we left. He basically ignored me and walked away. My husband and I will not be coming back here. There are better places in GOSHEN we can eat at and get good service and a delicious meal! read more

This place was better when it was a townie dive bar. Pseudo fancy restaurant, serving Olive Garden style food in a building that also houses an SRO hotel. No thank you. read more

Service, waiters, food... all amazing! Restaurant week menu or main menu had a lot of good options! Will come back for sure to try many other things. Great service and knowledgeable staff. Very sweet and food was delicious from apps to dessert! read more

To begin walking into this restaurant quickly changes your mood, the lighting, layout and decor instantly removes you from the outside world. We sat in the room with unique light live music being played passionately by the solo musician. As first time quest the server was very knowledgeable-and helpful in ordering, we started with the cheese plate and for entrees he had the filet mignon special (hands down one of the best! I've tasted) and I the chicken Alaska, and desert was to die for as well despite having to take it home because we were too full. The Cheff and host moved through the room with such hospitality it made you feel welcomed and we were happy to have the honor to meet him and see his passion. That passion shows in the service and the exceptional food. It wasn't just a dinner it was an experience. read more

Went here over the weekend. I didn't remember it being very good from years ago but my friend wanted to go for her birthday so I gave it another try with her. First the good: They have gluten free penne although they do not advertise it on their menu. They will make any pasta dish with it. So that was a nice surprise. They also don't charge you extra for it ! Bonus. Also the restaurant itself is beautiful. It's best in the summer when you can sit outside. Okay now the bad. The service was terrible. When our waiter first came over and asked if we wanted a drink, we asked him to come back in "5 seconds" so we could decided between two bottles of wine. 15 minutes later he was no where to be found. The food took a long time to come out, and when it came out, numerous things were wrong. For one, my friend ordered chicken parm and when she ordered it, she asked what it came with. The waiter said something along the lines of, "I know it's weird, but it comes with potatoes and vegetables" My friend replied that that sounded perfect to her. That came out with pasta. Another friend ordered penne a la vodka with chicken and it came out with no chicken. The food runner confused my gluten free pasta dish with someone elses in my party that ordered the same thing, but not gluten free and couldn't tell me which was which. Again, our waiter was MIA so we couldn't confirm with him. Then when we got the bill they had charged for my friend's chicken in the penne a la vodka, which never came, and also a glass of wine that we never got. With that being said, I thought my food was good (Lamb bolognese $18) though I think the food is kind of pricey for what it is. For what they charge, their service has to improve too. read more

Went there for a business dinner. Was pleased with the service and the food. Though we had a pre set dinner menu, the Antipasto, Calamari and the Penne Valentina that I tried were really good. Nice cosy ambience too. read more

Charming little place with a 1970's menu. Everyone is nice enough and the location is main street Americana, But how often do you want to order from the same stale entreaties? Potential not realized is what I found here. read more

We went here last night with friends because another restaurant couldn't seat us for over an hour and we had tickets to a show. We were so glad! All of the food was amazing! From the flavored oil that they give you to dip your bread in, to the friend calamari, to all of our entrees. We regularly order friend calamari as an appetizer when we go out to eat and, hands down, this was the BEST we have ever had. If I reviewed all of the dishes we had and how good they were and why, this review would be very long. Not only was everything perfect, but they service was wonderful and we left with plenty of time to get to our show without feeling rushed. I cannot wait to go back! read more

Very Good Italian food for goshen. The chicken parm is fantastic. They always have good specials. Only reason to take off a star is the speed of service. If its a busy fri or sat night, expect a long wait. read more

We had a such wonderful time celebrating our daughter's 19th birthday tonight. Service was OUTSTANDING. Everyone from the sweet hostess to every waiter and especially Edison, who went above and beyond to make sure we were satisfied. I can't thank him enough. What an amazing person! Food was delicious. Can't wait to celebrate another special event at Limoncello. read more

ehhhh That is about the best way to summarize Limoncello. I don't mind a bunch of Albanian's owning and putting out Italian food. I find it odd that every waiter tries to come off as if they are straight out of Goodfellas, when they are all as Italian as macaroni and cheese. I find it off putting that this place always manages to mess something up. The food is all decently edible, but not worth the price point you are shoveling out. Sure, I love some bread with a dipping oil and a free shot of limoncello. I do not love having to shovel out $$ when I can go down the street to Catherine's and have better......hmmmmm.....everything actually. I could see this being a good option during Spring/Summer as their outdoor seating is nice, but the interior kind of feels like your going back in time or over your grandparents house with dusty nick knickknacks all around. At the end of the day, this place doesn't do it for me. read more

Bread, dipping oil, salad all very good. Penne a la vodka fantastic, fish (sole stuffed w scallops & crab) a bit under cooked. I've eaten here before & will eat here again but won't get the sole again. Staff all very friendly & attentive. read more

