I've been here several times over the years, always enjoyed their pies, and even commissioned one with them (had them make a sugar cream pie, my favorite.) Somehow had never reviewed them. In an industrial-park type strip mall, off Maxtown. Nice and open inside, super friendly and helpful staff, plenty of pies on display. Fruit pies, cream pies, and my goal for the day: pot pies. I'd never had theirs, and with cold weather they sounded good. I got a standard chicken (they also have white meat, and chicken with broccoli) and beef. Other options were beef/broccoli/mushroom, I think, and one or two more. They come in small, medium, and large. Small is about what you would get at a grocery. Of course I couldn't resist the sweet pies, but I only got one small one, a win for my health. Coconut cream, for Kid K; I ended up eating half of it, but she loved it too. Pot pies: I got mediums, about 2 servings worth. Very tasty. Sturdy but flaky crust, packed with meat and potatoes and veggies. All pies are in very sturdy boxes. I almost saved one to reuse around the house, they're that good. Definitely will be back. A bit out of my way, and I miss their other locations which were a little more handy for me, but these are worth the detour. read more

Best pies I've ever had!!! I stopped in here on my way home from a work trip. This place has been on my Yelp to-dos for a while, and I was finally in the area. I ordered a seasonal blueberry, cherry, apple with oat crumb topping, a small buckeye, and small butterscotch pies. This is a cute, quaint pie shop that's as straight forward as its name. Service was very quick - I arrived when they had just opened. The pies were incredible. Loved the meringue on the butterscotch. The buckeye pie was very rich and chocolatey! The star of the show was the fruit pie by far! I am trying to figure out what cinnamon they used, because it's amazing. I will be back again sometime! read more

See all

Just pies is so lovely! Their pies are so good and fresh and it's such a good shop with amazing prices. The customer service is amazing and quick, staff so friendly! Shout out to Saundra for great customer service. Best place for your party needs or holiday pies!! I love the banana cream and coconut read more

Sorry to say the pies weren't very good. Frankly the pies at Sam's Club are better. Counter people are helpful but the pies are just less than stellar, especially for the price. The crust was quite heavy and the filling tasted like canned filling. read more

Continuing a long standing Thanksgiving tradition, we spend the holiday with our kids and grandkids in Louisville, KY and our contribution is PIES. The kids and grandkids always look forward to grandpa showing up with pies from Just Pies. I'm usually in line (a really long line) at 8a on Tuesday. This year I didn't get there until about noon. Still had to wait in line but not as long a line as 8a. Still had an excellent selection of pies and I was able to get a large pumpkin and 2 medium apple pies (they were out of large ones). As usual, the pies were delicious and were a hit in Kentucky. read more

See all

Love their pies! Both savory and sweet ones. I only wish they still had a location closer into town. But, when I need housewarming gifts, holiday desserts, or have a serious craving, they're totally worth the drive. (Call early for holiday pies!) read more

If you love pies this is your place to get them. We were going to a dinner party and brought the 8" Buckeye and 8" Three Berry pies and they were a huge hit. The kids LOVED the Buckeye pie. I also got a 6" butterscotch pie for my family. We didn't try any of the savory ones, yet. The lady that helped me was so sweet and nice. read more

Just Pies - 6" Butterscotch - Bakeries Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

The food is very yummy. I don't like pie and I tried the blackberry pie and it's pretty yummy.

Great pies, large variety. You can order on the phone or just stop in. Open every day except Sunday.

There's just two words for Just Pies - Just Go! They make amazing pies. I love the peach/berry Peach Riot, and also enjoy the cream pies - chocolate, coconut, etc. All of the pies are generously filled and ultra fresh. They do and will sell out. Either go early, or you can pre-order, which is highly recommended if you want a certain kind. What I really love is that they make a 6 inch size that's just right for a couple of days of pie for one person as well as full sized! Also, don't sleep on the pot pies. They are fantastic! They make a normal chicken pot pie, a dark meat chicken, and a chicken/broccoli/cheese number, all of which I have purchased multiple times and will again. Again, these come in the small and large sizes. The pot pies are sold frozen, and take about an hour to cook, so factor that into your calculations. Please also note - they do use lard in their crust. While I don't normally eat pork, I do make an exception for the best frigging pie crust in the city. No joke. You can also pick up their wares at some of the local grocery stores around town, so if you see them, take advantage, though a trip to the Mother Ship is always a good idea! read more

The pies are delicious and the staff are so friendly! I love getting the little pies when I want to try one without buying a large one. My favorites are the banana cream and the strawberry cream cheese! read more

This was my first trip to just pies after hearing raving reviews over the past year. It did not disappoint. I had a beef pot pie which isn't at all like the poor pot pies we grew ip with. It was more like a pot roast in a pie crust. It was pure deliciousness. I also purchased an apple crumble pie and the peach riot pie. The peach riot is an amazing pie consisting of peaches, blueberries and cherries. The kids loved it. The apple crumble reminded me of a better version of my moms pie growing up.....shhh...don't tell her but it's true. I'll be back for sure! read more

