Well, where do I start ?! My hubby really wanted to go out of our way to this place so I picked what I like , turkey and provolone . Looked really good , I'm a simple eater , meat cheese lettuce and tomato, mmmmm....., mmmmmmm . He got an Italian reg size for both . When I opened my sandwich I was mystified as to where the cheese went ?!?!?! There wasn't any . That's what I thought until I noticed a slight color change of the meat that was shaved the width of a C hair. There on the bottom was the " also " shaved like a C hair cheese . You couldn't even see it let alone taste it and it looked like they spared no expense ( for themselves ) on sprinkling lettuce on my $9.25 cent Sammy. The tomato , also shaved. Sad face sad face . I still shared with my puppy Joe Peshey as he don't care. ‍ I would have brought them back but I had to travel to get there so I just won't go back. Do better !!!! What is the actual weight of cheese lettuce , tomato and meat that's supposed to be on this sandwich? Doesn't say but the picture is misleading. Bate and switch . read more

See all

Love it when my purchase helps a cause. I ordered two sandwiches and had to wait, but it was so worth it. The atmosphere was friendly. The staff was busy, but gave every customer a polite smile and tried to work efficiently. read more

I am picky about subs. They have to be perfectly balanced among just the right ingredients. To much of one thing (esp. mustard) and the whole sub is ruined. Mike's has great options, made with efficiency and care. I recommend ordering it "Mikes way" -- hadn't been in a while and forgot about that. I really love the sub oil. Also: great bread, generous portions and quality ingredients -- i.e. the meat/ and (REAL!!) cheese are sliced to order at the counter. Does that remind you of Subway? Me neither. Go here if you have the option. read more

they're hot subs are incredible! i love this place and any time i want a hot philly steak, i'm going here.

I'll take Jersey Mikes over any sub place ANYDAY. The chicken philly.. SOOOOO GOOD. they make my sandwhich right everytime and it's always enough food. They're fast, and efficient . The staff is sooo nice. read more

Today will be my 3rd sandwich/sub ordered from Jersey Mike's. I get the #9 Mike's Way. I don't know what else to say but, hands down, the best sub I've ever had. Super fresh bread and hand cut meats and cheeses. Whatever is in that shaker juice ROCKS MY WORLD. Nice staff and great food. read more

This place used to be the gold standard for subs when I recently moved back to willoughby I was excited to have this place back used to be a 2x a week place for me until today when I went in I ordered my giant 13 and was excited till I saw the lady put mayo on like she was painting a whole house with 1 gallon of paint and I asked for extra jalapeños got 6 on a giant sub idk when they thought them to be so cheap on mayo on jalapeños but let's just say I wasn't excited when I opened my sandwich read more

Stopped here for a quick lunch in between clients. This place has real (non-turkey based everything) lunch meat that's freshly sliced to order. They bake their bread in house, too. I got a veggie sub and it was awesome! I'm so over going to Subway! These guys have them beat and I'll go out of my way to go to them when I have a craving for one! read more

Love Jersey Mike's Subs overall but for some reason the sandwiches don't taste the same from location to location. Ordered big kahuna chicken cheesesteak with chipotle mayo added and there was hardly any flavor. Overall decent but not what I'm used to flavor wise. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Willoughby, Ohio

See all

This place is tasty - and also should give my company some referral money for all the people they send their way ;) I was in town for training and we came here twice. The first time I tried their Philly Cheesesteak...with chicken!!!....and it was extremely tasty and stuffed with fillings & meat. The second time I just got a club supreme with Mike's Way for toppings. They cut the cheese & meat right then and their so you know it's fresh! That was one of the best cold cut subs I've ever had in my life. Just thinking about it almost makes me want to go back to Cleveland. Almost...... Stays quite busy during lunch but the staff is quick & efficient so the line goes quickly. read more

Sandwich! I am giving this place 5 starts because this is one of the best sandwiches I have had. My logic is that this is fast food, its bread ,meat and toppings, not gastro rocket science. Five stars as this place does it well consistently. Big Kahuna, grilled beef or chicken, shrooms, peppers, onion, hot peppers, cheese and typical sub toppings plus chipotle mayo. Great bread, not greasy, and great customer service. No fried shit. This place does sandwiches well, everything is fresh. Its a chain, I hate chains, but the several times a year a crave this kind of stuff, i will drive out of my way for it. The meat does not give me heartburn. The portions are nice,it is also pretty economical. 14 inch subs for under 9$ plus coupons. Puts subway to shame. Other subs fanstatic. So for a fast food sub place I have not found better, unless you like copious amounts for grease and cheap meat, going into a mall, and rude service : ) read more

