We visited on Jan. 23rd and bought a pie mix to bring home for my mom as a present. Well she made it and it didn't taste good at all. It actually tasted so bad that we couldn't even eat it. We had to throw it out. She was so disappointed. Then we realized it expired on Jan. 27th. I was shocked that it expired so soon. I haven't even had a chance to give to her before the expiration date. If you are looking for something to buy do not get the The Key Lime Pie Mix. read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - It was expired! Tasted disgusting. - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

Seems like the ingredients changed! I came here in 2015 and as I remembered, the Key Lime pie was nice and tart, with a slightly thicker graham cracker crust.. Fast fwd to 7 July 18, it pretty much tasted like some sort of Key Lime "sherbet" in a really thin graham cracker... I didn't really enjoy it! You couldn't even taste the Key Lime.. I don't think I'll be back! read more

I can definitely say this is the best Key Lime Pie I've tasted during my trip to a Key West. I bookmarked highly rated Key lime bakery and restaurants and tasted all of them but this is the one that came back home with me. It was the perfect sweetness and tart. read more

Despite the warning from the woman at the counter, we found the Key Lime Pie not very tart! We also got a slice of Key Lime cheesecake, and although tasty, not as tart as we would have liked! Both were yummy, rich, and creamy. For $11.23 (for both) it was a bit pricey, but this is a touristy area, so there you go. That said, I liked this is the place better than the Key Lime shop down the street. read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

The key lime pie at this location was pretty good, one of the better ones in key west. The staff were efficient, but a little dismissive and seemed to just be trying to get people out the door. read more

Supposedly the best Key Lime Pie in KW. I will be the judge of that. Similar to most places we went to HOWEVER we decided to try something different. They have a coconut Key Lime Pie...one word: amazing. Creamy, coconut-y, graham cracker crust-y...dreamy. Smaller, souvenir shop looking place but don't let that fool you. They have a few tables throughout the sections where you can sit down and enjoy a slice of heaven. We also purchased some cookies to bring back to Jersey. Definitely worth a stop to try their CKLP. ENJOY! read more

What can I say about the place that has the only amazing key lime pie I've ever tried? You really can't go wrong with anything you order. I usually have the Key Like Cheesecake which no words can describe how delicious it is. I brought home (4 hour drive) and tried the Coconut Cream pie for the first time and loved it so much (audible groans with each bite) that I savored it over the course of 3 days, only taking one bite at a time. Just go and get some of the best pie. Sorry I don't have more pictures, the slices we ate inside the shop were devoured within 2 min. read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Key Lime Cheescake - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

I am IN LOVE, i repeat, IN LOVE with their pie. The service was amazing, and the shop is so cute and lovely. Definitely would go again, specially for their chocolate key lime pie bars read more

Good food, small selection, nice cashier, mostly a souvenir shop. Sells a lot of key lime products

The pies are made on site. While waiting for a delicious slice of pie you can shop for souvenirs. I must admit I didn't like key lime pie until today. The store keepers were very nice. read more

Best Key Lime pie from Boca down to the keys. Hands down. We tried A LOT OF PIE during a week stay in Florida (we ate fast food key lime pie, frou-frou merengue topped key lime pie and even chocolate dipped key lime pie) and this was the best. We chose the Coconut Key Lime Pie and it was EPIC. Perfect crust to pie ratio, creamy filling not too tart but enough of a key lime kick to make your mouth pucker. Very clean and bright store and our cashier/pie server was super friendly and happy. Cute schwag if you're looking for souvenirs. There are many key lime pie joints in the keys but save yourself the time and start (and end) here. read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Coconut Key Lime Pie - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

Best key lime pie! Bakery is clean friendly and modestly priced. Definitely the best!

