It's been more than a decade since i wrote my first review about OLD TOWN BAKERY.... and since then, NOTHING BUT GOOD STUFF ! Obviously the food is great... and the staff is awesome... We normally pickup a couple sandwiches... hubby gets the VEGETARIAN and I get the VEGAN... both of them on baguette. Let's not forget they are a bakery and that bread is delicious. Now and then we think of the kids (grown-ups) and pick them up goodies too. My husband and my older son love the O.M.G. BROWNIE. Personally I think it's too rich but they love them. My other son is simpler so I try new stuff for him. Don't miss out.... if you are in Key West, then do yourself a favor and visit ! read more

Quaint to-go cafe in key west. We tried the cafe since Fitch hotels offered a $10 discount/day. We tried the following: - croissant breakfast sandwich with egg and cheese 4/5. The egg was cooked perfectly, nice and fluffy - lunch wrap - 3/5. A bit plain. Tasted really healthy like I could've made it myself - ham and cheese croissant - 4/5. Hit the spot, but nothing unique - roast beef sandwich - 3/5. The roast beef was a bit stringy - iced coffee - 4/5. Nice and smooth read more

See all

This is a five star destination! Great coffee, top notch pasteries and breakfast sandwiches and burritos that are worth every penny. If this bakery was in my town I'd never spend a morning elsewhere. The only place I visited twice in my Key West stay. read more

Old Town Bakery - Old Town Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Key West, Florida

We stop to inquire about a golf cart rental. He provided us information for the rental, and also told us to check out Old Town Bakery since my husband was on a search to find a good key lime pie. They offer street parking, which was great and they weren't busy at our time of arrival. We knew what we wanted and it didn't take long to order and receive it! It's a small bakery, so it may not be conducive for dining in, but it was perfect for to-go orders. I'm not a huge fan of key lime pie, but it wasn't tangy which I was expecting it to be. It came with some whipped cream, but it wasn't piled on. It had a good flavor overall. My husband also enjoyed it, but wished it was a little lighter and fluffier. read more

See all

I was on the hunt for best Key Lime Pie! There are so many places who claim to be the best, but Old Town Bakery hit it out of the park! This is a must stop if you want to indulge in the best pie around! read more

Old Town Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Key West, Florida

I enjoyed a deliciously large bacon, egg and cheese croissant breakfast sandwich from Old Town Bakery. It was packed full of scrambled eggs covered in melted cheese with nice crispy slices of bacon. Service was fast early in the morning and the coffee was flavorful as well. We took our order to go to enjoy poolside at our hotel which was lovely. read more

Old Town Bakery - Bacon, egg and cheese croissant sandwich plus coffee - Bakeries Near Me - Key West, Florida

Great pastries, coffee, and iced drinks! Small store - clean, no indoor seating. Service was great and pretty fast - especially because they were busy. Get there early! read more

Delicious! Come here for delicious coffee, pastries, and sandwiches. I love the frozen coffee. I also love the multiple veggie sandwich choices. Their bread is so good, although the crust is sometimes hard. The curry chicken salad sandwich with apples and sprouts is sooo good. The TBJ is one of my favorites, it's stuffed huge! My husband didn't like the French dip very much, it wasn't stuffed as much as my TBJ or curry chicken. The sticky bun is amazing! So are the croissants. Great prices here too! Which is rare for key west. No seating, order at the counter and take it Togo. I'll be back!! read more

Old Town Bakery - Curry chicken salad w/ apples & sprouts - so good! - Bakeries Near Me - Key West, Florida

We loved this spot in Key West. Every item we ordered was delicious - standouts included the cafe mocha and the danish tastes even better than it looks. The entire pastry lineup has an artisan look and frankly taste as well. The employee that took care of us was super sweet and friendly and didn't hesitate to ask questions and make recommendations based on what we were looking for. It can't be helped really, but the only thing that would have made this place even better is if there was space to have a few tables to grab a seat and enjoy - the only option for that being a shabby wooden bench outside by the street corner. We were on our way out of town anyhow, so we took it all to go and enjoyed the coffee drinks and baked goods on the go! read more

See all

I saw this shop on the corner and turned around because I needed a breakfast sandwich. I left with a pastry and this amazing sandwich of the day. It was roast beef, chimichurri, pickled onion, roasted red peppers, arugula, and cheese on their Italian bread. When I say that the flavor of this sandwich was complex and every ingredient was needed. The women working were so friendly and engaging. It's a cute and small place that exudes friendliness and wanting to help. Highly recommend! read more

Old Town Bakery - The sandwich special of the day and me very excited about it. - Bakeries Near Me - Key West, Florida

