Used to be pretty good. Loved when it was Caruana's. Pizza is tasteless now. The booths are strangely shoved all together in the middle so it's really tight. Feels like they don't want you to sit & stay. Guy behind the counter made some comments only he thought were funny. Won't go back. read more

The pizza is good and they have a daily special 2 plain with soda for $8 The only thing, I really didn't like the guy was touching the money and make pizza without glove , no hygiene !!! read more

Stopped in to get a slice of regular and a slice of Sicilian. The Sicilian slice is mostly bread and didn't taste like anything much. The regular slice fared a little better. The pizza is overpriced compared to other local pizzerias in the neighborhood. Ironically, it's 12 noon and one person is only here beside me. I think that speaks volumes in itself. read more

Ordered several cheese pies and a margherita pie for delivery. They delivered right on time and called to let me know when they arrived. All pies arrived in perfect condition and were still piping hot! The slices are quite large (8 big slices for an 18" pie) and have the perfect amount of ingredients. The crust was neither too thick or too thin. And the sesame seeds are a great addition to the slice! My friends enjoyed both types of pizza and we'd definitely order from here again! read more

Outrageously over priced pizza for what you get. Nothing special at all about the pizza. Their sesame crusts are tasteless, NOT crispy, and feels like they just toss a mountain of flour on it. They're so many other pizza parlors in the area that are so much better. Avoid this at all costs. read more

Reopened after a couple of years, got a couple of slices of pepperoni pizza. Pizza was good but nothing special. Compared to the neighborhood prices are much cheaper to other pizza shops close by. Service from the staff was quite friendly read more

Joey's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Maspeth, New York

See all

This place is a rip off and way overpriced for no reason even though Rosa's pizza is right across the street from here with much cheaper prices, this place still has the audacity to overcharge, and people are stupid enough to keep going here, for example, you can get spaghetti and meatballs like $5 cheaper at Rosa's pizza across the street, and it's the same exact thing and same exact taste and same exact amount because I had them both, the only difference is, Joeys Pizza will overcharge you like $5 more for the same exact dish. read more

Ate here today for lunch by myself while biking to Maspeth. I had brought and ate the cheese pizza with a can of soda. It was great and delicious. The service there was also fast, quick and attentive that I didn't feel rushed about what to choose a pizza to try for the first time. I couldn't agree more. Finally, I would definitely eat and come back again next time! :) read more

Joey's Pizza - a slice of pizza and a can of soda - Pizza Near Me - Maspeth, New York

the plain slice here is quite honestly the best in all of maspeth. there is also an assortment of various pies and menu items to choose from. The staff is delightful and has been so for years, with each experience as pleasant as the last. read more

Ordered on too good to go, when I arrived they say they sold out and refused to give me my refund. They told me to come back another time for the pizza. I came back another time and they refused to give me my pizza again. Such a scam read more

Great slice very convenient off the q18 bus worth the trip from Astoria good group of people price is reasonable

I always get delivery so not sure about eating in the restaurant. Food is always good. Rigatoni bolognese is my favorite. My kids enjoy the personal margarita pizza. They say it tastes better than the bigger pie. read more

Have dietary restrictions? Don't come here. Get ready for the staff to laugh at you and act unprofessionally. I went inside and asked if they had a simple Sicilian pizza with just tomato sauce and no cheese. The server at the counter said they didn't have any non dairy options so I asked for garlic knots instead. As the server was heating the garlic knots, another coworker asked what happened, and in Spanish the sever told him I asked if they had options without cheese. This guy then laughs out loud. I told the server in Spanish to forget my order, that I overheard their conversation and thought it's not right to laugh at a customer just for asking a simple question. I said they have no idea why I asked, I could be lactose intolerant, vegan, whatever. Customers are allowed to ask about ingredients and share dietary restrictions at a FOOD business. Reasons why someone would ask if something has dairy and/or meat: they are lactose intolerant, religious reasons (Muslim and can't eat pork, Jewish and having kosher ingredients), they are vegan or vegetarian, they have food allergies, they have acne and are avoiding dairy, weight loss goals. and any other reason that's their business only. Is it that laughable to ask for a non-dairy option at a NYC Italian pizzeria? No. Many traditional Italian dishes have vegan options (tomato pasta, pizza marinara, farinata, salad with cheese withheld, polenta, the list goes on). Other pizza spots like Rosa's Pizza carry pizza marinara and other options-- and have staff that are professional and won't laugh at you. This business is making a mistake and missing out on a whole wide diversity of customers. Many pizza spots have vegan and vegetarian options (they substitute with vegan cheese or simply have a slice with just marinara.) I won't be spending my money here or bringing friends or family here. As someone who lives in the neighborhood, I'm insulted and disgusted by their rude and outright mean service. Everyone has a right to think what they want and have an opinion.. In a place of business: you treat customers from all walks of life with respect, no matter what. I was close to half those men's age and have more emotional maturity and common sense on how to treat a person. read more

