Key Lime Pie Bakery

115

1125

3371

7 years ago

If you're on vacation in Key West Key Lime Pie is a must. This is a small more quieter spot then the other Key Lime places. They also sell souvenirs and all things Key Lime related. The Pie is pretty good too. I highly recommend. read more

Helpful 4

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Doshia S.

3 years ago

Everything a classic key lime pie should be: tart, creamy, well set, and just a touch of whipped cream. The crust was just as delicious as the filling; I usually eat a bit of the crust and skip most of it, but this one was so good, I couldn't resist every bite. We took ours to go and walked a full 30 minutes on a warm day, popped it in the fridge until evening, and it was still in perfect shape. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Winchelle R.

341

1173

8 years ago

Where do I begin...? The hubs and kids goal was to go deep sea fishing, perhaps catch a Marlin or even a huge dorado. Mine was actually just to eat a slice of key lime pie. Seriously. Came here after dinner.. a bit harder to find parking than other key lime places but soooooo worth it! Took it to go to eat at the hotel. My son who said he would have just ONE bite as he's not a fan of key lime, ate a whole slice by himself! THAT GOOD! Worth every calorie. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Alex A.

334

7 years ago

Stopped on our way out of the keys... the original slice was only $4.95, not a bad price! The pie itself was almost like a cheese cake, very dense and rich which I had never had it like before, but could just be the right way! Would 100% stop by again and recommend... delicious! Ate it immediately. read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Original Key Lime Pie - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Aaron C.

188

150

4 years ago

Great pie, nice souvenirs, all at a perfect location in Ley West. Grab a slice of pie and head over to Mallory Square for a picture perfect sunset. During my visit I got to meet the most delightful young man from Ukraine. He was the most polite employee that I've met during my week long visit in Key West. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Julie M.

Elite 23

4 years ago

Lady at register was super friendly and got a pretty damn good key lime pie! Our family gives it a 10. Boyfriend got a cappuccino it was a 5. Kid got ice cream and she said it was a 10. But when is breakfast ice cream never not a 10 lol . Got a cute beer coozy and a magnet lol. Cute little gift place! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Yamely G.

100

4 years ago

One of the best key lime pies in the keys! We ordered the chocolate dipped key lime pie and it was so delicious. We tried 3 different spots for key lime pie and this was one of my favorites. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rob L.

3 years ago

Key lime pie was pleasing, definitely worth getting a whole pie (cost per slice is 6 bucks and you get 8 slices for $24). Service was friendly read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

C C.

4 years ago

I had the coconut pie and key lime pie. They young man working today was very polite and helpful. Taking extra effort to make me feel welcome and enjoy my brief stay in their cool a/c. Really makes a difference when you combine your pie with great service! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lindsey R.

6 years ago

THE BEST KEY LIME IN KEYWEST!! Seriously the best my family and I has found in the keys. The staff is so friendly and the shop is always clean too. We have gone every day this week!!! Hands down the best! read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Key lime juice - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jessica M.

3 years ago

ladies working were friendly and efficient. Updated equipment and able to accept Apple Pay.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Marianna F.

6 years ago

Delicious! Great balance of crust, cream, sweetness and tartness. Fast and efficient service, got the pie and walked to the beach for a lovely dessert. read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Original Key Lime Pie Slice - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sara T.

3 years ago

Better than Kermit's! We tried both pies and this one was the best key lime pie! The flavor was much more balanced.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

bob j.

140

7 years ago

Went in to try Key Lime Pie and since this is the original we went to try it. One bite into the coconut pie and I felt I was elevating to heaven. Wow I loved it and going to crave it for the rest of my life Loved it read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Bill W.

4 years ago

I Trydent all the rest and this place is the BEST and made every day.I guess that why it's call Key Lime Pie BAKERY !! read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jimmy L.

4 years ago

I couldn't tell if the key lime pie here taste any differently than the ones sold elsewhere.. but the lady working there was super nice and a rooster walked into the store multiple occasions lol read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Britt D.

Elite 22

293

431

794

9 years ago

Small place, but worth the trip. Had to try some original key lime pie in key west! The crunch was crunchy graham cracker which was a good mix with the very tart key lime pie. My favorite was the key lime cheesecake. It isn't as tart, but has the graham cracker crust that everyone loves. There are other various key lime gifts and other options. This did not disappoint! read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Key lime pie - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Front - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Billy A.