Great sub shop! Fresh cut meats to order and their delish homemade Italian style vinegar Dressing really makes this sandwich off the hook, tasty!!! My favorite was the signature sub, and I liked you could order reg or gigantic, if you want to share! :) Seriously, one of the best subs I ever had! Busy place but the line moves fast even if out the door. When in the Cleveland area this is a MUST stop lunch stop! I wish jersey mikes would come to Seattle! read more

This place is awesome! They receive a 5 star rating in more than one way! Starting out, their store is very clean and neat. Also the service was fantastic! People were smiling and cheerful! Now time for the nitty gritty...the subs...AMAZING! They slice the meats and cheeses right in front of you! Oh and their sizes are large! The Giant Club Deluxe is enough for 2 meals! Definitely get your sub "the Mike's way" and join there rewards program. It seems to be a great deal! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Giant Club Deluxe - Sandwiches Near Me - Willoughby, Ohio

Pros: They get your sub done fast. The line was to the door when we stepped in, but got my order in and completed within 7 minutes. It is really cool to see them slice the meat in front of you. You know that it is going to be good. Cons: Not much that I can say. It was not the best sub sandwich that i have had, but it is very decent for the price. Conclusion: I would eat here again if I were to visit Ohio! read more

They were a little nervous when the hot sub shop moved in next door; but each place fills a need and this place does just fine. Gets pretty busy at lunch but they recognize me and my turkey wrap no cheese mike's way is almost my signature sandwich now. The turkey seems to be the pressed turkey that subway uses but I like it nonetheless. I wish they used the unprocessed turkey breast but overall a great sub shop. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Looking to the rear from entry - Sandwiches Near Me - Willoughby, Ohio

This was my go to sub shop when I lived near by when I was younger, and now that i work and live near by again it is going to be my go to lunch stop. The store is always clean and neat and the service and consistency has not changed in 10 plus years. The bread is always fresh with a soft interior and a crispy exterior, meat is slice to order and toppings are very fresh. The best part is that the sandwich construction has not ever varied, the sandwiches are always well put together and not sloppy at all. My only reason for not giving 5 stars is the price I feel is a little high for even the quality of service and ingredients. That being said I will be back but not as frequently as I would like since I need to save $$ between visits. read more

Best sub joint around! I love this place. The food is always so fresh and they use real ingredients. I've read some other reviews saying that subway is better because of the fact that it is cheaper. While Jersey Mikes is slightly more expensive they are much more generous with their portions of fillings in their subs but they also use much better ingredients. Subway has very bad food and people get very sick from it. If you are looking to get a sub this is your place!!! read more

I'm writing this because I have to disagree with a previous review from Josh. This was our first time visiting because they had the GF bun for my wife. According to her the bun was the best GF she has had, only a little dry unlike most GF bread which crumbles and is very dry. The bread was fluffy and had a hard crust and did not crumble, she gave it a 7-8 if 10 is a normal bun. So kudos to Jersey Mikes for finding a great GF bun. Josh is right the subs are more expensive than Subway but they offer three sizes and the amount of meat on the sub is significantly larger. If you prefer a significantly smaller amount of meat and more bread go to Subway at Jersey Mike's they pile it on. I included a picture of the amount of meat never seen anything this thick unless you get the triple meat at Subway or in their commercial but remember there is an up charge for additional meat. We both had the medium Italian which is 8 inches not 6, we both only ate half because of the amount of meat. I have no problem eating the 6 inch at Subway and always want more. Remember you get what you pay for and we obviously don't eat subs much any more since the GF allergy but will be back to JM's no doubt. By the way Josh was dead on with cleanliness and friendliness. read more

I would have to encourage anyone who hasn't had a Jersey Mike's sub has to. I'm biased, I think they have the best sandwiches. Very friendly staff. I've never had a bad experience. read more

Greats subs made with high quality ingredients. Always made quick so you can get back on your way. Or sit down in their clean eatting area and watch some tv. Highly recommend read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Fresh subs made high quality ingredients. Always made quick - Sandwiches Near Me - Willoughby, Ohio

Authentic, yummy subs. Friendly staff. Fresh taste!