A nice store that sells Key Lime related products. During my visit, I tried their Classic Key Lime pie. It was really good. It was a good combination of sweetness and tartness. I could really taste the key limes. Customer service was friendly. The place was clean. I also tried the key lime pecans. It was OK. I tried another slice of Key Lime pie at another location on Greene Street for the sake of comparsion. I would come back again. read more

See all

Love it here! The owner and everyone who work here are super sweet and amazing! Stopped here for late night coffee and left with great little souvenirs for my family! Very happy I stumbled across this place! read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

One of the best places to get a homemade Keylime pie. The place is right off of DeVale Street. Absolutely delicious pies. read more

See all

To much lime. I love key lime pie and this is not a good one. To much lime. The lime is overpowering. The key lime pie at Hot Tin Roof is amazing! read more

I waited in the line as you do at many places no biggy. I get to the counter and I ask the lady which one is the best seller. She says I don't know just pick one. (Which is fine), but when you use a tone that disrespects the customer who simply asked a questions out of curiosity and interest towards the products. I ended up leaving. There are numerous locations in keywest with the same delicious options! read more

We ate key lime pie every night during our stay but only what was served at restaurants which left a bit to be desired. We FINALLY came into this shop and hit the jackpot of key lime pie. Tart - not too sweet - no 6" of meringue mucking it up. Key Lime Pie perfection!. The woman working was very kind to let us barge in 6 minutes after closing (online it says they close at 11 but bc of staffing shortages (thanks Covid!) they're closing at 9) and grab one perfect slice of key lime pie. Highly recommend this little shop which is on the WEST end of Greene St (near Whitehead) There are a couple key lime pie shops along/near Greene so don't get drunk and confused! The one across from Tropical Vibes is the one you want!! read more

Great pies. And i don't even like pies. Coconut key lime pie was particularly great. Awful service. terrible service. I had the yelp offer - he said oh great! I smiled and waited for him to put in the discount. He looked like he was struggling so I said - oh it says this offer code, if that helps. He shoots me a dirty look and says - Do you know how to bypass the system? Otherwise you can't help. OK- just offering some help. Then my brother asked what pie bar was. He starts speaking loudly and says - you DIP the pie .... - ok. my brother speaks english. We're asians. Great pie though. read more

Now I'm a key lime pie connoisseur and I made the trip to key west just to eat pie. The pie was good but not great I felt like it was missing something. I'm not sure if it was the consistency of the filling or the crust? I do know the pie was sweet but it is a key lime pie. I got the key lime cheesecake as well and I liked it much better then the pie. I got both because the person that was working could not say much about the pie or the cheesecake which was a disappointment. But hey I got a great bottle of key lime juice when I was there. read more

The lady working was very kind and helpful - customer service at its finest. We had lots of questions as my daughter has food allergies. We are so appreciative of her help. We got the chocolate dipped key lime pie and the coconut cream pie. Both were outstanding! read more

We tried the key line pie original and the coconut key lime pie . The original crust was not home made . The coconut key line pie had home made crust . The Bakery was open later then the other key lime shop . But It's not as good as Kermit's key lime pies. If you want the best Kermit's is it . I did the sampling for you . read more

Seriously yum....we tasted the regular and cheesecake...I think we agree both are great with a slight edge going to the regular. Enjoy! read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

Hands down the best key lime pie I ever had. I had the one with toasted coconut on top. The pie wasn't too sweet nor too sour. The price was right and I can't wait to go back to purchase a whole pie. read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Key lime pie with toasted coconut. Amazing!! - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Now THIS is Key Lime pie! Fresh,tart and creamy with a delicious crust. It was our first stop in Key West before lunch! If you want a true key lime pie just go here. read more

Great pies and ice cream. Service is fast and prices are about right. Only issue is with sitting area as there aren't many.

After taste testing and comparing key lime pie from Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe, Key Lime Pie Bakery, and Key West Key Lime Pie Company we have a tie! My favorite was Kermit's Chocolate Dipped Key Lime Pie. It was a perfect portion with a good balance between sweet and sour. My husband on the other hand loved Key West Key Lime Pie Company best. I would say that it was my second favorite. The pie wasn't your usually consistency. It was firmer and creamier almost like it was ice cream. The graham cracker crust was very buttery and crumbly. Our third favorite (because you can't not love all Key Lime Pie) was Key Lime Pie Bakery. This one was a smaller portion and had a firmer crust. The pie filling though had a more tart finish than the other two. Obviously everyone has their own style of Key Lime Pie they like best so give each one a try and let me know which is your favorite! read more

