Great Buffalo style pizza and wings. I wasn't expecting much due to the unassuming location but I must say that the pizza is as good; if not better, than the big guys. Do yourself a favor and stop in and give them a try. read more

My wife and I bought a cheese and pepperoni sheet with 50 wings for a 30th birthday party and everyone loved fatmans!! We will be coming back many more times for their quick service and great food!! read more

Fatman's Pizza - Bacon bbq and medium wings!!! - Pizza Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

See all

1st timer.the pizza was just ok.the top was cooked just right but the bottom was way undercooked almost doughy.lots of cheese but didnt taste like it should have.when you teenage girl didnt like it what more car i say . read more

I love Fatman's! It is a staple in this area and a sure thing with great pizza & wings! TheRoyal Sub is pretty damn amazing too! The owner and staff always provide great service so you'll always be happy with your order... A big believer in Local businesses so want to support great places like this. read more

Sooo a fellow Yelper won an award for the most updated reviews and it seemed to be for this place. With that type of promotion WHY NOT .... We perused the menu and it appears they have a lot of specialty pies you can order and the coolest thing was that they allow you to do a "split" ...yes you read that right. Pick a specialty pizza and if you are stuck like me between making a decision ....then you select 2 and split so you can try them both. And that is what we did. When we called to order the guy was like "I can do that, no problem" Steak and cheese, along with a Sriracha basil pie ... and OMG I will admit the crust was a bit thicker and on the doughy side ...just a tad bit more than I am accustomed...but the flavors were dead on. There was a great mix of spice and tangyness. The steak and cheese was delicious. It had flavor and the meat was great. I would have liked the peppers a bit smaller, but the ingredients were evenly distributed and tasteful. We have been stepping outside the box trying to find another favorite pizza place ...so I am glad I gave this one a chance. Pick up was simple and easy. The guys were pleasant and in the zone making pies. We will be back. read more

Fatman's Pizza - Our split pie - Pizza Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

See all

Very good authentic WNY pizza. Fair price. In a tiny location in a small strip plaza on Niagara Falls blvd near the creek

K. So I went in there today.. and BOMBACLAAAT was the food BUSTING!!! As soon as I walked in I immediately networked and felt an intense connection with the cashier, I have never had a pizza experience taste so good. I also met an avid Fatman enjoyer by the name of Muhammed, who has been going there every Friday for over 7 YEARS! Good lord. The pizza was good though can't lie had the maple bacon wings as well. Very interesting to say the least.. Expect my return with my multiple connections in the future. read more

Finally got to check out this pizza place. We ordered a large pizza, half meatball half sausage and char BBQ chicken fingers. I really liked their sauce and it was very cheesy. The char barbecue fingers were great. I was turned off by the smell of cigarettes in the restaurant and seeing all the guys rolling pizza dough without gloves, but I think a lot of pizza places don't wear gloves which is kind of gross. Prices were pretty fair. read more

Fatman's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

See all

We were looking for a new pizza place and thanks to Yelp we found this gem. Driven by here a million times yet never thought twice about stopping, and now I'm sorry that I didn't! We got a cheese and pepperoni pizza and a meatball parm sub and both were outstanding! First of all the small pizza was anything but small, the size of most mediums and some larges. Ample amounts of sauce, cheese and pepperoni on top and the crust was on point! Sauce was on the sweeter and thicker side which is how we like it. The meatball sub had 7 good sized meatballs on is and plenty of sauce which had the same sweetness as the pizza sauce. Definitely a place we will go to again!! read more

Fatmans is one of the best pizza places in Buffalo without a doubt. The epitome of "Buffalo style" pizza, with hands down the best sauce of any pizzeria in WNY. Absolutely love it and always look forward to getting it. read more

I had Fatman's for the first time during the AFC Championship game. Although the Bills couldn't get the win, I won't forget how UNBElIEVABLE this pizza was. The pizza was thick (Buffalo style), with the perfect amount of cheese and some of the best sauce I've ever had. Fatman's is now easily in the top 3 in Buffalo and might even move to my #1 spot. Service was excellent and it was delivered right on time! The pizza was still piping hot even after delivery. I wish I could give this place 100 stars! read more