Elite 25

104

209

5 years ago

I have had better key lime pies from our local Publix...need I say more? But hey, you got to try this place when you visit Key West.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Beni C.

135

7 years ago

Air conditioned! Fast service and friendly. Lattes are strong and amazing. They have souvenirs too.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Mary I.

Elite 23

194

262

8 years ago

Awww the little key lime pie shop that I've remembered for 5 years which is the last time I went to Key West. So colorful and cute. I went a few times while on my most recent trip. I got their key lime cheesecake twice and loved that oh so much. Their key lime pie wasn't the most amazing pie of the trip though. It was delicious but I did find that I wish they had a higher ratio of crust to key lime pie filling. There was hardly any crust in the two slices I had tried on my trip. They also have a store inside with candy and such. I bought a few things there for gifts that were nice read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Key Lime cheesecake - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Laurie V.

865

2056

3754

8 years ago

Try the coconut key lime pie. Creamy, flavorful, and delicious. You get a dollar off with your yelp check-in, but I saw it too late to use it. (Oh well- next time I'll remember). There are really a million places to get a slice of key lime pie here, and this one was among the most satisfying I've had. Small seating area in this shop and also lots of key lime souvenirs. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Sam D.

Elite 24

265

472

9 years ago

Can you really go wrong in Key West with Key Lime pie? NO! Our go-to is the chocolate-covered key lime pie-on-a-stick. It comes prepackaged and already made. Once upon a time, it was a fresh pie. It's served with a plate under it so if anything drops, the plate will catch it. The place itself is a bit small, but they have some tables inside. But really, why not sit outside and enjoy the weather? It's a short walk away from Mallory Square--the perfect combo. read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - The key lime pie selection. - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

Key Lime Pie Bakery - So many key lime products to choose from. - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Monique R.

938

1057

641

13 years ago

While docked on Key West with a cruise line, I wandered the streets of key west. It was hot and muggy. After hours of walking and wandering, i ended up in front of the lovely Key Lime Pie Factory. The staff are extremly sweet. They greeted us warmly when we entered. They let us look around and it didnt take too long for me to order up a slice of tart and creamy key lime pie. For $4.95 you get a hearty slab of key lime pie and I hear they have frozen key lime pie on a stick (!) and sometimes it can be dipped in chocolate (!!!). The pie was great. I cooled off a bit in the store. Great place for anyone looking to make key lime pie or even getting key lime flavored anything. Awesome. read more

Helpful 5

Thanks 0

Love this 4

Oh no 0

Christian M.

6 years ago

Walked in 5 min to close and went straight to the counter for some to go key lime pie slices. Friendly staff, lots of cool stuff to take home but we really just wanted to satisfy our sweet tooth which it definitely did. Tasty and the right portion. Thank you. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kerry D.

5 years ago

I would love to give this five stars, but the truth is, I had a better Keylime pie at another establishment the night before. But, if only for the nostalgia, this is the birthplace of authentic Keylime pie Enjoy read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

R W.

5 years ago

Gluten-free key lime pie. If you're in Key West you have to try the key lime pie. This place is as good as any place you're going to find. And they have Gluten-free options! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cynthia L.

196

587

681

15 years ago

Key Lime Pie on a stick dipped in chocolate? Yes! Key Lime Pie Factory is a crazy crazy place for key lime pie lovers. I must confess that I've never had key lime pie before. I don't love sweets but the pie has that tangy flavor which makes me go back for more and more. And not only do they have pie, they have key lime pie dressing, cookies, salsa, dips, oil, gel, etc! It's endless. Also, in the back there is a nice seating area with a pond with Koi fish. And the baker is in the backroom and sometimes he'll come out with his awesome green hat . read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Phuong O.

697

2764

13 years ago

I got the original key lime pie. I also got the key lime pie dipped in chocolate from Kermit to do a comparison. I think the tart filling here is a bit too sour/limey but the best part is the whipped cream on the top which helps balance out the flavor. Not bad, $5ish for a tiny slice as expected. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Julie F.

271

1027

122

11 years ago

You simply can't visit Key West without eating Key Lime Pie! I came for a slice of pie and took advantage of the $1 off a slice with the Yelp check-in. The pie was delicious. The key lime pies I've eaten in Los Angeles tend to be less pure with more cream. This store also had a lot of key lime products and goodies. I bought some things to take home including key lime shortbread cookies, key lime pecans, and a key lime cake which was yummy and tasted of liquor/vodka. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Gaby F.

