We really enjoy this place for all their unique pizzas that are offered. They have different types of crust (ex: sesame), slice cut options, and quick delivery. We ordered delivery this week and we were told about an hour and the guy was at our house in 35 minutes! Win! Although we also order from other places for pizza, we like having the option to do something different, like the chicken pesto pizza; my personal favorite! read more

Just Pizza - Chicken pesto pizza with tomatoes - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

It's a small pizza place typical for our area but it's a branch. The owners and staff are a little sketchy which is why I don't go back. The one lady that works there reminds me of the momma from the goonies. read more

They really do close at 9pm. Can't always believe what you see on the net... or on the door.

Pizza is the best in town. Their blackberry wings are really good too. I like their creativity too.

I've been to this location before the new ownership so all the negative reviews are justified but I recently heard that they have new owners and they decided to clean up the place. It's improved drastically since then. I ordered a cheese and pepperoni pizza & a old fashion Italian white & they both came out spectacular. I like the flavor and the thin crust. Overall they've improved a ton at this location & I'm willing to try more again in the future read more

I don't like shitty reviews but I just got a pizza and first they messed it up no biggie but 3 of us were messed up I ordered double cheese pepperoni and mushrooms this had barely any cheese and the sauce was terrible you guys better get it together and it's not the first problem. read more

Burnt pizza. Terrible. Inedible. It's smells and tastes more burnt than it looks. Consistency is all over the place and we're done with this company. read more

Just Pizza - Burnt pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

I ordered med pizza, wings , and two sandwiches. Wings are awesome! Pizzas is delicious! Great job! read more

Ok I hate to do this BUT I must be honest because I'm a foodie and Just Pizza has definitely lowered the bar when it comes to quality and providing good food. We ordered the 3 Cheese Steak Hoagie and there was barely any cheese, flavor or anything else. Unfortunately, my mom had to throw it away because it was so undesirable. What a waste of money. Spare yourself. So disappointed!! read more

OMG what a great place! My wife and I adopted a our dog from the SPCA and this Just Pizza sponsored Archie. They gave us a gift certificate along with his adoption, this gave us the opportunity to find a great new favorite pizza stop. We ordered the chicken club pizza and 30 wings, both were amazingly good. This is definitely a go to place locally owned and operated, and it shows. My pic is the reason I have a new favorite pizza place. Meet Archie, we changed his name from Pork Chop. read more

Just Pizza - a dog with a missing slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

We received coupons for 2 free slices of pizza and a drink, which had no expiration date. However, they told us that the coupons were expired and refused to honor them. This is terrible business practice. read more

I thought a place called Just Pizza should have good pizza, it was just expensive. I could go to Niagara Falls and get pizza at several places for less than half of what Just Pizza charges for its flavorless pies. I hear their specialty pizzas are their strong suit but if you can't make a decent cheese and pepperoni then I'm just not interested. Also tried their chicken fingers but they were more like chicken flavored bread fingers. Sorry but for a place called Just Pizza, just disappointing. read more

We get a pizza and sub from here about once a month. Pizza is away really good with a sesame seed crust surround and plenty of pepperoni. Sub is a good priced, seeded roll, Royal that we usually get., Food is also ready when they say it will be . read more

Every so often you go someplace and you're like how's this place in business we'll this was one. We stopped to get a slice of pizza and a drink, simple tight?? Nope they had a few options for pizza we look at the drink options a couple of diet ginger ale and mounts dew in the 20 oz bottles not our drinks of choice but they did have 2 liters Pepsi and diet so we figured we'd get that and a lice we asked about cups they said they didn't have any? They also said they didn't have any paper plates either.. The lady said they were on a boat somewhere? I know there are some supply chain issues but this was the first time I've heard this one. Anyways do yourself a favor and read the reviews read more

Stopped in for lunch today and the pizza was so fresh & delicious. The guy working the counter had probably the best personality for a customer service position I've seen in a really long time. His energy was just awesome. It's really nice to see happy, genuine people are still out there. read more

I recently tried to put in an order, when I called in I was informed that the prices on the website were only ballpark figures. My order was almost $9 more than advertised. It's not the customers fault that the business is not competent enough to update its website. They should have honored the prices that were advertised. read more

Just Pizza = Just Awful. They should rename it "Just The Worst Pizza" because, notwithstanding the chains such as Papa John's and Pizza Hut which are the very definition of 1-star pizza, this is the most appalling pizza in town. Especially at this location, which actually complained to me - in a fairly rude manner - when I asked them to heat up a slice for me. Ah well, they can't all be wonderful places. They do have a good selection of (miserable tasting) slices, and they do have nice neon lights. And it's a locally-owned franchised chain rather than a series of individual stores, so it can't score a rock-bottom 1. However I'm embarrassed that I used to eat a lot of pizza here. In my defence I lived just down the road, but that's no excuse. It was within cycling distance of my house, but nobody who takes cycling seriously should really be cycling to Just Pizza anyway, should they? read more

I don't know anything about the quality of the food because I never ate there. This review is about customer service. We received two coupons for pizza and a drink from our Oct 23 visit to the haunted house in North Tonawanda. When we went to use them on Nov 11 we see a sign on the door of the place that says the coupons are only honored through Nov 6. The coupon did not have any indication or wording regarding an expiration date. We talked to the counter people but essentially their answer was too bad, it is our prerogative to decide when the coupons expire. Fine, but put something on the coupon if you want to do this. P.S. regarding the food, from the other reviews I can see that the food is not that great nor is the customer service. Good luck in staying in business- you are going to need it. read more

We ordered here the week before and it was great. Tonight the pepperoni and crust were burned. we called. They said we had complained before (over the summer) so there was nothing they could do. The staff said it was a corporate policy! read more

Had a pizza and wings delivered to us to last night and the food was maaaaybe at best a 2/10 quality and ice cold!!! I've never been a fan of Just Pizza and this might have been the nail in the coffin for me for them... read more

Awful. We called to place an order for delivery. The first girl that picked up the phone was straight up rude. She seemed so inconvenienced to be taking our order. All we wanted was there deal of pizza and wings. Half hot and half garlic parm. We asked can you do extra garlic parm so that the wings are saucy. They said sure. Once halfway through our order the girl said hold on we've got to start the order over, her reasoning I still do not know, the order was simple. Then after holding a new girl picks up and starts our order all over again. Then right before we give her our credit card number she asks us to hold. Then after holding for a second time a new girl picks up the phone and starts asking us questions about our order that we already told the previous two girls. So we talked to a total of three people and did our order twice one the phone just for 1 cheese and pepperoni pizza with 20 wings. What a joke. Never once did we receive a sorry or an acknowledgement that they were passing the phone to a different person. We eventually got our wings, but what a joke. Completely over done and as you can see from the pic they look like plain fried wings. No butter and no parm in sight. Disgusting never again. read more

Just Pizza - Garlic parm wings, disgusting - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

I come literally everyday and this Just Pizza has nothing but greatness when you walk in. I'm greeted by the amazing owner of this store and always leave smiling and laughing. They know my order every time. Also they always have slices fresh. The employees behind the owner make sure that the restaurant runs smooth. I just am so happy with the service and connection I get from this place. Thank you guys so much for always going above and beyond to make your customers and me happy. read more

The owner's daughter, Stacey (who is also the manager), is very rude and thinks it's okay to berate elderly customers. There have been many complaints about her behavior but the owner won't do anything. Guess she condones her daughter's behavior. Mistakes happen when you're preparing orders, but you best not tell Stacey your order is incorrect or she'll get nasty with you either on the phone or at the pizzeria. read more

Just Pizza (NFB) used to be my go to pizza place, tonight was the last time I'll be ordering from there. I dont know if its all locations, but their customer service and their quality has gone way down. I've had better pizza from 7-11 (that burnt, cleaning chemical tasting pizza), and I never eat that on purpose because its horrible. This particular pizza was under done, the pepperoni was haphazardly thrown about the pizza, with 3 to 4 slices ending up on top of one another. This place needs new management. read more

Just Pizza - a pizza in a box with a spatula - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

Called to report pizza made as if someone in a hurry, ordered a large pepperoni pizza, some slices had no pepperoni and others had multitudes, pizza was cut some tiny tiny slices and others huge slices. Reported to manager and was told it was door dashes fault! NOT, read more

Pizza is GREAT!!! Garlic crust. Perfection. We also ordered 50 wings and they let us split the bucket into 5 flavors. The honey sesame charred wings were my favorite. We also tried Bourbon Honey Mustard, dry Rub Cajun, BBQ, and medium original style. The medium was lacking in heat and flavor but beside that- we were more than impressed. Might be our new go to wing place! read more

La Nova's, Bocce's, Zetti's, Santora's, Romeo and Juliet's, Pizza Plant, Pizza Works, Pizza Junction, John's, Papa John's, Casa-Di-Pizza, Prima Pizza, Mr. Pizza, Daddio's Pizza, Wiseguy's Pizza, Avenue Pizza, Bob and John's...the list goes on and on and on and on and on. Buffalo has THOUSANDS of pizza places that deliver and most of them are pretty damn good. By and large this area has some of the finest local pizzerias around...and most of them make pretty remarkable wings to. So why should I pick one pizza place over another? Just Pizza* has created one food item that is soooo spectacular the idea of it makes me instantly salivate: Three Cheese Steak and Cheese Pizza with Hot Peppers and an onion crust. AMAZING!! I have ordered this pizza multiple times from multiple locations and it has always been amazing. THIS IS FOOD PORN... A square-sliced pizza with a thin crust which is covered with tiny bites of chewy carmelized onions. Savory and well seasoned pieces of thin cut steak, mushrooms and hot banana peppers are smothered in three distinct cheese. While I am unsure of what the actual cheeses are my best guess is Mozzerella for stretch and chew, Monterey Jack for creaminess and Parmigiano Reggiano (the undisputed king of cheeses) for flavor. Of course, it could be provolone, white American and Piccorino Romano...but the effect would be just about the same. Point being, this is the perfect blend of cheese (and meat) each creating a synergy of deliciousness!! I don't get take-out very often and I hate to splurge calories on pizza, but if I gotta...I mean really gotta...for me there is no other choice then this amazing slice of Buffalo food porn. *They also do a great job on their pit wings (BBQ Wings fried then char grilled)...though La Nova still makes the best. read more

Tonight with my kids home for Thanksgiving we ordered the Super Saver 4 for $38.35 with an upcharge on one more topping for one of the pizzas. When my kids went to pick up the pizza and wings they charged us $72. When my boys went back in to complain they gave them $6 off. The girl at the counter told them it happens constantly that the prices are wrong on multiple sites but they haven't had them changed. We will never again order from Just Pizza. And I suggest that no one else orders from this store either. read more

I've tried this place on numerous occasions by recommendation of some family and some of their food is good like the fish fry/subs and some random others. However their customer service is horrible.The spray tanned woman in her late 30s with her hair always up (who must be the sister of the owner blonde haired woman who works there) had a very snarky,condescending tone with me in there when they made my order Incorrectly. She is rude and has no right to treat people so poorly when they go there to spend their money. There are plenty of other pizza places without he attitude to spend out money at. Edit: as far as the food it wasn't that big of a deal and I would have gladly paid again for it to be done as I ordered it, but obviously they don't want the money. Food 4/5 stars Staff 0/5 stars if I could read more

Honey Garlic BBQ wings = good Cajun dry dusted: yuck Pizza: still out for the verdict We ordered their one large pizza one topping And double order of wings. Best thing about it was the HG wings. The pizza smelled honest to god weird. It had fake bacon on it. And the Cajun wings tasted burnt. We haven't tried anything else from this location, so there may be other stuff here that's good. But if you are going somewhere for pizza or wings, go somewhere else. read more

I would give 0 stars if possible!!! Pizza is nowhere as good as other locations!!! STACEY, the MANAGER, is very unprofessional!!! When I came to pick up my order, I heard her using all types of profanity!!! I asked who the manager was, and it was her. I didn't even bother to say anything right then. Will never order from here again!!! read more

Skimped on toppings, overpriced, there are so many other amazing pizza places around - skip just pizza and go somewhere good. We did a blind pizza taste test with several local places, I literally thought the pizza from Just Pizza was from a buffet. It sucked and it was embarrassing for the person who brought it. read more

My favorite pizza by far here is the steak and cheese and I love to stop and get a fresh slice! I love to get party pizzas for gatherings because they're are so many different favors to be devoured! The staff is always professional and friendly! read more

I don't know what's up with all the bad reviews. This was my first time going there, it wasn't bad. I ordered a veggie pizza half of it with no onions the other half no Olives White sauce and sesame seed Crust, and they got it right and it tasted good. Only thing I didn't like is that you feel rushed when you are on the phone but I think that anywhere, but overall customer Service experience was good. read more

Very disappointed on how my pizza wasn't cooked all the way through I had to place it in my oven for 6 mins to fully cook the dough throughout .... I expect it to be cooked on arrival. Probably won't go back again. read more

Extremely unprofessional and disrespectful. We made a Grubhub order and apparently they didn't have any of the things I ordered that were listed. The Grubhub driver was calling me trying to get it figured out and the loser employees kept yelling at him and refusing to help him fix the order. As i was on the phone, I had The driver ask the one employee how many slices were in a large pizza and he replied "I DONT KNOW!! MAYBE YOU SHOULD LOOK AT THE MENU". Disgusting people and disgusting service. They let the driver sit there for 45 minutes on purpose. They also made him leave and refused his service for whatever reason. Don't go to this trash place. read more

I went in person Thursday night. Ordered a Jumbo pizza to be delivered on Friday afternoon at 12:30. Paid cash and tip for the driver. It needed to be there for a work crew. I called at five after one and they said 10 more minutes. Arrived 1 hour and 10 minutes late at 1:40 Very disappointed in their service. I won't be patronizing them again. read more

One star is way too much for this horrible place. After reading some of the reviews from other yelpers this place have a history of being rude!!!! I called this location on Monday November 6 at 11:30 to place a large order for my employees. The women who answered the phone was rude. Her name was Mary. I told her she is not so friendly over the phone. She got really nasty and told me I don't need to place an order from her and hung up the phone on me. I called back she told me she will not take my order. I asked to speak to the manager. She hung up on me 4x. On the last call she said she is the manager and I can't complain to anyone. I told her I will call the Cheektowaga location to get the information who I need to contact. She called me a bitch!!! I can't even believe she said that over the phone! I got in my car and showed up to the location and asked to speak with her. She said I was calling the Cheektowaga location to place an order. Really!! Cheektowaga location is going to deliver to Amherst. I told her no I was calling the Cheektowaga location to get the information who I can contact to file a complaint. She told me she didn't care who I complain too. The whole situation got ugly from there. My husband took me out of the store and he called the store and asked to speak to the owner. Mary said she was the owner and hung up on him. We are beyond disgusted it's got so trashy on both ends. All we were trying to do was buy lunch for our staff. This was beyond unprofessional! I emailed someone at the business office by the name of Mark. He forwarded her the email. she decided reply to my email that was never sent her and calling me a lier! I screenshot her email read more

Just Pizza - Mary is so rude and nasty! Zero customer service! - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

Ordered cheese and pepperoni pizza on garlic crust and some wings...pizza was burned on the bottom and cheese melted..not cooked on top...wings not so great either... will not be ordering there again. read more

Are you kidding me?!!!! I have tried to be patient with this place but enough is enough. The location at Colvin and Eggert in Tonawanda has a drive thru for slices. The problem is, more often than not they are out of slices. This has happened to me four times in the past year or so. How can a place called Just Pizza ever be out of cheese and pepperoni pizza?! It reminds me of the Cheese Shop sketch from Monty Python. Look it up and you will understand. read more