Another Saturday, another fantastic pizza from Fatman's Pizza! As usual, the service was friendly and efficient. I called and placed an order for pickup on a Saturday around 5pm. I paid for my pizza over the phone with my credit card and was told my order would be ready in 25 minutes. When I arrived 25 minutes later, one of the employees came out to my car, with a facemask on, and asked for my name and what I ordered, then promptly brought it to my window - I don't think I was in their parking lot for more than two minutes! Now onto the good stuff. I ordered a small (12", eight slice) Poor Man's Lasagna pizza. My goodness, this pizza was delicious! To start off, I LOVED the fresh ricotta cheese - It adds so much flavor and the soft texture of the cheese makes the pizza creamy and a joy to eat. The melted mozzarella on top of the ricotta though pushes it to the next level, adding even more melty goodness and helps to keep the toppings in place on each slice. The chopped meatballs on top were phenomenal - Huge chunks that were incredibly tender and had the perfect balance of flavor and spices. Their garlic marinara sauce pairs perfectly with the toppings on this pie but it doesn't come off overly garlic-y. They also added a little herb and spices, nothing overbearing, on top of the cheese, which I thought was a nice touch. Their crust is excellent where it definitely steers more toward the Buffalo-style with being a little thicker/doughier, but this place has it so it isn't too thick and doughy, while maintaining that great chew and texture. This pizza truly does taste like you're eating a piece of lasagna! The size of the small is perfect for a big appetite like mine where you could eat it all in one sitting but not full over full (I usually skip lunch on Saturdays in preparation though :) ). This pie is definitely denser than other specialties on their menu, but I hope they don't change that, this pizza is perfect as is! A few pro-tips though: I recommend throwing the pizza into your oven, at 400 degrees, for about ten minutes when you get home as this will heat up the pizza, crisp up the crust a bit, and brown the cheese on top making it nice and gooey. Also, I ordered this pizza to be sliced into six slices instead of eight as I like having a bigger slice. I will definitely ask for my pizza to be cut into six slices from here moving forward. Fatman's Pizza once again comes through with a great specialty pizza! They've easily become my favorite pizza place in Buffalo. read more

See all

It's easy to miss this spot when you're driving down the boulevard, but is definitely worth looking into. We ordered the honey sriracha pizza with pepperoni and a small Cesar salad. The pizza was excellent, I especially liked their crust and the subtle heat from the sriracha. The croutons on the salad were definitely made fresh, but they were a little too oily for me. Customer service over the phone and in the restaurant was friendly and polite. Looking forward to coming back and trying more of the menu in the future. read more

Fatmans was mentioned on a WYRK post about then a fiend told me how good it was. WOW, first time we ordered was last night. Pizza was great. Love the sweet sauce. Pizza was thick with good crust and lots of cheese. A good amount of pep but not too much! NICE! read more

Stumbled across this place on a Step Out Buffalo page of underrated restaurants to try. Its on Niagara Falls blvd and I pass it every day and never knew it was there. They have a large menu and their prices seem to be a bit lower than competitors for what they offer. I must say their boneless bites were some of the best I have had in the area! I asked for them crispy and saucy and unlike most places that don't care, they were perfectly done. I will definitely be back and highly recommend! read more

Fatman's Pizza - Honey Sriracha Pizza (with garlic crust) - Pizza Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

See all

Ordered a variety of items to split with friends for a game. Everything came nice and hot! We ordered a Buffalo chicken pizza, a pepperoni pizza, bbq wings, and breadsticks. I thought everything tasted really good! I particularly liked the breadsticks. I would definitely recommend. read more

If they sold envelopes it'd be Flap Man Pizza. If they took a lot of criticism it'd be Flak Man Pizza. If they were popular for only 5 minutes, they'd be Fad Man Pizza. And if they were owned by a guy with a moustache who ran a questionable empire in Central Europe in the early 1940s, they'd be Fascist Man Empire, and probably wouldn't make very good pizza. But they do. They make wonderful pizza. And sensational sub sandwiches too... especially the chicken finger. Mmmmmmm. What to get: Pizza & Chicken Finger Subs What else: You can give me a finger but don't give me *the* finger Not only is this some of the best-tasting pizza around (and there's plenty of competition, but this is one of the best), but they also have some of the largest, heaviest and most filling slices in WNY. And don't get me started on the price. How can you only charge $2 and change for a slice twice as big as Franco's $4 slices (which are wonderful, but still). Chicken Finger subs are a Buffalo-WNY specialty, and Fat Man has one of the best 5 in the region. Only Jonny C's, Mike's (Kenmore), Mia Mangia (Transit), and not-sure-about-the-5th can really compare. You have to try a Chicken Finger sub, medium, extra saucy, to know the true wonder of it. Trust me. You'll be converted for life. Excellent service too. The guy running this place is awesome, and the cute girl who served me the other day when I was in here (who seemed new), is really friendly too. Definitely not one of the best-known or most popular pizzerias in this region full of spectacular pizzerias, but absolutely one of the best. Try the aforementioned Franco's, as well as Mattina's and Good Guys (all in the Northtowns), as well as Imperial, Bella and Mineo's (in the Southtowns) and Mr. Ventry's & Pizza Oven up in the Falls for NF Slices. But whatever you do, make sure you get down to Fat Man and try one of these too. And whatever else you do, do not sleep on the Chicken Finger Sub. It's one of the best sandwiches in the region. Nommmmm. Get it medium, extra saucy. Trust in the Fox. And whatever else you do, make sure your slice is heated up. They usually do it without you even asking, here. But just in case they don't - be sure to ask. It's so much better when it's gooey and melty and piping hot out of the oven. Speaking of ovens, would you like a bun in yours? I'm free tonight. read more