367

313

2693

12 years ago

The service was amazing. The two ladies are very very friendly and they are willing to help the tourists in any way. I am basing my rating on their coconut and key lime pie. They are made right there where you can see the preparation and smell the pies cooking. The crust layer was ok but the other two layers( one coconut and one key lime) were on the mild side. I expected the pie to be better. It was not bad, but it didn't fulfill my expectations either. They have a large range of key lime snacks and candies. I took a couple but haven't opened them yet. Next time ill try their chocolate covered frozen key lime pie stick. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Dakota S.

6 years ago

I had never had key lime pie before today but wow was it amazing. This is a nice little shop with candy, souvenirs and the yummiest key lime pie. The ladies in the shop were super friendly and made the experience even better! I had one slice of pie and then turned around and ordered another! Loved it! read more

See all

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Esther Z.

403

638

13 years ago

I had Key Lime pie @ (KLP) from Kermit's and two restaurants. I liked the tartness and crust of this places KLP more than the other 3 places. KLP likes/dislike is like drinking Scotch and wine. It's good only if Y-O-U like it; a very personal choice. None of us are wrong; just have different palettes. Give this place a try before you rate the best KLP in KW though. :-) They have Key Lime everything including tea. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Julie A.

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

1152

951

2396

13 years ago

Key lime pie has the consistency of cheesecake, but more limey. Definitely more limey and tangy. I had to put some whipped cream to calm the tartness down. This place opened my eyes. The consistency is much better than the gel-ish consistency that i'm used to eating at places that claim their pies are "key lime." psshh yeah right! Now I know what the real deal tastes like! I wanted to ship this pie to a certain someone, but they no longer do key lime pie shipments. This is the only latitude where key lime is grown but alas, you must come here in person to try the real deal or get one of their recipe books and a jar of the key lime juice to make the pie yourself at home. And unfortunately, I'm not that great of a cook. Lol. There are a lot of other key lime themed gifts here, including key lime cookies, candles, and other key lime souvenirs. They also have coffee here in case you need to wake up after eating too much pie. If you want to try the real deal key lime pie, make this a stop on your culinary itinerary! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Charlie P.

293

240

4 years ago

I mean it was good but maybe I'm just not a fan? For the price I can't say the pie is worth it. Fun to try while you're in the area but nothing to write home about read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dan W.

16 years ago

The best Key Lime Pie on the Key West island. It's a must go for me everytime I'm on the island (that and the Conch). The owner is very nice and talkative, the others are just like the common Key Westers, laid back and happy. The Pie was truely awesome: the crust was crumbly and sweet but not over powering, the filling was light, sweet, with just the right amount of lime flavor. So it's not a pie that you'd get sick of after a few bites. The free coffee goes great along with the pie too. And there're chairs outsidethe store, painted like the paradise, to enjoy the pie with. Also, they have good Key Lime Float, ice cream, and hot sauce. The price is typical for Key West but it's a good place to go to take a break from walking or shopping or alcohol. Not to diss the Blond Giraffe, but I think their pie is like any generic ones you find in the freezers in the supermarkets. Service was so-so and there's not really any tropical feel to the stores. Plus it's not that much cheapter anyway, typical chain stuff. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Travis L.

Elite 21

165

8 years ago

I couldn't leave Key West without trying some key lime pie. Wasn't sure where to go, as I was walking through Mallory Square I saw this bakery and decided to come back later in the day. I ordered a slice of Key Lime and a slice of Key Lime Cheesecake. It was made to perfection! Highly recommend taking the short walk from wherever you are in Key West if you want some authentic key lime. Lots of souvenir's as well. I bought some Key West BBQ seasoning mix also. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Katie E.

3 years ago

The chocolate covered key lime pies are absolutely amazing!! The worker was also so funny and kind. Definitely recommend stopping here.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 4 of 10

412 Greene St
Key West, FL 33040
Directions
(305) 296-9515
Call Now
Visit Website
https://keylimepiebakery.com

Hours

What time does Key Lime Pie Bakery open?

Key Lime Pie Bakery opens at 9:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Key Lime Pie Bakery close?

Key Lime Pie Bakery closes at 9:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

Mon-Sun 9:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Key Lime Pie Bakery take Bitcoin?

No, Key Lime Pie Bakery does not take Bitcoin.

Does Key Lime Pie Bakery take credit cards?

Yes, Key Lime Pie Bakery takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Key Lime Pie Bakery have catering options?

No, Key Lime Pie Bakery does not have catering options.