Simply stated, "What a great meal with great service" We have heard good things about this restaurant but picked of all days last night Valentines Day for our first visit. Restaurants tend to have the " Get them in, get them out" version on these special nights. Not here! We tested them with one of my favorite dishes, a simple Linguine Vongole and Chicken Bolognese. Wow! Flavorful, seasoned to perfection and plentiful. If I sound a bit over the top, it's because it was really a great meal. To Luigi the owner and Vonny our waiter, "Thank you for a great meal" I need to add this: After seeing many many table being served a super looking steak, I asked someone and they said, " The real secret is that this is one of the best steak houses in the area" Gives me a reason to return! read more

This place is awful. Poorly organized kitchen with average food. Service is awful (where does the wait staff hide?) and prices are very high for the food served here. The drinks are quite expensive (try $22 for a bottle of beer). Stay away and you will not be disappointed. Go, and you will be disappointed. We had 6 different meals and all were poorly made and small portions. Save your time and money for Catherine's. read more

Big Lou from the Bronx! ! Not to far from Woodbury Common. I hear Gorge Washington once own it.Eat in be happy!

Changing my review tonight upon 3rd chance. Chef and wait staff very knowledgable and helpful with my wife's Celiac Disease and preparing gluten free food. Drink selection still amazing and the food is vastly improved from my first 2 times here. Highly recommended. Thanks Limoncello! read more

Terrible food. Service was great, owner was present and very friendly the place seemed clean and is beautiful, I went with some friends who say the food is good but I'm sorry some people believe if it's overpriced therefore it has value I ordered filet mignon with a shrimp prong , the shrimp WAS ROTTEN. It had gone very bad. Which is obviously why they made it a special to get rid of it. My friend got the same thing we both had to send the shrimp back. The filet was cooked fine but was just a hunk of flavorless meat. I can make that with more flavor and juices, for 60$ I expected more was all. I tasted my boyfriends food he got some kind of seafood bowl with clams, mussels and a filet of fish. The fish was so fishy the broth it was in just tasted like seawater. Everyone there was very friendly but the food was just a poor poor representation of themselves. I've worked in a restaurant for years I would never make a big stink and not pay but I was actually kind of mad the bill was $200 cause the food was just terrible. Oh and I spend that night and the whole next day with my face in the toilet couldn't even keep water down. Something there turned my stomach something fierce read more

Between the wonderful service, delicious food, and the ambiance, I will DEFINITELY be a returning customer. We tried it for the first time last night, and were impressed. We got a chicken dish, scallops and shrimp over pasta, a dragon fruit mojito and a coconut mojito, and everything was amazing. The little shot of limoncello (on the house) at the end of the meal doesn't hurt either :) read more

Excellent food, outdoor seating, and the fact that they have flourless chocolate cake is an automatic good rating in my book. Odd that I didn't actually see limoncello on the dessert drink menu though... read more

We entered today for brunch, for our first visit to the Stage Coach. We are greeted by a nice host and then seated. No one came and finally 15 minutes later we decided to leave. We decided to go down the road to Limoncello and had the BEST meal, drinks and the service was above and beyond superb! I give Limoncello 5 stars and ZERO for the Stage Coach Inn. Thank you Limoncello and shout out to all of your wait staff who were extremely nice and made our experience just perfect, thank you for saving our day date, we will be back for dinner and thinking about wedding 2019 brunch with you folks!! read more

We held our reception to our children's baptism at Limoncello. The whole process was simple and Carly was very polite and easy to talk to. The food was great and everyone loved it. It was very well done and organized. The banquet menu had lots of options and it was wonderful! All the food was delicious! read more

Excellent food, price and service. Would give it 5 stars but just a bit noisy for conversation especially for an elderly person who could not hear the specials presentation well. read more

I visited during Hudson Valley restaurant week and had a very nice time! The food was delicious, my favorites were pumpkin bisque and duck charcuterie- some of the best food I've had! Perfectly cooked and seasoned. The wait staff were friendly and helpful. They were very knowledgeable about the menu and able to recommend wines to pair as well. The atmosphere was cozy and invitkng. I already can't wait to come back. Highly recommended! read more

It was my 1st time there and it was a great experience . The bartender knew about every beer on tap, which was a big help in choosing one. We started off with the calamari and was by far some of the best I've had. As for entrees, I had the chicken limoncello, it was amazing! And my boyfriend had the chicken bolognese which was also delicious. We were both to full for dessert but I'm sure they have quite a selection. We will be definitely going back. read more