See all

My work must really like these guys. Had their pizza this time. Great dough and crust. Sauce was sweet and zesty. Pizza is everywhere in a city like this, but this is definitely a great choice! Hope to try more stuff soon! read more

Fatman's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

See all

I've had a lot of this type of pizza. It's cheesy, cup & char pepperoni, a little greasy (though, not as bad as some), with a softer crust. What makes this pizza solid is the spicy pepperoni, paired with a slightly sweeter sauce and their nicely charred but not overly thick crust. Overall it's a solid WNY style pizza. read more

Fatman's Pizza - Fatman's - Small Double Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

See all

Not too bad. Got a large pizza sliced in squares and a turkey sub! The sub was bomb. Tasty, fresh, and thick lol. My only downside was the pie needed to be put in the oven for 5-10 minutes as it was undercooked. Also, be aware the sauce came pretty sweet. It would be nice to have been warned of that but it almost was too sweet. It's pizza not candy! read more

Fatman's Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza Super Sweet - Pizza Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

See all

3.5/5 I placed an order for pickup / large cheese & pep pizza and a chicken finger sub. I almost couldn't see the location- it was a tiny store front and the sign was hard to see at night. The guy at the counter was nice, but the place is a serious hole-in-the-wall. Definitely no frills. The pizza - * sauce is too sweet for me and kind of taste like canned pizza sauce- i prefer a little more savory and saltier * the dough is soft and super fresh but kind of mediocre not very flavorful * hefty amount of cheese - tyvm * the pepperoni is on point - perfect crisp and taste * I like that they cut them in triangle slices Kind of disappointed with the pizza overall flavor wise - didn't go back for a second slice. Chicken finger sub - * fresh toppings but they forgot the tomatoes * the bread is really good! Prob the best part tbh lol. * I ordered a medium but it didn't taste like medium Would eat oneagain but wouldn't say it's the best I've had. read more

Fatman's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

I ordered a fried Turkey for Thanksgiving. It was delicious. The ordering and service when I picked it up was quick and efficient. Thanks to the staff for working Thanksgiving morning to take care of us. read more

Food - 5 Price - 4 Atmosphere - n/a Service - 5 There are tons of pizza options here in Buffalo New York. But I really think this place has the best pizza. If your new to this establishment I suggest double cheese, pepperoni, and sausage. Also, all flavors of the wings are excellent. Personally, I always go with extra crispy. I also have to confess that I live about 5 minutes away from them so freshness is never an issue. Seriously though, you can thank me later luvs:) read more

Fantastic pizza. Go once and you'll never go to any other place. Great crust and sauce. alway great.

Don't get ripped off by Frankos There prices are fake just to get you in the door. There sad business operations read more

Jeff, thanks for the offer, but we still order from ya. Come to find out none of the other clean their fryers often either, lol. Seriously, we're good and respect for reaching out. read more

Despite an impressive statement claiming to have health and safety of customers at the top of their list, it basically gross inside this place and many employees handle to food with out gloves. When a guy wipes his nose with the back of his hand and immediately goes back to handling food... my advice is DONT GET FOOD HERE read more