Indoor Amenities

Does Key Lime Pie Bakery allow dogs?

Yes, Key Lime Pie Bakery allows dogs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Key Lime Pie Bakery have bike parking?

Yes, Key Lime Pie Bakery has bike parking.

Does Key Lime Pie Bakery have parking?

Yes, Key Lime Pie Bakery has parking options. Street Parking

Other Amenities

Does Key Lime Pie Bakery have free WiFi?

Yes, Key Lime Pie Bakery has free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

Delicious & Decadent Key Lime Pie Desserts. We are locally owned and operated and specialize in fresh baked Key Lime pie every day for our visitors. We also carry a large selection of souvenirs our world travelers can take home to remember their visit to Key West. Stop in and visit next time you are in Key West. Enjoy our online shop and make sure you join our fun and fast-growing Facebook community.

History

Established in 2009.

We are locally owned and operated and specialize in fresh baked Key Lime pie every day for our visitors. We also carry a large selection of souvenirs our world travelers can take home to remember their visit to Key West. Stop in and visit next time you are in Key West. Enjoy our online shop and make sure you join our fun and fast-growing Facebook community.

Meet the Business Owner: Bill W.

Bill and his wife Robin came to Key West in 2004. right away they opened a small shop called Key Lime Pie Outlet. After the locals called it home business was so good that they opened another shop two doors down and is very successful.

Key Lime Pie Bakery Reviews in Other Languages

Ask the Community - Key Lime Pie Bakery

Better Than Sex

4.5(1.7k reviews)

0.7 mi

I have a sweet tooth, a tremendous sweet tooth indeed, For…read moreice cream and desserts are the things that I need. I've had dessert in the desert near Area 51, And underground in Antarctica, far from the sun. I've had it in graveyards, beneath moonlight so fair, And even in a dessert restaurant, yes, I've had dessert there! At Better Than Sex, the Fever was mine, And it tasted so splendid, so luscious, divine. I tried one of their special coffees as well, And it was so delicious, I nearly swooned under its spell. But the night's grandest moment, the finest display, Was when our waiter arrived with the desserts on a tray. He looked straight in my eyes as he named each delight, With a confidence both curious and wonderfully bright. My dessert was a huge phallus, impressive and grand, With two giant balls resting beneath it in hand. It was covered in "splooge sauce," a curious sweet stream, A dessert of such drama it belonged in a dream! I truly enjoyed this place and would gladly return If I lived nearby, where the sweet candles burn. They are masters of dessert, of flavor and flair-- A deliciously mischievous treasure tucked away there.

We went to Better Than Sex after eating a full meal at Duffy's right in front, so there wasn't much…read moreroom left in us. But oh man was it amazing. An extremely unique ambience and decoration. But it's not too much or too little. The seating is comfortable and private. Our server was very nice, he checked in at all the right times and was sweet. We only ordered one dessert and it got there promptly. Everything on the menu looked excellent and delicious. We settled on the cookie nookie cake, it was super fresh with many contrasting flavors that made every bite a pleasure. Overall had an amazing time and recommend this place for anything from a late night dessert or a full dessert meal. If we're ever around again, we are definitely going back and trying a lot more than just one dessert.

Cream in my coffee

Red velvet cheesecake

See all

Moscato, white chocolate rimmed glass

Moondog Cafe & Bakery

4.5(1.6k reviews)

0.6 mi

Michelin-rated Moondog Cafe & Bakery was excellent. On a Friday morning,1030ish, mid-October,…read morethere was a 20 minute wait which didn't seem long at least because there was a rooster outside providing clucky entertainment. We sat at the bar and ordered coffee which was a bit bitter. But that didn't really matter because the Blueberry-lemon Quinoa Pancakes and the Quiche Loraine were fantastic! The stack of pancakes were quite delicious and I couldn't stop eating them - I'd say they were a bit heartier than regular pancakes and they had sweet, plump blueberries a top and bb filing in the middle. The large leaning wedge of quiche had pieces of tasty ham throughout and its consistency was perfect. Next, we tried the key lime pie and it was one of the best we ever had. It had a very tall layer of merengue, lightly torched on top floating over a creamy, light key lime heart with a touch of tartness and sweetness, and a thin bottom crust. In fact, the entire bakery of desserts and pastries looked amazing!

