Since becoming a part of the Yelp Elite Squad in Buffalo a few years ago, I remember seeing pictures and great reviews for this little BBQ joint called La Verdad Café. I quickly bookmarked them but never made it there, for one reason or another. But in May 2021, I FINALLY took the opportunity to try this place and now I'm kicking myself for waiting so long!
On a warm Friday evening in May, around 4:45pm, I arrived and was able to find a parking spot in a small parking lot across the street. Surprisingly, there was a good amount of parking available on the road but I opted for the parking lot since I remembered hearing that La Verdad Café has been doing takeout since COVID started in 2020. I walked in and was immediately greeted by a nice young woman who let me take a seat at the bar. Afterwards, she came over and gave me the food and drink menus and gave me a few moments to browse while I sipped on some water (with lemon!). The ambiance inside was very comfy and relaxing and everything was well maintained and clean. The staff working seemed genuinely happy to be there and seemed to be having a great time. I placed my order and was told the wait would be about 20-25 minutes, which was perfectly fine with me, I just wanted to sit and relax for a bit and take in the scene, munching on complimentary Cajun-seasoned popcorn and sipping my birch beer.
Then, a little over 20 minutes later, my food arrived. Now, something I truly did not understand was how generous they are with their portions. As all of the food was placed in front of me, I knew I wasn't walking (or rolling) away hungry. For dinner, I ordered the following: The StretchMark Brisket (slider/sandwich), which was topped with The Benzinger Gouda Mac & Cheese, KaleApple Slaw, and their bourbon barbecue sauce. I also ordered the Burnt Ends StretchMark (slider/sandwich), which was topped with The Benzinger Gouda Mac & Cheese, KaleApple Slaw, and their bourbon barbecue sauce. Both of these sandwiches also came with potato chips on the side. In addition to these sandwiches, I ordered two sides to go with them - a small (8 oz.) KaleApple Slaw and a small (8 oz.) Regent Holla Mac & Cheese (jalapenos). This was a meal fit for a king!
Where to begin... The StretchMark Brisket was amazing. The brisket was tender and hot, cooked/smoked perfectly, easily some of the best brisket I've had, and that's coming from someone who lived in Kansas City, has travelled to Austin, TX, and St. Louis, MO. The Burnt End StretchMark was even more amazing as it was jam-packed with those tender, smoked pillows of meat. Their bourbon barbecue sauce atop both sandwiches was excellent, creating an excellent blanket over the meat with a little sweetness. The KaleApple Slaw and Benzinger Gouda Mac & Cheese on top of both sandwiches was perfect by adding a little creaminess and texture, contained in the soft, fresh rolls. The KaleApple Slaw side was excellent, a nice and mild taste with a little sweetness/tartness from the Granny Smith apples and it wasn't water-y, a nice balance of soft and crunchy textures. The Regent Holla Mac & Cheese (jalapenos) side was rich and creamy with a little bit of pepper/spice on top and slices of jalapenos within, but it wasn't overbearingly hot, just a nice little kick. As I mentioned earlier, the portions are very generous and I did not walk away hungry or disappointed. Somehow, I managed to eat everything except for all of the potato chips that came with both sandwiches - I wanted to make sure I had room for everything else. Also, I felt the price for my meal was incredibly fair for the portion size and excellent quality!
I had a great experience here and felt so welcome. It was great to meet the owner, Vivian, and talk about my meal and give her praise for how awesome it all was! I definitely will be coming back again with family and friends as I want them to have the great experience I did and also because I'm already craving the brisket and burnt ends again. read more