I love going to this place when I'm visiting Willoughby. It's my dad's favorite sub shop and now mine as well. Not too "froo-frooy" on the toppings, it is pretty much standard lettuce, onion, pepper, Havarti, pepper jack etc, but they load it up and the dressings are really good. I also really liked the anti pasta salad, never had anything like it before, all cheesy, meaty and spicey. read more

Was here when I spent a month in Cleveland for work, the training facility was a few blocks away, so one day for lunch we passed by and a friend mentioned them so we decided to stop, and dag nab it I'm glad we did! Awesome sub shop! super fast and friend workers, OK amount of parking and great selections of food! GET THE SUBS DUH! They fresh cut your loaf of bread, meat, and cheese as you pick you toppings and condiments. Fresh, tasty and relatively cheap! The large size is really two sandwiches so splitting one is can easily be done. If I'm every back in Cleveland for work I plan on coming back! read more

Excellent service by the majority of staff, food was typical; however, I had paid with a large bill and received quite the stare by one of the ladies, as if It was a fake one. She seemed to be a manager. Not very happy about this, if you don't want large bills, say so, don't give dirt looks instead. Will return but I guess it will be only bills smaller than 20's read more

What's happening at the Willoughby Hills, Ohio location? I stopped in for two giant subs last evening and was left baffled to what I had received. The sandwiches were not Jersey Mike standard. I was so disappointed in the low quality of our sandwiches. Has management changed? I am afraid to go back to this location. Strange enough, for the first time ever I did not get the usual Step Above review sent to my email. The bread and vegetables were not fresh. The meats were scarce, and bacon burnt. My husband was very hungry after a busy, late day and ate his soggy sub. I on the other hand was totally disappointed I trashed my sandwich. This is very unusual at this location . Again, what's going on at Willoughby, Ohio Jersey Mike's? I am afraid to go back. read more

My dude Squirrel eats a LOT of subs so to switch it up we come here from time-to-time. To me paying 7-9 bux for something that can be made at home for 2 is nuts and kinda damn lazy too but thats how Squirrel gets down. Staff is fun and the subs look as fresh as lunchmeat can get. I used to live in Jersey so the maps and diagrams on the wall bring me back to the days of taking the Path train into the city wearing Davey Dukes, tripping on shrooms with Jim and Terry... read more

By far my favorite sub shop in town. I get pretty easily grossed out by lunch meat... Especially turkey and they have, hands down, the best turkey I have ever tasted. Fresh sliced meat, cheese, and bread to order and always a friendly helpful staff. I've made it a Christmas eve. tradition to include a Jersey Mikes sub tray on the menu! Everyone expects it now!!! read more

Awesome subs, I'm from East PA an it reminds me of home! My fiancee got the cheese steak and it's legit!

Really quick service at lunch time! Everyone working there was incredibly nice. Awesome sub, great quality. Delicious!

I think the key is to know what to order here. I had the turkey sub once, and it was eh, just ok. I then returned and got the veggie sub with everything other than olives and jalapeños, and it was AMAZING! I'd suggest eating it there though, because if you get it with the oil and vinegar it is going to be a 100% soggy mess. If you like your bread more bread than soup, just take my advice, and pop a squat at one of their tables. Super yummy veggie sub though, I find myself craving it!! Not normal for just veggies and bread!! read more

Better sandwiches than the other choices in the area. Depends a lot on who's working behind the counter, though. Some of them don't know how to make a wrap; some are more generous with the fillings than others. read more

Kinda overpriced for what you get. The meat is good but the gym is a little lack luster. I do enjoy their roast beef. The employees are always very nice when you walk in. It is very clean as well read more

My fave place for a sub sandwich. The meat is sliced right in front of you. All the boasting Subway does about "Eat Fresh" , they should take a page from Jersey Mikes book. read more

Always a great sub and great staff. They are very nice and approachable every time I walk in. Plus the food is fresh and tastes amazing.

Great service, subs are fresh and made how you like them. Zak and Ashley were helpful and friendly.

Great philly subs, probably best in the area. A little pricy but worth it if you're treating yourself once in a while. The restaurant itself is very clean and orderly. Nice service as well. read more

After years of driving past this sub shop I finally decided to grab my wife and I subs for lunch from here. The MAIN reason I can only give three stars is for almost $15 I got two of there medium subs with nothing on it to make it that expensive. We both got #9 which came with turkey and roast beef and bacon. The roast beef was nice and rare. You have the option to add mayo onion lettuce tomatoes banana peppers and pickles. The sandwich did not taste bad but we feel you do not get your monies worth at this establishment.One of the good things I noticed though is they cut your cheese and meats to order so the freshness is good here. Save your self the money and go to another sub place. You get more food for you buck at subway or Alesci's of Shoregate. Younger kids working around lunch time. Friendly and people seem to like jersey mikes and the dining area was full around 1pm. (No photo of our subs) read more

OMG!! It took me a day to recover! Jersey Mikes in willoughby !! I will be back! THE BEST philly steak I have had since For Ever!! Comfortable, friendly staff and as a newbie in OH this place serves an EPIC Philly Steak! Your new loyal Customer, Deb read more

excellent service and food! young blonde girl was very helpful and offered a kind smile with her service!

this is my favorite sub spot, good food, good prices, everyone is friendly and it's always clean.