Watched the ice cream guy make two flavors of ice cream using the nitrogen process in the mixers. It was an experience that actually persuaded me to buy ice cream tonight. Each of the people I was with had a different flavor but I chose the pistashio ice cream in a waffle cone which was excellent. read more

See all

Great little ice cream spot. I got the vegan coconut agave which was delicious. Not overly sweet and very smooth. My kids enjoyed their vanilla and strawberry. Best part was the home made berry drizzle that the owner had made for it. You can tell he really puts a lot of effort into his craft. Would love to see even more vegan/ dairy free options. Definitely will be back!! read more

I love to see that this place is still here! Their Cookie Butter Pecan is my absolute favorite. I have eaten two cups in one sitting before. We visit every single time we come to the Keys. read more

See all

Cute ice cream Parlor where the owner makes the ice cream. I got the vegan coconut with biscoff Carmel topping and it was amazing! I will say that my friends got the strawberry and key lime and just threw them away. Another got chocolate and said it was okay. read more

See all

This place caught my eyes, I had the pistachio ice cream with pistachios on top and inside. The ice cream taste great very refreshing for the hot weather in key west. The service was great she was showing how big 3 or 4 scoops are. She was very helpful. The place has few seating area. Nice decor. I'll come back to try other the other ice cream. read more

Wicked Lick - Pistachio ice cream 4 scoops - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

Interesting atmosphere, I saw the vibe they were going for. The service was great! Super nice folks. The ice cream was mid, though! Also, my daughter is allergic to nuts and couldn't have a single thing in there! The cross contamination was unavoidable and very disappointing for her. I wish more people considered that when they made places like this. read more

Very smooth, light tasting ice cream. Service was friendly. She explained that their ice cream was made with liquid nitrogen. Flavors were good. Scoops were a bit small and they ran out of many flavors since it was at night. Very casual atmosphere. read more

Wicked Lick - Menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

WOW. I was blown away the cuban coffee ice cream is to die for, a MUST for any coffee lovers. Reasonable prices and helpful staff. 11/10

A little pricey but so grateful for vegan options! Friendly service. Delicious. Great break from the tropical heat. Worth checking out! read more

Wicked Lick - Vegan coconut agave - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Amazing customer service. Delicious ice cream and tons of options. Four small tables on the inside and few select shirts available. read more

Wicked Lick - Biscoff - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

Sweet ladies at the booth, allowed me to taste multiple flavors before I made up my mind. They were also sweet enough to make a Oreo milkshake for a friend even though they technically don't sell milkshakes on paper. The ice cream was great! They freeze the concentrate using liquid nitrogen to make the cream due to which the texture is soft and tastes really good. Not too sweet and just right! It's a cute shop with minimal seating which works really well! I highly recommend it! read more

Wicked Lick - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

Not a big fan of the ice cream--very expensive and it just kinda taste like ice with a faint flavor. Just wasn't my favorite. read more

Wicked Lick - Blueberry cobbler - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

Great service! I was so excited to try something made with liquid nitrogen. I got the cuban coffee ice cream with oreo on top. Absolutely dreamy mouth feel! Creamy and what a delicious coffee flavor. Really hit the spot! I didn't take a picture, because I ate it read more

Ordered Key lime ice cream and blubbery cobbler. Ice cream was so smooth. Key lime was just perfect! Not too citrusy. Not too sweet, just perfect! They have some seating options. The store location is very convenient. read more

See all

Love this place. Smooth and they great mix ins and you can bring your own too. Staff is very cool.

AMAZING! You simply will not be disappointed by this establishment. The ice cream is quality and the waffle nachos are to die for. Very pricy but at least it was worth it. Love the vibe here. Plenty of options to choose from. Staff is friendly! Not many complaints besides wishing it was less expensive. read more

Wicked Lick - Mint ice cream nachos (2 scoops) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

The ice cream is made with fresh ingredients. It's quite good. Service was great and friendly. Pricy though but it's in the tourist area of Duval St. read more

10/10. I got the waffle cone with a scoop of Cuban coffee and a scoop of Ghirardelli chocolate. Amazing overall. The ice cream feels like icy and not super heavy and milky. I loved it and didn't take a photo because I was busy inhaling it. Also the Cuban coffee flavor is so unique and distinct from regular coffee ice cream. Happy I was able to sample it before. The lady was very nice! read more

Absolutely delicious ice cream and friendly service. Great local on Duval street. We always make this stop after dinner.

Yuuuumm! Wickedly good! On vacation this is what we had for breakfast! :) Had to try the Key Lime of course - with Biscoff cookies. Also, the Mexican vanilla. Flavors are deep and delicious. Owner and staff are super friendly and polite. Breakfast, lunch or dinner, you can't go wrong going Wicked! read more

See all

I got a sugar cone with a chocolate mint icecream. I should have asked to try the ice cream first. It was a bland vanilla icecream with Andes mints thrown in. Definitely won't be back for a $10 cone. The cone itself was delicious. read more

The ice cream was delicious. I had chocolate ice cream + marshmallows in it. Age 7- was a little messy but worth every lick!