Easy to order online or call in and order. If you want sandwiches, they do make them after 7am, but you have to call it in since the online order for sandwiches doesn't start until 11 am. It's a small store. Not much place to sit. Got the TBJ: 3.5 stars. turkey bacon and onions helped jam. Turkey and bacon were good. But the onion jam was lackluster or maybe there was not enough of it. Vegan sandwich:4 stars. Glad they had this option for my mom. The caprese sandwich with added salami. :4 stars. The little one ate it all up which means it was good. Good prices for lunch sandwiches. read more

See all

Was craving a quick and easy lunch and decided to try this place out. Parking is weird in the area but I was able to find a spot like a block and a half away. Walked in and said hello to the cashier (I was the only customer in the bakery at that time) and she did not say anything back. Once I said I'm ready to order is when she acknowledged me and said what will you be having. I ordered the build your own sandwich. I ordered it with turkey, fontina, lettuce, tomato, onion and then I paid the 0.75¢ extra for the basil pesto. When my sandwich was ready I took it back to my car to eat it (there isn't anywhere to sit and eat here). I was disappointed to find out the basil pesto was barely there. Only on one spot in the middle of each half. So the majority of the sandwich was dry. The sandwich was good but dry, especially when I ordered it with the pesto and paid extra for it (didn't pay a lot but you get the point). The bread was good. Overall a good not great experience. Would I come back? Yes. Would it be my first suggestion? No. read more

Old Town Bakery - Build your own sandwich - Bakeries Near Me - Key West, Florida

Total Yummm, the staff is prompt and courteous. Very cozy with no seating, it's a grab and go situation, but everything is so so good. It's a must for sure read more

Cute little coffee shop and bakery on Eaton Street. Get yourself a danish - blueberry and cream cheese is excellent and so is the raspberry. Their ratio of cream cheese to pastry and fruit is perfect. Wash it down with a cup of coffee and it makes for a perfect start to a day in paradise. They are super friendly and service is fast. A must try for a grab and go breakfast before heading out for an adventure. read more

Cute little grab and go coffee shop and bakery on Eaton Street. Flaky pastries, yummy breakfast items and huge sandwiches for $10. A great place to pop in for breakfast or a sweet treat. We enjoyed the breakfast sandwiches, croissants and freshly baked breads. Didn't try the scones, which are normally my favorite because 3 mornings in a row they were raspberry and I'm a weirdo that doesn't like raspberries . Great variety of items and wonderful, friendly and efficient service. read more

See all

Good place to grab coffee and breakfast. The shop is pretty small with no seating, just a bench outside so plan to eat elsewhere. There is paid street parking or a garage one or two streets down. I enjoyed by egg and cheese breakfast sandwich on a croissant. The raspberry cheese danish was also good. The staff were friendly. read more

Sticky bun roll was yummy also ordered cafe con leche which can be better. Service is amazing. read more

Old Town Bakery - Also tried the key lime pie - not as creamy as the one in Hurricane Hole. It's cheaper though. - Bakeries Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Maybe 4 1/2 stars. Service A, fast and friendly. Ambiance OK. Food A fabulous. Hearty baguette . Delicious Danish type pastries. A really good bakery. read more

Good pastries, good coffee, great key lime pie (maybe the best on the island overall)!

Stopped by to pick up egg cheese and sausage on a croissant breakfast sandwiches and sticky buns. Freshly made to order. Outstanding!!! We will be back! Only difficulty is finding a parking space within a couple of blocks - very few spaces that are not reserved for residents. But it was worth the search! read more

While in Key West we tried A LOT of key lime pie slices and this was THE BEST by far. Perfectly tart and the best texture. We also had a huge chocolate chip cookie which was voted the best in the world by my daughter. read more

The brie cheese is so good! There's a lot of selection and you can customize your own thing too. Prices are really reasonable too, especially these days. The key lime pie is super good too. Staff is friendly and service is quick. As a heads up though; there's nowhere to sit other than a bench outside of the restaurant. We'll be back to try more things soon! read more

Old Town Bakery - Key lime pie, so good! - Bakeries Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Love this place in the morning always get a breakfast sandwich and coffee. Staff is great and fast

THE BEST KEY LIME PIE! We've tried at least four in the last couple of days, this is definitely the mess! The perfect crust, perfect flavor, perfect topping read more

Cute small bakery with homemade pastries. I had a key like pie to go and really enjoyed it. Probably one of my top 3 key lime pies that I tried on the island! They also have these cute shirts for merch that I plan on purchasing upon my return. The staff were also friendly. Great service! read more

See all

I had the croissants. They were very good exactly what you'd expect. I would definitely stop back and have a croissant.

Mr./Mrs Niall, first of all, I don't remember the owner serving, cooking or been at the cash register that morning, secondly, if the other lady who was making the coffee and preparing the food for the customers was you (the owner) then she would've step in and asked what was the problem, so I don't think you were there to witnessed what happened, but I had witness that were with me, and to say that I was loud or screaming, you must be out of your mind. Third, evidently you will favor your employee vs the customer, something we don't see ever or often since the phrase "the customer is always right" exists, even when not in all cases the customer is right, but in this case, it fell of the wagon. Bottom line, next time you're am in Key West, which I had a wonderful and an amazing time there, with the exception of stepping in your bakery, don't you worry, cause I will Not go back to your bakery as long as I live. Btw, and at my age I do know what a great and an amazing customer service should be since I've been dealing with people all my life, and unfortunately in today's society customer service has decreased in value due to people like your employee or business owners like you. Have a great life! read more

Old Town Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Cute little shop. Grab and go as no real seating. I've tried the sticky bun and a raspberry croissant and both were excellent. Highly recommend. They offer other breakfast items as well as lunch sandwiches, and of course coffee. Worth a visit when in town! read more

Honestly the best baked goods in town Only complaint- Why the breakfast croissants are made using smaller croissants than the rest of the croissants They are SMALL BUT- Staff is amazing always Everything is delicious and the prices thankfully are still reasonable Get the ham and Swiss croissant! read more

Try the Ham and Swiss croissant ... it's absolutely delicious!!! We'll be back for sure!!!

I like that this bakery is local. The pastries were a little picked over a couple hours after opening. I was still able to order a chocolate croissant and a slice of key lime pie though. Add a sausage egg croissant to that and the total is nearly $15. The key lime pie was good. But imo nothing outstanding. The crust tasted like it was made out of ginger snaps which was a nice twist. The chocolate croissant was certainly in the smaller side.. but it was packed with chocolate! The breakfast sandwich did not look like anything special.. but it in-fact tasted better than it looked and it was obvious how fresh the croissants were after biting into this buttery delight. read more

See all

Kimpton gave us $9 breakfast vouchers which we used for lunch since we had breakfast plans. We ordered key west chicken wraps which had grilled chicken with cheddar cheese, lettuce tomato and guacamole. They were tasty, but we should have gotten chocolate croissants and scones instead, we were just trying not to go crazy. Staff was friendly and efficient, we'll be back for the baked goods for sure! read more

Old Town Bakery - the front of the building - Bakeries Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Everything is great, but their peach cobbler is incredible! Cookies are very good too, but get there early.

Coffee good Pasties good. The peach danish was fantastic and so was the raspberry croissant. The key lime pie was super tart! Def try it out! read more

We came here for a slice of key lime pie since I saw it on many lists for places to try key lime pie in Key West. I really loved the filling. It was perfectly tangy how I think it should. Many of the others we had were not as tangy. The crust, on the other hand, was not good. It was the worst crust of the 5 pies we had. That being said, it's worth having for the filling alone. read more

Old Town Bakery - Key Lime Pie | Instagram: @telephonesmoothie - Bakeries Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Get the blueberry and peach Danish. Get the chocolate croissant. It's not on the menu...but get the mocha. I wish I had pictures...it needed up in my belly waaaaaay too fast. read more

Stopped by this afternoon for pastry to have in our room in the morning with our in room coffee and tea. I asked for two berry scones and the employee/owner said "you are going to get more than two scones because I'm closing for the day in 10min."Super nice of her. Yum! read more

Line out the door but so worth it. Quality food at reasonable prices. I had an egg sandwich and it was so good. I would highly recommend

This is a must visit when visiting Key West! There are two places we visit when we first arrive in Key West. Old Town Bakery and then off to Books & Books to purchase some books to read for the week. Get to the bakery early for a good selection. It's slim pickens later in the morning. They also offer great sandwiches and soups for lunch. Below is a list of items we purchased and 100% enjoyed during our week visit to Key West. Ham and Swiss Croissant French Dip Sandwich Tomato Brie Soup Cobbler Danish Raspberry Cheese Danish Pumpkin Muffin - Gluten Free Pumpkin Cream Cheese Muffin Guava Pastry read more

Old Town Bakery - Our favorite bakery to visit in Key West! No seating, all orders are to go. - Bakeries Near Me - Key West, Florida

Easy three or four. What a nice case of interesting bakery delicacies. And the black coffee was good enough for me though quite strong. Perfect, really, for adding whatever all else. In one door out the next. That's the flow here, not too covid confusing. Looks to be an interesting prospect for lunch or fulfilling emergency take away charcuterie. Nice and affordable cheese assortment. Breakfast burrito was unremarkable in a good way, I guess, liked em' enough. read more

See all