Great desserts with a funky Key West vibe here…read more After a tour of the Hemingway house we wanted to sit down for a bit with some coffee and a snack. Moondog is right near it so we walked over and it was a great choice. Plenty of seating and a cool mural on the main dining area wall. The key lime pie here is delicious, but I wish the slice was a larger portion. Full menu of items here as we saw some of what our neighbors were eating and the burgers looked awesome. Good selection of craft beers and cocktail list too. Nice and friendly service.

Dining room

Key Lime Pie

See all

Blackberry Bourbon Bacon French Toast

Mattheessen's

4.5(437 reviews)

0.2 mi

AMAZINGGGGG!! Enjoyed everything we had here, but specifically went back multiple times for the…read moregigantic cookies. We tried the peanut butter, chocolate chip, and the peanut butter cookie with fudge and peanut butter on top. All three were perfection, so moist, and still fresh tasting the next day. I also loved the frozen key lime pie slice dipped in chocolate!

We stopped off here to grab a giant chocolate chip cookie to go for much later. These are huge and…read moreplenty to share. One cookie is equivalent to 2-4 typical sized homemade. Great flavor and texture. Store is clean and appears well maintained. Staff are friendly and helpful, as well as patient with indecisive customer choices!

Slice of Key Lime Pie

See all

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe

4.4(1k reviews)

0.2 mi

We wanted the best pie in town, and Yelp sent us here! Let me just say, as an art major, I…read moreabsolutely fell in love with the decor! This place is amazing inside! They literally have everything and anything that is key lime flavored, from ice cream and hard candy to Dole Whip, which I didn't even see until we were leaving!!! LOL We'll definitely be back for that, BTW! After making our purchases, we headed to the back patio to try the pie. Wow! It was so sweet and flavorful, yet light and fluffy. Honestly, it was the best pie we've ever had! The ladies working were so nice, too, and overall, if you have time for a slice, we definitely recommend fitting this place into your itinerary!

Classic key lime pie 5/5 Location 5/5…read moreSeating 1/5 Service: N/A We came here when the rain came, this is where you go to grab your key lime pie to go. They have a good size patio seating for you to enjoy your pie but unfortunately it was all drenched and they had zero seats inside. The pie was definitely tasty. There weren't any free cup of water you can get besides the drinks that they sell in the fridge. Stop by on a Sunny day might be much better.

Inside store cash register

Key Lime Dark Chocolate Coconut Key Lime Pie Bar

See all

Exterior at sunset

Blue Heaven

4.3(5.5k reviews)

0.5 mi

Blue Heaven is one of those rare places that feels less like a restaurant and more like a second…read morehome you somehow never knew you'd been missing. The food is excellent--flavorful, thoughtfully prepared, and consistently satisfying--but what truly sets this place apart is the service, especially when you're seated at the bar. As a bar guest, I experienced something far above exceptional. It felt like walking into a place I already loved and being shown the very best of it by people who genuinely care. To the bartenders and staff who made every visit feel that way: Dairy-ah (I'm almost certainly butchering the spelling, but the pronunciation stuck with me), thank you for the warmth, the skill, and the way you made the bar feel welcoming every time. Lucy--always with the hat on backwards--you became my spirit animal the moment I realized how perfectly that energy matched the whole vibe of the place. Thank you for being exactly who you are behind that bar. Brittney, the chillest of them all: your calm, easy presence made everything feel lighter and better. Chelsea, I only got to have you serve me once, but that one time was enough to know how good you are at this. And to the Servers, Paul and Lola: even in our brief interactions while I was at the bar, both of you brought such strong, genuine personalities that it elevated the whole experience. Thank you for that. Blue Heaven is an amazing restaurant with great food and even greater service. But more than that, it's the people who make it feel like coming home and being shown the best time in a place you love the most. Thank you--truly--to all of you for making it feel that way. And to Henry, a longtime regular at the bar, who passed away during my visit. "His" presence was clearly part of the fabric of this place, and I'm grateful I got to share that space, however briefly, with the people who knew and cared for him. Thank You All, and sorry if I didn't list your name in this review because there were far more of you than I've mentioned, just Know my early mornings sitting at the Blue Heavens Bar, was the highlight of everyday I spent in Key West. Sincerely, Brian.. (or as my friends call me, "Jonesie")...

Loved food & excellent service! Ate here at least two times on each trip to Key West! The Key Lime…read morePie is a must!

Bar inside

Lobster Grits

See all

Key Lime pie with super tall meringue

CAFE MATON

4.8(17 reviews)

0.7 mi

We love coming here! Service is unmatched - We love and will legitimately miss you, Nina!…read more Coffee is outstanding and mango smoothies (with Rum) are life-changing! Will return as soon as we can.

It was hot. I needed something to quench my thirst and a key lime lemonade sounded perfect…read more It was absolutely what I wanted. Cool and full of flavor. There are two outside tables to sit under so you can enjoy the people walking by.

Lobster roll

See all

Lemongrass mojito

Flamingo Crossing

3.8(248 reviews)

0.8 mi

Pros: staff was super friendly and helpful even when really busy, ice cream was good, meet…read moreexpectations. Nothing earth shattering. Cons: they didn't have all of their flavors available, shop is really small can get extremely cramped, due to the warm temperature in the shop ice cream was extremely soft and melted very fast Overall, it was a good experience, but nothing amazing either

Shakes in any ice cream flavor and decent selection. Store is cold so good break from the heat, but…read moreno seating inside so out in the heat to eat it.. Employees were very nice and service was fast.

See all

Mango and strawberries and cream ice cream. It was amazingly delicious.

Banana Cafe

4.2(1.4k reviews)

0.9 mi

It's always tough to pick the spot to enjoy your last meal before leaving Key West but we are so…read morehappy with our choice of Banana Cafe. We were promptly seated upstairs on a busy Sunday morning. The older home offered charm and character in its dining spaces which we always appreciate. Our caramel latte and banana bread latte were the best coffee we had on this trip. For our meals we chose a seafood crepe and a veggie breakfast scramble which we thoroughly enjoyed. The portion sizes were perfect and the prices were fair. Be sure to consider this great restaurant for breakfast, lunch and or dinner while visiting Key West!

FYI, not stated anywhere but tipping is *mandatory* here. We know because our waitress refused to…read morecheck us out until we tipped. Bill was $120.40 and my father put $121. He was going to leave tip on the table (as boomers do) but the server literally brought back the check said "tip is not included" and dropped it back on the table. We counted the money like 4 times because we thought we had miscounted the bill but nope. She simply refused to check us out until she saw her tip included in the folder. Wonder what she would have done if we hadn't paid with exact change? Would she have just kept the change and not said anything? Very weirdo behavior!

Photo of restaurant

See all

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe

4.3(447 reviews)

0.2 mi

Kermit's Key West offers a delightful assortment of key lime pie on a stick, dipped in various…read morecoatings such as chocolate, coconut, white chocolate, and several other tempting flavors. They also sell miniature cookies that taste remarkably like key lime pie, each one dusted in flavored powders. The main attraction, however, is the cake counter, where numerous varieties of key lime pie await their fate. The pies come neatly packaged in small takeout containers, making them wonderfully convenient to carry while wandering about Key West, or to bring home before the Florida heat claims them. The shop itself is rather small, with limited room for indoor dining. There is outdoor seating available, though most visitors simply claim their chosen delicacy and disappear into the streets, leaving only the faint scent of lime and sugar behind. Naturally, I asked whether I might speak with Kermit himself. I was informed that he was away on a visit to Fraggle Rock and had recently suffered an unfortunate encounter with the Count. The details were not discussed, though the silence that followed was ominous. All in all, Kermit's Key West is a convenient and enjoyable stop for anyone with a fondness for key lime pie. The variety is excellent, the portions are easy to handle, and the desserts are perfect for enjoying on the move or surviving whatever strange adventures may await beyond the door.

My aunt was on the hunt for some key lime pie. She always comes here to get the frozen pie that was…read moredipped in white chocolate on a stick. I saw that they had pineapple dole whip and key lime dip. The woman was kind enough to let me sample it. If you like the pineapple, you'll love the key lime even more. It's a cute little shop. If you are thirsty, there is a cooler full of drinks. I almost bought the t-shirt that's in my picture for my daughter. It's totally her. A shirt with an attitude.

One single use plastic used for 5 minutes!

See all

Key lime cooler

Rooster Treats

4.2(29 reviews)

1.0 mi

This is a super cute truck in the area of the Southernmost Point that offers soft serve ice cream…read moreor mini donuts with toppings! The service was quick and there was some seating outside with some sand so even though it is a few blocks inland there was still a relaxed, beach feel to the place. I got the coconut joy mini donuts and my boyfriend got the chocolate paradise ice cream. The mini donuts did get a little soggy from the toppings so I would maybe eat a little faster than I did (though I didn't take an unreasonable amount of time) or go for the ice cream. For Key West, they seemed reasonably priced and hit the spot for something sweet. If you're already in the area and looking for something sweet, I would stop here.

We stopped in on our last night in Key West after trying several of the ice cream shops during our…read morestay. I think Rooster Treats is a fun change of pace from the more traditional storefronts lining Duval Street. Instead of a typical shop, it operates out of a permanent trailer. You order from a raised deck platform, then head down to enjoy your treat at one of the tables set up in a makeshift sandy beach area. The whole setup works surprisingly well. It gives you that relaxed, toes-in-the-sand feeling, almost like you're unwinding right by the water. It has a great vibe. We're not huge fans of soft serve, mainly because the flavors and textures can feel limited. Rooster Treats makes up for that with the generous amount of toppings you can add. I ordered the Chocolate Paradise, which came with chocolate drizzle, sprinkles, and Oreo crumbs. It was delicious, and the portion size was very good. Glad we checked it out before heading home.

Sandy "beach"

Just add your favorite toppings!

See all

Relax and enjoy your soft serve ice cream or freshly made mini donuts

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

14 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

W C.

13 years ago

My group was cruising on a cruise line and this was our last stop before returning to Miami. We rented bikes and rode around Key West for the majority of the day. We saw places to buy pie everywhere, but this is where we stopped. I am not sure exactly why THIS was the location we stopped at, but it wasn't a fancy restaurant and not too small either. We were not disappointed. Some of our group didn't like Key Lime and they offered a coconut creme pie as well. I opted for the key lime/coconut 50/50 mix. I loved it. I am not sure how they made it, but I didn't see it offered anywhere else they way it was made here. After we purchased our pie, the owner came over and asked how we liked it. She was very nice and I was surprised that she had time to talk to a tourist that would not likely return. Great pie. Great little shop. You will not be disappointed. read more

Jara J.

601

10 months ago

Tried the key lime cheesecake at the Key Lime Pie Bakery, and it was absolutely delightful. Every bite was rich, creamy, and perfectly balanced with that classic key lime tang. The cozy ambience made the experience even better, and the staff were warm and welcoming. Overall, it was a wonderful and memorable visit. read more

phillis b.

15 years ago

Found this place after people recommended we try the best key lime pie on the island of Key West. LOVED it - and loved the really nice people working there. Friendly girl behind the counter. IT was the best key lime pie I've ever had. We'll be back. read more

Tania B.

10 years ago

KEY LIME PIE FACTORY is a registered trademark, the use of this name is a trademark infringement. Please remove pictures immediately to avoid further action. read more

Emmanuel K.

4 years ago

It's Key Lime & Key West!!! What more could you ask for 5/5 A must go Destination of ol Key West. read more

Bill W.

5 years ago

the best and frshestkey lime pie on the island !!!! made right there ,every day , fresh !!!!!!! read more

Tracy M.

7 years ago

What more can I say besides authentic yumminess? I've tried a lot and this is among the best!

Bill E.

5 years ago

Four of us bought a whole ie as it was cheaper than four slices. There were no leftovers...

Georg B.

114

2 years ago

Worst key lime pie I have ever had Ill taste this cancer ridden fake everything til I die read more

Paola H.

4 years ago

Good pie. Rude lady. skakskskokakaknakakskakjsjakakaksksksjsjsjjsjdjjdjdjs read more

Brandi R.

102

13 years ago

the. best. key. lime. pie. ever.

Doris Z.

11 years ago

just lemon cheese cake too sweet

Natalie L.

Elite 14

104

322

15 years ago

Key Lime Cookies. Do it!

Jess L.

15 years ago

Great key lime pie

Key Lime Pie Bakery - desserts - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Key Lime Pie Bakery also viewed

Kermit's Key Lime Shop

4.4

(37 reviews)

We stopped in to get some key lime pie to take back to our place. The service was great…read more Our key lime pie was so tasty and the crust was delicious. Highly recommend for a quick to go dessert.

We had to visit this shop for experience the key lime pies. Everyone said it's famous in Key West…read moreand we surely wanted to taste it . The shop was really good from inside . Looked colorful and service was awesome . They had lots of tasting of cookies and chocolates. Their key line pie was hmmmmm ... I didnt like it much . Was sour and wasn't my taste . May be that's how it tastes :) but not for me ! The ice creams were really good and tasted good . The cookies were good too. They had some space at the backside to sit and eat . Good experience overall.