After spending time walking in the hot sun we stopped in here for a scoop of ice cream... the positive is that they make their own ice creams and they have some fun, unique flavors. The only negative was that they don't serve/sell a single scoop - Doesn't make any sense, as every other place does and being mildly lactose intolerant, I prefer to limit my ice cream intake, especially on a very hot day. They do let you try before you buy and they have a decent size selection to choose from. The flavors we tried were awesome! Highly recommend stopping in. Oh, one more negative is they only have chocolate sauce, not hot fudge to go on top. They would totally get 5 stars if it wasn't for this and the lack of selling a single scoop. read more

Wicked Lick - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

This is so yummy!!!!!!!! Loved every bite! The girls were great and service was speedy! The store was busy but clean and very efficient for a packed night! read more

Pretty nice spot we hit up on our last leg of Florida. It had Sturgis vibes and the kids were given a frisbee as their plate. They loved that! read more

We stopped by twice on our January trip this last winter...IceCream and staff were awesome! Made to order while you wait..and DELICIOUS! read more

Wicked Lick - A cup of awesomeness!! Can't wait to get back!!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

Wicked Lick came onto my radar during my first trip to Key West after doing some research and walking temptingly past it several times right along Duval Street. But sadly, we didn't ever stop to further investigate. So when we came back a few months later it was an easy choice. The lady working made the entire experience. I didn't see what her name was but she was sweeter than the ice cream, and she even gave us coupons! I got the peanut butter ice cream and it was literally like eating frozen peanut butter- which is totally a good thing! Their menu seemed really fun too- the entire place is pirate themed, and they call the toppings to the ice cream a "booty" and other small fun touches. Overall a fun little place and a good stop along the walk to shops and the other end of the island! read more

See all

Lots of fun flavors to choose from. Our favorites were key lime and peanut butter! Definitely recommend a top if you are on Duval St

Not good ice cream. I'm used to Ben & Jerry's and this was like sherbet. I also wasn't a fan of many flavors.

Very very expensive ice cream. It was over $7 for one scoop in a bowl. I tried the mint chocolate chip ice cream and it was horrible. It was vanilla ice cream with big chunks of what look like Andes mints. I didn't expect it to be that way and it just had a bad mouth feel. The people with me tried a Biscoff caramel ice cream and theirs was delicious. read more

Wicked Lick - Mint chocolate chip - one scoop small - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

pistachio ice cream was great! good portion sizes and great flavors available... just what you need on a walk to mallory square

This was one of the most unique ice cream experiences I've ever had!! It was so cool to literally watch it turn from a liquid to ice cream in minutes. There were several flavors to choose from, I went with good ol vanilla! I added rainbow sprinkles cuz I was feeling a little fancy :) I tried the strawberry and that was very good too! They use a stand mixer to make this concoction. In goes the liquid, add the nitro and wallah! Ice cream. I've never seen anything like it. I was happy that the flavor was good and the consistency was what you'd expect for ice cream. If you ever get the chance while in the area, be sure to try it! read more

Wicked Lick - Making nitro ice cream! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

Ice cream magic is being spun up at Wicked Lick. The sign outside mentioned nitrous ice cream which I have seen a ton on TV but never actually tried in person. The kicker that drew us in was that among all of the delicious sounding regular flavors including Mexican vanilla, sugar-free pistachio, and seasonal pumpkin pie, they had a non-dairy (vegan) coconut ice cream. Because of the way the ice cream is super frozen with liquid nitrogen, the texture becomes super smooth instead of crystallized. I 100% recommend Wicked Lick to help cool down on a hot Key West day. read more

See all

The best homemade ice cream I ever had! It was flavorful and soft. It was made with a unique texture as soft serve but as hard ice cream. In addition, the dairy free option was a bonus. I would love to see more dairy free flavors. The two staffs were super friendly and welcoming, allowing us to try all sorts of different flavors but we decided. read more

Watery ice cream with no flavor. What a waste of $25 for two people. The service was ok.

The icecream here was very good, and is in a convenient location right next to Kermit's, which is of course a Key West must see. If you have littles who don't like key lime pie, this is the perfect spot to go right after Kermit's. Service was quick and the shop was clean. A little pricy though. Overall I would recommend! read more

Made a day trip from Islamorada to Key West and would make the drive again just to visit Wicked Lick! Hands down exceptional ice cream, unique flavors, and loved the ice cream nachos. Great friendly service too. This has to be the best ice cream in Key West. Highly recommend. read more

Wicked Lick - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

This ice cream was really good! Whenever we travel, we try to sample a local ice cream spot and this one really delivered! They had interesting flavors, tons of toppings, and the nitro ice cream had great texture. The service was fantastic, as they let us sample before deciding what to get! Would definitely recommend this spot for dessert any day of the week. read more

I can't believe I didn't find this place earlier.... Best coconut sorbet/vegan ice cream I ever had!! I saw the sign for vegan, called them "no corn syrup, no artificial ingredients all naturals cane sugar and coconut cream! The only problem is that I ordered 6 scoops! read more

Wicked Lick - Vegan coconut ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

It was so hot outside, and this tasty treat of ice-cream was A++. We well be back soon. read more

Wicked Lick - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida