We wanted the best pie in town, and Yelp sent us here! Let me just say, as an art major, I absolutely fell in love with the decor! This place is amazing inside! They literally have everything and anything that is key lime flavored, from ice cream and hard candy to Dole Whip, which I didn't even see until we were leaving!!! LOL We'll definitely be back for that, BTW! After making our purchases, we headed to the back patio to try the pie. Wow! It was so sweet and flavorful, yet light and fluffy. Honestly, it was the best pie we've ever had! The ladies working were so nice, too, and overall, if you have time for a slice, we definitely recommend fitting this place into your itinerary! read more

See all

Classic key lime pie 5/5 Location 5/5 Seating 1/5 Service: N/A We came here when the rain came, this is where you go to grab your key lime pie to go. They have a good size patio seating for you to enjoy your pie but unfortunately it was all drenched and they had zero seats inside. The pie was definitely tasty. There weren't any free cup of water you can get besides the drinks that they sell in the fridge. Stop by on a Sunny day might be much better. read more

See all

A fav stop during our time in Key West and popped in multiple times. Their cookies make great gifts to bring back to friends and family, the key lime coolers was my favorite flavor. They have samples of each flavor, which I appreciate! We loved the frozen key lime pie dipped in chocolate and the original pie. Delish. For dog lovers, there is a cute key lime pie toy as well! read more

See all

Stopped in here with my family while walking around Key West. First off, it is adorable and smells amazing as soon as you come in. My kids loved walking around in here and they have free samples you can try. We ordered the key lime pies on sticks dipped in chocolate. My kids loved them. It wasn't the best key lime pie I had on our trip but I enjoyed mine as well. They do have tables in the back to eat at. Definitely a fun place to stop at when in Key West. read more

Every review I read about the best Key Lime Pie in Key West included Kermit's at the top and I now know why. It was truly the tastiest best key lime pie I've ever had, the coconut key lime specifically! There's so many locations around Key West so it's easy to get to any of them and you have to try a slice. They even offer so many cookie samples along with other key lime flavored treats. It's a can't miss spot when visiting Key West! read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Coconut Key Lime Pie Slice - Specialty Food Near Me - Key West, Florida

I love Kermit's! After trying many different key lime slices across two different trips, this is the spot I keep coming back to. The pie is tart, with only a dollop of whip cream on top, which is just the way I like it. We also tried some pie with the meringue top and that's definitely not for me. My only complaint? It's so good I could eat two pieces in one sitting. Cute location with outdoor seating and you can also purchase lime inspired gifts as well as natural products. read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Specialty Food Near Me - Key West, Florida

I love this shop! Super cute inside with lots of goodies to chooses from. They let you help yourself to samples from cookies to jelly beans to key lime flavored peanuts. The staff are very friendly and helpful. I ended up buying two bags of cookies because they are so good. They also have chocolate covered key lime pie available. read more

See all

So many samples to choose from! There are two locations nearby but this one is the original . read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Specialty Food Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

After reading tons of reviews on different key lime pies in key west, I knew I wanted to stop by Kermit's. The place is surprisingly large. The inside has a merch area where you can order your food and then there's a large patio with ample seating out back. The staff was nice and the key lime pie was really good. I highly recommend checking them out! read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Specialty Food Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

I stopped into Kermit's to see what they had to offer, and I'm glad I did. The shop has such cute, inviting decor, and there's a wide variety of treats to choose from, including ice cream, cookies, cakes, and even dog treats. One thing I really appreciated was . they offered samples of many of their items, so you can try before committing to a purchase. I ended up getting a key lime iced pound cake, graham cracker cookies, and some key lime hard candies. Everything was tasty, and I'm already looking forward to my next visit so I can stock up on more cookies. read more

See all

They serve an excellent slice of key lime pie! The store sell lots of key lime items but the pie is start of the show. It has a firm tanginess to it and you get a fresh blast of the lime all atop a firm biscuit base. They do use fresh cream on top of the pie and I did think it was a bit too much for my preference. There's a nice sitting area at the rear of the store where you can relax and enjoy your pie. A slice sells for $5.95 Service is quick and friendly. Pay at the counter. read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Specialty Food Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

When in Rome... You can find all things key lime here and I do mean all things. chap-stick, candles, soap, candies, pies, cookies, home decor, etc. So many great things to take home as a souvenir or a gift. The shop itself is bright and attractive and put together very well. The lime green just makes everything pop! Of course we had to try the pie so we grabbed a couple slices to share as a family outside on their inviting patio to cap off the night. Prices were pretty reasonable for a majorly hyped product such as key lime pie and the pie itself was pretty good. I'm always a sucker for Publix's mango/key lime pies when I'm in the south but I know that that isn't the most authentic so it was nice to try the original in it's place of origin. We picked up some fudge and candy on our way out to take back to Minnesota as unique gifts and the items packed well and were greatly received. read more