Wicked Lick

4.0

(106 reviews)

Watched the ice cream guy make two flavors of ice cream using the nitrogen process in the mixers…read more It was an experience that actually persuaded me to buy ice cream tonight. Each of the people I was with had a different flavor but I chose the pistashio ice cream in a waffle cone which was excellent.

Great little ice cream spot. I got the vegan coconut agave which was delicious. Not overly sweet…read moreand very smooth. My kids enjoyed their vanilla and strawberry. Best part was the home made berry drizzle that the owner had made for it. You can tell he really puts a lot of effort into his craft. Would love to see even more vegan/ dairy free options. Definitely will be back!!

La Michoacan Ice Cream

4.8

(24 reviews)

Amazing service, it was just one man who helped us out but everything was phenomenal. We liked all…read morethree of the items we ordered. We are from California and came to the Keys for vacation. Will be coming back the days we're here for our vacation. This business deserves more foot traffic! It was empty when we came in but about 3 other customers trickled in while we were there. If you come you should ask them about the menu. It's a Mexican shop but contains some Nicaraguan treats ;) Thank you so much sir! Hope the best for your business

Soooooo insanely delicious, the mango berry was to die for. Could not recommend this place enough,…read morehug portions as well

Rainbow Cone

5.0

(5 reviews)

Pros: Very convenient location, right off of Duval…read more Couldn't be any easier to get here if you're visiting Key West. Service was quick and efficient. The ice cream itself was very high quality. The flavors were well represented without tasting fake or like extract. Cons: No cons. Tips: Get the rainbow cone! It's too fun not to get it. Would love to come back.

Short, sweet, simple, to the point. That is how my visit was, and that is how my review will be…read more Right off the main street in Key West, you walk in, you wait in a very fast-moving line, you get your Tik Tok trending ice cream cone, and you race to eat it as you continue to walk down Duval. This was a happy surprise for me, because I had never heard of this thing and had no idea it was trendy with the kids. The Rainbow Cone (Our famous cone made with slices of Chocolate, Strawberry, Palmer House, Pistachio & Orange Sherbet). Very photogenic. And surprisingly, it was also delicious! Somehow, all of these flavors melded together in my mouth into one cohesive bite. I was a fan. I would definitely come back.

Moondog Cafe & Bakery

4.5

(1.6k reviews)

Icestream At Morning Joint

4.5

(12 reviews)

What a cute little place for ice cream in the Keys. Variety of daily and months flavors listed…read morealong with the option for shakes, sundaes, cones and toppings. Behind the trailer they have cornhole, darts, tables and umbrellas. Even areas for dogs while you enjoys your in-house made ice cream. Right next door is a Morning Joint coffee house and a cute shop. The airstream opened at two until 930 when we were there on a Friday afternoon in late June. I tried Thai tea because they were out of snickers, a friend had a brownie sundae and another friend had sea salted munchies. Thai tea was very tasty, if sweet and friends said theirs was good but also very sweet. Saw the owner making a new batch of ice cream in house. Our server was kind enough to take out picture for us outside. Friendly service and a cool place to stop with 25 miles north of Key West

Kids loved the ice cream…read more Got the crème brûlée sundae.... Let's just say it wasn't quite what everyone said. Super Gooey top was more like snot consistency than brûlée..... took a few bites and threw it away. For single scoop once cream kids say yes.

Key West Cakes

4.4

(111 reviews)

The best cupcakes!! I visit every time we are in Key West, and they do not disappoint. The owner…read moreis helpful and will customize for you.

I stopped at this bake shop while walking down White St. and was pleasantly surprised at how good…read morethe baked goods were. As I entered the shop, I noticed that it was in a bit of disarray due to a pending move. That didn't take away from how good the pastries looked. I got a slice of carrot cake and a key lime pie slice. I got both thinking I wouldn't be able to finish them but I was wrong! The pastries were rich and flavorful without being overly sweet. Cake icing usually tends to be too sugary for me but the icing on the carrot cake was good and not overpowering. I am a fan of key lime pie and this was made perfectly in my opinion. I absolutely recommend stopping at this bakery for a quality sweet treat!

Gelateria Nuovo Fiore Key West

4.4

(18 reviews)

Best sorbet/ice, ice cream run by mom and pop. We make sure to stop by every time we're on the…read moreisland. The fruit flavors are 100% natural, it's like eating frozen fruit.

Best home made ice cream on the island! Key lime and coconut flavors are superb. Hidden gem and…read moreworth visiting.

Cupcake Sushi

4.5

(38 reviews)