This place is a seafood lover's dream! I've been wanting to check out this place for awhile and I'm…read moreglad I finally got to try. We got the lobster AYCE for $125pp and they had so much variety and everything was made fresh to order. The portion sizes were generous and the quality of the seafood was great. I love the flavors of everything we got. The service was also amazing! So quick and efficient. My faves: - Fried Sea Bass w. Sweet Chili Sauce - Old Bay Shrimp - Pan Seared Fresh Jumbo Scallop - Shrimp w. Cajun Butter Sauce

Food: This restaurant offers an AYCE seafood meal for $90 per person (or $120 per person for…read moreunlimited lobster and lobster mac and cheese). The AYCE menu includes a variety of items including appetizers (broccoli, calamari, corn, iron steak, crab rangoon, clam chowder, fried rice, garlic noodles, chicken wings, spareribs, general Tso's chicken, spring rolls, edamame, french fries, and more) and main seafood entrees (steamed or hand breaded shrimp, blue crab, dungeness crab, snow crab legs, crawfish, salmon, seabass, mussels, steamed clams, raw oysters and clams, and more). The items I would recommend the most are iron steak, crab rangoon, blue crab, snow crab legs, and crawfish. The seafood is fresh, and if you love seafood, this AYCE meal is a good value for the variety and amount you get. There is no limit to how much you can order at a time; you can order as many rounds as you'd like. Service: Service is excellent here; staff are friendly and very attentive. They come to check on you throughout the meal and clear empty dishes. Food comes out very quickly after you place an order. The staff are also nice about giving you another menu to place another order. They are generous with their portions and food unlike other AYCE places that seem to not want you to order as much. Ambiance: The restaurant is big and spacious; seating is comfortable. There are tables and booths that can accommodate both small and large groups. The restaurant is kept clean, and the decor is very nice. During the warmer months, there's outdoor seating in Mongolian-style tents on the patio that overlooks Surf Avenue and Luna Park. Overall, I would highly recommend this restaurant if you like seafood!

Lovely restaurant. The atmosphere and our view from the bar was amazing…read more I try the lobster roll and had a margarita. Service was outstandin. The lobster roll was fresh and the bread was warm. The Mayo with the lemon gave it a good taste.

Went to Nick's Lobster for a date night with my hubby during Restaurant Week. The location is…read moredefinitely a highlight, right by the water, and I can already picture how lovely this spot must be in the summer. We would absolutely love to come back when the weather is warm. The service was impeccable. Our server was very attentive and made sure we were well taken care of all evening. Now, let's get to the food. I started with the Caesar salad, but the dressing was a bit too anchovy forward for my taste, so I didn't really enjoy it. My husband had the lobster bisque. It was very creamy, but there was hardly any lobster in it. We both ordered the grilled octopus. I wasn't a fan, but my husband enjoyed it, especially paired with the lime based slaw. On the side, we ordered the fried calamari, which was one of the highlights. The calamari was tender, and the sauce really made the dish. For our main entrées, I had the whole lobster, which unfortunately was overcooked and lacked flavor. My husband ordered the snow crab legs and really enjoyed them. Dessert was the best part of the evening. I had the red velvet cake and he had the key lime pie. Hands down my favorite dish of the night. I'm not sure if the experience was impacted by Restaurant Week, but between the beautiful location and great service, I'm willing to give Nick's Lobster another try, especially during the summer.

Came hungry. Left satisfied Great spot to hang out and…read moreenjoy seefood and drinks Will definitely be coming back with a more friends and family

Delicious sea food boil. I was in crab legs heaven with the boil eggs, potatoes and corn …read more I got the punch that was saved in a pouch bag. 10/10 Service was excellent It's still Valentine Day so love on you and take yourself out and celebrate. Decorated beautifully still for Valentines Day. You could feel the L O V E as soon as you walk into Cap't Loui establishment.

This was a recommendation from a friend in the neighborhood. She was spot on this place. Not too…read morecrowded, spacious and very clean. The staff was super friendly, accommodating and polite overall. Food: Shrimp basket was delicious the fries were a little salty on my end. Picked 3 seafood (Shrimp head off, Snow crab legs, crawfish. The crawfish was a little sus, so the waitress Sue was able to take it off bill. Everything was really good and fresh!! Get the garlic noodles, pretty damn good!! Overall, I'm definitely coming back here!! I had a great experience from the food to the staff!! There is shared parking with Dollar tree which is next Door.

