Went here with a group of friends, and we brought our old friend who is in a nursing home We had a very nice server who was very attentive to all of us, which included five of us in the party The chicken wings we ordered, medium, or absolutely delicious! They were very meaty, and the medium buffalo sauce coating them was definitely on point, along with the blue cheese dressing served on the side We also ordered a large Jim's special pizza, which consisted of hamburger, sausage, peppers, onions, mushrooms, which was thick like a Greek style This was a large enough pie to feed five of us with two pieces to bring home. Nice job Jim's. The pie was $23 for the special, and I think it was $13 for the buffalo wings. We tipped generously because we stayed there a little bit overtime, speaking with our friend that we took from the convalescent home for a few hours I look forward to coming back here. It's definitely worth multiple visits. read more

See all

They have gone down hill in the last couple of years. I stopped going Spring of 2025. At that time, it seemed as if they experienced staff turnover. The wait staff would place my order with the kitchen staff and it would come to my table incorrect. My favorite dish is Veal Franchese. Very simple to make. One time, the veal was not fresh and tasted off. I sent it back and ordered something I really DID NOT want. The pizza is ok. My lamb Gyro is usually wrong. Their most experienced waitress moved on to a better opportunity which was awesome for her and bad for Jim's. We used to go there a lot 10-years ago. Now, I stick with a place I know that is not Italian. I have been to three other Italian establishments in Windsor. Not happy with all four in total. I am a pretty easy going person as someone who eats out infrequently. When I have to send things back and wait 20-30 minutes for a simple dish and order something I am not happy with; it was time for me to go elsewhere for a decent Italian meal. The ambiance is lacking as well, unless they completely redecorated. It is a "family" style restaurant. So no cozy, intimate ambiance. Especially at night. It's loud, impersonal and the ladies room needs to be stocked and checked. Thankfully, I carry wipes and hand sanitizer. Hopefully, they have upped their game since Spring of 2025 considering all the new housing being built in Windsor. Considering I drove past the middle of last week around lunchtime and there was one car in the parking lot; I'm not holding out hope. Good luck finding a decent real, Italian Restaurant in Windsor. I have yet to find one. read more

Stopped in a few days ago, returning from Wethersfield. Was seated by Nisha, who was excellent, handling two large groups (and me). The turkey club I ordered was different, but also excellent. Different in the sense that it was served on thinly sliced and toasted Italian bread. It was also Dagwood-sized, and my pearly whites had a difficult time fitting it in my biggggg mouth (as Ralph Kramden would say). Turkey, lettuce, tomatoes, and bacon all in abundance. Came w French fries and some pickle medallions. Very tasty and reasonably priced. One more thing about Jim's. In business since 1966, and does a lot for the community. As one example, a few years ago, Jim's donated an enormous amount of food at a benefit to help a cancer survivor pay medical and other bills. Kudos to them always! 4 and 1/2 stars read more

See all

This is absolutely a go-to spot for classic REAL pizza. Not talking NYC style, thankfully!! You won't find it fancy, but if you're about old school New England pizza this place is a must. read more

Our first try there we sat in the dining room. The wait staff was friendly enough, though it was very confusing to me why they wanted to know if we wanted ice in our beverages. Next, my granddaughter order plain ravioli with sauce on side; the staff was so confused about what we were asking for. They apparently only bake their ravioli dish and couldn't understand that we just wanted them boiled. After all that, the raviolis were a bust Our second time was a call in order to try their pizza. I order the pizza and when I got there, they repeated an order to me that had an item I didn't order. When I said there must be a mistake, I was met with hostility and how I was wrong and that is what I ordered! Wow! They begrudgingly made another pizza, for which I still tipped, apologized for any confusion on my part and still can't even meet halfway! And they refused the tip!!! I dare say, that is the last trip for us. read more

I was in desperate need of a grinder and decided to give Jim's a chance! They deliver so with lunch time typically being nap time at home I don't get out much! I would have loved a cappicola grinder but they didn't have any so I settled and got an Italian combo grinder and it was so perfect and HUGE! I added banana peppers and oil and vinegar and it was the PERFECT combo! Hopefully they get cappicola back and add that in too next time! Their hot Buffalo wings are so good as well! read more