Cute little place on the corner. They have a lot of free samples so you can try before you buy. They also have ice cream and slices of different flavors of Keylime pie. Of course they have the original, but they also have strawberry and Keylime coconut. The staff was very inviting and encouraging when it comes to trying free samples and asked if we needed any help. Perfect spot to try free samples soak up the AC and takes a little bit of what Key West has to offer when it comes to the sweeter side of things. read more

See all

Cute little shop! Decorated bright and cheerful. Seating inside is air conditioned-it was a good break from the heat. We went in because we wanted to try their take on a key lime pie. It was good and had a lot of flavor- What was really good were the key lime cookies- you can go in and try them- both gluten free and regular. Staff is friendly and helpful. read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Key lime cookies - Specialty Food Near Me - Key West, Florida

Loved all of the product samples all over the store. This was the second best key lime pie we tried throughout the Florida Keys, but the best for the variety and samples available. Bought pie, salt water taffy and tried their other products like jelly beans, cookies and crackers. Their cookies were delicious. Took the slice of pie and ate it later. Tart and delicious. Cute shop and very friendly service. read more

Stopped in for a quick slice of key lime pie. Didn't try other places in the area so can't say if this is the best in the area but it was really good. Able to pop in and grab a quick prepackaged slice. Their was plenty of seating out back where you can enjoy the pie after. Now for the pie it was amazing! Not too sweet not too tart, it was perfect. Staff were friendly and the store was very well decorated. Really gave the key west vibe. They also had a little cookie crisp area where you could try some different cookies before purchasing a larger bag. read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Specialty Food Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

After touring the national park we had ask the local guide for the best key lime desserts. Immediately said Kermit's. Such a quite cozy place. They have a lot of options and we scooped up some pie and heading away. Really good tangy pie ;) so good we forgot the before pictures but made sure we showed it was really that good :) read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Only the packaging left of this tasty piece of pie - Specialty Food Near Me - Key West, Florida

I just love Kermit's! The ambiance and decor feel so key west, and the staff is out of this world! I tried the line made and key lime pie - delish! read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Specialty Food Near Me - Key West, Florida

Wow We came here just to see about the pie but the cookies were outstanding. We ended up getting the key lime coolers which were delicious $10 a bag but well worth it The lady Tracy at the counter was super friendly and gave us all kinds of good information of places to eat. Beautiful little shop with happy green and yellow colors. I like it here.. read more

See all

I will start with I don't like key lime pie. But how can you not get key lime pie in the key lime pie city? I shared a slice with my family just to have a taste and say we got real key lime pie... we ended up all getting a slice and wanting more. Kermit's converted me to a key lime pie lover! Tangy, sweet, and balanced. Not overly puckery. After the pie, make sure you try the cookie bar. Very interesting flavors of cookies that you won't find anywhere else. If you are in key west, this is a must do! read more

See all

Came here for dessert since they offer GF items. I had a GF key lime pie and they also had GF key lime coolers which I bought to take home. Love how they have GF options. read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Specialty Food Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

So, so good! Get the original - it was the BEST we had while in Florida and their crust is divine! We tried the strawberry, too, but preferred the original. We also met Kermit at the door! Love how cute the shop was and both Kermit and the staff were awesome. read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Sorry! We were so excited I forgot to take the picture before we had a few bites. - Specialty Food Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Yummy and friendly dessert parlor of all things Key lime. We popped in and had frozen slices of Key lime pie on a stick covered with milk and white chocolate. The chocolate complemented the tartness of the Key lime and made for a tasty frozen dessert. The atmosphere is adorable and inviting. While Key lime is not a dessert I generally gravitate towards, I had to try it while here in Key West. read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Chocolate covered Keylime pie slice at Kermits - Specialty Food Near Me - Key West, Florida

Well the pie was wonderful! The place was very clean. The staff was not very friendly but I wouldn't say rude either.

This is the king of the tourist spots in Key West for Key Lime pie. They are good. Don't expect fresh made that hour. Key lime pie has to be chilled before served. The pie slice we had was made the night before and prepared for retail sale in plastic individual packages. The pie is smoth and creamy sweet on the first bite with a back-end tartness. It is a great tourist spot for anyone visiting the Keys. read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Specialty Food Near Me - Key West, Florida

If you plan on going to Key West, you must stop in at Kermit's. Your one stop shop for key lime EVERYTHING! You want pie? They've got it. You want cookies? They've got it. You want a drink? They've got it. You want lip balm? They've got it. You want candy? They've got it. You want something for your dog? They've got it. Basically anything you want key lime flavored can be found here, but they have other flavors of things as well for those who are maybe not key lime enthusiasts. They also had some samples, but I'm not sure if this is always the case. The staff is helpful and knowledgeable. They stay pretty busy since it's a tourist destination, but they're pretty quick as well. It's a nice little shop with a laid back "I'm on vacation" vibe and friendly employees. I would definitely recommend stopping by and checking them out. read more