I've only had food from Puerto Plata once and it was to go. I had to wait over 4 hours to eat it…read morebecause we had it catered for a Poconos outing. That was a year ago and the food remains on my mind. The service is perfect Beverly and the other waitresses came over to check on us often. We drank. We laughed and oh boy did we eat. I had the chicken chunks fried with bone w/ tostones and a side of garlic sauce. I stole a shrimp off one plate and a corn from another, finally a spoon of mash and I was spent. At the end of the night Rey came over with a hookah and it was perfect! We danced in our seats and at the end of the night we made sure to thank everyone for a wonderful evening. The food was delicious. The drinks were boss! If you want seafood you have to go next door and order then bring it to your seat. They call you when it's ready to be picked up. We didn't mind that at all. It was worth it. Every thing is made with love. Please go it really feels like a homely spot. You won't be sorry - promise

I ordered a delivery of the Big Papi, seafood platter from Puerto Plata maybe two months ago. I was…read moreat home, eating through my feelings but even a greedy girl like me wasn't ready for so much food. The Big Papi is enough for plenty of people's feelings. A deep dish aluminum pan filled with shrimp, lobster tails, corn and potatoes was good NOT great. The seafood was a tad bit bland. The shrimps were large but a bit undercooked for my liking. I ordered some sort of side sauce but that was also lacking. It didn't taste like anything- no spice, no buttery flavors. Nothing. Big plus was the amount of food that you get for your money. I would get food from Puerto Plata but in person. I believe that if I'm present to tell the cook just how I want my food seasoned and prepared, I'll have a greater taste experience.

Still a great spot. We came for an early Mother's Day dinner and the food was spot on. Service…read morewas friendly and the speed we were served was surprising. Definitely one of my favorites for seafood!

So decided to give this place another try since my last time 6 plus years ago…read more Staff was great and courteous. Place was pretty empty at 5pm on Memorial Day. Surprising or not ? We had an app, a salad and two pasta dishes . They had a generous amount of seafood BUT what's the point of having it if they don't flavor any of their sauces. Both were watered down and had some flavor but needed salt and we had to add Parmesan to it. This isn't my idea of a good meal when you have to season your own food. So you are okay with good enough this is your places but there are many others

This is a hidden gem in Brooklyn. We came here to celebrate a birthday with a party of 12, and the…read morerestaurant thoughtfully gave us a private room. They even offered a complimentary bottle of wine and a few small appetizer dishes, which was a very nice touch. It's a seafood restaurant and seafood is clearly their specialty. They also have a live seafood market, so we were able to pick our own seafood. Everything was very fresh and delicious. Other dishes, the chicken was surprisingly tasty as well. Since it was a birthday celebration, we took our time and stayed a bit longer. Even though we ended up staying past their closing time, they didn't rush us to leave. We really appreciated that and had a wonderful time there.

Good prices on family set meals. Came here twice for celebrations and ordered the family meal for…read more8. The meal includes geoduck sashimi, jellyfish & mixed appetizer, soup, steamed fish, crab & lobster with sticky rice, abalone, steamed shrimp, noodles, and veggies. Some dishes were bigger than others. Both times I came they didn't have abalone so we substitute the dish for garlic scallop (which I prefer). The menu also says it comes with house special dessert but we never gotten any. For any seafood, it's market price plus they add a 30% processing fee, which is strange to me. For a Chinese restaurant which usually does not charge tax if you pay with cash, they charge tax here whether you pay by card or cash. The restaurant is pretty big and spacious. They have pretty large tables, suitable for parties and celebrations. There's a private space upstairs with 3 large tables for parties. The restaurant is pretty slow in the afternoon.

Sam and all the staff were 5 star. Brought my service dog and everyone was so nice to her too. She…read morewas super chill and just sat but at least 4 customers and all the staff said hi. For the food and drink - AMAZING. Idk why I haven't been here as a local but we'll definitely be regulars

03.08.26 @ 5:45pm Made reservations for 3. When got here…read morestill needed wait a bit and got seated on the bar. Came here for the oysters due to it have much variety to choose from. Our bar waitress was nice, friendly and easy going. Feel very comfy seating at the bar. The oysters were all fresh.

Took my visiting from the Midwest sin here on a Friday night and listen that place was very much…read morethe popping in a way I absolutely appreciated to show him NYC style of seafood boils. The experience was worth every single penny he left lifted and full. Lol

A Family get together for dinner. Mom's wanted us catch up, myself, cousin Dale, uncle and herself…read more We had a good time catching up and the food was just as tasty as the last time we came awhile ago. The clam chowder is the bomb as well as the wings. I can't remember the name of the drink. However its definitely strong and one is all I needed. Our waitress was great and she took care of us very well.

I found this place on Yelp and decided to try it, I thought it was a sit down. It's a small take…read moreout with no tables to sit and eat. The place is clean, that's a plus for me. I had the fried shrimp and fish combo which was pretty good.

I couldn't even eat the food I bought. Everything was clearly refried hard and not cooked fresh…read more From the whiting, to the shrimps and even the "orange" steak fries. Like if you are not cooking items fresh post a sign to warn us. For $20 save your money and go to fish market instead. Terrible!!!