Once upon a time, Le Procope hosted the likes of some very famous players in history. The names Jefferson, Franklin, and Robespierre ring a bell? Well they have all dined at Le Procope and I bet they had a dandy time too. Unfortunately for me, my experience wasn't quite as spectacular. For a restaurant so storied, hyped up, and expensive, I would gather to say that Le Procope isn't a bad restaurant, just a majorly disappointing one.
I came with a large group of students as part of my study abroad program who were visiting Paris for a week. We came here for our closing ceremony dinner and were treated to a three course meal with drink. The drink served was a champagne cocktail with liquor soaked cherries which was nice and not too sweet. I don't know if it was on the menu, but it was a good start to the meal. The first course we were served was a green salad with shaved golden carrots, endive, and cured salmon. First thing I noticed was that it seems that someone in the kitchen wasn't paying attention, because portion sizes varied greatly between plates. The difference between a "lacking" and "generous" plate was almost double. Many of us also had issue with the severe lack of dressing. I figured that the salad was prepared in a large batch and dressed at once, but from what I could tell, the only dressing was a meager amount of olive oil and maybe a pinch of salt. If you've ever tried eating a salad with endive and raw carrot sans dressing, you know it isn't very appealing. Overall, disappointing. About half the people at my table didn't even finish the salad.
The main course served was a Duck L'Orange with pan fried polenta. While the flavour of the duck and polenta were good overall, the sauce was less so. Overly thickened, they used kumquats in the sauce which was way too overpowering for the dish. The duck itself was cooked medium-rare which was good, but the meat was on the tough side and the skin hadn't had enough fat rendered out and wasn't good enough to be eaten for me- a pity, because duck skin can be amazing if cooked properly.
The final course was dessert which was a lemon tart with a meringue topping and raspberry coulis. There were quite a few things wrong with this dessert for me. One, the crust was tough. Leave it to one of the most famous restaurants in Paris to provide the first sub-par pastry offering to me since arriving in Europe over a month ago. Two, the meringue was way, way too sweet. I have a huge sweet tooth, like I crave cookies 24/7 huge, but they worked so much sugar into this meringue that I literally was able to eat two bites before putting my fork down in defeat. Finally, portion size control again. They seem to have a problem with that in general here. To be positive though, the raspberry coulis was lovely.
So the food was a flop. What about the space and service? Well, Le Procope obviously worked hard to lay on the old-world charm when inside the restaurant, and they definitely succeeded. The dining rooms are divided by walls and banisters which make everything feel very intimate and special. Add in the historical value and you know you're going to smile just sitting in this place. Service was decent overall too; a bit slow as others have noted, but it was nothing too horrible - just have a decent conversation partner with you. Finally, as for value, adding up an average three course meal - appetizer, main course, and dessert will easily run north of 50 Euros, add more for drinks. Our dinner reportedly ran around 50 Euros or so a head. So yes, eating here will cost a pretty penny indeed.
For tourists who must do everything their little guide books recommend, Le Procope might be worth the visit. Same goes for history buffs who will get a thrill from eating in a restaurant hosting famous figures since the late 1600s. However, if you're just in the city and are looking for dinner, I would say that you can easily find better spots for less in a culinary hub like Paris. read more