I first ordered 6 months ago when I moved to this area - it was good (was probably hungry) Ordered a second time weeks later- mediocre I decided to give them one more try today... This pizza is horrible! They market a $15 large pie special but I think they cut back on quality ingredients, as it is awfully difficult to deliver a quality product for that small amount of money. Most great pizza are $22 and up. Anyway, I won't be ordering again and I must say, Maspeth needs a brand new pizza joint. Anybody up for the challenge to open one? read more

See all

Many years ago I was introduced to Joeys Pizza. I kept hearing from friends that lived in Maspeth that it's the best in the neighborhood. I was skeptical because I was already living in Kew Gardens and to me the best pizza in Queens is from Dani's (don't fight me). The first time I went I tried the plain because I think that's the best way to test out a pizza place, by the plain. If that's not good then you can just forget about anything else. When I got my slice I noticed there were sesame seeds on the crust. I was intrigued and delighted after that first bite. I don't know why but I would have never thought of adding sesame seeds to pizza dough. My life was honestly changed after that because I'll go through periods of craving "that-pizza-with-the sesame-seeds". The other day we were running errands and passed Joey's and we had to turn the car around and get a few slices from here. If you are in Queens be sure to try the pizza here, it's honestly worth it. Currently, because of COVID seating is limited to like 2-3 guests but they definitely deliver and pick up is available. read more

Joey's Pizza - BBQ Chicken Slice - Pizza Near Me - Maspeth, New York

Very good for late night eats! We had the Korean wings, and shared a slice of pepperoni pizza. Our food was delivered to our hotel, fresh and satisfying. read more

Kind of speechless. I ordered a personal bbq chicken pie.. I take a bite and I bit into something hard. I spit it out and it is a whole screw. I call the pizzeria and was asked to send a picture to a workers cell phone number ( had no problem doing it) he laughed and said wow.. I was then told to call grub hub to get a refund ..... The lack of customer service is upsetting. Definitely lost a customer. read more

Joey's Pizza - Screw in BBQ Chicken Pie - Pizza Near Me - Maspeth, New York

See all

Usually get it Delivered but lately hasn't been available on the apps? But when it is available its a solid choice for NY pizza slice!

Original owner sold the place.Pizza is not the same quality unfortunately.Sorry to say but I will never eat there again.

Today I tried the mini margarita pie and had to make it known that it is legendary. I'm doing these mini pies once a week now. I should have joeys on retainer. read more

#16 3.5 Sesame seeds on a slice of pizza.... definitely a first for me. It is a very different slice and I see why some will love it and some not so much. Looks like it has been in the neighborhood forever which is a good thing. Very generous portions of cheese, so if you love cheese, this is the spot for you. A slightly imbalanced pizza IMHO, but it was delicious. read more

Joey's Pizza - two slices of cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Maspeth, New York

Great food, great service and real queens pizzas great with the sesame seeds. Pasta is great also. Garlic bread decent

The pizza crust has sesame seeds on top, giving the pizza a little extra nutty flavor! This is a local dive and a lot of the customers come back that the shop workers are familiar with them. Old fashioned style pizza benches and tables much like how I remembered pizzerias to look like! Pre-made boxes are assembled and stacked ear windows. With the way the pizza taste, the box supply should dwindle in no time. The crust is thin, crispy and there is a lot is cheese! The kind that leaves the cheesy smell all over your lips and mouth! A regular slice is $3.50. Support your local businesses! read more

Joey's Pizza - Regular slice. I added the spices. - Pizza Near Me - Maspeth, New York

The pizza here is pretty good, they specialize on the sesame seed style crust which gives it an extra great taste. I really liked their bacon pizza slices and the Bbq chicken slice. It was fabulous. This is a good pizza spot and for the ones who like pizza like that you should definitely add this spot on your list! read more

Loved this place until recently when my go to Meatball Parm hero has been given the "less for more money" treatment. It used to come with 3 meatballs but now they have started using smaller bread and 2 meatballs cut in half. Oh well time to find a other spot. read more

Don't think I can order pizza from another place again. Joeys personal pies are always fresh fluffy and warm when they arrive. Their delivery people are also very lovely and kind!! read more

Joey's Pizza - Personal pizza with pepperoni and peppers - Pizza Near Me - Maspeth, New York

Wow just had the honey mustard chicken slice and I am In love! So much flavor and taste! Crust is unique with sesame seeds and it packs so much extra flavor making this pizza truly stand out! Definitely recommend 5/5 stars!! read more

Joey's Pizza - Honey Mustard Chicken slice - Pizza Near Me - Maspeth, New York

Let's start with the good, there is no good. This place has gone WAY down hill since one of the owners past during the pandemic. The men in that place are absolutely sleezy and talk about every single person walking in young old black white everything in btwn. I've been living in the area for 8 plus years now and have been a decent customer, my family and I. I've had already a issue with one worker there for over hearing him talk disgusting about a friend and I but figured I'd keep going when that person wasn't working,since it's convenient after school for my son and I to grab something real quick. WRONG. The many times I've seen one of the pizza workers go ahead grab money out the register for a transaction touch a cup to give to a customer and THEN handle the food same hand no washing of the hands no glove nadaaa, I should have stopped going then but seeing one more time the other day in your face took the cake ! Repulsing and straight nasty! The pizza isn't great and anything to rant or rave about especially with Rosas down the street OR Phillies in middle village. My mom and step dad have been going faithfully either for take out or in person weekly but I will surely make them aware of everything that's happened in that place. From the unprofessional ways you talk about your own customers and the lack of cleanness, y'all don't deserve to be in business at all. read more

I use to love their pizza but in the last few months the slices are smaller and less cheese and thus I have stopped going and also they started charging taxes on pizza slices sales. I can't understand why many pizza places are making their pizza with less cheese and smaller and think the customers won't notice and keep returning for basically glorified frozen pizza at 4 dollars a slice. read more

Yummy family oriented pizzeria. It opens till very late so that is convenient. For the veggie pizza it was 5.75, kinda pricy for veggies. Always looks busy and the lighting of the store could use some work. read more

Joey's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Maspeth, New York

The pizza is great as I have been coming here for years and years...However I was there yesterday and witnessed the manager (an older white man) belittling all the employees in the store. I found this very unprofessional and uncalled for. It was an older man yelling at the employees telling them that they all don't look like they want to work. Meanwhile no customers were waiting for service. I will never come back because of that terrible experience! read more

This place never disappoints. I've been ordering here for about 8 years and the quality is always on point. You will definitely get your moneys worth. I took a picture of the half pepperoni half mushroom Sicilian pie that I ordered (the dark shaded area on the top left is poor lighting in my kitchen, it's not the pizza) The pizza dough has that delicious fermented yeast taste that I love, it's not a bland dough. The marinara sauce tastes pure of tomatoes and homemade, it doesn't have that acid herb taste from a jar. The garlic knots are also decent. I always order them. I've definitely tried many pizza places around before but I always come back to this place. read more

Joey's Pizza - Sicilian Pie (Top left dark shading is poor lighting, not the pizza) - Pizza Near Me - Maspeth, New York

Love joeys always my go to ! This just a funny review I still love them but cmon guys you didn't cut my pizza today ! Lol read more

Joey's Pizza - Pizza isn't sliced - Pizza Near Me - Maspeth, New York

Very overpriced. $16 for a tiny pizza. It was literally the size of a slice of pozza. Should have called Rosa's.

Their pizza is incredible!!! I've lived here my whole life so I know pizza and when I say this pizza is the best, believe it. Sauce is so flavorful, sesame crust is delightful and my fave, the deep dish, always has the perfect crust. They use the good cheese, so the pizza is not greasy. It's so good. I normally order delivery, but I stopped in today and the pizza is even better straight from their oven. Don't hesitate to try. read more

I can't believe I had to enter this pizza place on yelp! This is my favorite pizza place of all time. I started coming to Joey's 2 years ago since my bf lives in the next town. Whenever I come (at least 2x a month), the bf strikes up a conversation with the owners (two brothers) since they go back a few years. The owners even recommended a good travel agency to us. There are always families and cops eating here so you know this pizza is delish. This is the only place I know of that has sesame seeds in the pizza crust. Myself, being a lover of sesame, can hardly contain myself with the thought of coming here. I've only had two types of pizza here, the chicken parm slice and eggplant slice. I'm not a fan of too much cheese so I always tell the guy not to add cheese before putting it in the oven. I also like the "older" slices vs. the slices that were freshly made so it's not as gooey. Make sure to put all the seasonings on, garlic powder, chili flakes, basil and enjoy! There's this big fat man that is always here everytime I go. I don't know what he does but he's always reading the paper or just "hanging out." I wonder if they pay him to sit here-that's why I'm taking one star away. If you are ever in the middle village or maspeth area, this place is a must for pizza. read more

We ordered a pepperoni and mushroom pizza with a sesame seed crust ... it was outstanding they definitely know how to make a great pie . Delivery was quick and Pizza Hit the spot. Can't wait to order again from this place . read more

I used to be a Rosa's fanatic as a little girl... but I have made the big "switch". Now, if it's not Joey's I don't want it! The staff is always so friendly and I can depend on them for the classic New York Slice. I never ate the crust on any of my pizza - until I tried the sesame crust here. Now I can't get enough. I recommend the Honey Mustard Chicken slice but anything is delicious. read more

It was really delicious the crush was so soft . The pizza excellent . I love the pizza . I will try to order it again

A great old school pizza shop. This place looks straight out of the 70s. The pizza has a nice sesame seed crust. Plenty of seating and a wide variety of pizza as well. read more