Jim's Pizza - Italian Cold Cut Grinder - Italian Near Me - Windsor, Connecticut

Got take out twice. The first time, both the Italian sub and the eggplant sub were the best my family has eaten in a long time. First time was better than our second take out. so concerns about consistency makes me hesitant to go back read more

I stopped by this place for lunch and wanted to try the pizza. The place itself was spacious clean and pretty empty. The pizza was piping hot and fresh and tasted delicious. I will say it was a bit salty possibly from the toppings but overall the service was great and the food was delicious read more

Jim's Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Italian Near Me - Windsor, Connecticut

I ordered a large pizza from them and paid $25 for it... Ended up being a mere 16" pizza. Horrible quantity for the price. Called to complain and after being 'on hold' (heard all conversations ), then they hung up! Will NEVER order from there again. read more

Jim's Pizza - You can see how tiny some of the 12 pieces are. The new owners are a disgrace!! - Italian Near Me - Windsor, Connecticut

A fall from a once great place! The antipasto was atrocious. All iceberg, very little olives and meats. The pizza was bland and nothing like from previous management. Wings were a sad representstion of a popular appetizer. Will not return read more

Jims is our favorite local pizza for dining in and take out. The staff is always friendly and patient even when they are super busy and the dining room is a really big place we have never waited for a table, it is clean and comfortable. I recommend the vegetable soup and Greek Salad with chicken. read more

Awesome Italian restaurant in Windsor center! Plenty of dining room space and tasty Italian food. read more

Jim's Pizza - Large antipasto salad. Yummy! - Italian Near Me - Windsor, Connecticut

See all

Pros Accommodating with letting me bring in dessert Private room Real plates for the pizza Staff was available Pizza price was very reasonable Cons Don't order your food for an event there in advance...I ordered four party size pizzas and they weren't even warm...you could look at them and tell they weren't warm...when you're in the moment of an event you don't really think about it...however, looking back the next day I realized I should have ordered upon arrival and waited the 30 or so minutes for it to come out...they clearly cooked these well in advance of our party and didn't bother to even warm them up before serving...not happy about that. read more

I ordered a large cheese pizza and the cashier told me that it looked over done and it was no problem to make me a new pizza. They did and this one was a lot better looking and it tasted so good. She was so nice and didn't think it was a burden at all to do it she wanted me to be happy. It's so nice to be treated like I matter as a customer to them. read more

Great pizza not a fan of the grinder. Buffalo chicken pizza is so good. Staff was nice and friendly

Popped in for lunch today. They have three pretty good sized dining rooms, two were empty and the one I was seated in had three tables of customers. They feature a very broad basic menu - soups, salad, wings, calzones, Greek, Italian, chicken, veal, steak, fried seafood, sandwiches, pizza, grinders, and wraps. I had a chicken barley soup and a half turkey grinder. The soup was very good -nice chunks of chicken in a thick comforting sea of reddish broth and barley. Room for improvement? Yes it was just lukewarm. The half grinder was solid- nicely toasted roll with shredded lettuce, ripe tomato slices and a generous supply of deli turkey (not slimy like a prior review mentioned). The server was polite, pleasant, and smiley. It's not gourmet dining, but if diner comfort food rings your bell, you should enjoy the tune Jim's plays. read more

See all

Stopped in after doing a Google search for local pizza places. It sits in the middle of a neighborhood and wow!!! What a great meal! They have a wide variety on the menu but my husband and I chose the classic Italian pizza. Yummy!!! The service was great...the one lady serving the sitting area was very nice and helpful in making choices. The pizza was absolutely delicious! Fresh ingredients and homemade. Will definitely visit again if ever in the area! read more

Jim's Pizza - Italian pizza made with ricotta, spinach and sausage - Italian Near Me - Windsor, Connecticut

I ordered calamari and an Italian sub from Jim's restaurant. Calamari was fried perfect. The grinder I saved for the next day, but the little piece I tasted was good. Delivery was on time I would order from there again. read more

Love this place and the service. Generous portions that are always fresh. Great place for families and large groups. Highly recommend.