We have lived around the corner from this little place for years and never stopped. Hubs and I were hankering for some pizza and I noticed the great Yelp reviews, so we decided to give Fatman's a try. Let me tell you, the reviews are not wrong. I'm Sicilian so I am picky when it comes to pies. It's all (mostly) about the crust and Fatman's did not disappoint. The crust formed a solid foundation for a true Buffalo-style pizza. Crispy, chewy, browned nicely without having to ask for it "overbaked." (Looking at you, Franco's.) The sauce is thicker than I have seen elsewhere. More tomato paste? (Not sure. Don't care. It was delicious!) It's also a bit sweeter than I normally like, but this is not a full sweet sauce...it walks the middle ground nicely and paired well with the spice of the pepperoni and the FRESH mushrooms (because canned are gross). I will definitely return. Sorry it took me 8 years in NT to try it!! read more

Wings were good. Pizza sauce was way to sweet. Crust was good pepperoni was nice and cris

The best sauce around! A little on the sweeter side, not overly sweet. They use fresh mushrooms which I Love! You get a lot for your money read more

After driving by here for years on the way to and from work, finally stopped on the way home. Now, i feel that when it's your first time trying a pizza place, you've gotta go with a plain cheese pizza. If a place can't do that right, all the toppings in the world can't hide poor crust & sauce. With that said Fatman's delivers a solid Buffalo style pizza. Crust is good, not too puffy. The sauce has a hint of sweet. The wings were great! Got 10 hot & extra crispy. They were huge. Sauce had a nice bite. Coulda used a little more crisp, as that aspect didn't quite hold up after the 15 minute drive home. Also got done pizza logs. Good, but smallish. Fatman's kept this Fatman satisfied. Overall a solid 4 for a takeout pizza joint. read more

Thank you Yelp for another great find I needed a few pizzas for a work event. The yelpers pictures attracted me to fat man's Pizza. 2 sheet pizzas with mainly veggies for Ash Wednesday today total was around $50. They offer $10 coupon if you sign up for their text messaging which I did. I met the owner Jeff who is really nice and offered to email me one of their new catering menus which are we taking advantage of soon. Everyone in the meeting like the pizzas that I brought and wanted to know where I picked them up. Thank you Jeff at Fatman's Pizza for the great food at a great price and you're awesome service! I'm sorry I forgot to get any pictures while in the meeting. read more

I had to give two stars just for the croutons! They are without exception THE BEST CROUTONS I HAVE EVER HAD! Can I make an order for just croutons, is that a thing? The telephone customer service and the delivery services were also exceptional, for another two stars. On the flip side and about the fifth star, I must say that the sweet pizza sauce wasn't for me. I'm sorry to say that I couldn't eat it. I'm sure may folks like it, so I chose not to complain. Overall, I think they're great in more ways. So I definitely recommend Fatman's for those who like sweet pizza sauce. read more

This place never disappoints! Pizza is the best around and at a great price. Subs are fantastic. I've tried the royal and the steak and cheese. Both were the best I've had in years. Recently tried a meatball calzone. Spectacular! Took me 3 days to finish it. Give this place a shot. You will look no further when your hungry once you try here. read more

Had a takeout plain cheese pizza. While waiting, I saw the delivery driver came back and started to help out in the kitchen. He submerged his bare hand into a container full of shredded cheese. He didn't have any hairnet or gloves on. He didn't bother to wash his hand after driving and moving boxes around. His face was still wet and the sweat was sliding down his jawline. I was thinking to myself if the pizza was any good, then all is good. But the pizza wasn't good enough to make me forget what I saw. The cheese was underwhelming. The tomato paste has no flavor. The crust was too moist and chewy. read more

This place never disappoints. Since my fiancé and I moved to north tonawanda last year this has been our new favorite. Definitely our go-to!

Amazing stuffed pepper calzone! Would absolutely recommend this place to anyone looking for some good food.

Fatman's Pizza you are totally awesome, I had a wonderful experience here yesterday. Good value for the money. You must definitely try Chicken Finger Sub, you just simply can not go wrong with it. The crew was extremely welcoming and service is impressive. Just what we needed. read more

Not bad. I've had a couple different pizzas here and it's really good... Nice and well done. The sauce is on the sweeter side but its not incredibly rich in flavor. But still you typical rich and good Buffalo pizza. I wouldn't experiment too much though (chicken Finger pizza wasn't very good). read more

This is my families new favorite pizza place. The pizza is delicious! Big crust, perfect amount of cheese, sweet sauce and finished off with their garlic crust... so good! We have also had their fries, wings and fingers. All cooked to perfection and their homemade blue cheese is probably the best in the area. The staff is very friendly and orders are always done on time. read more