Kermit's Key Lime Pie Shop 200 Elizabeth St. Key West, FL 33040 Key Lime Pie Located on the corner of Elizabeth Street and Greene Street is a dessert shop that specializes in key lime pie. This classic dessert is freshly made In house with actual key lime fruit. This tart flavored dessert with graham cracker crust is topped with fluffy whipped cream. Each piece of this pie is a taste in heaven. In addition to the original flavor, you can also purchase strawberry key lime pie or coconut key lime pie. Both indoor and outdoor seating is available for you to enjoy your dessert. My girlfriend and I were only here for the day before our cruise ship was scheduled to sail away; otherwise we would have definitely explored some more. All in all, we're grateful we made time to pay a visit to this local shop. #keylimepies #keywestflorida #keywestvacation #keylimepie #florida #flafoodie #limes #foodstagram read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Key Lime Pie - Specialty Food Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

We stopped here to get the 2nd Key lime pie to try during our visit. Our group were all troopers and taste tested right along with me. Well, this one was also 5 star and I'd do it all over again just to be sure. read more

Kermit's has the best homemade key lime pie in the Florida keys!!! They gave service with a smile as usual. The ambiance is a sweet little key lime pie shop!!! We will be back!!! read more

See all

Pretty solid key lime pie. Next time we have to try the frozen chocolate covered version.

I love this place! Key Lime is one of my favorite flavors so anytime we are in Key West, we have to stop in here. They have undergone lots of changes (good ones) since we first starting coming here. This is now a total destination, with all sorts of goodies - some for humans and some for our beloved pets. The employees were so kind and helpful and lead the entire line of patrons in a round of Happy Birthday for a customer. There are several types of samples available as well, even the key lime and strawberry key lime juice! I really appreciate they have a gluten free key lime pie option. It's really great. My husband enjoyed the dark chocolate covered frozen key lime on a stick. We sat inside to eat our goodies but the outside seating area looked nice too - shaded and inviting. The restroom was nice and clean as well. read more

See all

Yummy--amazing Keylime pie it's not cheap but it's definitely worth it. Take one home with you! That's going to be my first stop next time I go to Key West. read more

I appreciated that they had ice cream, cookies (with free tasters!), and other items, in addition to key lime pie. This is a great shop for gifts for friends and family back home. We came from the key lime pie and it was delicious with a nice balance of sweet and tart. I like the slice from the Blonde Giraffe more, but the comparison isn't apples to apples, as we had a merengue slice there. If you're looking to get a great slice of key lime pie (or cookies or ice cream) this is a worthwhile spot! read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Key lime pie! - Specialty Food Near Me - Key West, Florida

We went to the big main Kermit's where key lime pie was created. We sampled key lime rum cake, cookies & peanuts. My chocolate covered key lime pie on a stick was perfect. We enjoyed our snacks in their shady garden @ purchased key lime items as gifts. read more

A staple in Key West so I absolutely had to stop in. Key lime pie isn't my go-to dessert but I do appreciate it, especially when it's super tasty. And this was most definitely the best key lime pie I've ever had. Perfect balance of sweet and tart and the graham crack crust was the figurative icing on top :D The shop itself is very cute and they were selling additional items which looked just as tasty. We rented bikes to find the shop and it's so easy to zoom around the island, it makes for great exploring. The place is definitely liked by locals and the people working there were very nice and helpful. If I happen to be in Key West again a stop will for sure be made at Kermit's. read more

I feel like this place could be any other place - average key lime pie, with high/tourist prices. Not bad, but don't go out of your way for it. read more

This location of Kermit's is located in the Historic Seaport area of Key West. It is a large corner location. It boasts a gift shop with a variety of key lime pie assorted gifts to purchase. Everything around you is Key Lime colored! We were brought here while on a Key West Food and Cultural Walking Tour. When we arrived, Kermit himself was standing outside displaying a pie and greeting customers. He was very friendly and was happily posing for photos. We had a slice of the key like pie and a chocolate dipped Key Lime Bar. They were both very good! We sat in the covered outside seating area which was clean and comfortable. read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Kermit's with Kermit himself standing outside - Specialty Food Near Me - Key West, Florida

Cute, cute, cute and delicious pie! A must stop locale for key lime lovers! Friendly service. Lots of adorable merch too. read more

See all

The cute key lime santa greeted us and directed us to the feee cookie samples inside. There was a bit of a line but it went pretty quick. I had coconut key lime. It was okay but i couldn't really taste the coconut. The crust was okay but not great. The pie was okay but the atmosphere was fun. read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - coconut key lime - Specialty Food Near Me - Key West, Florida

Consistently good key lime pie. The service was fast and friendly. The storefront was clean and well kept