Okay, if you go to Key West you have to try Key Lime pie, right? Well, I went "full tourist" and tried it EVERYWHERE! And of all the places I tried it, THIS PLACE HAD THE BEST! Lots of other Key Lime flavored goodies here---cookies, fudge, etc. But I went there for one thing only, and I was not disappointed! Perfect blend of tart, sweet, with just the right amount of whipped cream. Not a lot of seating in the place, but that's not what you're looking for when you're searching for the BEST Key Lime Pie in the Keys. Look no longer--IT'S HERE! read more

The coconut key lime pie is DELISH!!! Wowieee what a yummy treat, the fresh coconut shavings were the perf addition. Def recommend! read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

While you might find this place ranked second behind Kermit's (a bakery that makes a disgusting excuse for key lime pie), this place actually earned its spot towards the top of the key west key lime pie rankings. We've spent all week trying different key lime pies from different places, and Key Lime Pie Bakery is officially the best. Great texture, great flavor, good crust. read more

THE BEST key lime pie EVER!!! Friendly customer service, great choices for souvenirs as well! I highly recommend it!!!

The worst excuse for a piece of key lime pie! $7 for a slice of crap! Very disappointed because I was looking forward to the "Best" pie in Key West ,according to reviews. read more

Nice people, excellent key lime pie! Everything is and has to do with Florida's key lime.

Super Tart Key Lime Pie- just how I like it. It's the first place to serve it in the keys. My rationale you ask? Well if it ain't broke why fix it. It's small, it's quaint, it's great, and it's the original. Think of the equivalent of eating a slice of pizza at Lombardía when in NYC. If you can't get that reference, take a flight to the big Apple after eating a slice (or 2) of Key Lime Pies at this bakery. read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Original Key Lime Slice - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

Not very impressed... Arrived right as they were "supposed" to open. The woman looked at us waiting outside in the rain, and turned around and acted like she didn't see us. First turn off. Luckily the guy who owns the shop next door wanted coffee, so she opened up. When I walked in she left the door open, so i asked her if she wanted me to close it since it was raining. She said why would I want it closed, I'm open. Second turn off. We really wanted to get a key lime pie before we left and this place had good reviews. All they had were frozen pies with a date on it that was 6 days old. So I asked if they made the pies here themselves. I guess that offended her because she replied smartly to me of course they do. I was simply curious since I'm not from here. Third turn off. To the woman with the curly hair that opened Tuesday morning - learn some manners and have some respect for others. If you don't like your job, get another one. The only thing that gave this place 2 stars was the actual pie itself. It was pretty tasty, but definitely nowhere close to the best I had on the island. read more

Holy Cow, I've had a lot of Key Lime Pie in my lifetime but this was the best that I've ever had. They had several different options but I went with the classic and I was glad my kids couldn't eat all of theirs so I got their leftovers. read more

They have some amazing pie here to enjoy on your visit! But wait... There is more... They also sell the key ingredients to take home and make your own authentic desserts! We always stop here for a slice of delicious pie but we also get a bottle of key lime juice to we can make our our own in the comfort of our own home! read more

I stopped in here for a slice of its namesake. So often in Key West the pies are too sweet. This pie was nice and tart. It was the best Key Lime Pie I had while in Key West. The staff was friendly, and the cup of coffee I had with my pie was tasty as well. The store sells all sorts of related items. This would be a good place to pick up a gift for someone when stopping in the keys. read more

Only in house bakery left. Nuff said. But yelp says I should add more words. So... It's delicious. Try the coconut key lime. On point. Nice ladies behind the counter too. read more

Sure it's cute. The pie on a stick was good, too. Definitely too rich for one person, even for a self-professed chocoholic and I-live-off-all-things-Key-Lime while visiting Key West sort-a-gal. But at almost $6 I'd rather go to "Kermie's." Not worth it here. Seems to cater to the cruise ship crowd who are frantically trying to take it all in and fast. So if you aren't in a hurry, I say, go to Kermit's instead. Their whole pie was pretty damn tasty and more reasonably priced, as were their white chocolate key lime to-die-for cookies. read more