This past Sunday we celebrated our 50th Wedding Anniversary and hosted a reception at Limoncello's for a group of fifty people in the main dining room. On a scale of a 1 to 5 star rating, we would give them SIX STARS. Having such a large group there could obviously be concern for quality of the food and especially the service, however, having enjoyed numerous dinners previously we had no "reservations" about the service nor the quality of the food. All of the guests that we spoke with expressed their delight with the venue (Limoncello's). We could not agree more - the quality of the food was more than worthy of a top Zagat rating and the service provided was impeccable. This was not a simple "eat and run" affair - our guests received a six course dinner to include separate servings of Cold and Hot antipastos; individual servings of a Wild Mushroom Ravioli; a Caesar salad; their choice of a chicken, salmon, veal or steak dish which were prepared with Limoncello's unique recipes. We would hold the event again at Limoncello's without any hesitation. We make special note of Carly, the Event Organizer and of Edison who "supervised" the entire event - he was ever vigilant assuring a wonderful dinner celebration for such a joyous event. Our most sincere gratitude to the entire staff of Limoncello's. Joe F read more

first off, i'll say every meal i've had here has been delicious. great appetizers, entrees, & the flourless chocolate cake is just amazing. the reason i'm writing this review is not only because the food is great, but the staff is incredible. I asked my waiter a lot of questions about the menu because i'm recently gluten & dairy free, along with a garlic intolerance. (why would i even go to an italian restaurant, right?) well, instead of being annoyed, which i imagined he would be, he was incredibly helpful. he took time to go over which dishes i could eat & what could be changed in each dish for me. when the food came out, there was a mistake & the pasta given to me was not gluten free. they kindly remade the entire dish & brought me an appetizer so i would still be able to eat with the rest of my party. when the meal did come out, it was delicious. fantastic food, atmosphere & incredibly helpful staff! read more

Always the best service! This year was our third year having our Holiday party there. Carly is always very helpful and courteous. The entire staff is outstanding. I have had my parents anniversaries there. Always a great experience. I will definitely be booking our Holiday party for next year. Aspen Dental appreciates your outstanding hospitality,delicious food and great service. Happy New Year!! read more

We have been in Goshen for about 10 years & visited Limoncello when we first moved here. Back then we were unimpressed. We went there tonight for my wife's birthday as she wanted to give it a second try. Sorry but it is still mediocre. Service was slow & often had to ask twice for things. Prosecco was flat, they forgot our off the menu order of shrimp cocktail appetizer, and cod special was meager. We'll be waiting another 10 years before we try again. read more

What happened, Limoncello? My family and i have come here many times in the past, though it was now a year since our last visit. Today's experience, which was supposed to be a special occasion given that it was Mother's Day, was appalling. Clearly the restaurant had overbooked; that was obvious from the tight, uncomfortable seating. Even though we'd made reservations, the table at which we were seated was positioned in such a way that it jutted out into the main walkway through which waiters passed carrying other tables over their heads, barely missing us on one occasion. So it was crowded. As soon as we sat down, a bus person came by to take our water order. We wanted to also give our drink order, but no go, she said, she could only ask about water. Two minutes later, another bus person came by and started filling our glasses with water. Because I'd ordered a bottled sparkling water, I told him not to fill my glass --- he misunderstood, and started to take away everyone's water. It seemed comical at the time, but actually was just a foreshadow of how disorganized and awful dinner would be. We ordered an appetizer of homemade mozzarella and a carpaccio of tomato, eggplant, basil and balsamic vinegar. After 40 minutes --- during which a group of five was seated next to us, served before us, and were already on dessert --- we were presented with a plate of cheese and eggplant, and olive oil. No tomato, no basil, no balsamic vinegar. I managed to get the waitress's attention, and she was as helpful as could be, returning the plate to the kitchen and asking them to re-do it properly. In another five minutes, the plate returned with three slices of a bland, nearly colorless supermarket tomato. Still no basil or balsamic. But we'd waited such a long time and were hungry, so we reluctantly accepted it, wondering what in the world was happening in the kitchen. Finally, dinner arrived. Let me say, I've had the chicken limoncello here several times in the past; it used to be the restaurant's signature dish, always quite tasty. The version of it that was served today was disgusting! The cutlet was thick and undercooked, and arrived lukewarm without any seasoning or sauce. II tasted bad, and after a few bites I stopped eating, afraid I might get food poisoning from it. Not even the ground pepper helped; and by the way while other tables had their own salt and pepper shakers, ours were missing, and both had to be asked for. The asparagus was also nearly raw, and the potatoes looked & tasted as if they'd been reheated. And mind you, we'd already waited an hour when finally served. I can honestly say that I've had many, many different types of dining experiences nationally and internationally, but today's will rank among my top ten worst dinners ever. Oh, I almost forgot another comical note --- after we were done with dinner, a new waiter came by and asked who'd ordered the cabernet! The wine had been ordered and thankfully served with dinner; I don't know on what planet people have their dinner wine after the meal rather than with it. A comedy of errors, except that it resulted in some of us going hungry while still having to pay for an inedible meal. The one star in this review is due to the only positive note in this, our waitress, who actually seemed embarrassed at having to serve us this slop. She was so nice that I felt a little bad for her when I declined taking home the rest of the meal. Finally, she offered dessert.... Well, guess what, of course they were out of nearly everything. The only things left were some frozen concoctions that are typically served in cafes with limited meal options. We got our check and left. Though we were happy to patronize this establishment in the past because of its food, clearly the place no longer cares enough about its customers to provide a positive dining experience in any sense of the meaning. We won't be returning. read more

Sat at the bar and had some wine and food from their bar menu. Everything was great except bartender was bitchy.