Came for an event, and I wasn't overly impressed. However it was nice inside and there was plenty of seating. I tried to cut them some slack because they were hosting two events at the same time, but when we arrived none of the food was ready yet. The wings looked like they had been sitting out for a while because the sauce had a slight film to it. The pasta in Alfredo sauce with chicken and broccoli was good, but the pizza was lacking. Maybe I'm just spoiled with pizza, but it tasted like something you'd get at Chuck E Cheese. I only came for the event and won't be making a trip back. read more

Lunch time my daughter wanted to eat pizza. We try the Italian bright.(small ) taste perfect. There is a waitress beautiful, lovely and smile always. We wait a little time as all the pizza are made on order. read more

Jim's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Windsor, Connecticut

See all

Just came back from celebrating my mom's birthday here, after I've been here once with a group to hang out and have ordered takeout pizza before. We ordered an extra large Italian Delight pizza, one that has mozzerella, ricotta, garlic, olive oil, spinach and sauces. The pizza was delicious, our server Rob was excellent and attentive, and we all had a great time. The only reason I'm giving it a four star is because unfortunately we did notice one empty teacup on a table and empty sugar packets were on the ground, it should have been cleaned up. read more

The pizza is okay. I called today to get delivery and she told me they were no longer delivering for the nite because they had to many so they stopped early! What in the name of business? I was disappointed because I called a whole house and 20 mins before closing! So you would turn me down as a customer because you have too many? Where is this done? Very unprofessional...she didn't even apologize! She said it like my order didn't mean a thing! Will not be supporting this subpar pizza business who does not value its customers! read more

I ordered a chicken parm family dinner for my daughters birthday and when I went to pick it up yesterday it was given out to the wrong customer. I was upset and aggravated and started to cry. My boyfriend went inside and talked to the lady and she quickly offered to make another family meal and have it delivered to my home. By the time I got home he was approaching my house with the hot food. I couldn't thank them enough. highly recommended read more

Really good food and healthy menu options. I ordered the Chicken Athenian and it was both tasty and a generous portion. The garlic bread is also very good -- not oily like in many other places. I am rating 4 stars only because they seem short staffed, for such a busy place -- the service may be a bit slower. read more

Great family run restaurant, with awesome service and great tasting food. We try to go regularly, and especially enjoy the Fisherman's Platter . Can't wait till we can eat table side again , but until then preorder and pick up is working great . All safety precautions taken , with social distancing and masks ... keep up the great service ... we'll keep coming back... Mike & Pat read more

Pizza is ok but service has gone downhill mostly with takeout. Many times pizza is not ready when promised and sometimes rushed and undercooked. Lots of other options around. read more

jims is usually our favorite neighborhood pizza I've gone here since I was a baby, but the last three times we got it, we all got food poisoning, I didn't think anything the first two times thinking maybe it's something else we ate or we had a stomach bug but no we tested the theory and turns out we were right. we got a buffalo chicken pizza a few nights ago and have all been violently sick since. food taste great until it's coming up a second time. read more

Had the veggie soup and spinach pie tonight! Awesome! I would definitely go back. Has a casual family feel about it.

I did not like Jim's. I ordered a chicken orzo soup and a turkey club grinder. The soup was so thick, almost a clam chowder consistency, which makes me think it was sitting there all day. The turkey on my grinder was slimy. My boyfriend got the fish and chips an thought it was terrible. He is used to getting fish and chips at this great restaurant we go to and you could clearly see the difference in the freshness of the fish. This fish had a gray, dull, almost translucent look to it. Horrible, I will not be back. read more

Jim's pizza windsor ct! Food is so delicious! Every time I go I am never disappointed!! Great family restaurant! I always get my pizza there and I live in suffield.. worth the drive... John Grace read more

