I've lived in the City of Salt for almost a year and have been recommended that I should eat at Kneaders a handful of times. So 11 months later, I obliged and went with some of my colleagues for lunch.
I walked in the door and was immediately overwhelmed with the interior. For such a small RESTAURANT there was a lot of floor space devoted to non restaurant items. The whole divider between the line and the dining area was filled with knick-knacks that I feel like I could only find in a Utah fast casual restaurant. Fast-casual doesn't seem like the right segment to try to pull a Cracker Barrel and have a country knick-knack store, not when your restaurant is just barely 3000 sq ft with a kitchen. Its just crowded. They could have fit 3 or 4 two tops in that same space and with their crowded dining room it was needed.
I found ordering to be difficult to prepare for as I approached the register. There were no paper menus to prep me as I approached and the menu boards were feet behind and above the registers. I don't have great eyes but I don't wear glasses and it was hard to choose till I was about one person away from ordering. I always get perturbed by folks that get to the register and don't know what they want and I really do my best to not be "that guy."
Finally, the food... the thing that everyone else seems to Yelp about. I honestly enjoyed the food. I'm a fan of sandwiches, delis, bakeries, etc etc. I ordered their Kneaders Club I think. It was on sourdough, had turkey, ham and beef. The quality of the meat was very good. I couldn't clearly see if they cut it on site but it seemed like fresh cut quality. If they do carve their meats on site they should advertise that as some of us appreciate the attention to detail. The bread was wonderful. My colleague's sandwich bread looked great too. I think they bake on site and it shows in the freshness. The sandwich had a creamy pesto that was delicious also.
I had a side of soup. I believe they had about 4 to choose from when I was in. I had the Potato Bacon soup. I'll be honest, anything that has bacon is top notch to me. It was a hearty creamy soup. The ingredients were fresh and it didn't taste like they poured Campbells into a pot. If I could add to it I would have topped it with a garnish, possibly some chives or a dash of shredded cheese. It would visually add to the appeal. My colleague had some Kettle brand chips, boring but good quality chips.
I also bought a Cannoli, a German Chocolate Brownie and a Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookie. The Cannoli was pretty good, but it wasn't terribly fresh. The German Chocolate Brownie was fresh, moist and very full of flavor. The Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookie was just dry, its too bad because I really enjoy pumpkin anything. And after eating the desserts, a sandwich and soup I was forced to run 8+ miles that night to work it all off.
I'd go back. Its a toss up if I'd go here more than Jason's Deli or Corner Bakery. I'm sure its allure is that its a local brand (for better or worse). If I could recommend them to do something is to lay off on the knick-knacks. I'm not going to kneaders to buy Christmas ornaments or have my gifts wrapped... I'm going for a great fresh sandwich. read more