Caffé Luna was a lovely find in Raleigh's historic City Market. I found it on OpenTable, liked the…read moresimple Italian menu, and decided to give it a try.
The restaurant itself is beautiful. It's tucked into a gorgeous restored historic building with dark wood floors, lovely architectural details, and a warm, old-world feel. The hostess was welcoming and gave me a wonderful little table by the window. I managed to find free street parking nearby -- despite some slightly confusing signage -- although I can see parking being more challenging during busier hours.
I started with a glass of Italian Prosecco, which absolutely hit the spot, followed by the Caesar salad. The salad was fresh and perfectly dressed, although the croutons tasted a little more packaged than homemade. A small detail, but fresh croutons would have elevated an otherwise excellent Caesar.
For dinner, I ordered the Tortelli Crostacci -- fresh pasta stuffed with lobster, crabmeat, and prawns in a cream sauce. The sauce was delicious, and I happily finished the dish, but I kept searching those little pasta pillows for the seafood. I could smell it more than I could taste it. A few visible pieces of lobster, crab, or shrimp in the sauce or over the pasta would have made the seafood component shine. It was good, but next time I'd explore something else on the menu.
They also brought bread with olive oil, which looked lovely, but I only have one stomach and had priorities!
Service was friendly throughout, even as the restaurant became quite busy with several large tables. I ordered tiramisu to go but, sadly, never got to enjoy it. When I opened it the next day, quite a bit of liquid had collected in the container and the dessert had become watery, so I decided not to eat it. I'm not sure what happened there, but tiramisu shouldn't weep like that.
One last quirky detail: even the restroom was adorable, although the accordion-style door took a little negotiating. Bonus points for having a shelf where I could set my takeout bag rather than putting it somewhere questionable!
Overall, Caffé Luna has plenty going for it: a beautiful historic setting, gracious hospitality, a straightforward Italian menu, and a lovely atmosphere. There were a few misses with my particular meal, but nothing that would keep me from returning. I'd happily come back and work my way through a different part of the menu.
Life is too short not to eat well. If you find yourself wandering through Raleigh's historic City Market, stop into Caffé Luna and find your next meal.