Jim's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Windsor, Connecticut

Jim's is a pizza place. If you're going for something else, you're going to be disappointed. The wings suck-- to put it nicely, and I wouldn't touch the fish with a ten foot pole. But Jim's has by far the best pizza I've ever had in my life. The crust is the PERFECT thickness, crusty on top but chewy and it doesn't get soggy if you leave it in the fridge for a few days. Ha, if it LASTS a few days. The toppings are perfectly proportioned to cheese and sauce. I've NEVER had a bad pizza here. My favorite is the Italian Delight...but the house special is great. My sister is a vegetarian and the meat-free pizzas do not leave you wanting. I cannot say enough good thing about the pizza here! Best in Windsor. read more

We now live in Southington but lived in Windsor for years! Jim's was a family favorite! We were in the area tonight and went back! The renovations to the dining room are very nice. We enjoyed delicious spicy wings, calzones, pizza and seafood. The service was great and we enjoyed being back at Jim's! read more

One word will describe my entire experience here: phenomenal. I got manicotti, delicious. My sister got ExCheese pizza, my mom got chicken Parmesan, and my dad got eggplant Parmesan. They all agree that it was delicious. P.S. I am ten years old. read more

Good was generously portioned and tasty. Service was fast and sincere. Family style dining with family run biz. Had simple pizza, pasta with meatball....they were both really good, the red sauce was really nice home made. Keep in mind, food was tad salty. read more

Nicely refurbished interior. However, waited 45 minutes for a small pizza and was told the "oven is slow today". They should not have opened if the oven was not functioning. read more

I wanted to give it three stars, but my grandmother is a raving fan and I put on an extra star for her. My grandmother absolutely loves their pizza. She always gets the same thing: cheese and pepperoni. I always get the GLUTEN FREE Hawaiian pizza. It's always delicious. Word of caution: the gluten free pizza always has one or two slices which are too cooked and stick to the pan. The toppings fall off easily on the gluten free pizza, but that is not necessarily their fault. At first glance, it may look like your pizza is skimpy on the toppings, but worry not--Jim's puts the majority of its toppings UNDER the cheese. Not sure why, but it's still there, and still tastes great. Tried Jim's originally based on a friend's suggestion and was not disappointed. DELIVERY: They do deliver, but only to some areas. Call and ask first before wasting time with your order. Their delivery is pretty fast and thorough. Beware: if you're going during the day and there's a bunch of old people, DO NOT talk about politics. They WILL stare at you intently the entire time. Lmao. read more

The pizza, calzones, and Greek salad were all very good. The wings were about the worst I've ever had - cold (I sent the 1st batch back), dry. It's hard to make wings disappointing, but they succeeded. They were bought precooked and frozen I'm sure and heated in the microwave or possibly the oven and then doused in sauce. My wife's chicken piccata was the worst ever. She's not one for sending food back but admitted later that she should have. I tried to bite and it was the driest worst chicken I've ever eaten way worse than the wings even. Granted my wife asked for it to be gluten-free so not coated with flour, but that's no excuse. Whatever food can't be cooked properly should be taken off the menu. The waitress was nice and accommodating for our group of eight. read more

Just went to Jims for the first time, we just sort of stumbled on it. It's not much to look at but they make some very good food. It's an Italian place, but I had the wings and they were amazing. They have 8 sauces and they give you a good amount. Why go to buffalo wild wings when Jim's is right up the road. My girlfriend had ravioli which was also very good. Good prices for beer and wine and they have a full bar. Didn't try the pizza, but it looked good. Definitely give this place a try. It looks like an old run down restaurant because it is. But that doesn't mean they don't have great food. I mean any place that's been open since the 1960s must be doing something right. read more

We get take-out quite a bit from Jim's for work. The times can be a bit inconsistent when waiting for food, but the pizza is great. They have some impressive specialty pizzas, and the food always tastes fresh. The one time they messed up my order, they more than made up for it by letting me keep the incorrect order on top of the fixed. I recommend the BBQ Chicken Pizza! read more