Just Pies - Perfecto!!! - Bakeries Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

See all

Absolutely amazing pies & my mother is an excellent baker... They are homemade, presentation is excellent, they look like they taste... YUMMY read more

I visited this bakery three times because of the great reviews. I really enjoyed the buckeye pie and french silk pie more than the fruit pies. On the second and third visit I noticed that the crust was a tad salty. A little salty crust on a savory pie I can deal with, but not on a sweet pie. Also, I was looking forward to trying the key lime pie, but I was very disappointed (glad I only purchased the small). For me, this pie really did not have a good flavor--just a strong tartness. I have had better key lime pie from other bakeries. I may make an occasional visit to Just Pies for the buckeye pie, but this will not be one of my favorite bakeries if the crust continues to be salty. Oh, I enjoyed the turkey pot pie . Excellent customer service, and bright and clean store. read more

Great tasting pies. Took friends there and they were pleased with their pies. We would all go again.

Boston Cream Pie was yummy but small- no larger sizes available. Red raspberry pie delish, too!

During our Columbus trip we stopped in and ate ... The Best pie ever!!! Service was great. Ambiance nice. Friendly staff read more

Just pies is amazing! Not only is everything we've tried there so delicious, they are extremely efficient. Based on the line at the door, we normally would have tried another day, but it was for Christmas so we got in line. We were in and out in less than 15 minutes. It was impressive, the number of people willing to wait for a pie. They are the real deal and you won't be disappointed! read more

Pies were great and the chicken pot pie is one of the best you will ever have. They are closed on mondays but other than great place

The buckeye pie was absolutely delicious! It must be one their best sellers as I got the last small pie, and I got there before noon. The pie was lite and not too sweet--just right. I sliced my pie and put in the freezer, and I can actually say, it was even better eating frozen/semi-frozen. It was like eating a pie, ice cream, and candy bar ( peanuts and chocolate chip topping) all at once--what a treat! I can't wait to try some of the other cream pies. I bought a small frozen peach pie, frozen chicken and small turkey pot pie that I have not tried yet. I appreciate them having small pies. Customer service was excellent. Store was bright and clean. read more

I've been to "Just Pies" many times before I moved to Mansfield. Let me tell you ... THEY ARE THE BEST, most DELICIOUS pies !!! You can't go wrong with any of these. Wish they would build one up this way. read more

Yummy! Big selection! A local family business. All different kinds of fruit, cream and even chicken pies! Don't go hungry! Order in advance for holidays. read more

Buckeye pie is to die for - must try. If you are going to try to get their pies around the holidays, make sure you go early as the line is outside the building! read more

Always have loved Just Pies, can't believe I haven't reviewed them before. I used to buy the pies at the bakery of local retail store, The Andersons, but after they shut down have been going to the Westerville location for pick up. My very favorite is their Buckeye cream pie, which has layers of chocolate cream, peanut butter cream, and whipped cream. It's like a bite of awesome. The pie is stacked high, so the slice is huge. The large costs about $17 and feeds about 8-10 people. I have tried their fruit apple and peach pies before as well, and they are equally good. The most recent time I went in was for a pickup during COVID. I had preordered the pie for pickup. They had it ready to go and just an FYI, 3 guests are allowed inside the store at a time. Definitely recommend this place for dessert at home parties. read more

Just Pies - Buckeye - Bakeries Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

See all

I'm so happy I found this place! I ordered a small butterscotch pie for my boyfriend's birthday and he loved it. It's the perfect size for one person to eat over a couple of days. The flavor was delicious and not overly sweet. It was pretty too! A+ for appearance. It was super easy to place an order. I called with my order and was on the phone for probably less than a minute. Pickup was just as easy. The actual store is cute. It's small, but packed with lots of pies and smells fantastic. I'm very pleased with my pie and the price I paid. I will absolutely order from here again. I can't wait to try the lemon meringue! read more

Just Pies - Small Butterscotch - Bakeries Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

Couldn't wait for Thanksgiving to check this place out. Thankfully my friends had a baby so I had an excuse to pick up a pot pie and a sweet pie...then some for myself. Check the hours, I think it runs normal business hours of 9:00 to 5:00 most days. Not as late as you might want it to be. During the holidays they no longer take orders, it's first come first serve. For COVID they have a designated entrance and exit, distance from the counter and a staff member will pull the pie out of the fridge for you then ring you up. They also sell gallons of ice cream to go. Lots of variety of fruit pies, seasonal pies. Check out their website before you head over. Honestly don't know how much they cost each but, I spent $50 got 4 pies and it seemed reasonable. One small buckeye pie (chocolate french silk, peanut butter, and whip cream), two chocolate chip pecan pies (which the staff member mentioned freeze well) I would call these small/average size pies, and a large chicken pot pie let's serve six to eight. I've tried the buckeye so far, crust is light and crispy and the filling has great flavor. Great little place, Glad I finally tried it! Nice for special occasion or a nice treat. I also hear they do seasonal summer pies. ENJOY read more

See all

Hot one of their chicken pot pies and an apple crumble pie for desert. Both were excellent and I would highly recommend. Place is always busy, so plan to get there early for the best selection. read more

Best pies in Columbus! Better than homemade! And way easier!!! The pumpkin pie is especially good.

This spring pie is available for a limited time. What's your favorite pie from Just Pies? The pie of the month is the Lemon Raspberry Ribbon - A ribbon of fresh raspberries nestled between layers of light creamy lemon filling, topped off with swirls of whipped cream with a hint of lemon. The flavors go really well together. The tartness of the lemon sets off the sweet raspberry filling and whipped cream. @ohiofoodlover read more

Just Pies - Lemon Raspberry Ribbon - Bakeries Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

Literally the best pies around!!! They are a must have for all holidays in our household

This is by far the best pie I've EVER had! Even Oprah Winfrey agrees! If you need a pie for a special occasion or a pot pie for dinner; you need to check this out! Artistry and skill are evident in every bite! I personally prefer the key lime pie!!! Yum! read more

See all

Really good pies and good prices. The associates here are very kind and helpful. They always have amazing free samples, and their pies are good every single time, no matter what I get. Easy in and out location, but it doesn't hurt to call and check that your pie is in stock, because they're known to be very good and do sell out!! read more

Great pies. Meat or fruit. Reminds me of the old mountain top pies. Good crust. Don't wait to long on weekend, they go fast. read more

So many pies, it's like pie Heaven. It's all take out. Perfect crusts and fillings. And they have pot pies.

Large selection still available when I stopped in at almost closing time on a weekday, Bought a key lime pie that was Yummy!

Very good and excellent pies very pleased with all their varieties for all different occasions

Om my Just Pie. I had no idea this place was practically in my backyard until a friend mentioned it last year. We tried them For thanksgiving and now Im a Pecan pie snob. Ive started offering to bring dessert if We are invited out as an excuse to patronize JP- not a huge "cream" dessert but the coconut cream & boston creme pie (this is actually a cake ) unexpectedly knocked my socks off - fresh, moist and simply delicious. Coconut pie - velvet flaky coconut-ty and scrumptious. If you are into savory pies - you MUST check out the broccoli & cheese (chicken) pot pie. Sold frozen, bake for 45-60 mins and ooey gooey, chunk meat comfort awaits beneath a buttery flaky crust. Sooo filling read more

Just Pies - Pot pie - Bakeries Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

See all

The place is tucked away in an industrial park. The store was fairly large. The customer service was ok nothing outstanding either good or bad. By the time we got there, they were pretty much out of the popular pies. I liked the Boston Cream pie! We also got a chocolate pie and a Chocolate Mint creation & P.B. Chocolate. The mint was overwhelmingly powerful leaving you breathless! The P.B., one was ok. The crusts however are very crispy over baked and flavorless. I was really disappointed. read more

My experience at Just Pies in Westerville, Ohio on November 20, 2023 RE: Complete lack of customer service, dishonesty, and no remorse. I drove nearly 20 miles from Upper Arlington today and arrived at JP's at approximately 10:30 this morning to pick up two pies, a pumpkin and pecan. I was able to purchase a pecan and was told the next batch of pumpkin would be available within an hour. I couldn't stay or return at 11:30 so the lady behind the counter said no problem, just call and see when the next batch of pumpkin pies will be available. As directed, I called from Lewis Center at 12:45 and was told pumpkin would be available at 2 pm. I drove approximately 10 miles over to Just Pies where I arrived at 1 pm. I went in and asked if they had any pumpkin pies available? They said 2pm but please call. I told them I will be waiting in my vehicle. At 1:30 I went in to check if they might have pies available and an older woman said let me check. She went into the kitchen and when she returned, she said they will be ready at 2pm. Again, I went back out to my vehicle to wait until 2pm. At 2pm I went back into the store and asked to purchase a pumpkin pie and was told they will not be available until 4pm. I explained the above scenario to the ladies behind the counter and all they would say pumpkin pie will not be available until 4 pm and said there was nothing they could do. As I left completely disgusted an enraged an older gentleman overheard me and told me that's exactly what they told him as well over the phone, pumpkin pies will be available at 2pm, he also left with none. And that is precisely why I will never do business with Just-Pies ever again and will tell everyone I know this disturbing experience. read more

Great pies. They are experts at what they make and it's pretty simple to understand........ just pies. Great staff, friendly service, and amazing pies of all types and varieties. I've never bought a pie I didn't eat from Just Pies!!! read more